$OOH5HFKWHDXFKGLHGHUhEHUVHW]XQJGHV1DFKGUXFNVXQGGHU9HUYLHOIlOWLJXQJGHU 'LSORPDUEHLWRGHUYRQ7HLOHQGDUDXVVLQGYRUEHKDOWHQ.HLQ7HLOGHU'LSORPDUEHLWGDUI RKQHVFKULIWOLFKH*HQHKPLJXQJGHV$XWRUVLQLUJHQGHLQHU)RUP)RWRNRSLH0LNURILOP RGHUHLQDQGHUHV9HUIDKUHQDXFKQLFKWIU=ZHFNHGHU8QWHUULFKWVJHVWDOWXQJUHSUR GX]LHUWRGHUXQWHU9HUZHQGXQJHOHNWURQLVFKHU6\VWHPH6FDQQHQRGHUHLQDQGHUHV 9HUIDKUHQYHUDUEHLWHWZHUGHQ=XZLGHUKDQGOXQJHQXQWHUOLHJHQGHQ6WUDIEHVWLPPXQ

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

0 Abstract

,QGHUYRUOLHJHQGHQ'LSORPDUEHLWVROOGLH(QW VFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ()LQNRPSOH[HQ 6LWXDWLRQHQXQWHUVXFKWZHUGHQ$UEHLWVJUXQGODJHLVWGDEHLGLH]XP=HLWSXQNWGHU%HDU EHLWXQJDNW XHOOH/LWHUDW XU]XGLHVHP7KH PD %HVRQGHUV]XHUZlKQHQLVWGDEHLGDV LP$V KJDWH9HUODJHUVFKLHQH QH%XFKÄ'HFLVLRQ0DNLQJLQ&RPSOH[(Q YLURQ PHQWV³KHUDXVJHJHEHQ YRQ0DOFRP&RRN-DQ 1R\HVXQG

'LH]XU]HLWDQJHZHQGHWHQ0RGHOOH GHU()VROOHQSUlVHQWLHUWZHUGHQ'DEHLZLUGLQV EHVRQGHUHGLH()LQGHUNRPSOH[HQ8PJHEX QJHLQHV9HUNHKUVIOXJ]H XJVEHWUDFK WHW %HLVSLHOHDXVGHU3UD[LV VRZLH)OXJXQXQG=ZL VFKHQIlOOHQVROOHQGLH= XVDPPHQKlQ JHEHLGHU()YHUGHXWOLFKHQ

'DEHLZLUGXQWHUVXFKW ZHOFKH(LQIOVVHDXIG HQ(QWVFKHLGHUE]ZGLH(QWVFKHLG HU ZLUNHQXQGZHOFKH)ROJ HQGLHVH(LQIOVVHDXI GLH()KDEHQXPVRD EOHLWHQ]XN|Q QHQZLHGLH()XQWHU GHP%HZXVVWVHLQ YRQPHQVFKOLFKH Q)HKOHUQX QG1HLJXQJ HQ RSWLPDOGXUFKJHIKUWZ HUGHQNDQQ 'DUDXIDXI EDXHQGHUJLEWVLFKGHU 9RUVFKODJG HV ()0RGHOOV),7)25'(& ^‹ $X‰HUGHPLVWGLH %HZHUWXQJYRQ&UHZ5HVVRXUFH0 DQD JHPHQW&50HLQHJUR‰H+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJ'DKHU ZLUGLQGLHVHU$UEHLWHLQJUDILVFKHV %HZHUWXQJVV\VWHPIUGHQ3UR]HVVGHU (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJLQQHUK DOEGHV&50 7UDLQLQJVPLWGHU%H]HLFKQXQJ&5DSKLF ^‹ YRUJHVWHOOW

7URW]VWH LJHQGHU$XWRPDWLVLHUXQJ LVWGLH() LP&RFNSLWXQG DQGHUHQNR PSOH[HQ8P JHEXQJHQQRFKLPPHUGLH$XIJDEH GHV0HQVFKHQXQGGDVEHL]XQHKPHQGNRPSOH[H UHQ6\VWHPHQ,QGLH VHP=XVDPPHQKDQJZHUGHQ$XWRPDWLRQXQG6LW XDWLYH$XIPHUN VDPNHLWMHZHLOVLQH LQHPHLJHQHQ.DSLWHOEHWU DFKWHW$XFKGHUDNWXHOOH6WDQGGHU)RU VFKXQJ]XP7KHPD'HWHUPLQDWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQZLUGSUlVHQWLHUW

L

  )HOL 0DQQV0 JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ  

Inhaltsverzeichnis

6HLWH   

1.  Einleitung  

2.  Komplexe Entscheidungsfindung  

  'HILQLWLRQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ  

7KHRULHGHU  (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ  

  (QWVFKHLGXQJVDUWHQ  

0HUNPDOHYRQ.RPSOH  LWlW  

3.  Prozess der Entscheidungsfindung  

RPSRQHQWHQGHV  (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJVSUR  HVVHV

0RGHOOHGHU  (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ  

  (QWVFKHLGXQJVUHJHOQ  

  (LQIO VVHDXIGHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVSUR  HVV

HLW   

RPSOH  LWlW  

  ,QGLYLGXXP  

8PIHOG««   

  (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJLQGHU UXSSH  

HZHUWXQJHLQHU  (QWVFKHLGXQJ  

9HUJOHLFKGHU  (QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJDQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ UEHLWVSOlW HQ  

4.  Entscheidungsfindung in der Luftfahrt  

0HUNPDOH   

8QWHUVFKLHGHQDFK  )OXJ HXJPXVWHUQ  

5.  Weitere Aspekte der Entscheidungsfindung  

6LWXDWLYH  XIPHUNVDPNHLW  

  'HWHUPLQDWLRQGHV0HQVFKHQ  

LL   

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

$XWRPDWLRQLQGHU9HUNHKUVOXIWIDKUW««««««««««««««««« Fazit der bisherigen Ausführungen««««««««««««««««« Vorschlag eines Entscheidungsfindungsmodells für komplexe

Situationen.««««««««««««««««««««««««««««« Vorschlag eines grafischen Bewertungssystems für den Prozess der Entscheidungsfindung.«««««««««««««««««««««««

Ausblick auf die zukünftige Entwicklung der Entscheidungsfindung«««

Quellenangaben««««««««««««««««««««««««««« Anhang«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««

$EE(OHPHQWHGHV()3UR]HVVHV««««««««««««««««««« $EE=XVDPPHQKDQJ]ZLVFKHQ=HLWXQG$UWGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ«««« $EE=XVDPPHQKDQJ.RPSOH[LWlWXQG$UWGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ««««« $EE'DUVWHOOXQJGHU3RRU-XGJHPHQW&KDLQ««««««««««««««« $EE&5DSKLF ^‹ RKQH(LQWUDJXQJHQ«««« $EE&5DSKLF ^‹ VWXILJPLW(LQWUDJXQJHQ«« $EE&5DSKLF ^‹ VWXIHQORVVWXILJPLW(LQWUDJXQJHQ«« $EE127(&+V«««««««««««««««««««««««««««« Tabellenverzeichnis:

7DE.RQVHTXHQ]6WXIHQ«««««««««««««««««««««««««

7DE$QWZRUWHQDXIGLH7KHVH“My decision making ability is as good in medical emergencies as in routine situations”««««««««««««««««« 7DE$QWZRUWHQDXIGLH7KHVH“Junior team members should not question the decisions made by senior team members”«««««««««««««« 7DE+XPDQ)DLOXUH0RGHV«««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE9HUJOHLFKYRQ$UEHLWVSOlW]HQPLW()LQNRPSOH[HQ8PJHEXQJHQ«««««

LLL

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

7DE9RUEHUHLWXQJ±),7««««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE$QDO\VH±)25«««««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE(QWVFKHLGXQJ±'(&««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE$FWLRQ±)2' ^‹ ««««««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE&5DSKLF ^‹ ±9RUEHUHLWXQJ««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE&5DSKLF ^‹ ±$QDO\VH«««««««««««««««««««««««« 7DE&5DSKLF ^‹ ±(QWVFKHLGXQJ««««««««««««««««««««««

LY

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

1 Einleitung

3LORWHQIHKOHUVLQGPLWHW ZD3UR] HQWGLH+DX SWXUVDFKHI U8QIlOOHLQGHU/XIWIDKUW 6HLWZLUGHLQ OHLFKWHU5FNJDQ JLQGLH VHP$QWHLOYHU]HLFKQHW,QQ HUKDOEGLHVHU )HKOHUJUXSSHIDQGHLQH9HUVFKLHEXQ JGHU$QWHLOHVWDWW(VZLUGGDYRQ DXVJHJDQJHQ GDVVLQ 3UR]HQWDOOH UGXUFK0HQVFKHQYHUXUVDFKWHQ8Q IlOOHLQGHU /XIWIDKUWNHLQH RGHUXQ]XUHLFKHQGH(QWVFKHLGXQJHQJHWURIIHQZXUGHQ,P=HLWUDXPYRQELV ZDUHQGLHV3UR]HQW &),QIR $XFK DNWXHOOH=D KOHQGHU,QWHUQDWLRQDO$LU 7UDQVSRUW$VVRFLDWLRQ,$7$EHVWlWLJHQGLHV'DQDFKJDEHVEHL3UR]HQWGHU 8QIlOOH(LQIOVVHGXUFKHuman Errors,$7$

8QWHUVXFKXQJHQGHV86DPHULND QLVFKHQ0LQLVWHULXPVIU9HUNHKUVVLFKHUKHLW GHP National Transport Safety Board176%EHVDJHQGDVV 3UR]HQWDOOHU8QIlOOHX QG 3UR]HQWDOOHUIDWDOHQ 8QIlOOHDXIIDOVFKH3OD QXQJXQG(QWVFKHLGXQJ ]XUFN]XI K UHQVLQG176%'DEHLVLQG)HKOHULQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQ J()DOV7HLO GHVCrew Ressource Managements&50ODXW GHU(LQWHLOXQJGHU,$7$LQGLH8QIDO O NODVVH+ HLQ]XVWXIHQ

(LQHP|JOLFKH%HZHUWXQJVNDWHJRULHGHV&50VLQG GLH1 27(&+VVLHKH.DSLWHO $QKDQJ'LHVHZHUGHQGHILQLHUW .ODPSIHU%+lXVOHU 5)DKQHQEUXFN*XQG 1DHI:)lKLJ NHLWHQGLH VLFKDXIGLH (LQVWHOOXQJXQGGDV9HUKDOWHQGHV 3LOR WHQLP&RFNSLWEH]LH KHQ'DEHLKDEHQGLHVHNHLQHQGLUHNWHQ=XVD PPHQKDQJ ]XU

6WHXHUXQJGHV)OXJ]H XJV0DQDJHPHQWGHV6\VWHPVRG HU Standard Operating Pro-cedures623V'LH NOTECHs ZHUGHQLQYLHU+DXSWNDWHJRULHQXQWHUWHLOW=X VDP PHQDUEHLW)KUXQJVXQG0DQDJHPHQW6LWXDWLYH$XIPHUNVDPNHLW6$XQG()

'HILQLWLRQ8QIlOOHPLW7RGHVRSIHUQGXUFKGHQ8QIDOOVHOEVWRGHUELV]X7DJHQDFKGHP 8QIDOO176%

,$7$DFFLGHQWLQFLGHQWFDXVHFODVVLILFDWLRQ6WDQG-XQL0HQVFKOLFKH.DWHJRULHQ+80 +,QWHQWLRQDOQRQFRPSOLDQFHRIOLPLWDWLRQVRU623V+3URILFLHQF\VNLOOIDLOXUH +&RPPXQLFDWLRQPLVFRPPXQLFDWLRQPLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQV&50LVVXHV +3URFHGXUDOXQLQWHQWLRQDO+,QFDSDFLWDWLRQIDWLJXHSV\FKRORJLFDORUSK\VLRORJLFDO

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

2 Komplexe Entscheidungsfindung

2.1 Definition Entscheidungsfindung

,QHLQHUYRUKDQGHQHQ(QWVFKHLGXQ JVVLWXDWLRQ GLHYRUKHUUVFKWZHQQHVPLQGHVWHQV ]ZHL+DQGOXQJVDOWHUQDWLYHQJLEWPXVVHLQH(QWVFKHLGXQJJHWURIIHQZHUGHQ(LQH(QW VFKHLGXQJLVWGHILQLHUWDOVGLHÄ:DKO]ZLVFKHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQ³+RQRV 'DEHLKDWGLH() YRUGL HVHU$XVZDKOVWDWWJHIXQ GHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQG XQJ() ZLUG DOVEHZXVVWHU3UR]HVVDQJHVHKHQ GHUGDV6DPPHOQXQG $QDO\VLHUHQYRQ,QIRUPDWLR QHQXQGGDVGDUDXIED VLHUHQGH7UHIIHQHLQHU (QWVFKHLGXQJE]Z$XVZDKOHLQHU$OWHU QDWLYHEH]HLFKQHW %URFNKDXV

2.2 Theorie der Entscheidungsfindung

,QGHU)RUVFKXQJZHUGHQ]ZHL$UWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJ VWKHRULHXQWHUVFKLHGHQ' LH

SUlVNULSWLYHVRZLHGLHGHVNULSWLYH(QWVFKHLGXQJVWKHRULH 'LH$XIJDEHGHUSUlVNULSWLYHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVWKHRULHLVWHVIRUPDOLVLHUWH9HUIDKUHQ]XP 7UHIIHQYRQ (QWVFKHLGX QJHQDQKDQGYRQUDWLR QDOHQ.ULWHULHQEHUHLW]X VWHOOHQXPVR GHQ()3UR]HVV]XXQWHUVWW]HQ6RVROO]%GLH()GHU3LORWHQLP&RFNSLWHLQHV9 HU NHKUVIOXJ]HXJHVRGHUGLH(QWVFKH LGXQJHLQHV$U]WHVXQWHUVWW]WZHUGHQ'LH)UDJH VWHOOXQJLQQ HUKDOEGHUSUlVNULSWLY HQ(QWVFKH LGXQJVWKHRULHLVW:LH N|QQHQ() 3UR]HVVHEHVVHUDEODXIHQ"

,P *HJHQVDW]]XUSUlVNULSWLYHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJ VWKHRULHEHVFKUHLEWGLHGHVNULSWLYHGDV WDWVlFKOLFKH(QWVFKHLGX QJVYHUKDOWHQGHV0 HQVFKHQ,VWGLH.DSD]LWlWGHUNRJQLWLYHQ )lKLJNHLWHQHLQHV0HQVFKHQHUVFK|SIWGDQQILQGHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJHQE]ZGHU3UR] HVV GHU()QXUEHGLQJWUDWLRQDOVWDWW+LHUZLUGGHU)UDJHQDFKJHJDQJHQ:LHILQGHQ () 3UR]HVVHVWDWW"-XQJHUPDQQ+HWDO6

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

2.3 Entscheidungsarten

8QWHUVFKLHGHQZHUGHQNDQQHLQH(QWVFKHLGXQJ QDFKGHU6LWXDWLRQXQWHUGHUHQ%HGLQ JXQJVLHYRUZLHJHQGVWDWWILQGHW

x dynamisch:LQHLQHPEHZHJWHQ)DKU]HXJGKNHLQHVWDWLVFKH8PJHEXQJ x risikoreich: ]%5DXPIDKUW x komplex:]%/HLW]HQWUDOHHLQHV$WRPNUDIWZHUNV

'DEHLNDQQHLQH(QWVFK HLGXQJDXFKPHKUHUHQR GHUDOOHQGUHL.DWHJRULHQ]XJHRUGQHW ZHUGHQ6RVLQG NRPSOH[H(QWVFK HLGXQJHQLP&RFNSLW HLQHV9HUNHKUVIOXJ]HX JHV PHLVWDXFKGXUFKGLH'\QDPLNGHV7UDQVSRUWPLWWHOVEHHLQIOXVVW $X‰HUGHPNDQQXQWHUVFKLHGHQZHU GHQ wieGH U0HQVFKHLQH(QWVFKHLGXQJLQH LQHU 6LWXDWLRQIlOOW'LHVN|QQHQVHLQ

x Reflex:VRIRUWLJH5HDNWLRQDXIHLQHQ5HL]]%$EIDQJHQGHV.|USHUVPLWGHQ +lQGHQEHLP6WROSHUQ

x Heuristik:5HDNWLRQQ DFKHLQHPEHNDQQWHQ 6FKHPDGDVDXIGLH YRUKHUU VFKHQGH6LWXDWLRQDQJHZDQGWZLUGMHGRFKQLFKW]ZDQJVOlXILJ]XP(UIROJIKUW ]%EHLP9HUVXFKHLQH 7U]X|IIQHQDOOH6FKOVVHODXVSURELHUHQELV]XPHUV WHQSDVVHQGHQ

x Canned Decision:YRUKHUIHVWJHOHJWHV9RUJHKHQLP)DOOHGHILQLHUWHU.ULWHULHQ ]%GLHGXUFKHLQ%ULHILQJYRUKHU]ZLVFKHQ.DSLWlQXQG&RSLORWLP&RFNSLWRGHU GXUFK7UDLQLQJDEJHVWLPPWH9RUJHKHQVZHLVH x EF-Prozess:V.DSLWHO3UR]HVVGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

2.4 Merkmale von Komplexität

(LQHNRPSOH[H6LWXDWLRQRGHU8PJH EXQJNDQQGXUFKIROJHQ GH0HUNPDOHEHVFKULHEHQ ZHUGHQ+RILQJHU

x Umfang:9LHOH(OHPHQWHXQG5HODWLRQHQ]ZLVFK HQGHQ(OHPHQWHQPVVHQEH DFKWHWZHUGHQ

x Vernetzung:(OHPHQWHEHHLQIOXVVH QVLFK JHJH QVHLWLJ'LH 9HUlQGHUXQJHLQHV (OHPHQWVKDW(LQIOXVVDXIDQGHUH(OHPHQWHXVZ

x Irreversibilität:(QWZLFNOXQJHQVLQ GPHLVWQLFKW UHYHUVLEHO GDKHULVW( QWZLFN OXQJHLQHU/|VXQJQDFKÄ9HUVXFKXQG,UUWXP³PHLVWQLFKWP|JOLFK x Dynamik:(VILQGHWHLQHVWlQGLJH9HUlQGHUXQJGHU6LWXDWLRQVWDWW x Zeitverzögerung:'LH$XVZLUNXQJHQYRQ+DQGOXQJHQVLQ GPHLVWQLFKWGLUHNW HUNHQQEDU

x Informationsvielfalt: 9LHOHYHUIJEDUH'DWHQVLQGYRUKDQGHQGLHDXI5HOHYDQ] IUGLHYRUKHUUVFKHQGH6LWXDWLRQXQGZHQQEHQ|WLJWDXILKUH5LFKWLJNHLWJHSUIW ZHUGHQPVVHQ

x Schnittstelle Mensch - Maschine:]%LP &RFNSLW23/HLWVWDQGHLQHV .UDIWZHUNV

x Problemkonstellation meist unikal:(VNDQQNHLQHVWDQ GDUGLVLHUWH /|VXQJ DQJHZHQGHWZHUGHQ

%HUHLFKHNR PSOH[HU +DQGOXQJVSUR]HVVHJLEWH VLQVEHVRQG HUHLQGHQ%UDQFKHQ9HU NHKUVOXIWIDKUWFKHPLVFK H,QGXVWULH (QHUJLHYHUVRUJHU6WHXHUXQJYRQ .UDIWZHUNHQ 0HGL]LQ0LOLWlUVRZLH3ROL]HL)HXHUZHKU7HFKQLVFKHP+LOIVZHUNXQG5HWWXQJVRUJD QL VDWLRQHQ

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

3 Prozess der Entscheidungsfindung

3.1 Komponenten des Entscheidungsfindungsprozesses

8QDEKlQJLJGDYRQZHOFKHV0RGHOO]XU)LQGXQJ HLQHU(QWVFKHLGXQJDQJ HZHQGHWZLUG NDQQGHU3UR]HVVGHU( )LQ.RPSR QHQWHQXQWHUWHLOWZHUGHQ'LH5HLKHQIROJHGLHVHU .RPSRQHQWHQVROOWHGDEHLHLQJHKDOWHQZHUGHQXPHLQHQOHLVWXQJVIlKLJHQXQGVWUXNWX ULHUWHQ()3UR]HVV]XHUP|JOLFKHQ,Q$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQGHUYHUIJEDUHQ=HLWNDQQGLH 'DXHUGHUHLQ]HOQHQ.R PSRQHQWHMHQDFK6LWXDWLRQYDULLHUWZHUGHQ'DEHLPXVVEH DFKWHWZHUGHQGDVVGDV$XVODVVHQ HLQHUGHU.RPSRQHQWHQ]XHLQHUXQ]XUHLFKHQGH Q RGHUIDWDOHQ(QWVFKHLGXQJIKUHQNDQQ

'DV Erkennen einer EntscheidungssituationLVW GLH*UX QGODJHIU GHQ%HJLQQG HV ()3UR]HVVHV'DIUVROOWHVLFKGHU (QWVFKHLGHUGHUDNWXHOOHQ6LWXDWLRQEHZXVVWVHLQ ]%GHVDNWXHOOHQ=XVWDQGVGHV)OXJ]HXJHVXQGGHVVHQ8PJHEXQJ,QWHUQDWLRQDO KDW VLFKK LHUIU GHU%HJULII Situational Awareness6$]X'HXWVFKÄ6LWX DWLYH$XIP HUN VDPNHLW³HWDEOLHUWV. DSLWHO6 LWXDWLYH$XIPHUNVDPNHLW1XUVRNDQQGHU+DQG OXQJVEHGDUIIHVWJHVWHOOWZHUGHQ

'DQDFKIROJWGLH Analyse der Situation'LHVHVROOWH ]X %HJLQQ]HLWOLFKHLQJHVFK lW]W ZHUGHQGD YRQGLHVHP )DNWRUGLH$UWGHV(QWVFKHLGXQJVSUR ]HVVHVDEKlQJW(UVWGD QDFKVROOWH GLHYRUKHUUVFKHQGH6LWX DWLRQJHQDX DQDO\VLHUW ZHUGHQ(VLVWZLFKWLJ DQ GLHVHU6WHOOHGHV()3UR]HVVHVDOOHEHQ|WLJWHQ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ]XVDPPHOQGDVRQ VWLQ GHQQlFKVWHQ6FKULWWHQ DXIJUXQGGLHVHUPDQJHOQGHQRGHUI DOVFKHQ,QIRUPDWLRQHQXQ ]XUHLFKHQGH$OWHUQDWLYHQHQWZLFNHOW XQGVRDX FKHLQH VXERSWLPDOHRGHUIDWDOH(Q W VFKHLGXQJJ HWURIIHQZHUGHQN|QQWH'LH$QDO\V HLVWGLH*UXQGODJHGHVZHLWHUHQ()

4XDOLWlWGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJKlQJWYRQGHU$QDO\VHGHU6LWXDWLRQDE 'LHDefinition eines ZielesLVWHLQ ZLFKWLJHU6FKULWWEHLHLQ HUQLFKWDNX WHQDEHUNR P SOH[HQ(QWVFKHLGXQJVVLW XDWLRQ'DEHLNDQQGLH)UDJHVWHOOXQ JVHLQ:DVVROOHUUHLFK W ZHUGHQ",VWGDV=LHOPD [LPDOH6LFKHUKHLWRGHUQRFKPHKU]%3QNWOLFKNHLW.RPIRUW RGHU(IIL]LHQ]"'LH=LHOHN|QQHQLQ HLQHUVSH]LI LVFKHQ$UEHLWVXPJHEXQJZLH]%GHU 9HUNHKUVOXIWIDKUWIHVWJHOHJWVHLQV.DSLWHO(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJLQGHU/XIWIDKUW

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

1XQPVVHQP|JOLFKH Alternativen entwickeltZHUGHQ]ZLVFKHQGHQH QGLH(QWVFKHL GXQJVWDWWILQGHQE]ZZL HGDV=LHOHUUHLFKWZHUGHQVROO%H]RJHQDXIGLH/XIWIDKUWHLQ %HLVSLHO'DVUHFKWHGHU]ZHL7ULHEZHUNHHLQHV$LUEXV$LVWDXVJH IDOOHQ0|JOLFKH $OWHUQDWLYHQHUJHEHQVLFKQXQXD LQ$EKlQJLJNHLWYRQ:HWWHUXQGGHUEHUHLWV]XUFN JHOHJWHQ6WUHFNHVRZLHYRUKDQGQHQ5HVWNHURVLQPHQJHLQGHQ7DQNV x 5FNIOXJ]XP'HSDUWXUH$LUSRUW x :HLWHUIOXJQDFK3ODQ]XP'HVWLQDWLRQ$LUSRUW x :DKOHLQHV$XVZHLFKIOXJKDIHQVDXIGHU6WUHFNH

,P$QVFKOXVVGDUDQILQGHWGLH Abwägung der AlternativenVWDWW'DEHLPVVHQGLH IROJHQGHQ)UDJHVWHOOXQJHQEHDFKWHQZHUGHQ x :HOFKH5LVLNHQELHWHWMHGHGHUHQWZLFNHOWHQ$OWHUQDWLYH" x :HOFKH9RUWHLOHXQG*HZLQQHEULQJWMHGHGHU$OWHUQDWLYH" $QKDQGGLHVHU%HZHUWXQJGHU$OWHUQDWLYHQVROOW HGDQQGLH EntscheidungIUHLQHGHU HQWZLFNHOWHQ$OWHUQDWLYHQJHWURIIHQ XQGNRQVHTXHQWXPJHVHW]WZHUGHQ 'DEHLLVWH LQH VWlQGLJH(U JHEQLVNRQWUROOHQDFKG HP*UXQGV DW] „Expect the Unexpected!“XQHUOlVV OLFKXPLP=ZHLIHOGHQ3UR]HVVGHU()XQWHUGHQYHUlQGHUWHQ%HGLQJXQJHQQRFKPDOV EHLHLQHU$QDO\VHGHUQXQYHUlQGHUWHQ6LWXDWLRQ]XEHJLQQHQ

Ein Beispiel aus der Luftfahrt zum EF-Prozess: &),QIR

(LQ$LUEXV $EHILQG HWVLFKQ DFKGHP6WDUWLQ0QFKHQLP6WHLJIOXJLQ5LFKW XQJ 1RUGHQ*HSODQWHV=LHOLVWGHU)OXJKDIHQ+DPEXUJ'HU6WHLJIOXJZLUGXPGLHYRUKD Q GHQH9HUVSlWXQJDXI]XKROHQPLWHLQHU*HVFKZLQGLJNHLWYRQNWVGXUFKJHIKUW1DFK GHP3DVVLH UHQYRQ Flight Level)/ JHKW HLQ6FKWWHOQGXUFKGD V9HUNHKUVIOX J ]HXJ'LH9HUPXWXQJG DVVPDQGX UFKGLH9HUZLUEHOXQJHQHLQHVDQGHUHQ)OXJ]HXJ V JHIORJHQVHLZLUGQDFKZHLWHUDXIWUHWHQGHP6FK WWHOQYHUZRUIHQ'LH,QVWUXPHQWH]HL JHQHLQHQ$EIDOOGH VEngine Pressure Ratio(35YRQ7ULH EZHUN1XPPHUDQ$OOH DQGHUHQ7ULHEZHUNVSDUDPHWHUZDUHQLPQRUPDOHQ%HWULHEVEHUHLFK'HU.DSLWlQ&0 GHDNWLYLHUWG LHDXWRPDWLVFKH6FKXEU HJHOXQJXQ G]LHKWGHQ 6FKXEKHEHOGHV]ZHLW HQ 7ULHEZHUNVODQJVDPDXI/HHUODXI'DVEHHQGHW GDV6FKWWH OQGHV)OXJ ]HXJVLVWMH GRFKQLFKWGDVYRPElectronic Centralized Aircraft Monitor(&$0DQJH ]HLJWH9RUJH KHQ,QGHU.DELQHKDEHQ3DVVDJLHUHDPUHFKWHQ7ULHEZHUN)ODPPHQEHREDFKWHW 'LH

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

3XUVHUHWWHLQIRUPLHUWVLFK]ZDULP &RFNSLWEHUGLH6LWXDWLRQJLEWGLH%HREDFKWXQJGHU 3DVVDJLHUHMHGRFKQLFKWDQGLH3LORWHQZHLWHU

Bewertung:$QGLHVHU 6WHOOHGHV()3UR]HVVHVILQGHW NHLQHDXVUH LFKHQGH $QDO\VHGHU6LWXDWLRQ VWDWW(VZHU GHQQLFKW DOOHUHOHYDQWHQXQGYHUIJEDUHQ 4XHOOHQJHQXW]W6RKlWWHHLQHUGHU3LORWHQGLH.DELQHQEHVDW]XQJQDFK $XIIlO OLJNHLWHQNRQVXOWLHUHQN|QQHQ

7ULHEZHUN1XPPHU ZLUGDOVGHIHNWD N]HSWLHUW(LQ6WU|PXQJVDEULVVDQGLHVHP 7ULHEZHUNZLUGQLFKWLQ%HWUDFKWJH]RJHQ,Q)/ZLUG7ULHEZHUN1XPPHUDXI Ma- EHWUlJWQXQ ximum Continuous Thrust0&7JHVHW]W'LH5HLVHJHVFKZLQGLJNHLW NWV7ULH EZHUN1X PPHU OlXIW HLQZDQGIUHL%HL7ULHEZHUN1XPPH UGHXWHWL P /HHUODXIQLFKWVDXIHLQH )HKOIXQNWLRQKLQ'HU.DSLWlQYHUVXFKWYRUVLFKWLJGLH/HLVWX QJ GHV7ULHEZHUNV1XPPHU]XHUK|K HQMHGRFKVHW]WGDV6FKWWHOQZLHGHUHLQ'DUDXI KLQHQWVFKHLGHWVLFKGLH 3LORWHQQLFKWQDFK+D PEXUJ ZHLWHU]XIOLHJHQVRQGHUQLQ )UDQNIXUW]ZLVFKHQ]XODQGHQ

Bewertung:+LHUZLUGGL H(QWZLFNOXQJGHUP|JO LFKHQ$OWHUQDWLYHQQLFKWDXVUHL

ODQGHQREZRKOGLHVHULQGLUHNWHU1lKHLVW'LHVZlUHHLQHLQWHUHVVDQWH$OWHUQD WLYHJHZHVHQ

%HLP)UHTXHQ]ZHFKVHOQDFK)UDQNIXUWJHKWGLH3XUVHUHWWHHLQZHLWHUHV0DOLQV&RFN SLWXQGLQIRUPLHUWGLH&UHZQXQGDUEHUGDVVGLH3DVVDJLHUH)XQNHQXQG)ODPPHQDQ 7ULHEZHUNJHVHKHQ KDEHQ:lKUHQGGHV6LQ NIOXJHVSUIHQGLH3LORW HQGHQELVK HUL JHQ9HUODXIGHV Abnormals'DEHLEHPHUNHQ VLHGDVVHLQH&KHFNOLVW HIUGHQ6W U| PXQJVDEULVVDQHLQHP7ULHEZHUNYRUKDQGHQLVW'LH(UNOlUXQJGHV.DSLWlQVIUG DV VSlWH,GHQWLIL]LHUHQGHU 6LWXDWLRQXQG/HVHQGHU&KHFNOLVW HODXWHWGDVVGDV(&$0 NHLQH0HOGXQJJHQHULHUWKDEHXQGGLH7ULHEZHUNVSDUDPHWHULPPHUQRUPDOJHZHVHQ VHLHQ

Bewertung:'LHVH%HWUDFKWXQJGHVHLJHQHQ+D QGHOQV]HLJWGLH$XVZLUNXQJHQ GHV Confirmation BiasGHV0HQV FKHQV.DSLWHO(LQIOVVH,Q VJHVDPW ZXUGHEHL GLHVHP%HLVSLHO NHLQH NRRUGLQLHUWH()GXUFKJ HIKUW'LH JHQDXH $QDO\VHGHU6LWXDWLRQJOHLFK]X%HJLQQGHV3URE OHPVPLW7UL HEZHUN1XPPHU KlWWHYHUPXWOLFKGLH,GH QWLILNDWLRQGHU8UVDFKHGHQ6WU|PXQJVDEULVV DQ7ULHE ZHUN1XPPHUXQGVRPLWDXFKGHUHQ%HKHEXQJEHUHLQ623P|J OLFKJH

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

PDFKW'LHVHV%HLVSLHO]HLJWDXFKZLHZLFKWLJHVLVWDOOHP|JOLFKHQ2SWLRQHQ EHZXVVW]X VDPPHQ]XWUDJHQ6R ZlUHHLQH DiversionQDFK1UQEHUJ LQGLH VHP)DOOVLFKHUOLFKIUGHQ*UDGGHU8QVLFKHUKHLWGHU6LWXDWLRQGLHEHVWH$OWHU QDWLYHJHZHVHQ

$EE(OHPHQWHGHV()3UR]HVVHV

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

3.2 Modelle der Entscheidungsfindung

(VJLEWPHK UHUHEHNDQQ WH0RGHOOH ]XU()$Q GLHVHU6WHOOHVROOHQGLH EHNDQQWHVW HQ DXIJHIKUWZHUGHQ'|UQHUGHILQLHUWHIROJHQGH.RPSRQHQWHQGHU()'|UQHU x=LHODXVDUEHLWXQJ x 0RGHOOELOGXQJXQG,QIRUPDWLRQVVDPPOXQJ x 3URJQRVHXQG([SORUDWLRQ x 3ODQXQJYRQ$NWLRQHQ x (QWVFKHLGXQJXQG'XUFKIKUXQJYRQ$NWLRQHQ x (IIHNWHQNRQWUROOHXQG5HYLVLRQGHU+DQGOXQJVVWUDWHJLHQ

,QGHU/XIWIDKUWVLQG0RGHOOHEHNDQQWEHLGHQHQMHGHU%XFKVWDEHHLQHV.XQVWZRUWHVIU GHQHUVWHQ %XFKVWDEHQGHU%H]HLFKQXQJHLQHU .RPSRQHQWHGHV()3UR]HVVHVVWH KW ZLH]%GDVDECIDE-Modell%HQQHU ' ± 'HWHFW ± (VWLPDWH & ± &KRRVH , ± ,GHQWLI\ ' ± 'R ( ± (YDOXDWH

'DVDODAR-ModellLVWGDVEHL%ULW LVK$LUZD\V YHUZHQGHWH()0RGHOO,P*HJHQVDW] ]X'(&,'(HQWKlOWHVQLFKWH[SOL]LWGLH%HWUDFKWXQJGHV5LVLNRVGHU $OWHUQDWLYHQ0XO OLQVHWDO ' ± 'LDJQRVLV 2± 2SWLRQV ' ± 'HFLGH $ ± $VVLJQ 5 ± 5HYLHZ

)HOL[$0DQQV0|JOLFKNHLWHQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJ

,QGHQ86$ZHLWYHUEUHLWHWLVWGDVDESIDE-Modell0XUUD\ ' ± 'HWHFW&KDQJH ( ± (VWLPDWH6LJQLILFDQFH 6 ± 6HW6DIH2EMHFWLYHV , ± ,GHQWLI\2SWLRQV ' ± 'R%HVW2SWLRQ ( ± (YDOXDWH

bKQOLFKGHP'(&,'(0RGHOOLVWLQ HLQHUJUR‰HQGHXWVFKHQ )OXJJHVHOOVFKDIWNRQ]HU Q ZHLWYRUJHJHEHQH FORDEC-Modell: +LHUZLUGLP9HUJOHLFK]XP'(&,'(0RGHOO GLH 5LVLNRHLQVFKlW]XQJDOVZLFKWLJHU7HLOGHU()EHWRQW'LHVH6WDQGDUGLVLHUXQJHUOHLFKWHUW GHQLQWHULQG LYLGXHOOHQ,Q IRUPDWLRQVDXVWDXVFKX QGGLH&UH ZPLWJOLHGHUEOHLEHQ KD QG OXQJVNRPSHWHQWV.DSLWHO(QWVFKHLGXQJVILQGXQJLQGHU/XIWIDKUW0HUNPDOH

3.3 Entscheidungsregeln

5HJHOQGHU(QWVFKHLGXQJ(5N|QQHQLQQHUKDOEHLQHVGHU0RGHOOHLQGHU.RPSRQHQWH GHU$XVZDKOGHU$OWHUQDW LYHQDQJHZHQGHWZHUGHQ%HL'|UQ HULVWGDVGHU3XQNWÄ(QW VFKHLGXQJXQG'XUFKIKUXQJYRQ$N WLRQHQ³EHL'2'$5GLH 6WXIHÄ'HFLGH³'(6,'( Ä'REHVW2SWLRQ³'(&,'(Ä&KRRVH³XQG)25'(&Ä'HFLVLRQ³

'LHQDFKIROJHQGH7DEHOOHYHUGHXWOLFKWGLHVDQKDQGHLQHUNRQVWUXLHUWHQ(QWVFKHLGXQ JV VLWXDWLRQPLW GUHLP|JOLFKHQ2SWLRQHQ$%XQG &VRZLHGHU$QJDEHGDUEHUZHOFKH $XVZLUNXQJHQGLH.RQVHTXHQ]HQ((XQG(DXIGLHYRUKDQGHQH6LWXDWLRQKDEHQ

7DE.RQVHTXHQ]6WXIHQ VHKUQHJDWLYH. VHKUSRVLWLYH.