,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV

'LH$QVHOP*DXQLOR.RQWURYHUVH

=LHOVHW]XQJJXQGG$XIEDXXGLHVHUU$UEHLWW±±'LHH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVIUDJHQQ ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHVV/LEHUSURRLQVLSLHQWH>@ 3UlOLPLQDULHQQ 'LHH7H[WJUXQGODJHH

'LHH.ULWLNNGHVV7RUHQDPPPRGDOLVLHUWHQQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLV

5HNRQVWUXNWLRQQGHUU*DXQLOR.ULWLNNDPPPRGDOLVLHUWHQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLV

=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJGHU(UJHEQLVVHGHU5HNRQVWUXNWLRQQ $QVHOPV(UZLGHUXQJJDXIIGLH.ULWLNN*DXQLORVLQQ5HVSRQVLR>@ %HDQWZRUWXQJGHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVIUDJHQ

'LHH$QVHOP*DXQLOR.RQWURYHUVH

%HUHLWVVLQGHU9RUUHGHHJLEWWHUNODU]XXHUNHQQHQZRULQVHLQQ9RUKDEHQQEHVWHKW

$QVHOP GHUGHP 2UGHQ GHU %HQHGLNWLQHUDQJHK|UWHKDWWHH DXII %LWWHQQ VHLQHU *ODXEHQVEUGHU KLQQ HLQH 6FKULIWGDVV0RQRORJLRQ 0YHUIDVVW'HU+DXSW]ZHFNNGLHVHVV:HUNHVVEHVWHKWGDULQGLHHÄZDKUKDIWH³ ([LVWHQ] *RWWHVV ]XEHZHLVHQXQG ]XX ]HLJHQ GDVVVGLHVHU GDVV ÄK|FKVWH *XW³ VHL 'RFK LVWW LKP GLHV± VHLQHU$QVLFKWWQDFKK±±QXUGXUFKKHLQHHZHLWYHU]ZHLJWHH$UJXPHQWDWLRQQJHOXQJHQ(LQ=LHOGHVV3URVORJLRQ VROO HVV QXQQ VHLQ PLWW +LOIHHQXU HLQHVV $UJXPHQWVVJHQDXX GDV ]XXHUUHLFKHQ ZDVV LKP LP0RQRORJLRQQXU GXUFKKGLH9HUNHWWXQJJYLHOHU$UJXPHQWHHJHOXQJHQVFKLHQ

=XX GLHVHP =ZHFN YHUVXFKW $QVHOP ]XX EHZHLVHQ GDVVV GDVMHQLJH YRQQ GHP QLFKWVV *U|‰HUHVV JHGDFKW ZHUGHQQ NDQQ XQGG YRQQ GHP HU JODXEW GDVVV HVV *RWW VHL H[LVWLHUW 'HQ ÄHLQIDFKHQ³ ([LVWHQ]EHZHLV YROO]LHKWWHULP]ZHLWHQ.DSLWHOGHVV3,PGULWWHQQ.DSLWHOJHKWWHUQRFKKHLQHQQ6FKULWWWZHLWHULQGHPHUU]X EHZHLVHQQYHUVXFKWGDVVVQLFKWWHLQPDOJHGDFKWWZHUGHQQNDQQGDVVVGLHVHVVIDPRVHH2EMHNWWQLFKWWH[LVWLHUW 'LHVVNDQQDOVÄPRGDOLVLHUWHU³*RWWHVEHZHLVVDQJHVSURFKHQQZHUGHQ

1HXHUHQQ XQGG GXUFKDXVV SODXVLEHO HUVFKHLQHQGHQQ hEHUOHJXQJHQQ ]XIROJHH LVWW PLWW GHQQ EHLGHQQ %HZHLVHQ MHGRFKK GDVV $QVHOP3URJUDPP ÄILGHVV TXDHUHQVV LQWHOOHFWXP³ QLFKWW DEJHVFKORVVHQ 'LH (LQVLFKWW LQ GLH ([LVWHQ]] *RWWHVV YROO]LHKWW VLFKK GHPQDFK QLFKWW LQ )RUP HLQHVV =ZHL6WXIHQ VRQGHUQQ HLQHVV 'UHL6WXIHQ $UJXPHQWV %HL GHU GULWWHQQ 6WXIHH KDQGHOWW HVV VLFKK XP HLQHQQ ,GHQWLILNDWLRQVEHZHLVV IU GLHH ,GHQWLWlW ]ZLVFKHQQ GHPMHQLJHQ YRQ GHP QLFKWVV *U|‰HUHV JHGDFKWW ZHUGHQQ NDQQ XQGG *RWW 'LHVHU %HZHLV EHILQGHWW VLFK HEHQIDOOVV LPP 3,,, (LQHH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ YRQQ 3,,3,9 GLHH HUVWPDOVV GLHVHH GULWWH 6WXIHH PLW EHUFNVLFKWLJW OLHJW PLWW GHP XQYHU|IIHQWOLFKWHQ $XIVDW] µ7KLVV H[HJHWLFDOO PRUDVVV±± =XX3,,,9¶¶ YRQQ *(2 6,(*:$5777YRU

1XQQ LVWW VHLW $QVHOPV 7DJHQQ GLHH 'LVNXVVLRQQ EHU GLH 3,, XQGG 3,,,$UJXPHQWDWLRQHQQ QLFKWW DEJHULVVHQ %HUHLWVVGHULQVHLQHU=HLWOHEHQGHH*ODXEHQVEUXGHU*DXQLORYRQ0DUPRXWLHUVXQWHU]RJJGLH$QVHOPVFKH %HZHLVIKUXQJJ LQ VHLQHU 6FKULIWW µ4XLGG DGG KDHF UHVSRQGHDWW TXLGDP SUR LQVLSLHQWH¶ /3, HLQHU HLQJHKHQGHQQ$QDO\VH'LHHYRQQLKPJHEWHH.ULWLNULFKWHWHHVLFKKMHGRFKKQLFKWWJHJHQQGLHH(UJHEQLVVHHDXVV3,, XQGG 3,,, VRQGHUQQ QXU JHJHQQ GLHH %HZHLVIKUXQJJ VHOEVWW E]Z JHJHQQ LQ LKU YRUNRPPHQGHH EHJULIIOLFKH 8QJHQDXLJNHLWHQ'LHVVOHJWHHGHQQ*UXQGVWHLQ]XU*DXQLOR$QVHOP.RQWURYHUVH $QVHOPHUZLGHUWHHVHLQHP.ULWLNHULQGHU9HUWHLGLJXQJV6FKULIWWµ4XLGGDGKDHFFUHVSRQGHDWWHGLWRULSVLXV OLEHOOL¶ 5(UUJODXEWHKLHUPLWWKLQUHLFKHQGGGDUJHOHJWW]XKDEHQGDVVVGDVV3ULQ]LSVHLQHUU%HZHLVIKUXQJJ LQ3,,,XQGG3,,,,NHLQHQQ'HQNIHKOHUDXIZHLVWWXQGGZLHHGLHDOVVSUREOHPDWLVFKKKLQJHVWHOOWHQQ%HJULIIOLFKNHLWHQ ]XXYHUVWHKHQVLQG

¹ Vgl. Anselm: Proslogion, §0, S. 7.

^{2 Campbell, R.: „Anselm´s three-stage argument - twenty years on“. 3} Geo Siegwart: „This exegetical morass“.

1

'DVVV$QVHOPGLHGXUFKKVHLQHQQ2SSRQHQWHQQYRUJHEUDFKWHH.ULWLNREZRKOHUVLH]XUFNZLHVGHQQRFKKDOV VLQQYROODQVDKZLUGGGXUFKKVHLQHH9HUDQODVVXQJGHXWOLFKGDVV33QXULP9HUEXQGGPLWGHP/3,XQGGHU5 KHUDXV]XJHEHQQLVW

=LHOVHW]XQJJXQGG$XIEDXXGLHVHU$UEHLWW²GLHH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVIUDJHQQQ

'LHVHH$UEHLWVHW]WWVLFKKPLWWGHU.ULWLNN*DXQLORVVDPPRGDOLVLHUWHQQ*RWWHVEHZHLVV$QVHOPVVDXVHLQDQGHU 'LHVHHEUDFKWHHHULP/3,,>@@YRU

'DVV+DXSW]LHOLVWWHVHLQIXQGLHUWHVV9HUVWlQGQLVVVHLQHU.ULWLNN]XXJHZLQQHQ+DQGHOWWHVVVLFKKKLHUEHLXP HLQHH GHVWUXNWLYHH RGHU XP HLQHH NRQVWUXNWLYHH .ULWLN"" =ZHLIHOWW HU GLH 8QGHQNEDUNHLW GHU 1LFKW([LVWHQ] *RWWHVV DQQ RGHU OHGLJOLFK GLH %HZHLVIKUXQJJ $QVHOPV"" /HJHQQ *DXQLOR XQG $QVHOP KLQVLFKWOLFKK GHU %HJULIIHÄ8QGHQNEDUNHLW³XQGGÄ8QYHUVWHKEDUNHLW³GLHVHOEHQQ%HGHXWXQJHQ]XJUXQGHHRGHUQLFKW±VSULFK UHGHQQVLHHLPVFKOLPPVWHQQ)DOODQHLQDQGHUYRUEHL"

=XU .OlUXQJJ GLHVHU )UDJHQ LVWW HVV XQHUOlVVOLFK GLH NULWLVFKHQQ hEHUOHJXQJHQQ *DXQLORVV KLQVLFKWOLFKK 3,,, ULFKWLJJHUIDVVHQQ]XXN|QQHQ=XXGLHVHP=ZHFNNZLUGHLQHH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHUDUJXPHQWDWLYHQ3DVVDJHQ DXVV/3,,>@@HUVWHOOW

=XGHPPXVVVGLHH$QWZRUW$QVHOPVVEHWUDFKWHWWZHUGHQPLWGHUHULQ5>@DXIIGLH.ULWLNN*DXQLORVUHDJLHUWH XQGGVHLQ9RUJHKHQLQQ3,,,,UHFKWIHUWLJWH'LHVVZLUGLQZHQLJHUDXVIKUOLFKHU)RUPJHVFKHKHQ 'DUEHU KLQDXVV VROO HLQHH $QWZRUWW DXII GLHH )UDJHH JHJHEHQ ZHUGHQ ZDUXP *DXQLOR LQQ /3,, >@@ HLQHQ VRJHQDQQWHQ 6SUHFKHUZHFKVHO YROO]LHKW 'LHVHU KDW X D - 6&+(5% GD]X YHUDQODVVW YRQQ GHU 6WDQGDUWHLQWHLOXQJ GHV /3, GXUFKK ) 6 6&+0,'77 DE]XZHLFKHQQ XQG GHQQ VLHEHQWHQQ $EVFKQLWWW LQ ]ZHL HLJHQVWlQGLJHH.DSLWHO]XXXQWHUWHLOHQ :LHVLFKK]HLJHQQZLUGWUlJWWGLH%HDQWZRUWXQJJGLHVHU)UDJHHHLQHQ EHGHXWVDPHQQ7HLO]XP*HVDPWYHUVWlQGQLVVGHVV/3,,>@@EHL

$XVVGHQQREHQJHQDQQWHQQ9RUKDEHQQHUJLEWWVLFKKIROJHQGHU$XIEDXGHU$UEHLW=XHUVWWHUIROJHQQJHQHUHOOH $QPHUNXQJHQQ ]XP 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQVYROO]XJJ $QVFKOLH‰HQG ZLUGG DXII GLH 7H[WJUXQGODJHH GHV 5HNRQVWUXHQGXPVV HLQJHJDQJHQ (VV ZHUGHQQ ]ZHL GHXWVFKHH hEHUVHW]XQJHQQ GHVV/3,, >@@ KHUDQJH]RJHQ XQGGHVVZLUGGHLQHH6WUXNWXULHUXQJJYRUJHQRPPHQQ$QVFKOLH‰HQGNRPPWHVV]XU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHVV/3, >@=XQlFKVWWLVWWGD]XXGLHHHUVWHH7H[WUDWHH]XXXQWHUVXFKHQZHOFKHHGLHH.ULWLNGHVV7RUHQQDPPRGDOLVLHUWHQ *RWWHVEHZHLVVHQWKlOWW'DUDXIIIROJWHLQHH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQQGHUNRJQLWLYHQQ3DVVDJHQQDXVVGHU]ZHLWHQ 7H[WUDWHZHOFKHHGLHH.ULWLN*DXQLORVVDPPRGDOLVLHUWHQQ*RWWHVEHZHLVVHQWKlOWW'LHVHU5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ VFKOLH‰WW VLFKK GLHH =XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ GHU GRUWW HU]LHOWHQQ (UJHEQLVVHH XQGG (LQVLFKWHQQ DQ 'HQ $EVFKOXVVV GHVV +DXSWWHLOV ELOGHWW GLH 8QWHUVXFKXQJJ YRQQ 5 >@ ZRULQQ $QVHOP GLH *DXQLORVFKHH .ULWLN ]XUFNZHLVWW$EVFKOLH‰HQGGNRPPWWHVV]XU%HDQWZRUWXQJGHU,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVIUDJHQQ

⁴ Vgl. Volpi, Franco (Hrsg.): Großes Werklexikon der Philosophie, S. 50.

⁵ Der „Sprecherwechsel“ meint, dass die vorgebrachte Kritik nicht mehr im Namen des Toren, sondern im Namen Gaunilos selbst erfolgt.

⁶ Scherb, Jürgen Ludwig: Anselms philosophische Theologie, S. 173.

2

,QWHUSUHWDWLRQQYRQQ/3,>@ 3UlOLPLQDULHQ

,P)ROJHQGHQZHUGHQQHLQLJHYRUEHUHLWHQGHH+LQZHLVHEH]JOLFKKGHVVZHLWHUHQQ9RUJHKHQVVJHJHEHQ'DV =LHOOLVWGHQJHVDPWHQQ$UEHLWVSUR]HVVVWUDQVSDUHQW]XXJHVWDOOWHQ

L$XIIHLQH*HVDPWZLHGHUJDEHGHV/3,ZLUGGYHU]LFKWHW'LHVVLVWWPHWKRGLVFKKJXWWYHUWUHWEDUGDVLFKKGHU VLHEHQWHH$EVFKQLWWWGHVV/3,DXIIGHQQVLFKGLHVH8QWHUVXFKXQJJLP.HUQQEHVFKUlQNWVLFKKKLQUHLFKHQGGVWDUN YRQQGHU3,,.ULWLN*DXQLORVVDEJUHQ]W'LHVHHZLUGLQQGHQHUVWHQVHFKV.DSLWHOQIRUPXOLHUWZLUG(VVJHQJW GLHH LQWHUQHQ 7H[WEH]JH GHVV /3, DEHU DXFKK GLH H[WHUQHQQ 7H[WEH]JH ]X 33 XQGG ]X 5 DQQ GHQMHQLJHQ 6WHOOHQQGHVV,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVXQGG5HNRQVWUXNWLRQVJHVFKlIWVV]XXEHUFNVLFKWLJHQZRRVLHHI|UGHUOLFKKVLQG LL $OV 7H[WJUXQGODJHH ZHUGHQQ ]ZHL hEHUVHW]XQJHQ GHVV /3,, LQVV 'HXWVFKHH GLHQHQ GLH WH[WQDKH hEHUVHW]XQJJ YRQQ 52%(577 7+(,6 XQGG GLHH ± KLQVLFKWOLFKK GHUU 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQQ NRJQLWLYHUU 3DVVDJHQQ VWlUNHU JHULFKWHWHH ±± hEHUVHW]XQJJ -h5*(1 /8':,** 6&+(5%V 'LH $UEHLWW PLWW ]ZHL 7H[WHQQ LVW YRUWHLOKDIW 'HQ 9HUVWlQGQLVVFKZLHULJNHLWHQ GLHH VLFK DXVV GHUU XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQQ hEHUVHW]XQJJ GHV ODWHLQLVFKHQ$XVJDQJVWH[WHVHUJHEHQNDQQQKLHUGXUFKK]XP7HLOHQWJHJHQJHZLUNWWZHUGHQ LLL'LHH:HQGXQJµGDVMHQLJHHLQVROFKHVEHUUGDVVKLQDXVVQLFKWVV*U|‰HUHVVJHGDFKWWZHUGHQQNDQQ¶¶VROOO DXVV*UQGHQQGHU(LQIDFKKHLWWLQQGHUJHVDPWHQQ$UEHLWWDOVVÄGDVVIDPRVHH2EMHNW³EH]HLFKQHWZHUGHQ LY'LH%HJULIIHHÄ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ³XQGGÄ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ³GLHHLQGLHVHU$UEHLWWYHUZHQGHWWZHUGHQVLQGGQLFKW JOHLFK]XVHW]HQ(LQHHJUREHH7UHQQXQJJVROOKLHUJHQJHQÄ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQ³VWHKWWIUHLQQKHUPHQHXWLVFKHVV 9HUIDKUHQ ]XP 8PJDQJJ PLWW $UJXPHQWDWLRQHQ GDV GLH Ä$XIEHUHLWXQJ³ HLQHVV XPJDQJVVSUDFKOLFKHQ 7H[WHVV XQGG VHLQH :LHGHUJDEHH LQ HLQHU H[SOL]LWHQ 6SUDFKHH YRUVLHKW Ä,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ³ VWHKWW DOOJHPHLQQ IU GLHH 'HXWXQJJ E]Z $XVOHJXQJJ HLQHVV XPJDQJVVSUDFKOLFKHQQ 7H[WHVV GXUFKK HLQHQQ XPJDQJVVSUDFKOLFKHQ 7H[W

Y,QQ.DSLWHOVROOGLHH$UJXPHQWDWLRQQ*DXQLORVVLP'HWDLOQDFKJH]HLFKQHWWZHUGHQ±]XXGLHVHP=ZHFN ZLUGVLHUHNRQVWUXLHUW'HUXPJDQJVVSUDFKOLFKH7H[WLVWWGDVV5HNRQVWUXHQGXP'LHVHUZLUGGLQHLQHQ7H[W QDPHQWOLFKK GDVV 5HNRQVWUXHQV LQQHUKDOEE HLQHU 5HNRQVWUXHQVVSUDFKHH EHUIKUW )U GLHH DQJHVWUHEWH 5HNRQVWUXNWLRQQ ZLUG HLQH 6WDQGDUGVSUDFKH HUVWHU 6WXIH PLWW GHU (UZHLWHUXQJ XP GHQ (SVLORQ 7HUPTXDQWLILNDWRU XQG PLW GHQ )ROJHUXQJVUHJHOQ GHU NODVVLVFKHQ 4XDQWRUHQORJLN VRZLHH GHV ,GHQWLWlWVSUlGLNDWRUVYHUZHQGHW

'HU (SVLORQ2SHUDWRU ZXUGHH LP =XVDPPHQKDQJJ PLWW GHU *RWWHVFKDUDNWHULVLHUXQJJ HUVWPDOV GXUFK &$03%(///LQGLH'HEDWWHHLQJHIKUW 'DDHVVLP/3,,HEHQIDOOV]XXGHU,GDOLTXLG5HGHHNRPPWLVWWGLH 9HUZHQGXQJJGLHVHVV2SHUDWRUVDQJHPHVVHQQXQGGYRQQ9RUWHLO

⁷ Anselm von Canterbury: Proslogion (dt. übers. v. Robert Theis), S. 87-89.

^{8 Scherb, Jürgen Ludwig: Anselms philosophische Theologie, S. 171-174. 9} Vgl. Siegwart, Geo: „This exegetical morass, S.3.

3

$EVFKOLH‰HQGGVHLHUZlKQWGDVVVGLHH5HNRQVWUXNWLRQGHQEHUHLWVVHWDEOLHUWHQ5HNRQVWUXNWLRQVPD[LPHQQGHU

'LHH7H[WJUXQGODJHHH

=XQlFKVWW HUIROJWW GLHH :LHGHUJDEHH GHU EHLGHQQ GHXWVFKHQQ hEHUVHW]XQJHQQ YRQQ /3,, >@ LQ WDEHOODULVFKHU )RUP,P$QVFKOXVVVZLUGGLHLQQGHU7DEHOOHHUVLFKWOLFKHGXUFKGHQ$XWRUYRUJHQRPPHQHH6WUXNWXULHUXQJ GHVV7H[WHVVHUOlXWHUWWXQGGJHUHFKWIHUWLJW

¹⁰ Vgl. Reinmuth, Friedrich: Zur Rekonstruktion philosophischer Argumentationen, S. 28-46.

4

'DVV /3,, >@@ ZHLVWW HLQHQQ (LQVFKQLWWW DXI GHU GXUFKK HLQHQQ 6SUHFKHUZHFKVHO HQWVWHKW +LHUGXUFKK LVWW HV VLQQYROOGDVV.DSLWHOLQQ]ZHL7H[WUDWHQQ 75]XXXQWHUWHLOHQ'LHLQQ75YRUJHEUDFKWHH.ULWLNDQQ3,,, HUIROJWWQRFKKLP1DPHQQGHV7RUHQ0LW6HUIROJWWGHU:HFKVHOXQGGGLHH75EHJLQQW$EKLHUEULQJW *DXQLORHLQHQ.ULWLNSXQNWWLQQHLJHQHUU3HUVRQQYRU

,FKK VFKOLH‰HH PLFKK GHU 6LFKWZHLVHH 6&+(5%VV DQ GDVVVGHU 6SUHFKHUZHFKVHO HLQHH=lVXU LQQHUKDOE GHV /3,, GDUVWHOOW 'RFKK OHKQH LFKK DE GDVVV KLHUPLWW HLQQ KLQUHLFKHQGHU 5HFKWIHUWLJXQJVJUXQGG IU HLQH .DSLWHOQHXHLQWHLOXQJJ YRUOLHJW (VV ZLUG LQQ GLHVHU $UEHLWW GLHH $XIIDVVXQJJ YHUWUHWHQ GDVVV GDVV VLHEWH .DSLWHO HQWVSUHFKHQGG GHU .DSLWHOXQWHUWHLOXQJ GXUFKK ) 6 6&+0,'7 DOV HLQHH 7H[WHLQKHLW DXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQ ZHUGHQ PXVV 'HQ +DXSWJUXQG KLHU]XX OLHIHUW GHU NDSLWHOLQWHUQH JHGDQNOLFKH =XVDPPHQKDQJJ XQGG GLHH WKHPDWLVFKHH $XVULFKWXQJJ GHVV .DSLWHOV GDVV VLFKK DOVV HLQ]LJHVV XQGG KLHU DXVVFKOLH‰OLFKK PLWW GHPP PRGDOLVLHUWHQQ *RWWHVEHZHLVV DXVV 3,,,, DXVHLQDQGHUVHW]W (LQQ ZHLWHUHUU VLFKK DXV GHP6SUHFKHUZHFKVHOLQ75HUJHEHQGHU*UXQGZLUGGVSlWHUGLVNXWLHUWW¶3.6.

'DVV/3,,>@@ZLUGGHPHQWVSUHFKHQGGLQ]ZHL7H[WUDWHQQXQWHUWHLOW'LHVHHEHLGHQQ7H[WUDWHQQVLQGLKUHUVHLWVVLQ ]ZHL7HLOH]XXXQWHUJOLHGHUQ

75XPIDVVWWQXUHLQHQ6DW]'LHVHUEULQJWWGLHHWKHPDWLVFKHH7UHQQXQJJ]ZLVFKHQQ/3,,>@>@ZRULQQ HVVDXVVFKOLH‰OLFKKXPPHLQHH.ULWLNNDQQ3,,JHKWXQG/3,,>@ZRULQQ3,,,WKHPDWLVLHUWWZLUG]XP$XVGUXFN 755 XPIDVVWW 66 ± KLHUU ZLUGG GHUU HUVWHH .ULWLNSXQNWW DQQ 3,,,, JHlX‰HUW 'LHVV HUIROJWW QRFK LQ 3HUVRQQGHVV8QJOlXELJHQQ7RUHQ

,QQ755ILQGHWWHLQ6SUHFKHUZHFKVHOVWDWW'LH755NDQQQIROJHQGHUPD‰HQQDXIJHIDVVWWZHUGHQ*DXQLOR HUWHLOW LQQ 6 HLQHQ 5DWVFKODJ GHU DXII HLQHU LPSOL]LWHQQ 7KHVHH EHUXKWW ¶ ,QQ 6 HUIROJW GLH

¹¹ Scherb (Anselms philosophische Theologie) teilt das LPI in neun Kapitel ein (S.136) und rechtfertigt dies mit dem Sprecherwechsel in LPI [7] (S.173).

5

$UJXPHQWDWLRQQ IU GLHVHH 7KHVH $XVV VHLQHU 6LFKWW KDW HU VRPLWW HLQHH HUVWHH %HGLQJXQJJ ]XU OHJLWLPHQQ bX‰HUXQJVHLQHVV5DWVFKODJHVVHUIOOW'LHVH]ZHL6lW]HELOGHQQGLHH755

,QQ 66 IROJWW HLQHH ZHLWHUHH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ 'RFKK ZLUGG KLHUU QLFKWW IUU GLHH REHQQ HUZlKQWHH 7KHVH DUJXPHQWLHUWVRQGHUQQGLHH8QYHUWUlJOLFKNHLWW]ZHLHU$XVVDJHQPHQJHQQQDFKJHZLHVHQ'LHVVJHVFKLHKWWLQQ )RUP HLQHU 'LOHPPD6LWXDWLRQ 'LH $UJXPHQWDWLRQQ LQQHUKDOE GHU 75 ]LHOW DXI GLH ]XVlW]OLFKH (UIOOXQJGHU%HGLQJXQJJJ]XUbX‰HUXQJJVHLQHVVLP6IRUPXOLHUWHQQ5DWVFKODJHVVDE¶

'LHH.ULWLNNGHVV7RUHQQDPPPRGDOLVLHUWHQQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLVV

,QQGLHVHP$EVFKQLWWZLUGGHLQHH6DW]IU6DW],QWHUSUHWDWLRQQGHUHUVWHQQ7H[WUDWHHGXUFKJHIKUW=LHOLVWWHV GLHH)XQNWLRQQGHU75LP*HVDPW]XVDPPHQKDQJJGHVV/3,,>@@DQJHEHQQ]XN|QQHQ(VVZLUGJHNOlUWLQ ZHOFKHPP9HUKlOWQLVVGLHHEHLGHQQ7H[WUDWHQQGHV/3,,>@@]XHLQDQGHUUVWHKHQ

66RRZHLWZDVVMHQHUU7RUUHLQVWZHLOHQQDXIIGLHH(LQZlQGHHHUZLGHUQQZLUG

'XUFKKGLHVHQQ6DW]]ZLUGGGHUhEHUJDQJJYRQQGHU3,,.ULWLN]XXHLQHPWKHPDWLVFKQHXHQQ$EVFKQLWWWGHVV/3, VLJQDOLVLHUW *DXQLOR EHWRQWW QRFKPDOV GDVVV DOOH YRQQ /3,, >@>@@ DQJHVWHOOWHQQ hEHUOHJXQJHQ hEHUOHJXQJHQQ ZDUHQ GLH GHU YRQQ $QVHOP LP 33 HUZlKQWHH 7RU DXII GHQQ HLQIDFKHQQ ([LVWHQ]EHZHLV GHV IDPRVHQ2EMHNWVVYRUEULQJHQQN|QQWH(VPDJ]XQlFKVWLUULWLHUHQGDVVVLQ6GDYRQQGLHH5HGHHLVWGDVV GHU 7RU DXII (LQZlQGHH HUZLGHUW 'HP .RQWH[WJHIKO QDFKK ZDU HVV JHUDGH GHU 7RU GHU (LQZlQGH YRUJHEUDFKWHH±±QlPOLFKKDQ3,,(LQQ%OLFNNLQGLHhEHUVHW]XQJ6&+(5%VVNDQQQGLHVHHSODXVLEOHUH/HVDUW EHVWlWLJHQ

6'LHVVKlWWHHMHQHUU7RUUYRUHUVWWDXIIMHQHVV9RUJHWUDJHQHHJHDQWZRUWHW

+LHU ZLUGG HUVLFKWOLFKW GDVV $QVHOP NHLQHH (UZLGHUXQJHQQ YRUEUDFKWH VRQGHUQQ HWZDVV YRUWUXJ µ-HQHVV 9RUJHWUDJHQH¶PHLQWKLHUGLHH$UJXPHQWDWLRQQDXVV3,, (VVJHKWWZHLWHUUPLWWGHPP]ZHLWHQQ6DW]

^{6:HQQQLKPPGDUDXIKLQQYHUVLFKHUWWZLUGMHQHVV!JU|‰HUVHLLVRGDVVVHVVQLFKWWHLQPDOOGHPP'HQNHQQQDFKKQLFKWWVHLQQ N|QQHXQGGGLHVVZLHGHUXPPJHQDXXGDGXUFKKEHZLHVHQQZLUGGDVVVHVVDQGHUQIDOOVVQLFKWWJU|‰HUUZlUHHDOVVDOOHVVRRR N|QQWHHHUUGDUDXIIGLHVHOEHH$QWZRUWWJHEHQQXQGGIUDJHQ}

'LHVHU 6DW]] ZHLVWW GLHH )RUP HLQHU 6XEMXQNWLRQ DXI 'HQQ YRUGHUHQQ 7HLO ELOGHWW GDVV $QWH]HGHQV GLH %HGLQJXQJXQWHUGHUDXIGDVVLP6XN]HGHQVV(QWKDOWHQHHJHIROJHUWWZHUGHQQGDUI6JLEWWGHQQ,QKDOWWGHV $QWH]HGHQ]6GHQQGHVV6XN]HGHQVVZLHGHU

'LHH%HGLQJXQJJGLHH*DXQLORKLHUDQIKUWLVWWEHUHLWVVPLWGHQQ$XVIKUXQJHQQGHVV3,,,HUIOOW'LHVVLVWWGDV HLQGHXWLJHH$Q]HLFKHQGDVVVLFKK/3,,>@DXIGHQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLVLQ3,,,EH]LHKW$QMHQHU6WHOOHZLUGGPLW

6

HLQHU$UWGHU%HZHLVIKUXQJGLHDXFKKEHLPHLQIDFKHQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLVV]XX(LQVDW]NDPGXUFKK$QVHOP DXIJH]HLJWGDVVVGLHH0RGDOLWlWWGHUEHUHLWVVLQQ3,,,EHZLHVHQHQQ([LVWHQ]]GHVVIDPRVHQ2EMHNWHVVGHUDUWLVW GDVVV VLH GLH ([LVWHQ] XQGHQNEDU QLFKWW JHJHEHQQ VHLQ NDQQ .XU] 'LHH 1LFKW([LVWHQ]] GHVV IDPRVHQ 2EMHNWVVNDQQQQLFKWWJHGDFKWZHUGHQ

(VVVFKHLQWWSODXVLEHOGDVVVGLHH5HGHZHLVHHµMHQHVV!JU|‰HU¶LQ6VLFKKDXIIGDVVIDPRVHH2EMHNWEH]LHKW 'HVV :HLWHUHQQ VSULFKWW *DXQLOR LQQ 6 GDYRQGDVVV GHU 7RU HLQHH $QWZRUWWDXII GDVV 9RUJHWUDJHQHH JHEHQ N|QQWH GLH HU EHUHLWV ]XYRU ]XX DQGHUHQ =ZHFNHQ JHJHEHQQ KDW 0LWW µGLHVHOEH $QWZRUW¶ LQQ 6 LVW K|FKVWZDKUVFKHLQOLFK GLHH LQQ /3,>@ 66 JHJHEHQH $QWZRUWW JHPHLQW 'LHVHZLUG GRUWW ]XPP =ZHFN GHU(QWNUlIWXQJJGHVVHLQIDFKHQQ([LVWHQ]EHZHLVHVVDXV3,,,JHJHEHQ'LHHbKQOLFKNHLWGHU9RUJHKHQVZHLVH LQ/3,,>@@XQG>@@LVWWHUVWDXQOLFK

,QQ /3,, >@@ 6 VFKLOGHUWW *DXQLOR HEHQIDOOV LQQ GHU 5ROOH GHVV 7RUHQ HLQHH GRUW DXVV 3,,, VWDPPHQGH hEHUOHJXQJJXQGGVDJWH[SOL]LWÄ'DUDXIIDQWZRUWHHLFKK)ROJHQGHV³6HLQHHGRUWWJHJHEHQHH$QWZRUWWJOHLFKWWGHU LQQ/3,,>@@6JHJHEHQHQQ$QWZRUW

^{/3,,>@@66:HUUQXQQEHKDXSWHWGLHVVVHLZHLOOVRQVWWGDVZDVVJU|‰HUULVWWDOVVDOOHVQLFKWWGDVVLVWZDVVJU|‰HUULVWWDOV DOOHV DFKWHWW QLFKWW JHQJHQGG GDUDXII PLWW ZHPP HUU VSULFKW ,FK QlPOLFKK EHKDXSWHH JDUU QLFKW MDD YLHOPHKUU EHVWUHLWHH E]Z EH]ZHLIOHHLFKGDVVVMHQHVV!JU|‰HUHLQHUUZDKUHQQ:LUNOLFKNHLWWQDFKKVHLXQGGJHVWHKHHLKPPNHLQQDQGHUHVV6HLQQ]XXDOVVMHQHV ±±ZHQQQPDQQGHQQQ!6HLQVDJHQPXVVV±LQQ$QEHWUDFKWWGHVVHQQPHLQQ*HLVWWVLFKKDXIJUXQGGHLQHVVEOR‰‰JHK|UWHQQ:RUWHV HLQHHJlQ]OLFKKXQEHNDQQWHH6DFKHHDXV]XGHQNHQQVXFKW³}

,FKKIDVVHHGLHHhEHUOHJXQJJ]XVDPPHQ*DXQLORRYHUWULWWWLQQ/3,,>@@IROJHQGHH$XIIDVVXQJ 'HUU7RUUEHVWUHLWHW GLHH ([LVWHQ]LQ:LUNOLFKNHLWW GHVV IDPRVHQ 2EMHNWV 'DUEHU KLQDXV XQGG GLHVV LVWW GHU HQWVFKHLGHQGH 3XQNW JLOW HVV IU GHQQ 7RU DOVV QLFKWW EHZLHVHQ GDVV GDVV IDPRVHH 2EMHNWW LP 9HUVWDQGG H[LVWLHUW (U XQWHUVFKHLGHWW ]ZHL $UWHQ GHVV ,P9HUVWDQG6HLQV $XVV VHLQHU 6LFKWW H[LVWLHUW GDVV IDPRVHH 2EMHNW K|FKVWHQVVDOVÄEOR‰HH9RUVWHOOXQJ³LP9HUVWDQG

$XVV GLHVHP *UXQG NRPPW *DXQLOR ]XX GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GDVV GHU 7RU HLQHQQ $QODVVV KlWWH GHQQ 3,, %HZHLV ]XUFN]XZHLVHQ 'HU Ä*U|‰HU*UXQG³ XQGG GLH Ä6HOEVWSUlGLNDWLRQ³ ZUGHQQ QLFKWW ]XP WUDJHQ NRPPHQ GDD GHU 7RU EHUHLWV GDVV (UJHEQLVV GHU 1HEHQDUJXPHQWDWLRQ YHUZLUIW 'DVV IDPRVHH 2EMHNW H[LVWLHUWWQLFKWWLPP9HUVWDQG'DVVVPDQQYRQQHWZDVGDVQLFKWWLPP9HUVWDQGGH[LVWLHUWEHZHLVHQQZLOOGDVVVHV LQQ:LUNOLFKNHLWWH[LVWLHUWHUJLEWWIUUGHQ7RUHQNHLQHQQ6LQQ

$XII /3, >@ EHUWUDJHQ HUJLEWW VLFK IROJHQGHVV %LOG =ZDU lX‰HUWW *DXQLOR KLHU LQ 6 GDVV GHU 7RU ]XU (QWNUlIWXQJJ GHUU 3,,,$UJXPHQWDWLRQQ GLHVHOEH $QWZRUW JHEHQ N|QQWH GLHH HUU EHUHLWVV LPP /3,, >@@ ]XU (QWNUlIWXQJJGHU3,,$UJXPHQWDWLRQQJDE:DVV*DXQLORMHGRFKKPHLQWLVWGDVVVGHU7RUGDVVHOEHHKLQWHUGHUU $QWZRUWW EHILQGOLFKH 3ULQ]LS DQZHQGHQQ N|QQWH XPP DXFKK GLH 3,,,$UJXPHQWDWLRQ ]XUFN]XZHLVHQ 'LHV ZLUGGLQQ6GHXWOLFK

¹² Diese Interpretation resultiert aus der Untersuchung des gesamten fünften Kapitels des LPI.

7