The research will focus on finding benchmark data on the required size of companies that is necessary for a full SAP Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system implementation. The analysis will look into benefits and costs of the implementation and long term prospects generated by the system. Practical examples will be used to illustrate the main findings, both from a positive as well as a negative viewpoint.
[...]
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
2 Investment requirements and costs of ERP system implementation
2. 1 Structure of incurred costs
2. 2 Analysis of minimum requirements for successful rollout
2. 2. 1 Hardware & Infrastructure
2. 2. 2 Software
2. 2. 3 Consulting
2. 2. 4 Implementation Team
2. 2. 5 Training
2. 3 Benchmark data for minimum expenses
2. 4 On-going expenses from ERP systems
3 Generic benefits of implementation of ERP systems
3. 1 Cost savings
3. 1. 1 Productivity
3. 1. 2 Human Resources
3. 1. 3 IT maintenance
3. 2 Customer satisfaction
3. 2. 1 Service aspects
3. 2. 2 Quality aspects
3. 3 Aggregation of benefits in relation to organization size
4 Comparison of costs and benefits for threshold organization size
5 Resume
Research Objectives and Themes
This paper aims to determine the benchmark company size required for a successful full-scale implementation of SAP Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems, while analyzing the associated costs, benefits, and long-term strategic prospects for organizations.
- Analysis of implementation cost structures including hardware, software, and consulting.
- Identification of minimum organizational threshold requirements for a successful rollout.
- Evaluation of core benefits such as cost savings, increased productivity, and customer satisfaction.
- Examination of the role of Application Service Providing (ASP) in making ERP accessible to smaller businesses.
- Strategic comparison of implementation costs versus long-term operational benefits.
Excerpt from the Book
Software selection is not an easy task!
Before the more difficult part of software selection begins, a company should start with defining software needs by examining current processes that govern its flow of information and material throughout the order-to delivery process and ultimately the entire supply chain. There is a common tendency to shortcut this very important activity, but a company will suffer later on when it neglects this evaluation. A comprehensive methodology to plan, guide and control the effort has the potential for dramatic savings, not to mention the most important benefit: avoiding big mistakes. Another common mistake is the delegation of the selection of an ERP System to the IT department. The idea that this is strictly a technology project because software is involved is wrong and, in fact, is one of the leading causes of ERP failure. The IT function is not well-positioned to evaluate the business implications of various tradeoffs or to determine their impact on day-to day operating results versus strategic intent.
So we can highlight that the ERP software search, evaluation and selection process must be done right to minimize big risks. A good generic approach will start with thorough planning, which should follow a strategy-, people and process-focused methodology. This is very important to be successful with ERP implementation in the first attempt and it is the only way to manage the involved risk effectively. A good methodology covers all planable issues, but when the unexpected pops up, as it usually does, the company will be prepared to handle these exceptions without severe negative consequences, using a consistent risk and backup plan.
Summary of Chapters
1 Introduction: Introduces the research scope regarding SAP ERP implementations and the fundamental assumption that the focus is on comprehensive, value-chain-wide system integration rather than minor module adoption.
2 Investment requirements and costs of ERP system implementation: Analyzes the diverse cost factors including infrastructure, software licensing, consulting, internal team formation, and training required for a full ERP deployment.
3 Generic benefits of implementation of ERP systems: Discusses the tangible and intangible advantages of ERP systems, specifically focusing on cost savings through productivity gains, human resource management, and improved customer satisfaction.
4 Comparison of costs and benefits for threshold organization size: Provides a strategic visual and financial comparison of initial implementation costs versus long-term cumulative benefits for organizations.
5 Resume: Summarizes the research findings, highlighting that while ERP implementation is a significant investment with potential pitfalls, it is essential for modern business efficiency and integration.
Keywords
Enterprise Resource Planning, ERP, SAP, Supply Chain Management, Implementation Costs, Software Selection, Business Process, Productivity, Customer Satisfaction, CRM, Infrastructure, Strategic Management, Benchmarking
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core focus of this research paper?
The paper focuses on identifying benchmark data and organizational requirements necessary for the successful, full-scale implementation of SAP ERP systems, specifically evaluating the cost-benefit trade-offs.
What are the central thematic areas of the analysis?
The central themes include the breakdown of implementation costs, the strategic necessity of proper software selection methodologies, and the organizational benefits derived from integrated business processes.
What is the primary goal of the study?
The goal is to provide a framework for organizations to understand the minimum size requirements and financial commitments needed to move from legacy systems to a fully integrated, value-chain-focused ERP environment.
Which scientific methodology is applied?
The research uses a descriptive analytical approach, synthesizing existing industry case studies, survey data from firms like the META Group, and benchmark cost estimations to construct a strategic overview.
What topics are covered in the main section of the paper?
The main section covers cost drivers (consulting, hardware, training), strategies for successful implementation, the role of CRM, and the operational improvements in productivity and IT maintenance.
Which keywords best characterize the work?
Key terms include ERP, SAP, Supply Chain Management, Implementation Costs, Productivity, CRM, and Strategic Business Process Integration.
Why is the "software selection" phase considered critical according to the authors?
The authors argue that short-cutting the software selection process or delegating it solely to IT leads to a failure to align business goals with technical requirements, which is a leading cause of ERP implementation failure.
How does the paper differentiate the impact of ERP systems based on company size?
The paper notes that while large multinationals achieve economies of scale, smaller firms must ensure they are part of a larger value chain to justify the investment costs, as the infrastructure and maintenance requirements remain high regardless of size.
- Citar trabajo
- Nejc Martin Jakopin (Autor), Henning Kassen (Autor), Philip Kirst (Autor), 2002, Analysis of minimum size requirements of organizations for the implementation of enterprise resource planning systems, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/10068
