,QKDOWW

(LQOHLWXQJ««««««««««««

:LHHDOOHVVEHJDQQQ««««««««««« 'LHH6DDWWGHVV6WDDWV]HUIDOOV««««««««««« 'LHHVRPDOLVFKHH$JJUHVVLRQQJHJHQQbWKLRSLHQ«««« :HUU:LQGGVlW««««««««««««

5HDOLVWLVFKHH%HWUDFKWXQJHQQGHVV9HUKDOWHQVVGHUU91««

9HUlQGHUXQJHQQLQQGHQQ911QDFKK«««««««« bQGHUXQJJLQWHUQDWLRQDOHUU6SLHOUHJHOQQ .RRSHUDWLRQQVWDWWW.RRUGLQDWLRQ"««««««« 9HUKDOWHQVlQGHUXQJHQQGHUU650LWJOLHGHU"««« 3ROLWLFDOO2XWFRPHHGHUU9HUlQGHUXQJHQ

,PSDFWWDXIIGLHH$NWLRQHQQGHUU911LQQ6RPDOLD««« =ZLVFKHQQ+DOEKHU]LJNHLWWXQGGV\VWHPEHGLQJWHUUUUU 8QIlKLJNHLW81,6200,,XQGG81,6200,,

)D]LWW³:DVVYRPP7DJHHEULJJEOLHE´´ :HOFKHH5HIRUPHQQVLQGGQRFKKQ|WLJ"««««««««« /LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV«««««««««««««

1. Einleitung

'HUUDIULNDQLVFKHH.RQWLQHQWWLVWWVHLWWVHLQHUU³%HVHW]XQJ´´GXUFKKGLHH(XURSlHUUVWHWVVV 6SLHOIHOGGXQGG6SLHOEDOOOYHUVFKLHGHQVWHUU6WDDWHQQXQGG,QWHUHVVHQQJHZHVHQ6WDQGHQQ DQIDQJVVPHLVWWQRFKKGLHH5HVVRXUFHQQGHVV.RQWLQHQWVZLHH]%'LDPDQWHQQRGHUUJDUU PHQVFKOLFKHH$UEHLWVNUlIWHHLQQ)RUPPYRQQ6NODYHQQLPP9RUGHUJUXQGGLQWHUQDWLRQDOHUU 'LVSXWHVRRZDUHQQHVVLPP-DKUKXQGHUWWDXFKK]XQHKPHQGGVWUDWHJLVFKHHXQGGWHUULWRULDOHH )UDJHQGLHHVLFKKLQQGHQQ9RUGHUJUXQGGGUlQJWHQ'LHHWHUULWRULDOHH)UDJHHZDUULQQ$IULNDD VWHWVVDXFKKHLQHH0DFKWIUDJHVRJDUU.ULHJHHZXUGHQQXPP³HLQHQQ3ODW]]DQQGHUU6RQQH´ ELOOLJHQGGLQQ.DXIIJHQRPPHQ0HKUHUHH-DKUKXQGHUWHHODQJJEHKDQGHOWHQQYRUUDOOHPPGLHH HXURSlLVFKHQQQ6WDDWHQ6WDDWHQJHELOGHHGHQQVRJ³VFKZDU]HQQ.RQWLQHQW´´QLFKWWJHUDGHH QDFKKKXPDQLVWLVFKKDXIJHNOlUWHQQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWHQ

'HUUPHLVWWZHQLJJYHUDQWZRUWOLFKHH8PJDQJJGHUU.RORQLDOPlFKWHHPLWWLKUHQQ.RORQLHQQ VHW]WHHVLFKKDXFKKIRUWDOVVPDQQVLFKKDQVFKLFNWHGLHH³EHVHW]WHQQ*HELHWH´´LQQGLHH 8QDEKlQJLJNHLWW]XXHQWODVVHQ$PP5HL‰EUHWWWZXUGHQQ6WDDWHQQXQGG9HUIDVVXQJHQQ NRQVWUXLHUWRKQHHDXFKKQXUUHLQHQQ*HGDQNHQQGDUEHUU]XXYHUVFKZHQGHQREEGLHVHH 6WDDWHQQVRREHUKDXSWWEHUOHEHQVIlKLJJVLQG )UDQ]]$QVSUHQJHU EH]HLFKQHWWGDVV $XVKDQGHOQQYRQQ9HUIDVVXQJHQQ]ZLVFKHQQGHQQ.RORQLDOPlFKWHQQXQGGLKUHQQLQQGLHH 8QDEKlQJLJNHLWW]XXHQWODVVHQGHQQ.RORQLHQQLQQGHQQHUU-DKUHQQDOVV³9HUOHJHQKHLWV JHVWH³ 6FKRQQEDOGG]HLJWHQQVLFKKGLHH)ROJHQQGHVVUHFKWWXQEHUOHJWHQQ³QDWLRQEXLOGLQJV´´ XQGG³VWDWHIRUPLQJV´´´GHUUHKHPDOLJHQQ.RORQLDOPlFKWHGDVV3KlQRPHQQGHVV6WDDWV ]HUIDOOVVXQGGGHUU%UJHUNULHJHHJULIIILQQIDVWWJDQ]]³6FKZDU]DIULND´´XPPVLFK'RFKKVHOEVWW LPP$QJHVLFKWWYLHOHUU.ULHJVXQGG%UJHUNULHJV*UlXHOOJULIIIGLHHLQWHUQDWLRQDOHH *HPHLQVFKDIWDXFKKRGHUUYRUUDOOHPPLQQ*HVWDOWWGHUU911KlXILJJQLFKW]XXVSlWWRGHUUQLFKWW HIIHNWLYYJHQXJJHLQ,VWWHLQQIULHGOLFKHUUDIULNDQLVFKHUU.RQWLQHQWWGHQQ0LWJOLHGHUQQGHUU911 QLFKWWZLFKWLJJJHQXJJXPPHLQ]XJUHLIHQ""2GHUULVWWGDVV6\VWHPPGHUU911LPP5DKPHQQGHVV

.DLVHUU:LOOKHOPP,,

'LHHhEHUOHEHQVIlKLJNHLWWEHVFKUlQNWWVLFKKGDEHLLQLFKWWQXUUDOOHLQQDXIIGLHHZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHHVRQGHUQQDXFKK GDUDXIREEHLQHH,QWHJULWlWWXQGG6WDELOLWlWWHLQHVV6WDDWHVVJHVLFKHUWWLVWWXQGGQLFKWWGXUFKKHLQHHXQJQVWLJHH HWKQLVFKHH.RQVWHOODWLRQQGHVWDELOLVLHUWWZHUGHQQN|QQWH

)UDQ]]$QVSUHQJHUÄ'HPRNUDWLHHRGHUU6WDDWV]HUIDOO³³VLQQÄ3ROLWLVFKHH*HVFKLFKWHH$IULNDVVLPP -DKUKXQGHUW³³&+%HFN9HUODJ$XIODJHH

'DEHLLVSLHOWHHHVVVHLQHUU0HLQXQJJQDFKKIUUGLHH.RORQLDOPlFKWHNHLQHH5ROOHREEGLHVHH9HUIDVVXQJHQQ WDXJWHQQ$IULNDDZHLWHU]XKHOIHQ'DGXUFKKNDPPHVVQLFKWWVHOWHQQ]XUU$XVELOGXQJJGHVSRWLVFKHUU XQYRUVWHOOEDUHQQ$XVPD‰HV

SHDFHEXLOGLQJVVQLFKWWLQQGHUU/DJHHUHFKW]HLWLJJXQGGHIIHNWLYYHLQ]XJUHLIHQ""" 1DFKKGHUU(QWODVVXQJJGHUUDIULNDQLVFKHQQ³6WDDWHQ´´LQQGLHH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWWLVWW$IULNDD DXFKKRIWW]XPP6SLHOEDOOOXQGG6SLHOSODW]]GHUUDPPVRJ³NDOWHQQ.ULHJ´´EHWHLOLJWHQQ *UR‰PlFKWHH86$$XQGG8'6655JHZRUGHQQV=DLUHHX$$XIJUXQGGGHUUKHUDXV UDJHQGHQQ6WHOOXQJJGHUUEHLGHQQ*UR‰PlFKWHYRUUDOOHPPLPP916LFKHUKHLWVUDWW9HWR 0lFKWHXQGGLKUHUUPDFKWSROLWLVFKHQQ'LIIHUHQ]HQQZDUHQQGLHH911JU|‰WHQWHLOVVQLFKWWLQQ GHUU/DJHMDDHVVZDUULKQHQQWHLOVVQDKH]XXXQP|JOLFKKRGHUUHJDO" HLQQHLQKHLWOLFKHV $IULNDDEHIULHGHQGHVV9RUJHKHQQSODQHQQRGHUUJDUUGXUFKVHW]HQQ]XXN|QQHQ 'LHH)ROJHHIHKOHQGHUUVWDDWOLFKHUU6WUXNWXUHQQE]ZYRQQ6WDDWV]HUIDOOOXQGGGHUURIWWGDPLWW HLQKHUYRUKHUJHKHQGHQQ0LVVXQGG9HWWHUQZLUWVFKDIWWLVWWRIWW$UPXWZDVVZLHGHUXP QDFKKGHPPHKHP863UlVLGHQWHQQ7UXPDQQ³GHQQ1lKUERGHQQYRQQ7HUURUUXQGG*HZDOWW ELOGHW´,QQ$QEHWUDFKWWGHUUZHOWZHLWHQQ=XQDKPHHWHUURULVWLVFKHUU$NWLYLWlWHQQXQGG *HIDKUHQQPXVVV$IULNDDXQGGYDGHQQVRJIDLOLQJVWDWHVVPHKUU$XIPHUNVDPNHLWW JHVFKHQNWWZHUGHQ$PP%HLVSLHOOGHVV,UDNVVOlVVWWVLFKKGHUU=XVDPPHQKDQJJYRQQHLQHPP )DLOLQJ6WDWHHXQGGGHUU=XQDKPHHGHVV7HUURULVPXVVGXUFKDXVVQDFKZHLVHQZHQQJOHLFKK GLHVHUU6WDDWV]HUIDOOOMHGRFKKWHLOZHLVHHDQGHUHH*UQGHHKDWDOVVMHQHUULQQ6RPDOLD 'LHH*HIDKUUGDVV]XQHKPHQGHQQUHOLJL|VHQ7HUURULVPXVVLQQ$IULNDDLVWWMHGRFKKODWHQW 'LHHIROJHQGHH$UEHLWWVWHOOWWGHQQ9HUVXFKKGDUGLHHQHXXHQWVWDQGHQHQQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQQDEHUU DXFKKGLHH*UHQ]HQQGHUU911LQQHUKDOEEGHUUQHXHQQ:HOWRUGQXQJJLPP5DKPHQQIULHGHQV EHZDKUHQGHUUE]ZIULHGHQVVFKDIIHQGHUU0LVVLRQHQQLPP$QJHVLFKWWGHVV6WDDWV]HUIDOOVVLQQ $IULNDDDPP%HLVSLHOOGHVV%UJHUNULHJVODQGVV6RPDOLDDDXI]X]HLJHQ 'LHH$QDO\VHHGHUU0|JOLFKNHLWHQGLHHDPP%HLVSLHOOGHVV6RPDOLVFKHQQ%UJHUNULHJVV YROO]RJHQQZLUGVWHOOWW]ZHLL)UDJHQQLQQGHQQ0LWWHOSXQNWQlPOLFKKREEXQGGZLHHGLHH911 EHUKDXSWWLQQGHUU/DJHHE]ZREEGLHH0LWJOLHGVVWDDWHQQGHUU91YRUUDOOHPPLQQ*HVWDOWWGHUU 6LFKHUKHLWVUDWV0LWJOLHGHUDXFKKZLOOHQVVVLQGGDXHUKDIWHQQ)ULHGHQQLQQ$IULNDD]XX VFKDIIHQQXQGG]XXEHZDKUHQ'DEHLLZLUGGGDYRQQDXVJHJDQJHQGDVVVGLHH911NHLQQ HLJHQWOLFKHUU$NWHXUUVLQGVRQGHUQQQXUUGLHH6WUXNWXUUIUUGDVV+DQGHOQQGHUU0LWJOLHGV VWDDWHQQYRUJLEWZHOFKHHYRQQHEHQQGLHVHQQDXFKKEHHLQIOXVVWWXQGGYHUlQGHUWWZHUGHQQNDQQ

Ä*HQR]LGGXQGG&KDRVVLQQ5XDQGDDVLQGGRKQHHGLHHZDQNHOPWLJHH3ROLWLNNGHUU9HUHLQLJWHQQ6WDDWHQQGLHHHLQHH KXPDQLWlUHH,QWHUYHQWLRQQGHUU9HUHLQWHQQ1DWLRQHQQLPP-DKUUYHUKLQGHUWHQXQGG)UDQNUHLFKVVQLFKWW]XX HUNOlUHQ³Rainer ^{Tetzlaff: „/DQGNDUWHHGHUU.RQIOLNWH)DLOLQJJVWDWHVLQQ$IULND.XQVWSURGXNWHHDXVVGHUU} .RORQLDO]HLWXQGGHXURSlLVFKHH9HUDQWZRUWXQJ³ KWWSZZZLQWHUQDWLRQDOHSROLWLNGHDUFKLYMDKUJDQJMXOLIDLOLQJVWDWHVV V6XGDQQ

$XFKKGLHH)UDJHHQDFKKHYHQWXHOOOQ|WLJHQQ5HIRUPHQQLVWWHLQQHOHPHQWDUHUU%HVWDQGWHLOOGHUU YRUOLHJHQGHQQ$UEHLW

,PPHUVWHQQ7HLOOZLUGGDXIIGLHH(QWVWHKXQJJGHVV6RPDOLVFKHQQ6WDDWV]HUIDOOVVXQGGGHVVGDPLWW HLQKHUJHKHQGHQQQ%UJHUNULHJVVVRRNQDSSSZLHHP|JOLFKKHLQJHJDQJHQHUJlQ]WWGXUFKKHLQHH NXU]HH$QDO\VHHGHUU*UQGHHGHVV9HUVDJHQVVGHUU911LQQGHUU=HLWWGHVVNDOWHQQ.ULHJHVVXQWHUU =XKLOIHQDKPHHUHDOLVWLVFKHUU7KHRULHDQVlW]H,PP$QVFKOXVVVGDUDQQIROJWWGDQQQGLHH 'DUVWHOOXQJJGHUU9HUlQGHUXQJHQQLQQHUKDOEEGHUU91'LHVHUU'DUVWHOOXQJJOLHJWWGLHH)UDJHH ]XX*UXQGHREEGLHH9HUlQGHUXQJHQQGHUU:HOWRUGQXQJJDXFKK]XXbQGHUXQJHQQLPP 9HUKDOWHQQGHUU0LWJOLHGVVWDDWHQQLQQ%H]XJJDXII3HDFH.HHSLQJJE]Z%XLOGLQJJJHIKUWW KDEHQ$QVFKOLH‰HQGGZLUGGDXIIGLHH)UDJHZHOFKHQQ(LQIOXVVVGLHH9HUlQGHUXQJHQQDXIIGDVV %UJHUNULHJVODQGG6RPDOLDDKDEHQE]ZREEEHUKDXSWWHLQQ,PSDFWWHUNHQQEDUULVW HLQJHJDQJHQ,PPOHW]WHQQ$EVFKQLWWW³:DVVYRPP7DJHHEULJJEOLHE´´³ZHOFKHH5HIRUPHQQ VLQGGQRFKKQ|WLJ"³³ZLUGGGDQQQGLHH)UDJHHHU|UWHUWZHOFKHHLQVWLWXWLRQHOOHQQ9HUlQGHUXQJHQQ LQQHUKDOEEGHUU911QRFKQ|WLJJVLQGE]ZREEGLHVHHEHUKDXSWWP|JOLFKKXQGG ]LHOIKUHQGHIIHNWLYYJHQXJJVLQGXQGGZDVVDXVVGHPP'HVDVWHUULQQ6RPDOLDDLQQ+LQEOLFNN DXIIlKQOLFKHH.RQIOLNWHHZLHH]%LPP6XGDQQJHOHUQWWZXUGHZHUGHQQNDQQ :LHHDOOHVVEHJDQQQ

1DFKKGHUU$XIWHLOXQJJ6RPDOLDVV]ZLVFKHQQGHQQ.RORQLDOPlFKWHQQ)UDQNUHLFK *UR‰EULWDQQLHQQXQGG,WDOLHQQJHJHQQ(QGHHGHVV-DKUKXQGHUWVNDPPHVVDPP ]XUU9HUHLQLJXQJJGHVVEULWLVFKVRPDOLVFKHQQXQGGGHVVLWDOLHQLVFKVRPDOLVFKHQQ7HUUL WRULXPV'HUU6WDDWW6RPDOLDDZDUUJHERUHQ

'LHH8QDEKlQJLJNHLWWYHUOLHIIXQEOXWLJJRKQHHHLQHHHLQ]LJHH.DPSIKDQGOXQJJHLQHUU%HIUHL XQJVEHZHJXQJJZLHHHVVGDPDOVVGXUFKDXVVEOLFKKJHZHVHQQLVWW]%9LHWQDP$OJHULHQQ XVZ'LHHVFKRQQ]XXNRORQLDOHQQ=HLWHQQZLOONUOLFKKIHVWJHOHJWHQQ*UHQ]HQQZXUGHQQ EHLEHKDOWHQVRRDXFKKGLHH*UHQ]HH]XXbWKLRSLHQQE]Z]XPP2JDDGHQZDVVVSlWHUU$QODVVV ]XUUZHLWHUHQQ9HUVFKlUIXQJJGHUULQQHUVRPDOLVFKHQQ6LWXDWLRQQJHEHQQVROOWHGRFKKGD]XX VSlWHUUPHKU,PP-DKUUZXUGHHGHPPVHLWWGHPP-DKUKXQGHUWWLVODPLVFKKEHHLQIOXVVWHQQ QHXHQQ6WDDWWHLQHH9HUIDVVXQJJQDFKKZHVWOLFKHPP9RUELOGGPLWWHLQHPP0HKUSDUWHLHQV\VWHPP JHJHEHQLQQQGHUU$QQDKPHGDVVVGLHVV]XXVWDELOHQQ9HUKlOWQLVVHQQIKUHQQZLUGVRRZLHHHVV

DXFKKLPP:HVWHQQGHUU)DOOOJHZHVHQQLVW 'LHVVVROOWHHVLFKKVSlWHUUMHGRFKKDOVV,UUWXPPKHUDXV VWHOOHQ(LQQ6WDDWE]ZGDVV0RGHOOOHLQHVV6WDDWHVVQDFKK6FKQHFNHQHUUI ZLHH ZLUULKQQLQQXQVHUHPP.XOWXUNUHLVVNHQQHQKDWWHVVDOVVVROFKHVVLQQ6RPDOLDZLHHDXFKKLQQ PDQFKHQQDQGHUHQQDIULNDQLVFKHQQ6WDDWHQQ6XGDQ7VFKDGXDQLHHJHJHEHQ $IULNDDGLHQWHHIROJOLFKKHKHUUDOVV9HUVXFKVJHOlQGHHIUUGLHH6FKDIIXQJJYRQQ6WDDWHQ 5DLQHUU7HW]ODIIIEH]HLFKQHWWGHQQSRVWNRORQLDOHQQ6WDDWWLQQ$IULNDDVRJDUUDOVVV

³KLVWRULVFKHVV.XQVWSURGXNWZHOFKHUUVHLQHHKHXWLJHH([LVWHQ]]QLFKWWHWZDDDDDDDDDD LQQHUJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHUU(QWZLFNOXQJVRQGHUQ³ZLHHEHUHLWVVDQJHVSURFKHQ ³YLHOPHKUUUGHPP:LOOHQQXQGGGHQQ+HUUVFKDIWVDQVSUFKHQQULYDOLVLHUHQGHUUUU .RORQLDOPlFKWHH]XXYHUGDQNHQQKDW ´´

6RPDOLDDZDUUYRQQMHKHUUHKHUUHLQQ/DQGLQGHPPQRPDGLVLHUHQGHH9LHK]FKWHUULQQHUKDOEE HLQHUUIHVWHQQDFKKHWKQLVFKHUU=XJHK|ULJNHLWWJHWUHQQWHQQ&ODQ*HVHOOVFKDIWWOHEWHQ 6RRELOGHWHQQVLFKKDXFKKYLHOHHGHUUQHXXHQWVWDQGHQHQQ3DUWHLHQQDXVVGLHVHQQ MDKUKXQGHUWHDOWHQQ&ODQVWUXNWXUHQ KHUDXVMHGHUU&ODQQKDWWHHVHLQHHHLJHQHH3DUWHL ZHOFKHUUHVVHKHUUDXII0DFKWHUZHUEEXQGG0DFKW]XJHZLQQQDQNDPGHQQQDXII JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHH.RQVHQVILQGXQJJXQGGQDWLRQDOHH,GHQWLWlWVVWLIWXQJDXFKKIKOWHQQVLFKK GLHHJHZlKOWHQQ9HUWUHWHUUQLFKWWGHQQ:lKOHUQVRQGHUQQLKUHQQ&ODQVVJHJHQEHUU YHUDQWZRUWOLFKK

'LHVHH*UQGHHIKUWHQQXQWHUUDQGHUHPPGD]XGDVVVGLHHMXQJHHVRPDOLVFKHH'HPRNUDWLHH QLFKWWYRQQDOOO]XXODQJHUU'DXHUUZDU

V%5''QDFKKXQGG-DSDQQQDFKK 0RGHOOOGHUUÄGUHLL.HUQIXQNWLRQHQ³6LFKHUKHLW:RKOIDKUWWXQGG/HJLWLPLWlWVXQGG5HFKWVWDDWOLFKNHLWW 5DLQHUU7HW]ODIIIÄ/DQGNDUWHHGHUU.RQIOLNWH)DLOLQJJVWDWHVLQQ$IULND.XQVWSURGXNWHHDXVVGHUU .RORQLDO]HLWWXQGGHXURSlLVFKHH9HUDQWZRUWXQJ³³LQQQ KWWSZZZLQWHUQDWLRQDOHSROLWLNGHDUFKLYMDKUJDQJMXOLIDLOLQJVWDWHVV /LQHDJH3ULQ]LSSQDFKK((YDQV3ULWFKDUGGDXFKKDOVVVHJPHQWlUHVVSROLWLVFKHVV6\VWHPPEH]HLFKQHWW 9JO)RUWHV0H\HU(YDQV3ULWFKDUGG³$IULFDQQSROLWLFDOO6\VWHP³/RQGRQQ YJO-XWWDD%DNRQ\LLÄInstabile Staatlichkeit- =XUU7UDQVIRUPDWLRQQSROLWLVFKHUU+HUUVFKDIWWLQQ6RPDOLD³³ $UEHLWVSDSLHUU1U8QLYHUVLWlWW+DPEXUJJ,3:6III