1. Einleitung

'HU 7LWHO GHU HWKLVFKHQ $EKDQGOXQJ Ä(LQOHLWXQJ LQ GLH 0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW³ YRQ *HRUJ 6LPPHO XQWHUVFKHLGHW VLFK EHUHLWV LQ HLQHU %HJULIIOLFKNHLW YRQ DQGHUHQ :HUNHQ ]XU (WKLN 'HU %HJULII Ä0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW³ NHQQ]HLFKQHW ZHGHU HLQH EHVRQGHUH QRUPDWLYH (WKLN QRFK HLQH PRUDOLVFKH 0HWKRGLN 'HU ,QKDOW GHV ]ZHLElQGLJHQ :HUNHV YHUOHLKWGHP8QWHUWLWHOÄ.ULWLNGHUHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGEHJULIIH³VHLQHYROOH%HUHFKWLJXQJ$Q GLHVHU6WHOOHVWHOOWVLFKGLH)UDJHDXVZHOFKHQ0RWLYHQKHUDXV6LPPHOGLHVH*UXQGEHJULIIH NULWLVLHUWXQGLQLKUH%HVWDQGWHLOH]HUOHJW:RKOEHGDFKWHU|UWHUWHUGLHVLQVHLQHP9RUZRUW (U NRQVWDWLHUW GDVV GLH (WKLN ]X VHLQHU =HLW QRFK QLFKW PHWKRGLVFK DXVJHDUEHLWHW LVW 6LH EHUXIWVLFKDXIHUIXQGHQH3ULQ]LSLHQZHOFKHVLFKHKHUPLW0RUDOSUHGLJWDOVPLWVLWWOLFKHU *HOWXQJLGHQWLIL]LHUHQ'DEHLJHKW6LPPHOVRZHLWGDVVHUVHOEVWGHQ%HJULIIGHU(WKLNGHQ 6WDWXV GHU :LVVHQVFKDIW DEHUNHQQW 0LW GLHVHU (UNHQQWQLV LVW HU EHUHLWV HLQ 9RUUHLWHU GHV KHXWLJHQHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGYHUVWlQGQLVVHV'LHKHXWLJHQ%HUHLFKVHWKLNHQZLHEHLVSLHOVZHLVH GLH 7LHUHWKLN VLQG ,QGLNDWRUHQ IU GLH 7DWVDFKH GDVV EHUHLWV QLFKW PHKU YRQ HLQHU XQLYHUVDOHQ (WKLN JHVSURFKHQ ZHUGHQ NDQQ $Q GHQ YRUDQJHJDQJHQ 3XQNWHQ ZLUG GLH IROJHQGH8QJHZLVVKHLWHUNHQQEDU:REOHLEWGDV3RVLWLYH"

6LPPHO VFKULHE HLQH GHVNULSWLYH 0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW ZHOFKH (WKLN QLFKW DOV HLQH (LQKHLW EHJUHLIWVRQGHUQDXIPHKUHUHQ(EHQHQXQWHUVXFKWSV\FKRORJLVFKVR]LRORJLVFKKLVWRULVFK HYROXWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFK JHOWXQJVWKHRUHWLVFK XQG DQDO\WLVFK 'LH (WKLN DQ VLFK LVW VHLQHU 0HLQXQJQDFKLQNRQVLVWHQWGDVLHZHGHUSUDNWLVFKLVWQRFKGHQ0HQVFKHQYHUVLWWOLFKW

Ä3UDNWLVFKYHUVLWWOLFKHQGZLUGIUHLOLFKHLQHGHPHQVWVSUHFKHQGHSRVLWLYH(WKLNQLFKWZLUNHQGHUGDV

'LH'XUFKIKUXQJH[DNWHU(LQ]HOXQWHUVXFKXQJHQLVWODXW6LPPHOYRQ1|WHQÄ'DV6ROOHQ³ LVWHLQHWKLVFKHV(LQ]HOSULQ]LSZHOFKHVDP$QIDQJYRQ6LPPHOV:HUNEHKDQGHOWZLUG'LH YRUOLHJHQGH +DXVDUEHLW GLVNXWLHUW 6LPPHOV $XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLW GHP 6ROOHQ DXI YLHU YHUVFKLHGHQHQ(EHQHQ$XIHLQHUDQDO\WLVFKHQXPGDV6ROOHQDQVLFK]XHUNOlUHQDXIHLQHU KLVWRULVFKHYROXWLRQVWKHRUHWLVFKHQXPGHQ8UVSUXQJXQGGLH(QWVWHKXQJGHV6ROOHQVLQGHU 9HUJDQJHQKHLW ]X IRNXVVLHUHQ DXI HLQHU SKlQRPHQRORJLVFKHQ XP VHLQHQ RQWRORJLVFKHQ 6WDWXVXQG6LPPHOV:LUNOLFKNHLWVEHJULII]XHUOlXWHUQXQGHLQHUJHOWXQJVWKHRUHWLVFKHQXP GLH $PELYDOHQ] GHV 1RUPEHJULIIV KHUYRU]XKHEHQ XQG GLH 5ROOH GHU *HVHOOVFKDIW ]X

*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW(LQH.ULWLNGHUHWKLVFKHQ*UXQGEHJULIIH)UDQNIXUWDP 0DLQ6XKUNDPS9HUODJ6

HU|UWHUQ 'LH *UHQ]HQ PDQFKHU GLHVHU (EHQHQ ZLH ]XP %HLVSLHO GHU *HQHVH XQG GHU *HOWXQJGHV6ROOHQVVLQGIOLH‰HQG'HQQRFKZXUGHVLFKEHPKWHLQH*UHQ]OLQLH]ZLVFKHQ EHLGHQ]X]LHKHQ'LH*HQHVHILQGHW JU|‰WHQWHLOVLQGHU9HUJDQJHQKHLWVWDWWZlKUHQGGLH *HOWXQJPLWLKUHPG\QDPLVFKHQXQGVFKQHOOOHELJHQ&KDUDNWHUVLFKHKHUDQGHU*HJHQZDUW SRODULVLHUW

2. Analyse des Sollens an sich

.HLQH'HILQLWLRQGHV6ROOHQV

,P6WUD‰HQYHUNHKUVROOPDQDXIPHUNVDPVHLQ.LQGHUVROOHQGDVWXQZDVLKQHQYRQLKUHQ (OWHUQDXIJHWUDJHQZLUG(LQ$QJHVWHOOWHUVROO]XVHLQHU$UEHLWSQNWOLFKHUVFKHLQHQ'RFK ZDVJHQDXEHGHXWHWGLHVHVÄVROO³"6ROOPDQLP6WUD‰HQYHUNHKUDXIPHUNVDPVHLQZHLOPDQ HV ODXW *HVHW] PXVV RGHU VROO PDQ DXIPHUNVDP VHLQ ZHLO PDQ DXIPHUNVDP VHLQ ZLOO EHLVSLHOVZHLVH ]XU 8QIDOOYHUPHLGXQJ" :R LVW GLHVHV 6ROOHQ DQJHXIHUW XQG ZDUXP VROO PDQHWZDV%HVWLPPWHVWXQEH]LHKXQJVZHLVHXQWHUODVVHQ"

=XQlFKVWLVWIHVW]XKDOWHQGDVVGDV6ROOHQGHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQHU9RUVFKULIWEH]LHKXQJVZHLVH HLQHU$XIIRUGHUXQJWUlJW(VLVWHLQHHKHUVFKZlFKHUH9RUVFKULIWHLQ*HERW'RFKZHOFKH $XWRULWlW ZHQQ EHUKDXSW VWHKW KLQWHU GLHVHP *HERW XQG EHUZDFKW GHVVHQ %HDFKWXQJ" :HQQ HV NHLQH DQGHUH $XWRULWlW EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH $XWRULWlWVJUXSSH LVW LVW HV GDQQ QLFKW PHLVWHQVGDV,QGLYLGXXPVHOEVWZHOFKHVGLHVH3RVLWLRQHLQQLPPW"'DV6ROOHQDUEHLWHWDOVR JHZLVVHUPD‰HQPLW)UHPGRGHU6HOEVW]ZlQJHQ'HU)UHPG]ZDQJDOVYHUDOOJHPHLQHUEDUH )RUGHUXQJXQGGHU6HOEVW]ZDQJDOVHLQ*HIKOGLHVH)RUGHUXQJDQVLFKVHOEVW]XVWHOOHQ 'D]X NRPPW QRFK HLQ ZHLWHUHU $VSHNW GHU :LOOHQVNRQIOLNW :HQQ HLQ .LQG DXIUlXPHQ VROODEHUGHQQRFKGLH=HLWQXW]WXPZHLWHU]XVSLHOHQN|QQWHHV]XHLQHP:LOOHQVNRQIOLNW NRPPHQ(VZLOO6SD‰KDEHQDEHUHVZLOODXFKNHLQHQbUJHUEHNRPPHQGHQQHVVROOMD HLJHQWOLFKDXIUlXPHQ

6LPPHO NRQVWDWLHUW ]XP :HVHQ GHV 6ROOHQV PLW 5HFKW GDVV HV ÄNHLQH 'HILQLWLRQ GHV

6ROOHQV³ JLEW-HGRFKVROOWHXQEHGLQJWHLQHZLFKWLJH)HVWVWHOOXQJGHV%HJULIIHVGHV6ROOHQV JHQDQQWZHUGHQGHUOLQJXLVWLVFKH%HJULIIGHV,PSHUDWLYV E]ZGHVÄPRGXVLPSHUDWLYXV³ +LHUEHL OLHJW GHU 6FKZHUSXQNW DEHU QLFKW QXU DXI ÄLPSDUH³ EHIHKOHQ VRQGHUQ DXI

*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW6

YJO+DGXPRG%X‰PDQQ+J/H[LNRQGHU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWDNWXDOLVLHUWHXQGHUZHLWHUWH$XIODJH 6WXWWJDUW$OIUHG.U|QHU9HUODJ6

ÄPRGXV³ $UW :HLVH RGHU )RUP 'LH 7DWVDFKH GDVV GDV 6ROOHQ HWZDV EHIHKOHQGHV )RUPDOHVLVWELOGHWLKUZLFKWLJVWHV8QWHUVXFKXQJVNULWHULXP

ÃPRGXVLPSHUDWLYXVµGLH)RUPGHV6ROOHQV

6RZLHQDFK'DYLG+XPHÄQLFKWVLQVLFKVHOEVWZHUWYROORGHUYHUlFKWOLFKZQVFKHQVRGHU

KDVVHQVZHUW VFK|Q RGHU PL‰JHVWDOWHW LVW³ VR LVW DXFK GDV 6ROOHQ DQ VLFK QDFK 6LPPHO QLFKW QDFK EHVWLPPWHQ ,QKDOWHQ HUPDKQHQG IRUGHUQG RGHU JHELHWHQG (V ZLUG HKHU YRQ HLQHPJHZLVVHQ ,QKDOWEHVWLPPWRGHUDXVJHIOOW2KQHGLHVHQ ,QKDOWEOHLEWGDV6ROOHQDOV HLQH EOR‰H OHHUH )RUP EHVWHKHQ $XV GLHVHU OHHUHQ )RUP IROJW QLFKW ORJLVFK GHUHQ ,QKDOW VRZLH DXV GHP %HJULII GHU 9ROONRPPHQKHLW QLFKW GLH ([LVWHQ] HLQHV YROONRPPHQHQ

:HVHQVIROJHQNDQQ 'DKHULVWHVQRWZHQGLJGHQ%HJULIIGHV6ROOHQVDXIVHLQH)RUP]X EHVFKUlQNHQXQGYRQVHLQHP]XJHIJWHQ,QKDOWDE]XWUHQQHQ,P%H]XJDXIDQGHUH)RUPHQ ZLHGDV0VVHQRGHUGDV:ROOHQOlVVWVLFKGLH$PELYDOHQ]YRQ)RUPXQG,QKDOWDQGUHL $XVVDJHQEHVVHUYHUGHXWOLFKHQ [PXVVPRUDOLVFKVHLQ [VROOPRUDOLVFKVHLQXQG [ZLOOPRUDOLVFKVHLQ

$OO GLHVH $XVVDJHQ EHVLW]HQ GHQ VHOEHQ ,QKDOW EH]LHKXQJVZHLVH GLH VHOEH 3URSRVLWLRQ 'HQQRFKXQWHUVFKHLGHQVLHVLFKLQLKUHU(LQVWHOOXQJ]XGLHVHP,QKDOW6LPPHOYHUELOGOLFKW GHQ ,QKDOW DOV HLQH JOHLFKEOHLEHQGH 0HORGLH ZlKUHQG GLH (LQVWHOOXQJHQ IU GDV

7UDQVSRQLHUHQGHU0HORGLHLQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ7RQDUWHQVWHKHQ

'LH OHHUH )RUP GHV 6ROOHQV OlVVW VLFK YHUJOHLFKHQ PLW GHU 0HWKRGLN GHV NDWHJRULVFKHQ ,PSHUDWLYV YRQ .DQW :HGHU VLWWOLFKH 1RUPHQ QRFK PRUDOLVFKH :HUWH IROJHQ DXV GHVVHQ ([LVWHQ](UJHZLQQWHUVWVHLQHJOWLJH.UDIWGXUFKVHLQH$QZHQGXQJXQGGHU=XZHLVXQJ HLQHV,QKDOWHV

Ä:LH GLH JOHLFKH 0DWHULH YHUVFKLHGHQH $JJUHJDW]XVWlQGH DQQHKPHQ NDQQ >«@ VR NDQQ DXFK GLH JOHLFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJ LKUHQ ,QKDOW JHZLVVHUPDDVVHQ LQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ

SV\FKRORJLVFKHQ$JJUHJDW]XVWlQGHQGDUVWHOOHQ³ 6RPLWLVWGDV6ROOHQQLFKWQXUHLQH)RUP

'DYLG+XPH9RPVFKZDFKHQ7URVWGHU3KLORVRSKLH(VVD\V$XVZDKOhEHUVHW]XQJXQG1DFKZRUWYRQ -HQV.XOHQNDPSII*|WWLQJHQ6WHLGO9HUODJ6I YJOGHURQWRORJLVFKH*RWWHVEHZHLV QDFK6HDUOH

^{YJO*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW6} HEG6

DQ VLFK VRQGHUQ HLQ 'HQNPRGXV ZLH GDV :QVFKHQ RGHU GDV +RIIHQ ZHOFKH VLFK DOOHLQ

ÄGXUFK GLH )RUP GHV ,PSHUDWLYV³ LQ YHUEDOHU )RUP ]X GHQ DQGHUHQ 'HQNPRGL XQWHUVFKHLGHW

'LH%HVWLPPXQJGHV,QKDOWVGHV6ROOHQV

$XIJUXQGGHU/HHUKHLWGHU6ROOHQVIRUPZlUHHVLQNRUUHNWYRQHLQHP,QKDOWGHV6ROOHQV]X VSUHFKHQ 9RQ HOHPHQWDUHU %HGHXWXQJ LVW HKHU GLH ,QKDOWV]XZHLVXQJ XQG GHUHQ $UW XQG :HLVH ZHOFKH GXUFK VHFKV YHUVFKLHGHQH 0LWWHO JHNHQQ]HLFKQHW ZLUG GLH 5HDOLWlW GLH 1LFKWUHDOLWlW GHU LQGLYLGXHOOH 9RUWHLO GHU JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH 9RUWHLO GHU %HIHKO HLQHU HJRLVWLVFKHQ $XWRULWlW VRZLH GHVVHQ (QWJHJHQVHW]XQJ (LQ ,QKDOW ZHOFKHU DXV GHU 5HDOLWlW IROJHQ N|QQWH ZlUH EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GDV WUDGLWLRQVUHLFKH %HVFKHQNHQ ]XU :HLKQDFKWV]HLW :HQQ PDQ HWZDV JHVFKHQNW EHNRPPW VROO PDQ DXFK DQGHUHQ HWZDV VFKHQNHQ(LQQLFKWUHDOHU,QKDOWLVWHKHUPLWHLQHP8QWHUODVVHQ]XYHUJOHLFKHQÄ'XVROOVW QLFKW EHU URWH $PSHOQ IDKUHQ³ 'DV Ä1LFKWIDKUHQ³ LVW GLH 1HJDWLRQ GHU 5HDOLWlW GHP )DKUHQ'DVGULWWH0LWWHOGHULQGLYLGXHOOH9RUWHLOHULQQHUWYRUDOOHPDQGLHKHOOHQLVWLVFKH (WKLN XQG GHP %HJULII GHV +HGRQLVPXV 'HU $XVVSUXFK $ULVWLSSV Ä'LH /XVW EHKHUUVFKW

QLFKW ZHU VLFK HQWKlOW VRQGHUQ ZHU VLH JHQLH‰W³ EHGHXWHW QLFKWV DQGHUHV DOV Ä8P GLH /XVW ]X EHKHUUVFKHQ VROOVW GX VLH JHQLH‰HQ³ 0LW GHP JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHP 9RUWHLO

EH]LHKXQJVZHLVHGHP9RUWHLOÄIUGLH*HVDPPWKHLW³ DUEHLWHWYRUDOOHPGHU8WLOLWDULVPXV (LQ%HJUQGHUOHW]WHUHU/HKUHLVW-HUHP\%HQWKDPPLWGHVVHQ$XVVDJHGDVVÄHLQ]LJXQG

DOOHLQGHUDOOJHPHLQH1XW]HQ0D‰VWDEGHV+DQGHOQVVHLQVROOWH³ 'LHVH$XVVDJHN|QQWH ]X*XQVWHQ6LPPHOVSKLORVRSKLVFKHU7KHRULHIROJHQGHUPD‰HQXPIRUPXOLHUWZHUGHQÄ'X VROOVWVRKDQGHOQGDVVGHUDOOJHPHLQH1XW]HQ0D‰VWDEGHLQHV+DQGHOQVLVW³$OVIQIWHQ $VSHNWQHQQW6LPPHOGHQ%HIHKOHLQHUHJRLVWLVFKHQ$XWRULWlW'LHVN|QQWHEHLVSLHOVZHLVH ]XU=HLWGHVU|PLVFKHQ,PSHULXPVGLH$XIIRUGHUXQJHLQHVSURYLQ]LHOOHQ6WDGWKDOWHUVVHLQ Ä'X VROOVW PHKU 6WHXHUQ ]DKOHQ³ 'LH (QWJHJHQVHW]XQJ ]X GLHVHP %HIHKO ELOGHW GLH VHFKVWH$UWXQG:HLVHGHU,QKDOWV]XZHLVXQJ(LQ3URYLQ]ODQGZLUWN|QQWHVLFKGHP%HIHKO GHV6WDGWKDOWHUVHQWJHJHQVWHOOHQXQGVRPLWVHLQHQ0LWPHQVFKHQHLQ=HLFKHQVHW]HQÄ'HU 6WDGWKDOWHUVROOQLFKWPLWXQVPDFKHQN|QQHQZDVHUZLOO³

*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW6

0DOWH+RVVHQIHOGHU+J$QWLNH*OFNVOHKUHQ4XHOOHQLQGHXWVFKHUhEHUVHW]XQJ6WXWWJDUW$OIUHG .U|QHU9HUODJ6

^{*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW6} -RQDV3ILVWHU3KLORVRSKLH(LQ/HKUEXFK6WXWWJDUW5HFODP6

3. Die Genese des Inhalts des Sollens

6RZLHHV*UQGHGDIUJLEWZDUXPHLQ,QKDOWGLH)RUPGHV6ROOHQVEHNRPPWVRJLEWHV DXFK VSH]LILVFKH (LJHQDUWHQ GHU *HQHVH GLHVHV ,QKDOWHV 1HQQHQVZHUW VLQG YRU DOOHP GHU 8UVSUXQJ GLH (QWZLFNOXQJ RGHU GLH 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJ GHV ,QKDOWHV 'LHVH 3XQNWH VROOHQ LQ GHQQlFKVWHQ$EVFKQLWWHQHUOlXWHUWZHUGHQ

'DV6ROOHQDOV8UWDWVDFKH

8P GLH *HQHVH GHV ,QKDOWV ]X HUNXQGHQ ZHOFKHU GHQ &KDUDNWHU GHV 6ROOHQV EHNRPPW EHIDVVW VLFK 6LPPHO ]XQlFKVW PLW GHP 8UVSUXQJ GHU 6ROOHQVIRUP ,KP ]XIROJH LVW ÄGDV

6ROOHQ HLQH XUVSUQJOLFKH .DWHJRULH ZLH GDV 6HLQ XQG GDV 9RUVWHOOHQ³ XQG lKQHOW GHU 0RUDOLP$VSHNWGHU8QEHJUQGEDUNHLW'DKHUNDQQGDV6ROOHQDQVLFKZHGHUEHJUQGHW QRFK DXI HLQ HUVWHV 3ULQ]LS ]XUFNJHIKUW ZHUGHQ /HGLJOLFK GHVVHQ ]XJHZLHVHQHU ,QKDOW

ÄNDQQ DXI HLQHQ DQGHUHQ ]XUFNJHIKUW³ DEHU QLFKW ORJLVFK EHJUQGHW ZHUGHQ (V HUJHEHQVLFKLPPHUQXU ,QGL]LHQEHZHLVHVRGDVV HLQH'HGXNWLRQQLFKW HUIROJHQNDQQ$Q GLHVHU6WHOOH]HLJWVLFKHLQVFKHLQEDUHV3DUDGR[RQ:HQQGLH%HJUQGEDUNHLWGHUHLQ]HOQHQ ,QKDOWH LQGXNWLY HUIROJW ZDUXP WUlJW VLH GHQQRFK GHQ &KDUDNWHU GHU 1RWZHQGLJNHLW" 6LPPHOHQWNUlIWHWGLHVPLWHLQHUSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ(UNOlUXQJ'DV(PSILQGHQHLQHV6ROOHQV IROJW QLFKW DXV GHP 6ROOHQ RGHU DXV GHVVHQ ]XJHZLHVHQHP ,QKDOW VRQGHUQ DXV HLQHP DQGHUHP6ROOHQ

^{Ä.HLQ 6FKOXVV N|QQWH XQV OHKUHQ GDVV ZLU HWZDV VROOHQ ZHQQ ZLU GLHVHV 6ROOHQ QLFKW ZHQLJVWHQV} anderweitig empfunden hätten HU OHKUW HV XQV ZHQQ QXQ GLH %HGLQJXQJHQ GHV GDPDOLJHQ (PSILQGHQV DQ GHP jetzigen Fall VR DXIJH]HLJW XQG ]X %HZXVVWVHLQ JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ GDVV GLH

'LHV P|FKWH LFK DQ HLQHP NOHLQHQ *HGDQNHQH[SHULPHQW YHUGHXWOLFKHQ (LQ 6FKOHU OHUQW IUHLQHVFKZLHULJH/HLVWXQJVNRQWUROOHGDLKPYRQVHLQHQ(OWHUQDXIJHWUDJHQZXUGHGDVV HU OHUQHQ VROO XP HLQH JXWH 1RWH ]X HUKDOWHQ (LQ SDDU :RFKHQ VSlWHU ZLUG HLQH ZHLWHUH /HLVWXQJVNRQWUROOH JHVFKULHEHQ 'DVV HU MHW]W OHUQHQ VROO IROJW QLFKW ORJLVFK DXV GHU $XIIRUGHUXQJVHLQHU(OWHUQGDHVLKPGLHVPDOIUHLJHVWHOOWLVWREHUOHUQWRGHUQLFKW-HGRFK

^{*HRUJ6LPPHO(LQOHLWXQJLQGLH0RUDOZLVVHQVFKDIW6 HEG} HEG0DUNLHUXQJHQ61