,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLV

+LQIKUXQJ]XPP7KHPDDXQGG(UOlXWHUXQJGHUU)UDJHVWHOOXQJ««««««««

'LHH5HGHQQGHVV3HULNOHV«««««««««««««««««««««««

'HUU3HVWEHULFKW««««««««««««««««««««««««««

'HUU0\WLOHQH%HVFKOXVV««««««««««««««««««««««

'LHH3DWKRORJLHHGHVV.ULHJHV«««««««««««««««««««««

'HUU0HOLHU'LDORJ«««««««««««««««««««««««

'LHH6L]LOLHQ'HEDWWH«««««««««««««««««««««««

)D]LW««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««

4XHOOHQYHU]HLFKQLV««««««««««««««««««««««««

/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV«««««««««««««««««««««««

2

+LQIKUXQJJ]XP7KHPDDXQGG(UOlXWHUXQJJGHU)UDJHVWHOOXQJ

7KXN\GLGHVV JLOWW DOVV HLQHUU GHUU EHGHXWHQGVWHQQ +LVWRULNHUU GHUU $QWLNH 6HLQQ :HUNN EHUU GHQQ 3HORSRQQHVLVFKHQQ .ULHJ ZLUGG DOVV IUKHV 0XVWHU HLQHUU KLVWRULVFKHQQ 0RQRJUDSKLH GHPP YLHOHH DQGHUHH +LVWRULNHUU JHIROJW VLQG JHVHKHQ 2EE PDQQ LKQQ ZLHH +ROJHUU 6RQQDEHQGG DOVV 9DWHUU GHU NULWLVFKHQQ *HVFKLFKWVVFKUHLEXQJJ EH]HLFKQHQQ P|FKWH GDD HUU ÄKLVWRULRJUDSKLVFKHH 0D‰VWlEH JHVHW]W³ KDWW RGHUU LKPP ZLHH &LFHURR HKHUU NULWLVFK JHJHQEHUVWHKHQQ VROOWHH LVWW LQQ GHUU )RUVFKXQJJ XPVWULWWHQ 8QWHUU DQGHUHPP ZLUGG +HURGRW HEHQIDOOVV LQQ GHU $QWLNHH XQG YRUU GHUU =HLWW YRQ 7KXN\GLGHVV EHKHLPDWHW DOVV HUVWHUU *HVFKLFKWVVFKUHLEHUU EH]HLFKQHW +HURGRWW VFKULHEE VHLQH Ä+LVWRULHQ³PLWWGHP$QVSUXFKKDOOHVVVRRDXIJH]HLFKQHWW]XXKDEHQZLHHHUUHVVJHK|UWWKDEHHRKQHH VLFKKGDUEHUUHLQHH0HLQXQJJHELOGHWW]XXKDEHQ

+ROJHUU 6RQQDEHQGG VLHKWW +HURGRWW DOVV HLQHQ UHLQHQ &KURQLVWHQ GHUU QHEHQQ GHPP 6DPPHOQQ YRQQ 0DWHULDOOVFKRQQGDPLWWEHJRQQHQQKDWHVVÄ]XXVWUXNWXULHUHQ(UNOlUXQJHQQXQG%HJUQGXQJHQQIUU GHQQ (LQWULWWW GHUU (UHLJQLVVHH ]XX ILQGHQQ XQG EHUJUHLIHQGHH KLVWRULVFKHH =XVDPPHQKlQJH³ KHUJHVWHOOWWKDW'RFKKIULKQQLVWW7KXN\GLGHVVHLQHQQ6FKULWWWZHLWHUJHJDQJHQQXQGGKDWWHVVJHVFKDIIW GLHH.UlIWHDXVILQGLJ]XXPDFKHQGLHHÄGHUU*HVFKLFKWHHLKUHQQ/DXIIJHEHQ³ ZDVVGLHHK|FKVWHHXQG DQVSUXFKVYROOVWHH$XIJDEHHLQHVV+LVWRULNHUVVVHL

7KXN\GLGHVVYHUIDVVWHHLQQVHLQHPP:HUNNXQWHUU9HUZHQGXQJJGHUU5LFKWOLQLHQYRQQJU|‰WP|JOLFKHU *HQDXLJNHLWW XQGG GHUU 'RNXPHQWDWLRQQ GHVV ZDKUVFKHLQOLFKVWHQQ $EODXIHVV GHUU (UHLJQLVVH 'DQQ QLPPWW HUU IU VLFK LQQ $QVSUXFK KLQWHU GHQQ %HULFKWW ]XUFN]XWUHWHQQ XQGG GDVV *HVFKHKHQHH REMHNWLYY ]XX GRNXPHQWLHUHQ 6HLQQ =LHOO ZDU HVV HLQHQQ Äκτῆμα ἐς ἀεί³ HLQHQQ EHUU GLHH =HLWHQ UHLFKHQGHQQ%HVLW]]]XXVFKDIIHQZDV]XJOHLFKKÄZDKUVFKHLQOLFKKGLHHEHNDQQWHVWHH5HGHZHQGXQJ³ VHLQHVV:HUNHVVLVW

'DHUUQLFKWWEHLLDOOHQ)HOG]JHQXQGG9HUKDQGOXQJHQQZlKUHQGGGHVJHVDPWHQ.ULHJHVVGDEHLLVHLQQ NRQQWHVWW]HQQVLFKKVHLQHH%HULFKWHDXIP|JOLFKVWWYLHOHH$XJHQ]HXJHQZREHLLHUUDOVV=HLW]HXJHH GHVV.ULHJHVVZXVVWHZHOFKHH3HUVRQHQQ]XXEHIUDJHQQZDUHQ

6RQQDEHQG+7KXN\GLGHV'DUPVWDGW6

+HURGRW+LVWRULHVV$SRGH[LV'DVV*HVFKLFKWVZHUNNGHVV+HURGRWWYRQ+DOLNDUQDVVRV+UVJ%UDXQ7 )UDQNIXUWWD0,, 6RQQDEHQG6 (EG6 (EG6

/HQGOH2.WHPDHLVVDHL7KXN\GLGHVVXQG+HURGRW,Q5K006 (EG6

3

:LHH LQQ MHGHPP VHOEVWYHUIDVVWHQQ :HUNN NDQQQ PDQ EHLL HLQHUU WLHIHUHQQ $QDO\VHH YHUVFKLHGHQHU 7H[WVWHOOHQQDXFKKGLHH0RWLYDWLRQHQQXQGG0HLQXQJHQQGHVV$XWRUVVHUNHQQHQ,QQ7KXN\GLGHVV:HUN JLEWW HV PHKUIDFKK VROFKHH 6WHOOHQ LQQ GHQHQ XQWHUVFKZHOOLJJ VHLQHH HLJHQHH 0HLQXQJ HLQEDXW LVWW RGHUU GLHVV JDQ]] EHZXVVWW JHPDFKWW ZXUGH 'XUFKK GLHVHH $XV]JHH OlVVWW VLFKK IU GHQQ /HVHUU GDV 0HQVFKHQELOGG7KXN\GLGHVVKHUDXVDUEHLWHQ(VVLVW]XXHUZDUWHQGDVVV7KXN\GLGHVVGHQQ0HQVFKHQ XQGGVHLQHH(LJHQVFKDIWHQQVFKOHFKWWGDUVWHOOWWXQGGPLWWLKPPKDUWWLQVV*HULFKWWJHKWGHQQQHUUZDUUHLQQ $QKlQJHUU GHUU VRSKLVWLVFKHQQ /HKUH 'LHVHH ZLUGG FKDUDNWHULVLHUWW GXUFKK GLHH hEHU]HXJXQJ GDVVV GHUU 0HQVFKK DOVV HLQQ YRQQ 0DFKWWULHEE XQGG hEHUOHEHQVZLOOHQQ JHVWHXHUWHVV :HVHQ LVW GDVV EHU DOOHQQDQGHUHQQ:HVHQQVWHKW

(VVZLUGG]XXVHKHQVHLQLQZLHIHUQVLFKK+HURGRWVVXQGG7KXN\GLGHV¶¶0HQVFKHQELOGGXQWHUVFKHLGHQ EH]LHKXQJVZHLVHH ZHOFKHH *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQQ EHLGHH KDEHQ 6LHH VWDPPHQQ EHLGHH DXVV GHUVHOEHQQ (SRFKH GRFKK LKUH %HULFKWHH ZXUGHQ PLWW MHZHLOV DQGHUHQQ 0HWKRGHQQ JHVFKULHEHQ 7URW]GHPP P|FKWHQQEHLGHHK|FKVWHH2EMHNWLYLWlWWJDUDQWLHUHQ

'D 9HUJOHLFKH ]ZHLHUU $XWRUHQQ VHKUU NRPSOH[ XQGG VFKZLHULJ VLQG RULHQWLHUWW VLFKK GLHH $UEHLWW FKURQRORJLVFKKDQQGHQQJHZlKOWHQQ7H[WSDVVDJHQQGHVV7KXN\GLGHV%HLLGHQQPHLVWHQQ6WHOOHQQJLEWW HVVYHUJOHLFKHQGHH3DVVDJHQQYRQQ+HURGRWZHOFKHHGDQQQNXU]]DQDO\VLHUWWZHUGHQ=LHOOLVWWHVVGDV 0HQVFKHQELOGGGHVV7KXN\GLGHVV]XXDQDO\VLHUHQQXQGGHVVPLWWGHQQJHZlKOWHQQ6WHOOHQQGHVV+HURGRW ]XXYHUJOHLFKHQ

=X%HJLQQQGHUU$UEHLWWVWHKHQQGLHYRQQ7KXN\GLGHVVDXIJHVFKULHEHQHQ5HGHQGHVV3HULNOHVV, ±,,±,,± 'DUDXIIROJWGHUU3HVWEHULFKWWGHV7KXN\GLGHVV,,±LQGHP HUUGHQQJHQDXHQQ9HUODXIIGHUU.UDQNKHLWWXQGGGHQQ8PJDQJPLWWGHU6HXFKHHEHVFKUHLEW

(LQQZHLWHUHU$XV]XJGHUUGLHH9HUGHXWOLFKXQJYRQQ7KXN\GLGHV¶¶0HQVFKHQELOGGHUP|JOLFKWLVWW GLHH'LVNXVVLRQQGHUU9RONVYHUVDPPOXQJJEHUUGHQQ0\WLOHQH%HVFKOXVVV,,,±'LHH$WKHQHU KDEHQQ GLH (QWVFKHLGXQJJ JHIDVVW GLH JHVDPWHH %HY|ONHUXQJJ GHUU 3ROLVV 0\WLOHQHH XP]XEULQJHQ 'RFKK DPP GDUDXII IROJHQGHQQ 7DJ EHUGHQNHQ VLHH LKUHQQ %HVFKOXVVV QRFKK HLQPDO 'LHVHU 7H[WDEVFKQLWWWOlVVWWVLFKKVHKUUJXWPLWWHLQLJHQQ6WHOOHQQDXVV+HURGRWVV*HVFKLFKWVZHUNN,,,, YHUJOHLFKHQ LQQ GHQHQQ GLHH +HUUVFKHUU 3HUVLHQV GXUFKK GLHH )OOHH LKUHUU 0DFKWW NRUUXPSLHUW ZHUGHQ

9JO0HLVWHU.'LHHJULHFKLVFKHH*HVFKLFKWVVFKUHLEXQJ6WXWWJDUW6±

+HURGRW,,7KXN\GLGHV,±

7KXN\GLGHV'HUU3HORSRQQHVLVFKH.ULHJ+UVJ9UHWVND+5LQQHU:6WXWWJDUW

4

(LQHHZHLWHUH3DVVDJHLVWWGLHH3DWKRORJLHHGHVV.ULHJHVV,,,±7KXN\GLGHVVEHVFKUHLEWWGHQQ $XVEUXFKK GHUU 6WDVLV KHXWHH ZRKOO DOVV %UJHUNULHJ ]XX EH]HLFKQHQ DXII .HUN\UDD XQGG GLHH GDPLWW HLQKHUJHKHQGHH9HUURKXQJGHUU6LWWHQ

'HUU 0HOLHUGLDORJ ,9 ± LQQ GHPP GLHH $WKHQHUU PLWW GHQQ 0HOLHUQQ YHUKDQGHOQ XPP HLQ IULHGOLFKHVV (QGHH GHUU %HODJHUXQJ ]XX EHVFKOLH‰HQ LVWW GLHH YRUOHW]WH 7H[WSDVVDJH YRQ 7KXN\GLGHV%HLL+HURGRWILQGHQQVLFKGD]XXVHKUYLHOHHYHUJOHLFKEDUH6WHOOHQGDDGLHSHUVLVFKHQQ .|QLJHHVHKUURIWWlKQOLFKKDUURJDQWWZLHHGLHH$WKHQHUUDXII0HORVVJHKDQGHOWWKDEHQ

(LQQ OHW]WHUU $XV]XJ LVWW GLHH 'LVNXVVLRQQ ]ZLVFKHQQ 1LNLDVV XQGG $ONLELDGHVV YRU GHU 9RONVYHUVDPPOXQJ9,±ZREHLLGDUEHUUGHEDWWLHUWWZLUGREEPDQQHLQHH([SHGLWLRQQQDFKK 6\UDNXVV VWDUWHQQ VROO (LQHQQ JXWHQQ 9HUJOHLFKK KDWW PDQQ LQQ +HURGRWW PLWW GHPP 'LDORJ ]ZLVFKHQ ;HU[HVVXQGG0DUGRQLRVV9,,±GDDEHLLEHLGHQ7H[WSDVVDJHQHLQQ,QGLYLGXXPPVHLQHHHLJHQHQQ =LHOHHYHUIROJWWXQGGYHUVXFKWWGLHH(QWVFKHLGXQJVWUlJHUUGDYRQQ]XXEHU]HXJHQQGLHVHH]XXYHUIROJHQ

=XPP $EVFKOXVVV GHU $UEHLWW IROJWW HLQHH NXU]HH =XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ GHVV LQ 7KXN\GLGHVV :HUNN JH]HLFKQHWHQQ0HQVFKHQELOGHVXQGGHLQHPPNXU]HQQ9HUJOHLFKKPLWW+HURGRW

'LHH5HGHQQGHVV3HULNOHVV,±,,±,,±

2IWW NRPPWW HVV LQQ 7KXN\GLGHVV :HUN YRU GDVV VLFKK JHJHQEHUVWHKHQGH 3DUWHLHQQ DQRQ\P EOHLEHQQXQGGQXUUGLHH$WKHQHUURGHUUGLHH6SDUWDQHUJHQDQQWWZHUGHQ3HULNOHVVLVWWHLQHUGHUZHQLJHQQ &KDUDNWHUH GLH DOVV LPP HLJHQHQQ 1DPHQ VSUHFKHQGHH 3HUVRQQ YRUNRPPHQ ,Q ÄGUHLL JUR‰HQQ 5HGHQ³ ZHUGHQQ GLHH 3ULQ]LSLHQQ VHLQHUU 3ROLWLNN GDUJHVWHOOW ZHOFKH VLFKK DQQ GHQQ =LHOHQQ GHUU

,QGHUUHUVWHQQ5HGHZHOFKHHYRUUHLQHUU9HUVDPPOXQJ9HUEQGHWHUUVWDWWILQGHWWULWWW3HULNOHVVDXII XQGGUHFKWIHUWLJWGLHH6WHOOXQJ$WKHQVV]XXVHLQHQQ%QGQHUQ 'LHVHHZROOWHHQlPOLFKKGLHH6SDUWDQHU GD]XXEHUUHGHQQ$WKHQQ]XX]ZLQJHQVHLQHH0DFKWSRVLWLRQQ]XXUlXPHQ$OVVVLFKK*ULHFKHQODQGGPLWW GHQQ3HUVHUQQLPP.ULHJEHIDQGGXQGGGLHH /DNHGDLPRQLHUUVLFKKQLFKWWGDUDQQEHWHLOLJHQQZROOWHQGLHH 3HUVHUUDXVVGHPP5HVWW*ULHFKHQODQGVV]XX YHUWUHLEHQZXUGHQQGLHH$WKHQHUUJHEHWHQGLHH)KUXQJJ EHUU GLHH ZLGHUVWlQGLVFKHQQ 3ROHLVV ]X EHUQHKPHQ 3HULNOHVV EHVFKUHLEWW HVV DOVV $NWW GHUU PHQVFKOLFKHQQ 1DWXUU HLQHH 0DFKWSRVLWLRQQ QLFKWW ZLHGHUKHUJHEHQQ ]XX ZROOHQ ZHQQQ PDQQ VLH

9JO9RJW-7KHH3RUWUDLWWRI3HULFOHVVLQ7KXF\GLGHV,Q+UVJ5XVWHQ-7KXF\GLGHV2[IRUG6 ^(EG6 7KXN\GLGHV,

5

HLQPDOO LQQHKDW 'LHH VWlUNVWHQQ %HZHJJUQGH DOVR Ä(KUH )XUFKWW XQGG 1XW]HQ³ ZUGHQQ GLH $WKHQHUUGDUDQQKLQGHUQ$X‰HUGHPP KDEH$WKHQQLPPHUUJHUHFKWHUU JHKDQGHOWWDOVV PDQQDXIJUXQG VHLQHUU 0DFKWSRVLWLRQQ JHPXVVWW KlWWH (VV JLEWW DOVRR NHLQHQQ *UXQGG VLFKK QLFKWW YRQQ $WKHQ EHKHUUVFKHQQ]XXODVVHQGDPDQQVLFKKJOFNOLFKVFKlW]HQQNDQQVROFKKJXWHH%QGQHUUJHIXQGHQQ]X KDEHQ

'LHH ]ZHLWHH 5HGHH GHVV 3HULNOHVV LVWW GLHH VRJHQDQQWHH Ä/HLFKHQUHGH³ 1DFK MHGHPP .ULHJVMDKU ZXUGHH GHQQ LPP .ULHJ *HIDOOHQHQ JHGDFKWW XQGG HLQQ 5HGHH ]XX LKUHQQ (KUHQ JHKDOWHQ 3HULNOHV EHJLQQWW GDPLWW GHQQ =XK|UHUQQ YRQ GHUU *HVFKLFKWHH GHU 6WDDWVYHUIDVVXQJ XQGG GHQQ 2SIHUQ GHU 9RUIDKUHQ ]XX HU]lKOHQ (UU ZROOWHH LKQHQQ DXI]X]HLJHQ LQ ZDV IU HLQHPP EHZXQGHUQVZHUWHQ 6WDDWW VLHH OHEHQQ XQGG ZLHH ZHUWYROOO HVV LVWW GLHVHQQ ]XX YHUWHLGLJHQQ XQGG .ULHJ ]XX IKUHQ 'DPLW UHFKWIHUWLJW HU DXFK GDVVV GLHH *HIDOOHQHQQ IU HLQHQQ JXWHQQ *UXQGG JHVWRUEHQQ VLQG Ä)U GDV *HPHLQZHVHQJDEHQQVLHHLKUU/HEHQQKLQQ>«@,KQHQQHLIHUWWMHW]WWQDFKHUNHQQWWGDVVZDKUHH*OFNN LQQGHUU)UHLKHLW>«@³ 3HULNOHVVIRUGHUWWGLHH=XK|UHUUGD]XXDXIIZHLWHUKLQQGHPP3IDGGHVV.ULHJHV ]XXIROJHQQXQGGQLFKWW]XXODQJHGHQQ7RWHQQQDFK]XWUDXHUQGDDVLHHHLQHVVZUGLJHQQ7RGHVVJHVWRUEHQQ VHLHQ

'LHH GULWWHH XQGG OHW]WHH 5HGHH GHVV 3HULNOHVV LVWW QLFKW DQQlKHUQGG VRR IHLHUOLFK ZLHH GLHH 9RUKHULJH 1DFKGHPPGLHH6SDUWDQHUUPLWWLKUHPP.|QLJ$UFKLGDPRV MHGHVV-DKUULQQ$WWLNDDHLQILHOHQQXQGGGDV /DQGYRONNVLFKKKLQWHUUGLHH6WDGWPDXHUQQ]XUFN]LHKHQQPXVVWHEUDFKKHLQHHJUR‰HH6HXFKHHDXV9RUU ODXWHUU 9HU]ZHLIOXQJ ULFKWHWHH VLFKK LKUHH :XWW DXII 3HULNOHV GHUU HLQHQQ QLFKW NOHLQHQQ $QWHLOO DQ GLHVHUU6LWXDWLRQQKDWWHGDHUU$WKHQQLQQGHQQ.ULHJJHIKUWWKDWWH3HULNOHVVZHKUWHHVLFKKYHKHPHQW JHJHQQ GLHVHH 9RUZUIHH XQGG EHVFKXOGLJWHH GLHH $WKHQHUU GHUU :DQNHOPWLJNHLW ÄhEHUU HXHU KlXVOLFKHVV (OHQG HUVFKWWHUW VFKHUWW LKU HXFK QLFKWW XPP GLHH 5HWWXQJ GHVV *HPHLQZHVHQV XQG PLU GHUU ]XPP .ULHJ ULHW XQGG HXFKK VHOEVW GLHH LKUU LKQQ PLWW PLUU EHVFKORVVHQQ KDEW PDFKWW LKUU 9RUZUIH 8QGG GRFK 0LUU JUROOWW LKU HLQHPP 0DQQ GHUU ZLHH NHLQQ DQGHUHU >«@@ GLHH 6WDGW OLHEWW >«@³

7KXN\GLGHV,

(EG, 7KXN\GLGHV,,± (EG,,±

,PVRJ$UFKLGDPLVFKHQ.ULHJY&KU±Y&KUILHOOGHUUVSDUWDQLVFKHH.|QLJ$UFKLGDPRVMlKUOLFKPLWW VHLQHP+HHUULQ$WWLNDDHLQZDVVGLHH0HQVFKHQQGD]XYHUDQODVVWHVLFKKKLQWHUGHQQ)HVWXQJVPDXHUQ]ZLVFKHQGHUU 6WDGWWXQGGHP3LUlXVGHUU+DIHQDQODQJH]XXYHUVWHFNHQ 7KXN\GLGHV,,±

6