1. Einleitung

„ $OOHH0HQVFKHQQVLQGGYRUUGHPP*HVHW]JOHLFK

0lQQHUUXQGG)UDXHQQVLQGGJOHLFKEHUHFKWLJW>«@

1LHPDQGGGDUIIZHJHQ>«@VHLQHUU+HLPDWWXQGG+HUNXQIWW>«@EHQDFKWHLOLJWWRGHUU

EHYRU]XJWZHUGHQ³ 1

$OOHH GUHLL YRUVWHKHQG JHQDQQWHQQ $EVlW]H UHSUlVHQWLHUHQQ IUU MHGHUPDQQQ YHUVWlQGOLFKH XQXPVW|‰OLFKHH XQGG VLFK HLJHQWOLFKK GHP JHVXQGHQQ 0HQVFKHQYHUVWDQGG DOVV YROONRPPHQ ORJLVFKKGDUVWHOOHQGHH*UXQGUHFKWHZHOFKHLQQXQVHUHUPRGHUQHQSOXUDOLVWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW ZHLWKLQQDQHUNDQQWWXQGGJHDFKWHWWZHUGHQ6RRVFKHLQWHV

%H]RJHQQ DXII GDVV GHXWVFKHH %LOGXQJVV\VWHPP PLWW VHLQHPP I|GHUDOHQQ $XIEDX PXVVV DOOHUGLQJV GLHH)UDJHH JHVWDWWHWWVHLQZDUXPP JHQDXXGRUWZRR %XQGGXQGG /lQGHUUGLHH0|JOLFKNHLWWKDEHQ DXII GLHH 4XDOLWlWW XQG 4XDQWLWlWW IROJHQGHUU *HQHUDWLRQHQQ YRQ +XPDQ 5HVVRXUFHVV HLQ]XZLUNHQ VLFK GLH 8PVHW]XQJ GLHVHUU HUVWJHQDQQWHQ GRFKK HLJHQWOLFKK VRR HLQIDFK ]XX YHUVWHKHQGHQQ *UXQGUHFKWHH VRR VFKZLHULJ JHVWDOWHW $QGHUVKHUXPP VWHOOWW VLFKK QDWUOLFK HEHQIDOOVVGLHH)UDJHZRRGLHVHH5HFKWHHQXQQJHQDXXYHUOHW]WZHUGHQ"%HUHLWVVVFKULHEEGDVV 0DJD]LQQ GHUU 6SLHJHOO EHU GLHH 0DURWWHQ ED\HULVFKHUU .XOWXVPLQLVWHU ZHOFKHH PLWW teils JURWHVNHQQ %HJUQGXQJHQQ $ELWXU]HXJQLVVH QLFKWW DQHUNDQQWHQ ZHLOO VLHH LQQ DQGHUHQQ %XQGHVOlQGHUQQ DOVV %D\HUQQ HUZRUEHQQ ZRUGHQ ZDUHQ ZHOFKH KLHUU XQG GDD PLWW GHU $XVJHVWDOWXQJ GHU ED\eULVFKHQ 3ULPDUVWXIHH JHJHQQ JHOWHQGHH .0.-9HUHLQEDUXQJHQQ YHUVWLH‰HQQ RGHU DEHU WROHULHUWHQ GDVV PLWWHOVV JUR‰]JLJHU 1RWHQEHUHFKQXQJHQ LQQ GHUU 2EHUVWXIHH GHPP HLQHQQ RGHUU DQGHUHQQ 6FKOHU ]XPP $ELWXUU YHUKoOIHQQ ZXUGH ZHOFKHUU LQQ DQGHUHQQ%XQGHVOlQGHUQQGDPLW DOOHUGLQJV NQDSSSGLHH0LQGHVWSXQNW]DKOOYHUIHKOWWKlWWH.DQQ KLHUEHLL GDQQQ ZLUNOLFKK QRFKK YRQQ HLQHUU 1LFKW-%HYRUWHLOXQJ RGHUU HEHQQ DXFKK HLQHUU 1LFKW%HQDFKWHLOLJXQJ YRQ 0HQVFKHQQ XQDEKlQJLJ LKUHU +HUNXQIWW JHVSURFKHQQ ZHUGHQ" .ULWLNHU

EHKDXSWHQ LQQ HLQHPP ]HQWUDOVWDDWOLFKK JHOHQNWHQ %LOGXQJVV\VWHPP KlWWHH VRR HWZDVV QLFKWW YRUNRPPHQQN|QQHQ%HNDQQWHUPD‰HQJLEWWHVVDEHU.ULWLNHUUIUUAOOHVXQGGJHGHQGRFKKHEHQ JHUDGH EHLPP %LOGXQJVI|GHUDOLVPXVV LVWW GLHH )UDJHH QDFKK GHPP 6LQQQ RGHUU 8QVLQQQ XQGG GLHH VWlQGLJH 'LVNXVVLRQHQQ EHUU HLQHH ZHLWW UHLFKHQGH bQGHUXQJ GHVV EHVWHKHQGHQQ 6\VWHPVV VHLWW -DKU]HKQWHQ LPPDQHQW 6HLQH 9RU]JH VWHOOHQ VLFK LQQ GHUU $UJXPHQWDWLRQQ HLJHQWOLFKK DOVV

VLQQYROOOXQGGORJLVFKKGDU Xnd GRFKKZXUGHHE]Z ZLUG LPPHUUZLHGHUUGLHH)UDJHJHVWHOOW+DWW VLFKKGHUU%LOGXQJVI|GHUDOLVPXVVVHOEVWWEHUOHEW"

8P GLHVH )UDJH ]X NOlUHQ PXVV PDQ ]XHUVW HLQHQ %OLFNN DXII GLHH 6WUXNWXUHQQ GHUU HLQ]HOQHQQ 2UJDQLVDWLRQV- XQGG(QWVFKHLGXQJVHEHQHQQYRQQ%XQGGXQGG/lQGHUQQZHUIHQ'HUU)RFXVVZLUG KLHUEHLL NODU LQQ GHUU 9HUWHLOXQJ GHU .RPSHWHQ]HQ LQQ GHQ 0LWWHOQQ ]XUU 6WHXHUXQJ GHU %LOGXQJVSROLWLNN XQGG den -WURW]] ZHLWUHLFKHQGHU $XWRQRPLHH GHUU /lQGHU- EHVWHKHQGHn 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ GHU .RRSHUDWLRQQ ]ZLVFKHQQ EXQGHV- XQGG ODQGHVVWDDWOLFKHUU (EHQHH OLHJHQ 'LHVHH JUXQGVlW]OLFKHI|GHUDOH$XWRQRPLHHGHU /lQGHULVWWLPP*UXQGJHVHW]IHVWJHVFKULHEHQ XQGGGDKHUUDXFKKQLFKWW*HJHQVWDQGGGLHVHUU$UEHLW'LHH0|JOLFKNHLWWDXIIZHLWHQQ7HLOHQQDOOein XQGGEXQGHVVWDDWOLFKKXQDEKlQJLJ]XXHQWVFKHLGHQ KDWWVHLWWMHKHUUKRKHHNXOWXUHOOHH%HGHXWXQJ ZHQQJOHLFKK GLHVHH LQQ 'LVNXVVLRQHQQ RIWPDOVV KLQWHUU GLHH QLFKWW ]X YHUOHXJQHQGHQQ 1DFKWHLOH ODQGHVKRKHLWOLFKHUU %LOGXQJVHQWVFKHLGXQJHQQ JHVWHOOWW ZLUG .DSLWHOO GUHLL ZLUGG VLFh daher GLHVHQQ &KDQFHQQ XQG .ULWLNSXQNWHQQ ZLGPHQ. 'D]XX ZHUGHQQ GLHH 9RUWHLOHH YRQQ 9LHOIDOWW XQGG :HWWEHZHUEE HEHQVRR EHUFNVLFKWLJWW ZLH GDVV QRWZHQGLJHH *HERWW DXII GHPP JHVDPWHQ %XQGHVJHELHWW HLQKHLWOLFKHH *UXQGVWUXNWXUHQQ ]XX JHZlKUOHLVWHQ 'LHVHUU ]XJHJHEHQHUU 0D‰HQ NRPSOL]LHUWHH 'UDKWVHLODNW ZXUGHH ELVKHUU YRQQ GHQQ EHWHLOLJWHQQ SROLWLVFKHQQ $NWHXUHQ ZHLWHVWJHKHQGGYHUPLHGHQZHVKDOEEGLHVH$UEHLWW]XXHLQHPJHZLVVHQ$QWHLOODOVV.ULWLNNDQQGHUU JlQJLJHQQ3UD[LVVLPPGHXWVFKHQQ%LOGXQJVV\VWHPPYHUVWDQGHQQZHUGHQQGDUI

2. Überblick über die föderalen Ebenen deutscher Bildungspolitik

.RPSHWHQ]HQQGHUU/lQGHU

'HUU 7UDGLWLRQQ VHLWW GHP +HLOLJHQ 5|PLVFKHQ 5HLFK 'HXWVFKHU 1DWLRQQ IROJHQGG ZXUGH QDFKGHPPGLH1DWLRQDOVR]LDOLVWHQQGXUFKKGLHHVRRJHQDQQWHH*OHLFKVFKDOWXQJGHQ)|GHUDOLVPXV GHH IDFWRR XQG GHH MXUHH EHVHLWLJWW KDWWHQ LPP *UXQGJHVHW]] YRQQ DXFK GLHH WUDGLWLRQHOOHH I|GHUDOH 2UGQXQJ ZLHGHUU HLQJHIKUWW XQG HUODXEWHH HV GDPLWW GHQQ /lQGHUQQ ZLHGHU sich ZHLWHVWJHKHQGG DXWRQRP VHOEVWW ]X YHUZDOWHQQ XQGG DXFKK LKUHH HLJHQHQQ 9HUIDVVXQJHQQ XQGG *HVHW]] ]XX HUODVVHQ $UWLNHO ** OHJWW KLHUEHLL JDQ]] NODUU IHVW GDVV GLHH (UIOOXQJ GHU VWDDWOLFKHQQ $XIJDEHQQ XQGG $XVEXQJJ VWDDWOLFKHUU %HIXJQLVVHH YRUUDQJLJ /lQGHUVDFKHH LVW VRODQJHHVLHHNHLQHH%XQGHVDQJHOHJHQKHLWHQQEHWUHIIHQQRGHUUGDVV*UXQGJHVHW]]DQGHUZHLWLJGHPP

%XQGG GLH .RPSHWHQ] ]XUU *HVHW]VSUHFKXQJ ]XVDJW ,QVEHVRQGHUH GLHH %HUHLFKH %LOGXQJ :LVVHQVFKDIWWXQGG.XOWXUPDFKHQQGLHHVRRJHQDQQWH.XOWXUKRKHLWWGHUU/lQGHUDXVDXIIZHOFKH GHUU %XQGHVWDJ XQGG GLHH %XQGHVUHJLHUXQJ DOVV 9HUWUHWXQJ GHVV JHVDPWGHXWVFKHQQ 6WDDWHVV ELVV KHXWH LPPHUU ZLHGHU PLWW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQQ (UIROJ YHUVXFKW KDWW (LQIOXVVV ]XX QHKPHQ. ⁴ 'LH .RPSHWHQ]HQQ GHUU /lQGHUU LQ GHUU *HVHW]JHEXQJ EHVFKUlQNHQQ VLFKK GDEHLL QLFKWW QXUU DXII GDVV 6FKXO- XQGG +RFKVFKXOZHVHQ VRQGHUQQ XPIDVVHQ DXFKK %HUHLFKHH GHUU (UZDFKVHQHQ- XQG :HLWHUELOGXQJ 5

'LHH 7DWVDFKH GDVV EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH *UXQGVFKXONLQGHUU EH]LHKXQJVZHLVHH GHUHQQ (OWHUQ DXV 1RUGUKHLQ-:HVWIDOHQQ EHUHLWV QDFKK GHP YLHUWHQ 6FKXOMDKUU HQWVFKHLGHQQ PVVHQ DXII ZHOFKH 2EHUVFKXOHHLKUU.LQGGVSlWHUUJHKHQQZLUGZRKLQJHJHQQ6FKOHUUXQGG(OWHUQQLQ%HUOLQQ]%ELVV ]XPPVHFKVWHQQ6FKXOMDKUU=HLWWKDEHQLVWWGHPP8PVWDQGGJHVFKXOGHWGDVVVGLH(QWVFKHLGXQJHQQ EHUU 6FKXOSIOLFKWGDXHU GLHH hEHUJlQJH ]ZLVFKHQ GHQQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQQ 6FKXODUWHQQ XQGG GLH YHUJHEHQHQQ$EVFKOVVHHLQQGHU9HUDQWZRUWXQJGHUHLQ]HOQHQQ/lQGHUOLHJHQ$XFKKEHVWHKHQ LQQ HLQLJHQQ /lQGHUQQ EHVRQGHUHH )RUPHQQ GHV hEHUJDQJVV YRPP .LQGHUJDUWHQQ LQQ GLHH *UXQGVFKXOHH EHUU VR JHQDQQWHH 6FKXONLQGHUJlUWHQQ RGHUU 9RUNODVVHQ Weitere 8QJOHLFKPl‰LJNHLWHQQEHVWHKHQQLQQGHU 'DXHUUGHUU9ROO]HLWVFKXOSIOLFKWZHOFKHHMH QDFKK/DQGG ]ZLVFKHQQ QHXQQ XQGG ]HKQ -DKUHQ VFKZDQNW *HPl‰‰ HLQHUU 9HUHLQEDUXQJ GHUU 6WlQGLJHQ .XOWXVPLQLVWHUNRQIHUHQ] GHUU/lQGHULQQGHUU%XQGHVUHSXEOLNN'HXWVFKODQGG.0. sollten die $QHUNHQQXQJ YRQQ6FKXODEVFKOVVHQQXQGGGLHH 'XUFKOlVVLJNHLWW]ZLVFKHQQGHQYHUVFKLHGHQHQ 6FKXODUWHQQ OlQGHUEHUJUHLIHQGG MHGRFKK JUXQGVlW]OLFKK JHZlKUOHLVWHWW VHLQ ⁶ 'DVV HLQOHLWHQGHH

%HLVSLHOOKDWWDOOHUGLQJVJH]HLJWGDVVVGLHVVQLFKWWLPPHUUGHUU)DOOOLVW

,P %HUHLFKK GHUU %HUXIVDXVELOGXQJ WHLOHQQ VLFK /lQGHUU XQGG :LUWVFKDIWW GLHH .RPSHWHQ] IU 9HUZDOWXQJ XQGG (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ ,P GXDOHQQ 6\VWHPP EHUQHKPHQQ ZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHH %HWULHEHH GLHH SUDNWLVFKHH $XVELOGXQJ LQQ GHQQ 5lXPOLFKNHLWHQQ LKUHr 8QWHUQHKPHQ ZRKLQJHJHQQ GLHH /lQGHU PLWW GHPP 6WHXHUXQJVLQVWUXPHQWW GHU 5DKPHQOHKUSOlQH ]XVWlQGLJ VLQGG IUU ⁷ 2UJDQLVDWLRQQXQGG.RQ]HSWLRQQGHUEHUXIOLFKHQQ6FKXOELOGXQJLQQGHQQ%HUXIVVFKXOHQ

$XFKK LPP GULWWHQQ =ZHLJJ SROLWLVFKHUU %LOGXQJVDUEHLW GHUU +RFKVFKXOSROLWLN JLEWW HVV HLQHH =ZHLWHLOXQJZHOFKHLQQGLHVHP)DOOOMHGRFKK]ZLVFKHQQ%XQGXQGG/lQGHUQEHVWHKW,VW3ROLWLN

⁴ Vgl. Reuter (1996), S. 40.

⁵ Vgl. Sekretariat der KMK (2006), S. 32.

⁶ Vgl. Sekretariat der KMK (2009), S. 3.

⁷ Vgl. Wolf (2006), S. 221.

IUUGLHH+RFKVFKXOHQXQGGHUHQ7UlJHUVFKDIWJHQHUHOOO/lQGHUVDFKHJLEWWGHUU%XQGPLWWGHP +RFKVFKXOUDKPHQJHVHW]] GHQQ /lQGHUQQ GRFKK HLQHQQ UHODWLYY GHWDLOOLHUWHQQ XQGG GDPLW ]ZDQJVOlXILJHQJHQQ+DQGOXQJVVSLHOUDXPPYRU

(EHQIDOOVV LQQ GLH =XVWlQGLJNHLWW GHUU /lQGHU IlOOW GLH IUU DOOH GUHLL 7HLOEHUHLFKH ZLFKWLJH DGPLQLVWUDWLYHHXQGGJHVHW]JHEHQGHH.RPSHWHQ]LQQGHUU$XV- XQGG:HLWHUELOGXQJVRZRKOOYRQ /HKUSHUVRQDO DOVV DXFKK LKUHUU /DQGHVEHGLHQVWHWHQ ZDVV DXFKK GLHH )LQDQ]LHUXQJ YRQQ 7HLOHQ GHVV%LOGXQJVZHVHQVVLQQODQGHVKRKHLWOLFKHH+lQGHOHJW 8

(LQHH NRQNUHWHH $XIJDEHQWHLOXQJ LVWW LPP *UXQGJHVHW]] QLFKWW ]XX ILQGHQ VRR GDVVV VLFKK PLWW GHUU =HLWW GXUFKK GLH GH MXUH DOOHLQLJHH *HVHW]JHEXQJVNRPSHWHQ] GHU %XQGHVOlQGHUU HLQQ YLHOJHVWDOWHWHVV %LOGXQJVZHVHQQ HQWZLFNHOWW KDW LQQ GHPP GHUU ELOGXQJVSROLWLVFKHH +DQGOXQJVVSLHOUDXPPGHUU/lQGHULPP9HUJOHLFKK]XPP%XQG ]XPLQGHVWWKHRUHWLVFK ZHVHQWOLFKK

.RPSHWHQ]HQQGHVV%XQGHV

$XII%XQGHVHEHQHELOGHWWGDVV%XQGHVPLQLVWHULXPPIUU%LOGXQJXQGG)RUVFKXQJ %0%) den LQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQQ 5DKPHQQ IUU OlQGHUEHUJUHLIHQGH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ ZREHLL GDVV *UXQGJHVHW]]

'LHH=XVWlQGLJNHLWWGHVV%XQGHVVLVWWLPPWHUWLlUHQQ%HUHLFKDOVR EHLVSLHOVZHLVH LPP%HUHLFKKGHUU :HLWHUELOGXQJDOOJHPHLQXPIDQJUHLFKHUUJHVWDOWHWWDOVVLPP3ULPDU- RGHUU6HNXQGDUEHUHLFK6RR ZLUGG DXI %XQGHVHEHQHH EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH EHUU *HVHW]HH IUU DX‰HUVFKXOLVFKH EHUXIOLFKH $XV-XQGG :HLWHUELOGXQJ XQG IUU 5DKPHQEHGLQJXQJHQQ GHV DOOJHPHLQHQ +RFKVFKXOZHVHQV HQWVFKLHGHQ:HQQJOHLFKGLH)LQDQ]LHUXQJ ]XPPJUR‰HQQ7HLO GHQQ/lQGHUQQ]XIlOOWVRRKDWWGHUU %XQGGGRFKKGLHH*HVHW]JHEXQJVNRPSHWHQ]EHUGLHH%HVROGXQJXQG9HUVRUJXQJGHUU%HDPWHQ ZLHH /HKUNUlIWHQQ XQG +RFKVFKXOOHKUHUQ JHQDXVRR ZLHH HUU ZHLWHUKLQQ 5HJHOXQJHQQ EHUU GLHH 5HFKWVYHUKlOWQLVVHLPP|IIHQWOLFKHQQ'LHQVWWHUOlVVW 11

⁸ Vgl. Wolf (2006), S. 222.

⁹ ebd., S. 222.

¹⁰ ebd., S. 221.

¹¹ Vgl. Sekretariat der KMK (2006), S. 33.

8PP IU Jeden LQQ GHUU %XQGHVUHSXEOLNN DQQlKHUQGHH &KDQFHQJOHLFKKHLWW ]X JHZlKUOHLVWHQ HQJDJLHUWW VLFK GHU %XQGG EHVRQGHUVV PLWW ILQDQ]LHOOHQQ 0LWWHOQQ DQQ GHU )|UGHUXQJ YRQQ $XVELOGXQJHQQXQGEHVRQGHUVVGHUUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQQ)RUVFKXQJVRZLH GHUUWHFKQRORJLVFKHQQ *HQHUHOOOVSLHOWWGHU

ILQDQ]LHOOH$VSHNWWEHLLGHQQ.RPSHWHQ]HQQGHVV%XQGHVVHLQHHJU|‰HUH5ROOHHDOVVEHL denen der /lQGHU %HUXIVDXVELOGXQJVI|UGHUXQJ XQGG %HUXIVDXVELOGXQJVEHLKLOIHH VLQGG GLHH EHLGHQ ZLFKWLJVWHQQ,QVWUXPHQWHGHVV%XQGHVVXPPHLQHQQ*UR‰WHLOOYRQQ$XV]XELOGHQGHQQGHQQJOHLFKHQ ILQDQ]LHOOHQQ5DKPHQQ]XNRPPHQQ]XODVVHQXQDEKlQJLJGDYRQQLQQZHOFKHP%XQGHVODQGGsie LKUHH$XVELOGXQJDEVROYLHUHQ

,P %HUHLFKK GHUU +RFKVFKXOSROLWLNN LVWW GHUU %XQGG DXII DOOJHPHLQHH *UXQGVlW]HH PLWW HLQHU 5DKPHQJHVHW]JHEXQJ EHVFKUlQNW ZLUNWW KLHUEHLL DOOHUGLQJV EHVRQGHUVV LPP $XVV XQGG 1HXEDX YRQQ +RFKVFKXOHQQ XQGG LQ GHUU 3ODQXQJ VRZLH )|UGHUXQJ YRQQ (LQULFKWXQJHQ XQGG 9RUKDEHQ EHUUHJLRQDOHU ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHUU )RUVFKXQJHQ LQQ JUR‰HPP 0D‰HH PLWW GHQQ /lQGHUQQ ]XVDPPHQ 'LHH2UJDQHHXQGG,QVWLWXWLRQHQQIUUGLHVHVVEHUJUHLIHQGHH=XVDPPHQZLUNHQQYRQQ %XQGGXQGG/lQGHUQQZHUGHQQLPPIROJHQGHQQ$EVDW]QRFKKJHQDXHUUEHOHXFKWHW

BeVRQGHUVV SUREOHPDWLVFK VWHOOHQQ VLFKK DXII %XQGHVHEHQHH ZHLWW UHLFKHQGHH ELOGXQJVSROLWLVFKHH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQQ LPP 6FKDWWHQQ YRQQ ,QWHUHVVHQYHUElQGHQ 3DUWHLHQ XQG QLFKWVWDDWOLFKHQQ $NWHXULQQ GDU ZHVKDOE LQQ GHUU )|GHUDOLVPXVUHIRUPP YRQQ GLHH hEHUDUEHLWXQJJ GHU EXQGHVVWDDWOLFKHQQ2UGQXQJEHVFKORVVHQQZXUGHLQGHUHQ=XJH*HVHW]JHEXQJVNRPSHWHQ]HQQ LQQ GHQQ %HUHLFKHQ %LOGXQJ :LVVHQVFKDIWW XQG )RUVFKXQJ YRPP %XQG DXI GLHH /lQGHU ¹⁴ EHUWUDJHQQZXUGH

.RRUGLQLHUXQJXQGG.RRSHUDWLRQVSDUWQHU

'HUU $QIRUGHUXQJ GHUU %HZDKUXQJ I|GHUDOHUU (LJHQKHLWHQQ GHUU /lQGHUU EHLL JOHLFK]HLWLJHU 6WLIWXQJ NXOWXUHOOHUU (LQKHLWW LPP *HVDPWVWDDW XQG GHP GDUDXVV UHVXOWLHUHQGHQQ VWlQGLJHQ $EVWLPPXQJVEHGDUIILVWWHVVJHVFKXOGHWGDVVVLQ'HXWVFKODQGGHLQHH9LHO]DKOOYRQQ9HUZDOWXQJ-

¹² Vgl.Sekretariat der KMK (2006), S. 32f.

¹³ ebd., S. 33.

¹⁴ Vgl. Straubhaar (1996), 10f.