,QKDOWVYHU]HLFKQLVV (LQOHLWXQJ (OHPHQWDULVLHUXQJXQGG$QDO\VHHGHUU5HIHUDWHH Ä'HU+HLOLJH*HLVW³3DUWKHQLRV3DWULDUFKKYRQ$OH[DQGULHQQ

Ä.RPP+HLOLJHUU*HLVWW±HUQHXHUHHGLHHJDQ]HH6FK|SIXQJ³

(LQHH(LQIKUXQJLQQGDVVWKHRORJLVFKHH7KHPDDYRQQ 3URIHVVRULQQ&KXQJ+\XQQ.\XQJ

9HUJOHLFKKGHUUEHLGHQQ5HIHUDWHHXQGG3RVLWLRQHQQ

'LHH.RQWURYHUVHHLPP$QVFKOXVVVDQQ)UDXX&KXQJVV5HIHUDWWW )D]LWW :HLWHUIKUHQGHH/LWHUDWXU /LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLVV

(LQOHLWXQJ

'LHH6LHEWHH9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJGHVVgNXPHQLVFKHQ5DWVVGHUU.LUFKHQQg5.IDQG YRPPELV]XP)HEUXDUULQQ&DQEHUUDGHU+DXSWVWDGWW$XVWUDOLHQVVVWDWW XQGGGDVV7KHPDDZDUUGHUU+HLOLJH*HLVWNRQNUHWWDOVV$QUXIXQJRGHUU*HEHWIRUPX OLHUWÃ.RPP+HLOLJHUU *HLVWW±±HUQHXHUHGLH JDQ]H6FK|SIXQJ¶ $XIGHU 9ROO YHUVDPPOXQJZXUGHQQDPP)HEUXDU]ZHLL5HIHUDWHHJHKDOWHQQE]ZYRUJHWUDJHQ

'DVV HUVWH 5HIHUDW XQWHU GHP 7LWHOO Ä'HU +HLOLJH *HLVW³ KLHOWWGHU *UR‰ SURWRSUHVE\WHU *HRUJHV 7VHWVLV 5HSUlVHQWDQW GHVV gNXPHQLVFKHQ 3DWULDUFKDWV YRQQ.RQVWDQWLQRSHOOLQQ*HQI$XWRUGHV5HIHUDWHVZDUDOOHUGLQJV3DUWKHQLRVV,,, JULHFKLVFKRUWKRGR[HUU 3DWULDUFK YRQQ $OH[DQGULHQ GHU ZHJHQQ GHVV GDPDOLJHQ *ROINULHJVQLFKWWDQQGHUU9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJWHLOQHKPHQQNRQQWH (UUZXUGHH JHERUHQZXUGH3DWULDUFKKXQGEOLHEHVELVV]XXVHLQHPP7RG =XP6WLO

VHLQHVV 5HIHUDWHVV LVWW ]XX VDJHQ GDVVV GLHH 6SUDFKHH ]ZDU KlXILJ K|O]HUQQ XQGG ZLHH HLQHH DNDGHPLVFKH 9RUOHVXQJ NOLQJW XQG GDVVV VLHH ÄHLQJHEHWWHWW >LVW@@ LQQ HLQH GRJPDWLVFKGHILQLWRULVFKH 6SUDFKH³ DEHUU GLH 6SUDFKHH LVW NHLQHVZHJV QHXWUDO VRQGHUQQHKHUUIHLHUOLFKXQGGVLHHNOLQJWKlXILJZLHHLQQ&UHGRRRGHUUHLQQ/REOLHGDXII GHQQ+HLOLJHQ*HLVW

'DVV]ZHLWH5HIHUDWWZXUGHYRQQGHUUJHERUHQHQNRUHDQLVFKHQQ7KHR ORJLQQXQGG3URIHVVRULQQ&KXQJ+\XQQ.\XQJJHKDOWHQGLHH0LWJOLHGGHLQHUUSUHVE\ WHULDQLVFKHQ.LUFKHHLVWWXQGGLQQ6GNRUHDXQGGLQGHQQ86$$VWXGLHUWWKDW ,P$Q VFKOXVVVDQQLKUU5HIHUDWJDEHVVHLQH.RQWURYHUVHHXPLKUU5HIHUDW2UWKRGR[HHXQG (YDQJHOLNDOHHEH]RJHQQJHPHLQVDPPDXVVHLQHUUFKULVWRORJLVFKHQQ3RVLWLRQQ6WHOOXQJJ JHJHQQ )UDXX &KXQJ XQWHU DQGHUHPP ZXUGH LKUU GHU 9RUZXUI GHVV 6\QNUHWLVPXVV XQGGGHVV6FKDPDQLVPXVVE]ZGHUU*HLVWHUEHVFKZ|UXQJJHPDFKW

=XQlFKVWW HUIROJWW LQQ GLHVHU $UEHLWW HLQHH (OHPHQWDULVLHUXQJ XQGG $QDO\VH GHUUEHLGHQQ5HIHUDWHGDQDFKKZHUGHQQGLHH3RVLWLRQHQQPLWHLQDQGHUUYHUJOLFKHQXQGG HVV ZLUGG DXII GLHH .RQWURYHUVHH XPP &KXQJV 5HIHUDW HLQJHJDQJHQQ ZHUGHQ ELVGLH (UJHEQLVVHHGHU$UEHLWWVFKOLH‰OLFKKLQQHLQHP)D]LWW]XVDPPHQJHIDVVWWZHUGHQ

9JO/LQ]]8UEDQ6

9JO $UWLNHO3DWULDUFKK 3DUWKHQLRV ,,, RI $OH[DQGULDDQG $OO $IULFDD GLHV 2ELWXDULHV ^{85/ VLHKHH/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV=XJULII} /LQ]]]8UEDQ6

=XP$XIEDXGHUU$UEHLW$XVVWLOLVWLVFKHQ*UQGHQYHU]LFKWHLFKDXIGDV%LQQHQÄ,³DOVRUHGH LFKEHLVSLHOVZHLVHQLFKWYRQQ=XK|UHU,QQHQDXFKQLFKWYRQ=XK|UHUQXQG=XK|UHULQQHQ6RZHLW GHU.RQWH[WQLFKWHWZDVVDQGHUHVVQDKHOHJWVLQGDEHULPPHU)UDXHQXQG0lQQHUJHPHLQW

(OHPHQWDULVLHUXQJJXQGG$QDO\VHHGHUU5HIHUDWHH

)UU HLQ EHVVHUHV XQGG P|JOLFKVWW GHWDLOOLHUWHV XQG ZLUNOLFKNHLWVJHWUHXHVV 9HU VWlQGQLVV ZHUGHQQ ]XQlFKVW GLHH EHLGHQQ JHKDOWHQHQQ 5HIHUDWH LQ GHUU 5HLKHQIROJH ZLHHVLHHDPP)HEUXDUUJHKDOWHQQZXUGHQHOHPHQWDULVLHUWWXQGGGHUHQ7KHROR JLHE]Z*HGDQNHQQDQDO\VLHUW

Ä'HUU+HLOLJHH*HLVW³3DUWKHQLRV3DWULDUFKYRQ$OH[DQGULHQ

3DUWKHQLRVVEHJLQQWVHLQQ5HIHUDWLQGHPHUVDJWGHUgNXPHQLVFKHH5DWGHU.LU FKHQQ g5. EH VHLQH 7lWLJNHLWW LPP 1DPHQ GHV GUHLHLQLJHQ *RWWHVV DXV 3DU WKHQLRVVOREWWGLHH(QWVFKHLGXQJGHVV=HQWUDODXVVFKXVVHVVGHVVg5.IUUGLHVHH9ROO YHUVDPPOXQJJ GDVV 7KHPDD GHVV +HLOLJHQ *HLVWHVV DXI]XJUHLIHQ GHQQQ KLHUGXUFK NRPPHHPDQQGHQQ=LHOHQQQlKHUGLHLKPPDPP]HQWUDOVWHQQHUVFKHLQHQÄ>:@LU>EH ILQGHQ@ XQVV MDD DOOHH DXI GHPP :HJJ ]XUU (LQKHLWW GHUU .LUFKH GHUU (LQKHLWW DOOHUU 0HQVFKHQ>«@XQGGZLUU>P|FKWHQ@LQVV*HKHLPQLVV*RWWHVHLQGULQJHQ³

3DUWKHQLRVV NRPPWW ]XQlFKVWW DXII GHQ %HJULII Ä*HKHLPQLV³ ]X VSUHFKHQQ XQGG HUUEH]HLFKQHWW GLHH .LUFKHH XQGG GLHH +HLOLJH 'UHLHLQLJNHLW H[SOL]LWW DXFKK GHQ +HLOLJHQ*HLVWDOVVHLQQ*HKHLPQLVHUIlKUWWGDPLWWIRUW]XQlFKVWWGLH:HLWHHGHU (UIDKUEDUNHLWWGHVV+HLOLJHQQ*HLVWHV]XXEHVFKUHLEHQ (UUHQWJHJQHWWGHUU0HLQXQJJ PDQFKHUYHUPXWOLFKKRUWKRGR[HU&KULVWHQGHUU+HLOLJH*HLVWWVHL]XDOOHUUHUVWWLQQ GHUU 2UWKRGR[HQQ .LUFKHH ]X ILQGHQ LQGHP HUU VDJW Ä,FK JODXEHH YLHOPHKU GD‰‰ >VLF@DOOH.LUFKHQLPP+HLOLJHQ*HLVWWOHEHQQXQGZHEHQ.HLQHH.LUFKHNHLQ*H VFK|SINHLQ0HQVFKKOHEWWYRPP*HLVWWJHWUHQQW³ 'LHVHXQLYHUVHOOH6LFKWWGHU(U IDKUEDUNHLWW GHVV +HLOLJHQ *HLVWHVV JUHQ]WW HU DEHU NODUU HLQ GDD HU GHQQ +HLOLJHQ *HLVWWHLQGHXWLJPLWWGHUU7ULQLWlWWLGHQWLIL]LHUWWXQGGNODUVWHOOWÄ$X‰HUKDOEGHUU+HLO LJHQ'UHLHLQLJNHLWWJLEWWHVNHLQHQQ+HLOLJHQ*HLVW³ ,PZHLWHUHQQ9HUODXIIZLUGLQ GLHVHPP =XVDPPHQKDQJ DXFKK VHLQQ 9HUVWlQGQLVV YRQQ .LUFKH GHXWOLFK LQGHPP HUU

9JO3DUWKHQLRV6

^{6+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRPP9HUIDVVHU 9JO6 6} ,EG

HLQVFKUlQNHQGG IHVWVWHOOW Ä$XFKK GLH .LUFKH VHLQQ >VF GHU +HLOLJH *HLVW@@ 9RON

3DUWKHQLRVVFKDUDNWHULVLHUWGDVVYRUKHUUJHQDQQWHDEHUQLFKWQlKHUHUOlXW HUWHÄ*HKHLPQLVV*RWWHV³ZHLWHUDOVVÄGDVDOOHUK|FKVWHXQVlJOLFKHXQHUIRUVFK OLFKH XQDXVVSUHFKEDUHH XQGG XQHUID‰EDUH *HKHLPQLVV *RWWHV³ XQGG HUU LGHQWLIL ]LHUWWHVVPLWW&KULVWXVLQGHPPHUVLFKKDXI-RKKEH]LHKW 'LHVH$WWULEXWHHGHUU 8QEHJUHLIOLFKNHLWW WUlIHQ DEHUU QLFKWW QXU DXI &KULVWXVV ]X VRQGHUQQ DXFKK DXI GLHH JHVDPWHH7ULQLWlWXQGGHU]LWLHUWWKLHUU$WKDQDVLXVVGHQ*UR‰HQÄ(LQQ*RWWGHQQPDQQ HUIDVVHQQNDQQLVWWNHLQQ*RWW³

3DUWKHQLRVV VLHKWW GLHH *HJHQVWlQGH GHU 7KHRORJLH LQQ GLHVHPP )DOOO GLHH 7ULQLWlW &KULVWXV GHQQ +HLOLJHQQ *HLVW XQG GLHH .LUFKH DOV *HKHLPQLVVH QXQ QHQQWW HU QRFK HLQQ :HLWHUHV GDV Ä*HKHLPQLVV GHU 7KHRORJLH³ ZRPLWW HU KLHU YHUPXWOLFKKHLQHQQ*HGDQNHQDXVVGHU5HOLJLRQVNULWLNN)HXHUEDFKVVDXIJUHLIW)HX HUEDFKKDWWHJHVDJWGDVV*HKHLPQLVGHUU7KHRORJLHVHLGLH$QWKURSRORJLHGHP QDFKK VDJHH HLQQ *RWW E]Z *RWWHVELOGG YRU DOOHPP HWZDVV EHUU GHQQ 0HQVFKHQ DXV GHUDQGLHVHQQ*RWWWJODXEW 'HPPKlOWW3DUWKHQLRVVHQWJHJHQÄ'DVV*HKHLPQLVVGHU 7KHRORJLHH LVWW WULQLWDULVFK FKULVWRORJLVFK SQHXPDWRORJLVFK XQGG HNNOHVLROR JLVFK³ 6RPLWWVHLHQQQLFKWWQXUGLHH*HJHQVWlQGHHGHUU7KHRORJLHJHKHLPQLVKDIW VRQGHUQQDXFKKVLHHVHOEVW7KHRORJLVFKH(UNHQQWQLVHUIROJHVRR3DUWKHQLRVQLFKWW PLWW +LOIH PHQVFKOLFKHU :HLVKHLW $UJXPHQWHQQ RGHU GHV 9HUVWDQGHV YLHOPHKU VHLLKLHUU7RUKHLWWQRWZHQGLJXQGGPDQQPVVHHZLHGLH.LQGHUUZHUGHQ

3DUWKHQLRVV FKDUDNWHULVLHUW GDUDXIKLQ GHQ +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWW DOV 3DUDNOHW DOVRDOV+HOIHUE]Z%HLVWDQGGGHUU.LUFKH 'LH.LUFKHVHOEVWWEHVFKUHLEWWHUDOV HLQQ (UHLJQLV QLFKW DOVV HWZDVV 6WDWLVFKHV GDD VLH DXI LKUHP :HJ GXUFKK GLH *H VFKLFKWH VHL 'HU +HLOLJH *HLVWW VHLL LPP /HEHQ &KULVWLL SDUDNOHWLVFK WlWLJ JH ZHVHQQXQGGHUUVHLLHVVQRFKKLPPHUULPP/HEHQQGHU.LUFKHHWZDDLQGHQQVLHEHQQ6D

^{3DUWKHQLRV6+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRPP9HUIDVVHU ,EG 9JO6 6} ,EG

^{9JO)HXHUEDFK6RGHUUDEHUU3DUWKHQLRVEHUXIWWVLFKKLHUUDXI5XGROI%XOWPDQQXQGVHLQH $XVVDJH Ä:LOO PDQ YRQ *RWW UHGHQ VR PXVV PDQ RIIHQVLFKWOLFK YRQ VLFK VHOEVW UHGHQ³³ %XOWPDQQ6GLHH3DUWKHQLRVGDQQDOOHUGLQJVIDOVFKYHUVWDQGHQKDW 3DUWKHQLRV6+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRPP9HUIDVVHU 9JO6LQ$QOHKQXQJDQ.RUUXQG0WW} ,EG 9JO6I

NUDPHQWHQQGHUU.LUFKHEHLVSLHOVZHLVHLQQGHU(XFKDULVWLHHEHQVRRLQQNLUFKOLFKHQQ $PWVKDQGOXQJHQQXQGG%UlXFKHQLQQGHUU/LWXUJLHHXQGGLP*HEHWWVRZLHHLQQGHUUYRP

3DUWKHQLRVVVDJWGHUU+HLOLJH*HLVWWZRKQHH]ZDUUYRQQ$QEHJLQQQDQQLQQGHUUJDQ]HQ 6FK|SIXQJ DEHU HU EHWRQWW YRUU DOOHPP 3ILQJVWHQ DOVV GHQ %HJLQQQ GHU QHXHQ 6FK|SIXQJXQGGGHQQ*HEXUWVWDJGHU.LUFKH 'DVV3ILQJVWIHVWWLQQGHUURUWKRGR[HQ .LUFKHH EHVFKUHLEWW HU PLWW JHKHLPQLVYROOO NOLQJHQGHQ %HJULIIHQ ZLH ÄZXQGHU YROO³ÄZXQGHUEDU³³RGHUUÄVHOWVDP³

,Q %H]XJ DXI GDV /HEHQ GHUU .LUFKHH VDJW 3DUWKHQLRV GDVVV Ä>D@OOHVV >«@@ HLQHH*DEHGHVV+HLOLJHQ*HLVWHV>LVW@³ GDVVVDOOH.LUFKHQQ(UIDKUXQJHQQPLWGHPP +HLOLJHQ*HLVWWPDFKHQXQGGHUIJWWHWZDVVVSlWHUKLQ]XÄ'DVHLQ]LJHZDVVLFKK LQQDOOHUU%HVFKHLGHQKHLWWVDJHQQNDQQXQGGP|FKWHLVWWIROJHQGHV:LUUEUDXFKHQQ GDVV /HEHQGHV+HLOLJHQQ *HLVWHVVLQQGHU.LUFKHXQGGLQGHU:HOWGDPLWZLUGDV /HEHQQYRQQHEHQQGHPVHOEHQQ3DUDNOHWHQQXQWHUVWW]WOHEHQQN|QQHQ³ 1XQQ]LWLHUW HUUDXVVYHUVFKLHGHQHQQRUWKRGR[HQQ7UDGLWLRQHQGLHH*RWWWE]ZGHQQ+HLOLJHQ*HLVWW WKHPDWLVLHUHQ $XV HLQHPP /LHG HLQHP *HEHW VRZLH DXV GHP *ODXEHQVEH NHQQWQLVV YRQQ 1LFlD.RQVWDQWLQRSHO DOOHUGLQJV ZLHHEHL HLQHP WUDGLWLRQHOOO 2U WKRGR[HQQ]XXHUZDUWHQRKQHHGHQQILOLRTXH=XVDW] 'DV=XUFNJUHLIHQDXIGLHVH 7UDGLWLRQQ VHLL JXW GDPLWW GHUU +HLOLJH *HLVWW LQQ GHU :HOWW ZLUNHQQ N|QQH 1XQ ZHLVWW3DUWKHQLRVVDXFKKDXIIGHQQ*HJHQVSLHOHUU*RWWHVVKLQDXIIÄGDV*HKHLPQLVVGHVV %|VHQGHQQ7HXIHOGHQQ6DWDQ³ XQGGDXFKKDXII'lPRQHQQXUUGHUU+HLOLJHH*HLVW

3DUWKHQLRVV VSULFKWW QXQQ YRPP /HEHQQ GHU .LUFKH 'LH (LQLJXQJ GHUU .LU FKHQQN|QQHQXUUGDGXUFKKHUUHLFKWWZHUGHQGDVVVGLH(LQ]HONLUFKHQQVLFKKJHJHQVHL WLJLKUH)HKOHUXQGG6QGHQQHLQJHVWHKHQXQGGEHNHQQHQQXQGLKUHHDXIIXQWHUVFKLHG OLFKHQQ7UDGLWLRQHQQEHJUQGHWHQQ7UHQQXQJHQQEHUZLQGHQ'DVV%HKDUUHQQGDUDXI

9JO3DUWKHQLRV6

^{9JO6I 9JO6 6 6 9JO6 ,EG 6} 9JO6

DOVV (LQ]HONLUFKH GLH :DKUKHLWW DOOHLQQ ]X EHVLW]HQ YHUKLQGHUHH GDVV :LUNHQQ GHVV

'DQQQ QLPPWW HUU %H]XJ DXII GDVV %XFKK GHUU 2IIHQEDUXQJ JHQDXHUU GLH VLHEHQQ6HQGVFKUHLEHQQ2IIELQGHQHQYHUVFKLHGHQHH3UREOHPHLQQ.LUFKHQQ EHQDQQWW ZHUGHQQ XQGG ]XUU %X‰HH GDUEHUU DXIJHUXIHQQ ZLUG ZLHH HWZDD GDVV 'XOGHQQ YRQQ ,UUOHKUHQ /DXKHLWW RGHUU 7RGG GHVV *ODXEHQVOHEHQVV RGHUU GDVV 9HUODVVHQ GHU ÃHUVWHQQ /LHEH¶ HVV ZHUGHQQ DEHUU DXFKK JXWHH (LJHQVFKDIWHQQ LQQ GHQQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQQ .LUFKHQQ JHQDQQW ZLHH HWZDD *ODXEH 'LHQVW *HGXOG 0KVDOO RGHUU 7UHXH (U LQWHUSUHWLHUW GLHVV DOVV :RUWH IU GLH *HJHQZDUW GLH VRPLWW DXFK IU GHQ g5.. UHOHYDQWW VHLQQ N|QQWHQQ E]Z UHOHYDQWW VLQG 'DV (UUHLFKHQQ GHUU (LQKHLW GHU

1XQQ HUZHLWHUW 3DUWKHQLRVV VHLQHQ 9RUWUDJ GXUFK HLQLJH ZHQLJH SHUV|Q OLFKHH :RUWH LQGHPP HUU VDJW HUU VHLL VHLWW PLW GHPP g5.. YHUEXQGHQQ XQGG HUU VFKlW]HHHVGRUWW0HQVFKHQNHQQHQQJHOHUQWWXQGGYRQQLKQHQQJHOHUQWW]XKDEHQ'LHH (LQKHLWW EHVWHKHH VFKRQQ LQQ GHUU 7ULQLWlWW XQGG GLHH 7ULQLWlWW EHZLUNH GLH (LQKHLWW GHU .LUFKH :DQQ GLHVHH (LQKHLWW XQGG LQQ ZHOFKHPP 0D‰ YRQQ 9ROONRPPHQKHLWW GLHVH (LQKHLWWHUUHLFKWWZLUGVHLDEHUUQLFKWWNODUUXQGGDXFKQLFKWWZLFKWLJ$OVV,QGL]IUU HLQQ9RUDQVFKUHLWHQQGHVV(LQKHLWVSUR]HVVHVVIKUWWHUUGLHHZDFKVHQGHH=DKOOYRQQ0LW

,PGLUHNWHQQ$QVFKOXVVVGDUDQQVDJW3DUWKHQLRVZDVNRQNUHWW]XXWXQQE]Z ]XODVVHQQLVWXPPGLHH(LQKHLWWGHUU.LUFKHQQXQGGGHU0HQVFKKHLWW]XHUUHLFKHQHU UHGHWWDOVRREHUVHLQHH$JHQGD'LHH(LQKHLWWGHUU.LUFKHQQZHUGHHQLFKWWGXUFKlX‰HU OLFKH3UR]HVVHHUUHLFKWZLHHWZD$EVWLPPXQJHQVRQGHUQQGXUFKÄ%HVFKHLGHQ KHLWW XQGG 'HPXW 9HUJHEXQJ %X‰H DEHU DXFKK 0XWW XQGG 9HUWUDXHQQ XQG QLFKW

3DUWKHQLRVVVDJWGHUU'LHQVWWXQGGGDVV=HXJQLVVGHUU.LUFKHQQIUUGLHH(LQKHLWW EHJLQQHPLWWGHU0LVVLRQXQGGGHUU(YDQJHOLVDWLRQLPP1DPHQQ&KULVWL(UHUNOlUW DEHUU]XQlFKVWZDVVHUGDUXQWHUUQLFKWYHUVWHKWÄ8QVHUHH0LVVLRQQLQGHUU:HOWVROO RKQHH +DVWW VHLQ RKQHH )DQDWLVPXVV XQGG RKQHH 3URVHO\WLVPXVV DXII .RVWHQQ DQGHUHU

9JO 6 I RE HU GDV 3UREOHP DXI GHQ HLJHQHQ 7UDGLWLRQHQ ]X EHKDUUHQ QXU EHLL ^{DQGHUHQQ .LUFKHQQVLHKWRGHUDEHUDXFKKEHLVHLQHUUHLJHQHQRUWKRGR[HQ.LUFKHZLUGGKLHUUQLFKWNODU 9JO3DUWKHQLRV6I 9JO6} 9JO6I

6

5HOLJLRQHQQ RGHUU .RQIHVVLRQHQQ XQWHUU XQVV VHLQ³ 'LH )UHLKHLW EHVRQGHUVV GLH 5HOLJLRQV XQGG *HZLVVHQVIUHLKHLW PVVHH EHDFKWHW ZHUGHQ 3DUWKHQLRVV VSULFKW VLFKKKLQJHJHQQGDIUUDXVGHQQ'LDORJPLWWDQGHUHQQ5HOLJLRQHQQXQGG,GHRORJLHQQ]XX

*HNlPSIWWZHUGHQQPVVHDX‰HUGHPPNRQNUHWWDXFKKGDIUGLHH7UHQQXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQQ GHQQ 0HQVFKHQ ]X EHUZLQGHQ IUU )ULHGHQ *HUHFKWLJNHLW %LOGXQJ 5HOLJLRQVIUHLKHLW 0HQVFKHQUHFKWH XQGG 8PZHOWVFKXW] 'LHH :HOWW PVVHH ÃVHKU JXW¶HUKDOWHQQEOHLEHQÄZLH*RWWVLHHHUVFKDIIHQQKDWGHQQQEHULKUVFKZHEWWGHU +HLOLJHH*HLVW³ 'HUU.DPSIIIUGLHVH'LQJHVFKOLH‰WGDQQQDXFKKORJLVFKHUZHLVH GHQQ.DPSIIJHJHQ.ULHJ+XQJHU$QDOSKDEHWLVPXV6NODYHUHLLXQGG9HUWUHLEXQJJ HLQ $XII GLHVHP :HJ GHVV .DPSIHVV VHLHQQ DOOH .LUFKHQQ GHVV g5. JHHLQW 3DU WKHQLRVVHUPDKQWWVHLQH=XK|UHUUDX‰HUGHPPGD]XPHKUU0XWWIUUGDVV7UHIIHQQYRQ (QWVFKHLGXQJHQQ XQG GDV $XVVSUHFKHQQ GHU :DKUKHLWW DXI]XEULQJHQ QLFKW ]X

=XPP(QGHHVHLQHVV5HIHUDWVVVSULFKWW3DUWKHQLRVVQRFKKHLQQ3UREOHPPDQGDV VHLQHUU0HLQXQJQDFKKLPg5..EHVWHKW0DQQVSUHFKHHYLHOÄYRQQGHUU(LQKHLWGHUU .DWKROL]LWlWW XQGG GHUU $SRVWROL]LWlWW GHUU .LUFKH³ EHUJHKH GDEHL MHGRFK LKUH +HLOLJNHLW 'D GHU +HLOLJH *HLVWW LQQ GHU .LUFKH ZRKQH VHL VLH KHLOLJ DOVV =XVWDQG 3DUWKHQLRVV EHWRQWW DEHU DXFK GDVV HV LQ GHU %LEHO GDV *HERW ÃVHLGG KHLOLJ¶ JHEH Ä2KQH +HLOLJXQJ NDQQQ QLFKWVV )UFKWH WUDJHQ³ VDJW 3DUWKHQLRV XQGG IlKUWW IRUW Ä$OOHH XQG DOOHV XQGG EHVRQGHUVV GLHH (LQKHLWW GHUU .LUFKHQQ KDWW +HLOLJXQJ Q|WLJ %X‰H 9HUJHEXQJ *HEHW /LHEHH XQGG :DKUKHLW³ 'LH %LWWH XPP9HUJHEXQJYRQQ*RWWWXQGGGHQQ0LWPHQVFKHQQLVWWLKPKLHUUVHKUUZLFKWLJ8P

3DUWKHQLRV 6 9JO DXFK GD]X HLQ DNWXHOOHUHV 'RNXPHQW 5HSRUWW IURPP LQWHUUHOLJLRXVV FRQVXOWDWLRQ RQ &RQYHUVLRQ DVVHVVLQJ WKHH UHDOLW\³ 85// ]XX GHP 'RNXPHQW VLHKH /LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV =XJULII YRQ GHUU +RPHSDJH GHV g5. GDV GLHH (UJHEQLVVH HLQHUULQWHUUHOLJL|VHQ.RQIHUHQ]]LQ/DULDQRR,WDOLHQ]XVDPPHQIDVVW6LHHZXUGHHYRPg5.XQG GHPP9DWLNDQQRUJDQLVLHUWXQGLKUH7HLOQHKPHUJHK|UWHQQVHFKVXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ:HOWUHOLJLRQHQ DQ (V HQWKlOW lKQOLFKH *HGDQNHQQ ZLH GLH 3DUWKHQLRV¶ DOOHUGLQJV ZHUGHQ KLHU HWZDV PHKU =XJHVWlQGQLVVHH DQ Ä%HNHKUXQJHQ³ JHPDFKW QXU VROOWHQ GLHVHH QDFK EHVWLPPWHQ 5HJHOQ HWZD 7UDQVSDUHQ]] LQ GHUU :DKO GHUU 0LWWHOO XQG 0HWKRGHQ DEODXIHQ XQG QLFKW VR GDVV HV PLW XQHWKLVFKHQ 0LWWHOQ XQG 0HWKRGHQ ]XJHKW ZR]X EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH ^{GDV $XVQXW]HQ YRQ .LQGHUQ RGHUU0HQVFKHQPLWW%HKLQGHUXQJHQJH]lKOWWZLUG 9JO3DUWKHQLRV6 6 9JO6} 6

9JO6(UEH]LHKWVLFKKLHUUDXI/HYÄVHLGGKHLOLJGHQQLFKELQKHLOLJ³XQGGLHHQWO :LHGHUKROXQJGHVVHOEHQ*HERWHVLQ3HWUU

6

GLHVV WXQQ ]X N|QQHQ UXIWW HUU QRFKK GLHH Ä+HLOLJHH -XQJIUDXX 0DULD 7KHRWRNRV >VF *RWWHVJHElUHULQ@ 0XWWHU &KULVWL XQVHUHV *RWWHV³ XQGG 0XWWHUU DOOHUU +HLOLJHQ DQXPP+LOIHHYRQQLKUU]XHUELWWHQ(UEHHQGHWVHLQ5HIHUDWPLWGHP6SUHFKHQGHVV HUZHLWHUWHQ 7KHPDVV GHUU 9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJ DOVV *HEHW XQGG EHHQGHW HVV PLW

Ä.RPP +HLOLJHUU *HLVWW ±± HUQHXHUH GLHH JDQ]HH 6FK|SIXQJ³

(LQH (LQIKUXQJJ LQ GDVV WKHRORJLVFKHH 7KHPDD YRQ 3URIHVVRULQ

&KXQJ+\XQQ.\XQJJ

'LHHNRUHDQLVFKHH3URIHVVRULQQ&KXQJEHJLQQWWLKUU5HIHUDWWPLWWHLQHUUSHUV|QOLFKHQ XQGGKHU]OLFKHQQ%HJU‰XQJGHUU7HLOQHKPHUÄ0HLQHHOLHEHQQ%UGHUUXQGG6FKZHV WHUQ ZLOONRPPHQQ LQQ GLHVHPP /DQGG GHVV *HLVWHV³ 6LH VDJWW ZHLWHU Ä:LU VLQG KHXWHKLHUYHUVDPPHOWXPPYRPP+HLOLJHQ*HLVWW.UDIWIUXQVHUHH$UEHLWWGHUU(U QHXHUXQJGHUUJDQ]HQQ6FK|SIXQJ]XXHPSIDQJHQ³ 8PGHP+HLOLJHQ*HLVWWGHQ :HJYRU]XEHUHLWHQVHLHVVQ|WLJVLFKKVHOEVW]XXHQWlX‰HUQ$OVlX‰HUHVV=HLFKHQ GHUU6HOEVWHUQLHGULJXQJELWWHWWVLHHQXQQLKUHH=XK|UHUGLHH6FKXKHHDXIGHPPKHLOLJHQ %RGHQQ DXV]X]LHKHQ &KXQJ EHUXIW VLFKK KLHUEHL HLQHUVHLWVV DXI 7UDGLWLRQHQQ DXVV GHPP 5DXPP $VLHQ3D]LILN DQGHUHUVHLWVV DXI 0RVHV LQQ GHU FKULVWOLFKHQQ 7UDGL WLRQ 6LHULFKWHWGLHVH %LWWHDXVVLQQ(UZLGHUXQJGHVVHQZDVHLQHHDXVWUDOLVFKH 8UHLQZRKQHULQQ EHLL HLQHP %HVXFKK LQQ &KXQJVV .LUFKHH LQQ .RUHDD WDW 'DQQ IROJWW

9JO 3DUWKHQLRV 6 %HPHUNHQVZHUWHUZHLVHH VRUJWHQQ VROFKH XQG DQGHUHH RUWKRGR[HH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GLHH GHP 3URWHVWDQWLVPXV IUHPGG VLQG EHLL GHQ (YDQJHOLNDOHQ XQG DQGHUHQQ .ULWLNHUQ &KXQJV IU NHLQHQ $XIUXKU VSULFK IU .ULWLN DQ 3DUWKHQLRVV 5HIHUDW :HQQ PDQ &KXQJJ GHQQ 9RUZXUII GHVV 6\QNUHWLVPXVV PDFKW PVVWH PDQ 3DUWKHQLRV DXFKK GHQQ 9RUZXUII GHV 6\QNUHWLVPXVV PDFKHQ GD GHU 0DULHQNXOWW HLQH 9HUPLVFKXQJ YRQ FKULVWOLFKHQQ ^{E]Z ELEOLVFKHQQ} 7UDGLWLRQHQ PLWW GHP ,VLV.XOWW GHUU bJ\SWHUU LVW LQ GHP ,VLV DXFK DOVV 0XWWHUU *RWWHV YHUHKUW ZXUGHH 9JO GHQ 9RUWUDJ YRQ +HOPXW 6WHXHUZDOGG :LH GDV &KULVWHQWXP JHPDFKW ZXUGHH +LQWHUJUQGHH XQG 8UVDFKHQ GLH ]XU (QWVWHKXQJJ XQGG (QWZLFNOXQJJ GHV &KULVWHQWXPV IKUWHQ ^{85/ VLHKH /LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV 'HQNEDUU LVW GDVV PDQ LQ 3DUWKHQLRV HLQHQQ 9HUEQGHWHQJHJHQ&KXQJJJHIXQGHQKDWWHGHUWURW]GLHVHU3XQNWHDOVJHULQJHUHVVhEHOOJDOW 9JO 3DUWKHQLRV 6 (VV KDQGHOW VLFK KLHUEHLL XP GDVV 7KHPDD Ä.RPP +HLOLJHUU *HLVWW ± HUQHXHUHHGLHHJDQ]HH6FK|SIXQJJ³PLWWYLHUUGD]XJHK|ULJHQ%LWWHQ Ä6SHQGHUUGHV/HEHQV±±HUKDOWHGHLQH6FK|SIXQJ *HLVWWGHUU:DKUKHLWW±PDFKXQVIUHL *HLVWGHUU(LQKHLW±±YHUV|KQHHGHLQ9RONN +HLOLJHUU*HLVWW±YHUZDQGOHHXQGKHLOLJHHXQV³ 0OOHU5|PKHOG63DUWKHQLRV6 &KXQJ6} ,EG

9JO6.RQNUHWWEH]LHKWWVLHHVLFKDXI([

HLQQ 7DQ]] HLQHU Ä7DQ]JUXSSH LQQ :HL‰‰ >VLF@ XQWHU %HWHLOLJXQJ ]ZHLHU

(VVIROJHQQQXQQLQVJHVDPWW$QUXIXQJHQQYRQQ*HLVWHUQXPPGDVV6FKUHLHQQ GHVV *HLVWHVV XQGG GHUU 6FK|SIXQJ ]XX K|UHQ LPPHU QDFKK GHPP 6FKHPDD Ä.RPP *HLVW³³ XQGG GDQQQ GLHH HQWVSUHFKHQGH 3HUVRQQE]Z6DFKHDOV7UlJHULQGHVDQJH UXIHQHQ*HLVWHVEHLVSLHOVZHLVHVRÄ.RPP*HLVWGHU-XGHQGLHLPP+RORFDXVWW LQ GHQQ *DVNDPPHUQQ HUPRUGHW ZXUGHQ³ $QJHUXIHQQ ZHUGHQ GLHH *HLVWHU YRQ ELEOLVFKHQQ 3HUVRQHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH YRQQ +DJDU 8ULDD RGHUU GHUU *HLVWW ÄXQVHUHV %UXGHUVV-HVXV>GHVV%HIUHLHUV@GHUUDPP.UHX]JHIROWHUWWXQGGJHW|WHWWZXUGH³ GLH *HLVWHU KLVWRULVFKHUU 3HUVRQHQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVH YRQQ -RKDQQDD 2UOHDQVV ÄXQGG GHU YLHOHQQDQGHUHQQ)UDXHQGLHHEHLGHQÃ+H[HQSUR]HVVHQ¶LPP0LWWHODOWHUYHUEUDQQWW ZXUGHQ³ &KXQJJ JHKWW DEHUU DXFKK QRFK GDUEHUU KLQDXVV XQGG UXIWW GLH *HLVWHUU ]HLWJHQ|VVLVFKHUU3HUVRQHQKHUEHLHWZDDGLHGHUU2SIHUULPGDPDOLJHQQ*ROINULHJJ VRZLHHGLHH*HLVWHUUYRQQQLFKWPHQVFKOLFKHQQ*HJHQVWlQGHQHWZDGHQQ*HLVW GHVV ÄWURSLVFKHQQ 5HJHQZDOGHVV LPP $PD]RQDVEHFNHQ DQ GHPP QXQPHKUU WlJOLFK

'LHH%HJUQGXQJIUUGLHVHVVHKHUUXQJHZ|KQOLFKH9RUJHKHQQXQWHUU&KULV WHQZRGXUFKKÄGHU9RUWUDJYRQ)UDX&KXQJJ]XHLQHUU+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJWUDGLWLRQ HOOHU 7KHRORJLH³ ZXUGH OLHIHUWW VLHH IROJHQGHUPD‰HQ ,Q LKUHU NRUHDQLVFKHQ 7UDGLWLRQQ ZHUGHQQ GLHH 2SIHUU YRQQ 0RUGG RGHUU 8QJHUHFKWLJNHLWHQ ZDVV DXFKK GLHH VRHEHQQ DQJHUXIHQHQQ 3HUVRQHQQ E]Z 'LQJHH FKDUDNWHULVLHUW ]X XPKHULUUHQGHQ YRQQ+DQJHWULHEHQHQQ*HLVWHUQ +DQQVHLLÄ=RUQ>«@@*UROO>«@%LWWHUNHLW>«@ .XPPHUU >XQG@ URKHH (QHUJLHH IUU GHQQ %HIUHLXQJVNDPSI³ 'LHVHH YRQQ +DQ JHWULHEHQHQ*HLVWHUVHLHQGDUDXIIDXVGDVV DQQLKQHQQEHJDQJHQH8QUHFKWWZLHGHU JXW ]X PDFKHQ HWZDD LQGHP VLHH 5DFKHH DQQ LKUHQ 3HLQLJHUQQ EHQ &KXQJJ VDJW GDVVVGLHHYRQQ+DQHUIOOWHQQ*HLVWHUUÄ>L@P/DXIHGHUU*HVFKLFKWHHXQVHUHVV9RONHV DOVV 0LWWOHU GHVV +HLOLJHQ *HLVWHV DXIJHWUHWHQ >VLQG@ GXUFK GLH HU VHLQQ 0LWOHLGG

0OOHU5|PKHOG6

^{&KXQJ6I 6 ,EG ,EG ,EG 0OOHU5|PKHOG6} 9JO&KXQJ6

6

XQGG VHLQHH :HLVKHLWW IUU GDVV /HEHQQ YHUNQGHWW KDW³ XQGG GDVVV VLHH ÄGLHH JUHLIEDUU XQGGVLFKWEDUUJHZRUGHQHQ,NRQHQQGHVV+HLOLJHQQ*HLVWHV³ VLQG*HLVWHUGLHHYRQ +DQJHWULHEHQQ VLQG VLHKWW VLHH DXFKK DX‰HUKDOE .RUHDV HWZDD LQQ $XVWUDOLHQ GHPP *DVWODQGGGLHVHUU9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJZRRGLHH$ERULJLQHVVHLQHPP9|ONHUPRUG]XP 2SIHUU JHIDOOHQQ VLQG (EHQIDOOVV VLHKWW VLHH YRQQ +DQ JHWULHEHQHH *HLVWHUU EHL GHQ

6LHH VDJW LKUHH )UHXGHH EHUU GDVV =XVDPPHQNRPPHQQ GHVV g5.. VHLL GXUFK GDVV)RUWGDXHUQGLHVHV*ROINULHJVEHWUEWXQGGVLHVHLLYROOHUU7UDXHUUXQG0LWOHLG IUU GLHH 2SIHUU GHVV .ULHJHV JHIDOOHQH LUDNLVFKH 6ROGDWHQQ XQGG GHUHQQ WUDXHUQGHQQ )DPLOLHQDQJHK|ULJHQ6LHHVWHOOWWQXQQHLQHQQELEOLVFKHQ%H]XJKHU]XXGHQQEHUUGLH .ULHJVRSIHUU7UDXHUQGHQLQGHPPVLHHVLFKDXIHLQHQ9HUVDXVV-HUHPLDEH]LHKWLQQ ZHOFKHPP 5DKHOO NODJWW XQGG EHUU LKUHH JHW|WHWHQQ 6|KQHH ZHLQW VLFKK DXFK QLFKWW WU|VWHQQODVVHQQZLOO 9ROOHU9HU]ZHLIOXQJELWWHWW&KXQJGHQQ+HLOLJHQQ*HLVWXP +LOIH LQGHP VLHH GDVV 7KHPDD GHUU 9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJ DOV *HEHW DQQ LKQQ ULFKWHW

'LUHNWW LPP $QVFKOXVVV VWHOOWW VLH DEHUU GLHH UKHWRULVFKH )UDJH Ä'RFKK ZDVV PHLQHQZLUPLWWGLHVHP*HEHW"³ 6LHHOHKQWWHVVDELQGHQÄ.LQGHUJODXEHQ³ DQ HLQHQQ DOOPlFKWLJHQ DOOH 3UREOHPHH O|VHQGHQQ Ã0DFKR¶*RWWW ]XUFN]XIDOOHQ DQQ GHQQ*HEHWHHDOVV9RUZDQGJHULFKWHWWZHUGHQXPPSDVVLYYXQGGQLFKWVROLGDULVFKKPLW GHQQ/HLGHQGHQQ]XVHLQ &KXQJVDJWVLHHJODXEHHDXFKKQLFKWWDQQHLQHQQ*RWWÄGHU DOOHH*XWHQQHUUHWWHWWXQGGDOOHH%|VHQQEHVWUDIW³ 6WDWWGHVVHQQJODXEW&KXQJJDQXQGG YHUOlVVWVLFKK DXIIÄGHQQEDUPKHU]LJHQ*RWWGHULQPLWWHQQGHUJUDXVDPHQQ=HUVW| UXQJJ GHV /HEHQV PLWW XQV XPP GDV /HEHQ ZHLQW³ 'HU *HLVWGLHVHVEDUPKHU] LJHQ*RWWHVVVHLLVHLWW$QIDQJGHUU6FK|SIXQJDQZHVHQGHUUJHEHHGHPPJDQ]HQ8QL YHUVXPPGXUFKKVHLQHQQOHEHQVSHQGHQGHQ$WHPPGDVV/HEHQHUUEHIUHLHXQGGEHIlK LJH VHLL LQQ GHUU +HLOVJHVFKLFKWHH WlWLJ HWZD LQQ GHU$XIHUVWHKXQJ &KULVWL HUU EH

&KXQJ6

^{,EG 9JO6} ,EG

^{,EG.RQNUHWWEH]LHKWWVLHHVLFKDXI-HUHPLDD 6 ,EG 6 6I 6} ,EG

OHKUHH XQVV DEHUU DXFKK GXUFKK Ä6HJHQ XQGG )OXFKK GHUU 1DWXU >XQG GXUFK@@ GDVV 6FKUHLHQGHUYRQQ+DQHUIOOWHQQ*HLVWHU³ 1HEHQQHLQHUU2IIHQEDUXQJVWKHRORJLH YHUWULWWVLHHKLHUUDOVRRDXFKKHLQHHQDWUOLFKHH7KHRORJLH

$OVV(UNOlUXQJGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ/DJHGHU:HOWLQQGHUPDQQEHUDOOGLHH =HLFKHQQGHVV7RGHVVHKHVSULFKWW&KXQJMHGRFKKQRFKKYRQQHLQHPPDQGHUHQQ*HLVW GHUULQQGHUU:HOWWZLUNWWXQGGGHQQVLHHGHQQÄXQKHLOLJHQ*HLVWW%DEHOV³ QHQQW&KD UDNWHULVWLVFK IU GLHVHQ *HLVWW VHLHQQ $XIVWHLJHUWXP *HZLQQVXFKW *LHU 6SDOWXQJXQGGHUUVHLLGDVZDVV-HVXVVDOVV0DPPRQQEH]HLFKQHWWKDEH'LHVHUUE|VH XQGGXQKHLOLJHH*HLVWW%DEHOVVEULQJHHGHUU:HOWW7RGGXQGG=HUVW|UXQJXQGGVHLLZLUN VDPPGXUFKKGLYHUVHH)RUPHQQGHVV(JRLVPXV$OVV%HLVSLHOHZRR%DEHOVV*HLVWWZLU NHQHQQWWVLHHGLHH7UHQQXQJ.RUHDVVLQQ1RUGXQGG6GNRUHDGHQQ9|ONHUPRUGGDQQ GHQQDXVWUDOLVFKHQQ8UHLQZRKQHUQGLHH|NRORJLVFKHH=HUVW|UXQJGHU(UGHHXQGGGLHH .UHX]LJXQJ -HVX 'LHH WUDGLWLRQHOOHH 6LFKWW DXI 6QGHH DOVV VQGLJHH (LQ]HOWDWHQ YRQQ(LQ]HOSHUVRQHQQJHQJW&KXQJQLFKWVLHHVLHKWW6QGHHDOVVHWZDVVNROOHNWLYHVV

*RWWWKDEHHGDVV:LUNHQGHVVXQKHLOLJHQQ *HLVWHVV %DEHOVVMHGRFKQLFKWWKLQ JHQRPPHQ VRQGHUQQ DQQ 3ILQJVWHQQ VHLQHQQ +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWW DOVV $QWZRUWW DXII XQGG .DPSIDQVDJHHDQQLKQQJHVDQGW &KXQJJLQWHUSUHWLHUWWGDVV3ILQJVWHUHLJQLVDOVRGDV 6SUDFK XQG +|UZXQGHU QLFKWW QXU WUDGLWLRQHOOO DOVV HLQQ KHLOVJHVFKLFKWOLFKHV (UHLJQLVVRQGHUQQDOVVHWZDVVKHUUVFKDIWVNULWLVFKHVVXQGGUHYROXWLRQlUHV

Ä'DVV%UDXVHQQGHVVJHZDOWLJHQQ:LQGHVVXQGG*RWWHVV/HEHQVIHXHUUKDWVLH>VF GLHH 8UJHPHLQGH@ DXVV GHUU .XOWXUU GHVV 6FKZHLJHQV GHU *HZDOWW XQGG GHVV 7RGHVVKHUDXVJHUXIHQQXQGGVLHHGD]XJHEUDFKWLQQLKUHUHLJHQHQQ6SUDFKHH]X VSUHFKHQ 6LHH EUDXFKHQQ VLFKK QLFKWW PHKUU LQQ GHU 6SUDFKHH LKUHUU .RORQLDO KHUUHQ GHU +HUUVFKHU XQGG ,PSHULDOLVWHQQ ]X YHUVWlQGLJHQQ >VF GLHH ODWHLQ LVFKHH 6SUDFKHH GHUU 5|PHUU E]Z GLHH JULHFKLVFKHH 6SUDFKHH LP 2VWWHLO GHV 5|PLVFKHQQ 5HLFKHV@ 6LHH N|QQHQQ *RWWHVV %RWVFKDIWW LQQ LKUHU HLJHQHQ 0XWWHUVSUDFKHH K|UHQ 'LHH JHPHLQVDPH 6SUDFKH GLH VLH DP 7XUP GHU *LHUU LQQ %DEHOO YHUORUHQQ KDWWHQ ZXUGHH DQQ 3ILQJVWHQQ JUXQGOHJHQGG ZLHGHU

:HLWHU VDJW VLH 3ILQJVWHQQ KHEHH GLHH 7UHQQXQJHQQ ]ZLVFKHQQ GHQQ 0HQVFKHQ DXI GLH VHLWW %DEHO EHVWQGHQ HU EHIUHLH XQGG YHUHLQLJH 6FKOLH‰OLFKK VLHKW VLHH DXFKK

&KXQJ6+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRPP9HUIDVVHU

^{,EG 9JO6 9JO6II 9JO6} 66LHHEH]LHKWWVLFKKLHUUDXI$SJ

QRFKK HLQHH NRQNUHWHH +DQGOXQJVDQZHLVXQJ GHVV +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWHVV IUU KHXWH Ä'LHVHU JHZDOWLJH :LQGGGHVV /HEHQVV UXIWW XQVV DXI GLH QHXHH 6FK|SIXQJ OHLGHQ

:DVV VLH GDUXQWHUU YHUVWHKW E]Z ZDVV QXQQ NRQNUHWW ]XX WXQQ LVW VDJWW VLH VRJOHLFKLPP$QVFKOXVVÄ:DVVVROOHQQZLUUDOVRRWXQZHQQQGHUU*HLVWWXQVVUXIW"$OV HUVWHVVVROOHQQZLUU%X‰HWXQ³ 'LHVHH$XIIRUGHUXQJ&KXQJVVVWDPPWWYRQQ$QUHJ XQJHQQ YRQQ )UDXHQQ DXVV FKULVWOLFKHQQ %DVLVEHZHJXQJHQQ LQQ .RUHD 'HUU +HLOLJH *HLVW VROOHGHPQDFKKQLFKWVWlQGLJJDQJHUXIHQZHUGHQVRQGHUQQHUZLUNHEHUHLWV XQWHUUGHQQ0HQVFKHQ'LH%HVFKlIWLJXQJPLW*LHUGLH/LHEHH]XPP0DPPRQQXQGG GLHHKHLPOLFKHH6HKQVXFKWWQDFKKGHPP7XUPPYRQ%DEHOOYHUKLQGHUHHGDVV:LUNHQGHVV *HLVWHV GHVKDOE PVVH GDUEHU ]XHUVW %X‰H JHWDQ ZHUGHQ 'DV 3UDNWL]LHUHQ

&KXQJ YHUVWHKWW XQWHU %X‰HH MHGRFKK QLFKWW QXUU HLQHH %X‰HH EHU (LQ]HOVQGHQQ YRQQ (LQ]HOSHUVRQHQ YLHOPHKUU VHLL IUU Ä>H@FKWHH %X‰H 0HWDQRLD >«@ HLQHH UDGLNDOHH 5LFKWXQJVlQGHUXQJ LQ XQVHUHP LQGLYLGXHOOHQ XQGG JHPHLQ VFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQ³ QRWZHQGLJ'LHVH5LFKWXQJVlQGHUXQJNRPPHGXUFKHLQH $EZHQGXQJ YRQQ GHUU ÄSROLWLVFKHQQgNRQRPLHGHV7RGHV³ GHVV *HLVWHVV %DEHOV ]XVWDQGH XQGG GXUFKK HLQHH +LQZHQGXQJ ]X HLQHU ÄSROLWLVFKHQ gNRQRPLH GHV /HEHQV³ KLQQ]XXGHUU5LFKWXQJDXVVZHOFKHUGHU+HLOLJHH*HLVWZHKH'LHHHUVWH

&KXQJ6

6+HUYRUKHEXQJJYRP9HUIDVVHU

^{$QQ GLHVHU 6WHOOH LQQ GHU GHXWVFKHQQ hEHUVHW]XQJ GHVV 5HIHUDWHVV ZLUG GHUU +HLOLJHH *HLVWW GDV HLQ]LJHH PDOO PLW GHP 3HUVRQDOSURQRPHQ ÄVLH³ HUVHW]W VRQVWW LVWW HV LPPHUU ÄHU³ ,P HQJOLVFKHQQ 2ULJLQDOOGHV5HIHUDWVZHUGHQEHLGH3HUVRQDOSURQRPHQÄVKH³³XQGÄKH³³YHUZHQGHWZREHLLÄVKH³ EHUZLHJW$XFKGLHVVKDWWHHIU$QVWR‰JHVRUJWGDDPDQHVVJHZRKQWWLVWGHQ+HLOLJHQ*HLVWWDOV ]XPLQGHVWWJUDPPDWLNDOLVFKKPDVNXOLQHVV:HVHQQ]XXEH]HLFKQHQGHQQÄ*HLVW³³LVWWLP'HXWVFKHQQ HLQQPDVNXOLQHV1RPHQ9JO/LQ]8UEDQ6'DVKHEUlLVFKHH:RUWGDVLP$7IUUGHQ} *HLVWW*RWWHVDEHUDXFKKDOOJHPHLQQIU:LQG$WHPXQG*HLVWYHUZHQGHWWZLUGODXWHWWÄUXDFK³ XQGLVWWHLQIHPLQLQHV1RPHQVRPLWWLVWWGLH%H]HLFKQXQJGHV*HLVWHV*RWWHVDOVÄVLH³ E]Z Ä*HLVWLQ³ QRFK NHLQH +lUHVLH VRQGHUQ QXU HLQH :LHGHUJDEHH GHUU UHDOO H[LVWLHUHQGHQQ JUDPPDWLNDOLVFKHQQ9HUKlOWQLVVHLQQGHUKHEUlLVFKHQ6SUDFKH'DVJULHFKLVFKH:RUWWÄSQHXPD³ GDV +DXFK XQG *HLVW EHGHXWHW XQG LPP 17 IU *RWWHVV *HLVW GHQQ PHQVFKOLFKHQQ *HLVW XQG DXFKK DQGHUH *HLVWHU ^{YHUZHQGHW ZLUG LVW HLQ 1RPHQ LP 1HXWUXP HV PVVWH GDQQ DOVRNRUUHNWHUU:HLVHPLWWÄGDV*HLVW³ZLHGHUJHJHEHQZHUGHQZHQQPDQGLHHJUDPPDWLNDOLVFKHQQ 9HUKlOWQLVVHLQGHUUDOWJULHFKLVFKHQ6SUDFKHHLQGHUUGHXWVFKHQhEHUVHW]XQJZLHGHUJHEHQZLOO 9JO&KXQJ6 6+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRPP9HUIDVVHU ,EG+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRP9HUIDVVHU ,EG+HUYRUKHEXQJHQQYRP9HUIDVVHU} ,EG

JHSUlJW GLHH ]ZHLWHH YRQQ OHEHQVSHQGHQGHU .UDIW JHJHQVHLWLJHU +LOIHH XQG $EKlQJLJNHLWWXQGGYRQQ +DUPRQLH &KXQJ]XIROJHH VLQGGIUUGLHVH$EZHQGXQJ HLQHUVHLWVV XQGG +LQZHQGXQJ DQGHUHUVHLWVV GUHL NRQNUHWHH 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ QRW ZHQGLJ

,9RP$QWKURSR]HQWULVPXVVKLQQ]XUU/HEHQVEH]RJHQKHLW

6LHIKUWWDXVPDQQPVVHVLFKYRPPFKULVWOLFKKXQGGZHVWOLFKK JHSUlJWHQQ$QWKUR SR]HQWULVPXV DEZHQGHQQ XQGG VLFKK ]XUU /HEHQVEH]RJHQKHLW KLQZHQGHQ GLH GHU 9RUVWHOOXQJ GHUU DVLDWLVFKHQQ 9|ONHUU XQG GHUU 8UY|ONHU GHUU :HOWW HQWVSULFKW ,P $QWKURSR]HQWULVPXVV EHKHUUVFKH NRQWUROOLHUHH XQG ]HUVW|UHH GHUU 0HQVFK YRU DOOHPPGHUU0DQQGLH6FK|SIXQJ$OVV %HLVSLHOO IUUHLQH $OWHUQDWLYHHGD]XXQHQQWW VLHHHLQHUHOLJL|VHH9RUVWHOOXQJYRQGHQ3KLOLSSLQHQGLHHDXII/HEHQVEH]RJHQKHLWW EHUXKH+LHUUJLEWWHVHLQHH(UGJ|WWLQQQDPHQVV,QDZDVVLQGHUU/DQGHVVSUDFKHH7D JDORJJ0XWWHUEHGHXWHW'LH(UGHVHLLGLH0XWWHUE]ZGHUU8UVSUXQJGHVV/HEHQV XQGG PVVHH GDKHUU JHDFKWHWW ZHUGHQ 6LHH VHLL HLQQ YRQQ *RWWW EHOHEWHUU XQGG GXUFK WUlQNWHUU 2UWW XQGG UlFKH VLFKK DPP 0HQVFKHQQ IUU GLHH DQ LKUU EHJDQJHQHQQ 0LVVKDQGOXQJHQ &KXQJJ VDJW HVV EHVWQGHH DOVV $XVGUXFNN GHUU 6HKQVXFKWW QDFK *DQ]KHLWWEHUHLWVVHLQH%HIUHLXQJVWKHRORJLHIU0HQVFKHQGLHHXQWHUGUFNWWVLQG (VVHLDEHUULPP5LQJHQQQDFKKHLQHUUYROOVWlQGLJHQQ*DQ]KHLWWDXFKKHLQHH%HIUHLXQJV WKHRORJLHHIUUGLHHEULJH6FK|SIXQJQ|WLJDOVRRHLQH%HIUHLXQJVWKHRORJLHHDXVVGHUU

,, 9RP3ULQ]LSSGHVV'XDOLVPXVV]XP3ULQ]LSSGHUU9HUNQSIXQJ

'HUU'XDOLVPXVEHUXKHHDXIIXQ]lKOLJHQQ3RODULWlWHQZLHH0DQQQYV)UDX$UPHHYV 5HLFKH .|USHUU YV *HLVW 9HUVWDQGG YV *HIKOO RGHUU 6FKZDU]H YV :HL‰H ,Q GLHVHQQ3RODULWlWHQKHUUVFKHH]XGHPPHLQH:HUWLJNHLWWYRUUXQGGVLHIKUWHQ]X6SDO WXQJHQQXQGGJHVSDOWHQHQQ3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQ*RWWHVVXUVSUQJOLFKHH$EVLFKWWPLWWGHU 6FK|SIXQJVHLL6FK|QKHLW%H]LHKXQJ*DQ]KHLWOLFKNHLWXQGG+DUPRQLHHJHZHVHQ 'DVV GXDOLVWLVFKHH 3ULQ]LS VHLL GXUFKK :LVVHQVFKDIW 5HOLJLRQQ XQGG 3KLORVRSKLHH LQQ GLHH:HOWWJHNRPPHQQXQGGQXQQKHUUVFKHH7UHQQXQJ$XVEHXWXQJXQGG)HLQGVFKDIW

9JO&KXQJ6

9JO6I(LQHVROFKHH%HIUHLXQJVWKHRORJLHHHUKlOWEHLVSLHOVZHLVHHGXUFKGLHH.DWDVWURSKHHLP =XJH GHUU ([SORVLRQ DXI GHUU gOSODWWIRUP Ä'HHSZDWHUU +RUL]RQ³ LP $SULO XQG GXUFK GLH GDUDXVUHVXOWLHUHQGHHgOSHVWLP*ROIYRQ0H[LNRQHXH5HOHYDQ]%LVKHUULVWWHVVQLFKWJHOXQJHQ GLHH gOSHVW LQ DXVUHLFKHQGHUU :HLVHH ]X EHNlPSIHQ 9JO 'LHH &KURQLNN GHU gONDWDVWURSKHH ^DXII 7DJHVVFKDXGH85/VLHKH/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV=XJULII

XQWHUU GHQQ 0HQVFKHQQ YRU IUU 0LWJHIKO VHL NHLQQ 3ODW] $OV DOWHUQDWLYHH 9RU VWHOOXQJ ]XPP ZHVWOLFKHQQ XQGG FKULVWOLFKHQQ 'XDOLVPXVV JUHLIWW VLHH HLQHH ,GHH DXV GHPP 'HQNHQQ 1RUGRVWDVLHQVV DXI 'LHH /HEHQVHQHUJLH .L GLHH VLHH PLWW GHPP +HLOLJHQ *HLVWW JOHLFKVHW]WW RGHU ]XPLQGHVWW YHUJOHLFKW IOLH‰W ZHQQQ +DUPRQLH EHVWHKW %HLL 6SDOWXQJ RGHUU 7UHQQXQJ N|QQHH GDVV .L QLFKW IOLH‰HQ GDKHU VHL HV

,,, 9RQQHLQHUU.XOWXUUGHVV7RGHVV]XXHLQHUU.XOWXUUGHVV/HEHQV

$OVVHLQQ%HLVSLHOOIUHLQH.XOWXUUGHVV7RGHVQHQQWW&KXQJNRQNUHWWGHQQGDPDOVVJH UDGHHDNWXHOOHQQ*ROINULHJGHUUYRQYRUUDOOHPPZHVWOLFKHQQXQGGÃFKULVWOLFKHQ¶ /lQGHUQQ ZLHH GHQQ 86$$ XQGG *UR‰EULWDQQLHQQ JHJHQQ GHQQ ,UDNN JHIKUWW ZXUGH .ULHJ EULQJHH QLHPDOVV )ULHGHQ VRQGHUQQ QXU ZHLWHUHH 8QJHUHFKWLJNHLWHQ ,P .ULHJNlPSIWHQQXQGGVWUEHQQ6ROGDWHQQDXVVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQQXQGG|NRQRPLVFKHQQ 5DQGJUXSSHQQ IU GLHH ,QWHUHVVHQQ GHUU 0lFKWLJHQ &KXQJ VDJW Ä.ULHJ VHLL GLH .RQVHTXHQ]GHUUSDWULDUFKDOLVFKHQQ.XOWXU³ GDKLHUGHU6LHJZLFKWLJHUVHLDOV GLHH5HWWXQJYRQQ/HEHQ'XUFKK0LWOHLGKLQJHJHQQN|QQHHGLHH.XOWXUGHVV7RGHVLQ HLQHH .XOWXUU GHVV /HEHQV YHUZDQGHOW ZHUGHQ 8P GHQQ *HJHQVDW] ]ZLVFKHQ GLHVHQQ EHLGHQQ .XOWXUHQQ DXI]X]HLJHQ VDJWW VLH 0lQQHU YHUJ|VVHQQ DOVV 6ROGDWHQ %OXW ZRKLQJHJHQQ )UDXHQ DOV 7UDXHUQGH 7UlQHQ YHUJ|VVHQ MDD VRJDUU GDVV GDV :HLQHQ GLH HUVWH SURSKHWLVFKH 7DWW VHL $OVV HLQQ %HLVSLHO ZLH GXUFK 0LWOHLG HWZDVV*XWHVVEHZLUNWWZHUGHQQN|QQHQHQQWWVLHHLKUHQQ:XQVFKLKUHH9RUVWHOOXQJJ YRQQGHUU.XOWXUUGHV/HEHQVPLWGHPYRP.RUHDQLVFKHQQ1DWLRQDOUDWGHUU.LUFKHQQ HUNOlUWHQQ -XEHOMDKUU GHPP -DKUU GHUU 7UHQQXQJ .RUHDVV LQQ 1RUG XQGG 6GNRUHD ]XX YHUIOHFKWHQ 'LHH 7UHQQXQJJ HUVWLFNHH GDV .L DOVRR GLH /HEHQV

9JO&KXQJ6'HQ1DFKZHLVZRGXUFKZDQQQXQGZLHGLH9HUNQSIXQJJNRQNUHWGXUFK

GHQQ 'XDOLVPXVV YHUGUlQJW ZXUGH EOHLEW &KXQJJ MHGRFKK VFKXOGLJ HV VHL GHQQ VLH EHUXIW VLFKK KLHUEHL DXI GLH ELEOLVFKHQ *HVFKLFKWHQ YRQ GHU 6FK|SIXQJ *HQ XQG YRP 6QGHQIDOO 9JO*HQXQGGGHVVHQ)ROJHQGXUFKGHQOW3DXOXVGHUU7RGG]XDOOHQ0HQVFKHQNDP9JO 5|PIIXQGGHUVRJDUIUGLHJHVDPWH6FK|SIXQJJ7RGXQG9HUJlQJOLFKNHLWEUDFKWHH9JO

5|PII2GHUUDEHUUVLHHEHUXIWVLFKDXIIHLQHDQGHUHPLUXQEHNDQQWHHDVLDWLVFKHRGHUUDQGHUHH 7UDGLWLRQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH GLH +\SRWKHVH HVV KDEHH YRUU GHP 3DWULDUFKDWW DXI GHUU :HOWW HLQ YHUJOHLFKVZHLVHH SDUDGLHVLVFKHV 0DWULDUFKDWW JHJHEHQ 'HQQQ LQ GHUU MHW]LJHQ 1DWXUU KHUUVFKHQQ QlPOLFKDXFKGXDOLVWLVFKH3ULQ]LSLHQZLH.DPSIIXPVhEHUOHEHQ+LHUDUFKLHQ$PHLVHQKDEHQQ .|QLJLQQHQXQG$UEHLWHUXQG)HLQGVFKDIWHQYRUZHQQJOHLFKGLHVHHDXI,QVWLQNWHQEHUXKHQ(VV PXVVGDKHUUP(GHUU1DFKZHLVYRQ&KXQJHUEUDFKWZHUGHQZDQQLQGHUU1DWXUULQNOXVLYHHGHU 0HQVFKHQ 9HUNQSIXQJ E]Z ^{+DUPRQLH YRUKHUUVFKWH XQG ZRGXUFK GLHVHH DXIJHKREHQ ZXUGHH XQGGHUU'XDOLVPXVLQGLHH:HOWNDP 9JO&KXQJ6 6} 9JO6I

HQHUJLH 9HUV|KQXQJ XQGG 0LWJHIKOO PLWW1RUGNRUHDD VHL Q|WLJ XPP GLHH :LHGHU YHUHLQLJXQJ KHUEHLL ]XX IKUHQQ XQGG GLHH %HGURKXQJ GXUFK HLQHQQ VWlQGLJ P|J

=XPP(QGHP|FKWHH&KXQJLKUHQQ=XK|UHUQQLKUUÄ%LOGGGHVV+HLOLJHQQ*HLVWHVV >YHUPLWWHOQ@ VRR ZLHH HV >LKU@ YRQ >LKUHP@ NXOWXUHOOHQQ +LQWHUJUXQGG DXV HU VFKHLQW³ (VV VHLL LQQ GHQQ GUHLL YRQQ LKUU EHVFKULHEHQHQQ XQGG IUU GLHH 0HWDQRLD QRWZHQGLJHQQ5LFKWXQJVlQGHUXQJHQYHUN|USHUWGLHQLFKWWDXVVÄGHPP)DFKZLVVHQ LQQGHU6\VWHPDWLVFKHQ7KHRORJLH³ VWDPPWHQVRQGHUQQDXVVÄHLQHPPLQQHUHQQ*H IKO GDVV LPP NROOHNWLYHQ DXVV -DKUWDXVHQGHQQ GHU 6SLULWXDOLWlWW HQWVWDQGHQHQQ 8Q WHUEHZX‰WVHLQQ >LKUHV@9RONHV ZXU]HOW³ $OV %LOG GHV +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWHV XQG ZHLEOLFKHVV%LOGGIUU&KULVWXVIKUWWVLHHGLHHEXGGKLVWLVFKHH*|WWLQQ.ZDQQ,QDQGLH ÄLQQGHUU9RONVUHOLJLRVLWlWW2VWDVLHQVVDOVV*|WWLQQGHVV0LWOHLGHQVVXQGGGHUU:HLVKHLWW YHUHKUW³ ZLUG.ZDQQ,QKDEHHDOVVERGKLVDWWYDDOVRRDOVVHUOHXFKWHWHVV:HVHQGDV 5HFKWMHGHU]HLWWLQVV1LUZDQDHLQ]XJHKHQVLHYHU]LFKWHGDUDXIMHGRFKKIUHLZLOOLJ 6LH WXH GLHV GD VLH 0LWOHLGG PLWW DOOHQQ *HVFK|SIHQ KDEHH XQGG LKQHQQ EHL GHU (UOHXFKWXQJ KHOIHQQ ZROOH XPP GDQQQ JHPHLQVDPP LQVV1LUZDQDD HLQ]XJHKHQ ÄZRR

&KXQJEHHQGHWWLKU5HIHUDWLQGHPPVLHHLKUH=XK|UHUUELWWHWLKUHU$JHQGD ]X]XVWLPPHQ DOVRR GHUU hEHUZLQGXQJ GHUU SROLWLVFKHQQ gNRQRPLHH GHVV 7RGHVV GXUFKGLHSROLWLVFKHgNRQRPLHGHV /HEHQV6LHUXIWWGDKHUUGHQQ+HLOLJHQ *HLVWW XPP +LOIHH GDEHL DQ XQG VFKOLH‰W LKUU 5HIHUDW PLW GHP 7KHPD GHU 9ROOYHU

9JO 6 %HGDXHUOLFKHUZHLVH KDWWH &KXQJ KLHUU NHLQHQ (UIROJ XQGG HV EHVWHKW DXFKK KHXWH GLH 7UHQQXQJJ LQ GLH EHLGHQ 6WDDWHQQ 1RUG XQG 6GNRUHDD ZHLWHU 9HUVXFKHH GHU $QQlKHUXQJ VFKHLWHUQ LPPHU ZLHGHU ZLHH GHUU $UWLNHO Ä1HXHH (LV]HLW ]ZLVFKHQQ 1RUG XQG 6GNRUHD³ YRP DXII 7DJHVVFKDXGHH QXU EHLVSLHOKDIWW GHXWOLFK PDFKW 9JO 1HXH (LV]HLW]ZLVFKHQQ1RUGXQGG6GNRUHD85/VLHKHH/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV=XJULII ^{&KXQJ6 ,EG ,EG ,EG 6I} 9JO6

9HUJOHLFKKGHUUEHLGHQ5HIHUDWHHXQGG3RVLWLRQHQQ

1DFKGHPQXQQHLQQGHWDLOOLHUWHVV%LOGGGHV ,QKDOWVVGHU5HIHUDWHHQWVWDQGHQ LVWW XQGG GLHH GDULQQ HQWKDOWHQHQQ *HGDQNHQQ DQDO\VLHUWW ZXUGHQ ZHUGHQQ QXQ GLHH EHLGHQQ 5HIHUDWHH E]Z 3RVLWLRQHQQ PLWHLQDQGHUU YHUJOLFKHQ (VV EHVWHKHQQ HLQLJH *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ ]ZLVFKHQQ GHQ EHLGHQQ 5HIHUDWHQQ GHU EHLGHQQ 7KHRORJHQ 3DUWKHQLRVV XQGG &KXQJ MHGRFKK EHUZLHJHQQ PHLQHP (UDFKWHQQ QDFKK GLHH 8QWHU VFKLHGH ZREHLL KLHU HLQH GLIIHUHQ]LHUWHH XQGG JHQDXHH $QDO\VH QRWZHQGLJ HU VFKHLQW

'LHHJU|‰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U&KXQJJKLQJHJHQLVWW3ILQJVWHQQHLQQKHUUVFKDIWV NULWLVFKHVV(UHLJQLVVXQGG*RWWHVV.DPSIDQVDJHHDQQGHQQE|VHQQ*HLVW%DEHOV 6R ZRKOO&KXQJJDOVVDXFKK3DUWKHQLRVV]LWLHUHQQKlXILJGLHH%LEHORGHUQHKPHQ%H]XJJ ]XU %LEHO ZREHLL &KXQJJ VRZRKOO DXII GDVV $OWHH 7HVWDPHQW DOVV DXFKK GDVV 1HXH 7HVWDPHQWW%H]XJQLPPW3DUWKHQLRVVKLQJHJHQQQXUDXIIGDVV1HXHH7HVWDPHQWDXII 7H[WH GLHH GLHH .LUFKH HLQHVV VHLQHUU +DXSWDQOLHJHQ WKHPDWLVLHUHQ 'RFKK DXFKK HLQHHVROFKHH*HPHLQVDPNHLWQlPOLFKKGDVVVEHLGHHVHKUUYLHOODXVVGHUU%LEHO]LWLHUHQ HUVFKHLQWW WULYLDO GD HV VLFKK EHL GHUU 9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJ GHVV g5. XP HLQH FKULVWOLFKHH9HUDQVWDOWXQJKDQGHOWWXQGGGRUWWGLHH%LEHOLPP0LWWHOSXQNWWVWHKW'LHH 7DWVDFKHGDVVV)UDXX&KXQJVLFKKDXFKKDXIIGDVV$OWHH7HVWDPHQWEH]LHKWOLHJWDQQ LKUHUUEHIUHLXQJVWKHRORJLVFKHQ$JHQGDGDVLHVLFKDXI7H[WHEH]LHKWLQGHQHQ 7UDXHU:XW8QWHUGUFNXQJXQGG9HU]ZHLIOXQJWKHPDWLVLHUWWZHUGHQDEHUQLFKW VRR VHKU DXI QWO 7H[WH GLH GHQQ +HLOLJHQ *HLVWW LQQ GRJPDWLVFKHU :HLVH WKHPD WLVLHUHQZLHHVVEHL3DUWKHQLRVVGHU)DOOOLVW

%HLGHVLQGGGHU0HLQXQJGDVVVVLFKKHWZDVlQGHUQPVVH8PPGLHHEHLGHQQ 3RVLWLRQHQQ ]X YHUJOHLFKHQ LVW HVV DEHUU VLQQYROO KHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQ ZDVV VLH MH

9JO3DUWKHQLRV6I

9JO&KXQJ6

ZHLOVVZROOHQ(VVLVWWQLFKWVRGDVVVVLHHJUXQGVlW]OLFKKXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHUU0HLQXQJJ VLQG 6RR P|FKWHQQ EHLGH HLQH hEHUZLQGXQJ YRQ $UPXW .ULHJ 8PZHOW]HU VW|UXQJ XQGG 8QWHUGUFNXQJ LQQ GHUU :HOWW KHUEHLIKUHQ )UU 3DUWKHQLRV KDQGHOWW HVV VLFKK KLHUEHLL MHGRFKK XP 5HIRUPHQ VRR VROOH GXUFK NDULWDWLYHV (QJDJHPHQWW XQGGXQNRQNUHWWIRUPXOLHUWHHSROLWLVFKHH)RUGHUXQJHQHLQHH%HVVHUXQJGHU9HUKlOW QLVVHHLQQGHUU:HOWWKHUEHLJHIKUWZHUGHQ)UU&KXQJKLQJHJHQQLVWWGDVV]XXZHQLJ 6LHHP|FKWHHLQHH5HYROXWLRQ6LHP|FKWHHLQHhEHUZLQGXQJJGHUU'RPLQDQ]GHV FKULVWOLFKHQQ E]Z ZHVWOLFKHQQ 'HQNHQVV LQQ GHU :HOW KHUEHLIKUHQ GDVVV VLHH LQ HUVWHU/LQLHIUGLHhEHOOLQQGHUU:HOWWYHUDQWZRUWOLFKKPDFKW6LHHPDFKWWNRQNUHWH SROLWLVFKH)RUGHUXQJHQZLHHWZDGLHGLH9HUHLQLJXQJGHUEHLGHQQNRUHDQLVFKHQ 6WDDWHQQ KHUEHL]XIKUHQ 3DUWKHQLRVV KLQJHJHQQEOHLEWW]XPPJU|‰WHQ7HLOOLQQWUDGL WLRQHOOHQQFKULVWOLFKHQQE]ZRUWKRGR[HQQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQ)UULKQQLVWWGHUU:HJQDFK YRUQHH GDYRQQ JHSUlJW GDVVV PDQQ VLFK DXI GLH %LEHO YRUU DOOHP GDVV 1HXH

%HLGHH YHUZHQGHQQ ]ZDUU GDVV JOHLFKH 9RNDEXODU GRFKK VLHH PHLQHQQ GDPLWW MHZHLOVVDQGHUH]XPLQGHVWWHWZDVVDQGHUH'LQJH6RIRUGHUQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHEHL GHHDXII]XUU%X‰H )U3DUWKHQLRVEHGHXWHWGLHHJHIRUGHUWH%X‰HHLQHH5FNNHKU ]XX GHQ 7XJHQGHQQ GHU FKULVWOLFKHQQ 7UDGLWLRQ EHLVSLHOVZHLVHH 'HPXWW XQGG +HLOL JXQJXQGGHLQHHhEHUZLQGXQJGHU7UHQQXQJHQQ]ZLVFKHQQGHQQ.LUFKHQ'LHH*H PHLQVDPNHLWHQQEHLGHQQJHIRUGHUWHQQ7XJHQGHQQ]ZLVFKHQGHQQEHLGHQQ7KHRORJHQ EHVWHKHQQKLHUUQXUULQVRIHUQDOVVVLHHVRZRKOOLPP&KULVWHQWXPPDOVVDXFKKLQQDQGHUHQ 5HOLJLRQHQQ]XILQGHQQVLQGEHLVSLHOVZHLVHEHLGHU%HVFKHLGHQKHLWLP%XGGKLV PXVV XQGG LPP &KULVWHQWXP )UU &KXQJ VSLHOWW GLH FKULVWOLFKHH .LUFKHH HLQH HKHU XQWHUJHRUGQHWHH 5ROOH ]XPLQGHVWW EHL ZHLWHPP NHLQH VR JUR‰H 5ROOH ZLH EHL 3DUWKHQLRV GHVVHQQ $JHQGD HVV LVW GLHH (LQKHLW YRQ .LUFKH XQG 0HQVFKKHLW KHUEHL]XIKUHQ &KXQJJ KLQJHJHQQ YHUVWHKWW XQWHUU %X‰H HLQH $ENHKU YRPP ZHVWOLFKHQQ XQGG FKULVWOLFKHQQ 'HQNHQ KLQQ ]X GHQQ 7UDGLWLRQHQQ GHU |VWOLFKHQ 5HOLJLRQHQQ XQGG GHUU GHUU 1DWXUY|ONHU EHLVSLHOVZHLVH GHU DXVWUDOLVFKHQ 8UHLQ ZRKQHU 'DVV /HLG GDVV GXUFKK FKULVWOLFKHH .LUFKHQQ XQG (LQ]HOSHUVRQHQQ E]Z ELEOLVFKHH *HVWDOWHQQ GHQQ 0HQVFKHQQ DQGHUHUU 5HOLJLRQHQ XQGG 7UDGLWLRQHQ

9JO3DUWKHQLRV6IIXQGG9JO&KXQJ6II

,EG

]XJHIJW ZXUGH VSLHOWW EHLL &KXQJ HLQHH VHKUU JUR‰H 5ROOH 3DUWKHQLRVV KLQJHJHQ

3DUWKHQLRVV VLHKWW GHQQ +HLOLJHQQ *HLVW LQQ HUVWHU /LQLH LQQ GHU FKULVWOLFKHQ .LUFKHDXFKZHQQHUGHUJDQ]HQQ6FK|SIXQJ]XJHVWHKWGDVVVGHU+HLOLJH*HLVW LQQLKUUZRKQW+LHUUJHKWW&KXQJHLQHQQ6FKULWWWZHLWHUUXQGGVLHHYHUWULWWWQHEHQQHLQHU 2IIHQEDUXQJVWKHRORJLH DXFKK HLQHQQ $QVDW] QDWUOLFKHUU 7KHRORJLH 6LHH VLHKWW GHQQ +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWW DXFKK LQQ IHUQ|VWOLFKHQ UHOLJL|VHQ 7UDGLWLRQHQQ DP :HUN

(LQHUVHLWV YHUNQSIWW &KXQJ ELEOLVFKH 7UDGLWLRQHQQ PLWW DX‰HUELEOLVFKHQ 7UDGLWLRQHQ HWZD GDVV $XV]LHKHQ GHUU 6FKXKHH DXI KHLOLJHPP %RGHQQ EHLL VRZRKOO 0RVHVVDOVVDXFKKGHQQDXVWUDOLVFKHQQ8UHLQZRKQHUQ$XFKGHUU9HUJOHLFKK]ZLVFKHQ .ZDQQ,QXQGG&KULVWXVVFKHLQWVFKOVVLJGDEHLGH*HVWDOWHQQVLFKKDXIRSIHUQXPP DQGHUHQ]XKHOIHQ.ZDQQ,QYHU]LFKWHWYRUHUVWDXIGDVV1LUZDQDXP/HEHZHVHQQ (UOHXFKWXQJ ]X EULQJHQ XQGG &KULVWXV JLEWW VHLQQ /HEHQQ DOVV 6KQHRSIHUU E]Z (UO|VHUU IUU GLH 6QGHQQ GHUU :HOW &KXQJV &KULVWRORJLH EOHLEWW MHGRFKK HWZDV XQNODU6RRQHQQWWVLHH-HVXVLKUHQQ%UXGHUUXQGG%HIUHLHUXQGGEH]HLFKQHWLKQQDOVVHLQQ 2SIHUU YRQQ *HZDOW DEHU DOVV 6KQHRSIHUU E]Z (UO|VHUU ZLUGG HUU QLFKWW H[SOL]LW EH]HLFKQHW K|FKVWHQVV LPSOL]LW 'HUU 9HUJOHLFKK ]ZLVFKHQQ GHPP .L XQG GHP +HLOLJHQQ*HLVWDOVV/HEHQVHQHUJLHE]Z/HEHQVDWHPPVFKHLQWWHEHQIDOOVVFKOVVLJ XQGGOlVVWWQRFKKNHLQHQQNRQNUHWHQQ6\QNUHWLVPXVVHUNHQQHQ 3DUWKHQLRVVEOHLEWWLQ VHLQHP5HIHUDWWUDGLWLRQHOOOWULQLWDULVFKGHU+HLOLJH*HLVWWLVWWIULKQQGHU3DUDNOHW

$QGHUHUVHLWV EHUVFKUHLWHWW &KXQJ PLWW LKUHPP $QUXIHQQ GHU *HLVWHUU YRQ *HZDOW XQGG 0RUGRSIHUQ XQGG GHPP 9HUJOHLFKK YRQQ NRUHDQLVFKHQ YRQQ +DQ HU IOOWHQ5DFKHJHLVWHUQQPLWWGHPP+HLOLJHQ*HLVWWGLH*UHQ]HGHVVHQZDVIUYLHOH RGHUU GLHH PHLVWHQQ &KULVWHQQ DN]HSWDEHOO LVW 'LHH 7DWVDFKH GDVVV VRR HWZDV (P S|UXQJ KHUYRUUXIHQ ZUGH KlWWHH LKU NODUU VHLQQ PVVHQ GRFKK YLHOOHLFKWW VXFKWHH VLHH DXFKK JHUDGHH GLHVHH3URYRNDWLRQ 3DUWKHQLRVV HWZDD VSULFKWW LQQ VHLQHPP 5HIHUDW DXFKKYRPP7HXIHOOXQGGGHQQ'lPRQHQXQGGDXIIGLHH$XVVDJH&KXQJVÄ>L@FKKKRIIH GD‰‰ GLHH *HJHQZDUWW GHUU *HLVWHUU DOOO XQVHUHUU 9RUIDKUHQ ,KQHQQ NHLQQ 8QEHKDJHQQ

,EG

^{9JO3DUWKHQLRV6IIXQGG&KXQJ6XQGI 9JO&KXQJ6I 9JO6I} 9JO3DUWKHQLRV6I

YHUXUVDFKW³ ZUGHH 3DUWKHQLRVV VLFKHUOLFKK PLWW Ä6HKUU ZRKOO EHUHLWHW VLHH PLU 8QEHKDJHQ³³ HQWJHJQHQ XQGG KLHUU GLH YRQQ LKPP WKHPDWLVLHUWHQQ 'lPRQHQ DPP :HUNNVHKHQ&KXQJKDWWMHGRFKKPLWWGHPP7KHPDWLVLHUHQQGHUU6FKXOGGXQGG6QGH GLHHDQQGHQQ0HQVFKHQQE]ZXQSHUV|QOLFKHQQ*HJHQVWlQGHQQEHJDQJHQQZXUGHXQG GHUHQQ *HLVWHUU VLHH KHUDXIEHVFKZ|UW PHLQHP (UDFKWHQQ QDFKK HLQHQ ZXQGHQ 3XQNW DQJHVSURFKHQ 'HQQQ 6FKXOG 6QGHH XQGG 9HUVDJHQQ PVVHQQ WKHPDWLVLHUWW

,P *RWWHVELOG XQGG GHUU *RWWHVHUNHQQWQLV EHVWHKHQQ HEHQIDOOVV 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQQ &KXQJ XQGG 3DUWKHQLRV )UU 3DUWKHQLRVV LVWW *RWW GHUU JHKHLPQLVKDIWHH XQGG DOOPlFKWLJHH FKULVWOLFKHH *RWW GHU QLFKWW PLW PHQVFKOLFKHU :HLVKHLWWXQGGGHPP9HUVWDQGGHUNDQQWWZLUGVRQGHUQGXUFKK7RUKHLWWXQGGHLQHQLPP ZDKUVWHQQ6LQQHHGHVV:RUWHVQDLYHQVFNLQGOLFKHQ*ODXEHQ )U&KXQJJLEWW HVVGHQQDOOPlFKWLJHQQ*RWWWQLFKWWXQGGGHQQ*ODXEHQQDQQHEHQQGLHVHQQEH]HLFKQHWVLHH DOVV .LQGHUJODXEHQ GDVV DQQ LKQ JHULFKWHWHH *HEHW DOV NLQGOLFK 6LHH JODXEWW VWDWWGHVVHQQDQQGHQQEDUPKHU]LJHQ*RWWGLH(UNHQQWQLV*RWWHVVJHVFKLHKWWEHLLKU DXFKK GXUFKK GHQQ 9HUVWDQGG E]Z GDVV YHUVWDQGHVPl‰LJHH XQGG UHIOHNWLHUWHH hEHU

'LHH.RQWURYHUVHHLP$QVFKOXVVVDQQ)UDX&KXQJVV5HIHUDW

:LHHXQVFKZHUU]XHUNHQQHQQLVWZHLFKHQQGLHLQQEHLGHQ5HIHUDWHQQ]X7DJH WUHWHQGHQQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQQGDUEHUZDVVGHU+HLOLJHH*HLVWWLVWWE]ZQLFKWWLVWVWDUN YRQHLQDQGHU DE (VV IlOOWW VFKOLFKWZHJ DXI GDVV KLHU ZHQQ DXFK ]7 JOHLFKHV 9RNDEXODU JHEUDXFKWW ZXUGH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH KHUPHQHXWLVFKHH 3ULQ]LSLHQQ YHU ZHQGHWWZXUGHQ,P$QVFKOXVVVDQQ)UDXX&KXQJVV5HIHUDWWZXUGHHGDKHUUGHVVHQ,Q KDOWWNRQWURYHUVVGLVNXWLHUWEHLVSLHOVZHLVHHGLHHNRQWH[WXHOOHQQXQGGIHPLQLVWLVFKHQ $VSHNWH .ULWLVLHUW ZXUGH DQQ &KXQJ XQWHU DQGHUHPP GLH ÄXQSUl]LVH 5HGHH YRP

&KXQJ6

^{'DV /HXJQHQ GHUU 6FKXOG XQGG GHUU )HKOHU GLHH &KULVWHQ LQQ 9HUJDQJHQKHLW XQGG *HJHQZDUW EHJDQJHQQKDEHQE]ZEHJHKHQVWHOOWWVLFKHUOLFKHLQH%ORFNDGHHIUUYLHOH0HQVFKHQGDUDQGDVV} &KULVWHQWXP ]X JODXEHQ DXFK ZHQQ HVV YLHOOHLFKW QLFKW &KXQJVV +DXSWDQOLHJHQ LVW IU GDVV &KULVWHQWXP]X ZHUEHQ=XPLQGHVWELEOLVFKOlVVWVLFKGLHVHUU6DFKYHUKDOWW P( ^{EHOHJHQHWZD ZHQQ3DXOXVLQ5|PGLHH6QGHQXQGGLHH+HXFKHOHLGHUUGDPDOLJHQQ-XGHQDQSUDQJHUW XQGVDJWGDVVVÄGHUU1DPHH*RWWHV>«@@HXUHWZHJHQQXQWHUGHQ1DWLRQHQJHOlVWHUW>ZLUG@³ XQGPDQGLHVHQ6DFKYHUKDOWWDXIGLHHFKULVWOLFKH.LUFKHHEHUWUlJW 9JO3DUWKHQLRV6} 9JO&KXQJXD6I

+HLOLJHQ *HLVW³ RGHUU GHUU ÄDQWKURSRPRUSKHH $QVDW]³ EHLP 7KHPD 9HU ZLHVHQQZXUGHDXFKKDXIIGHQQÄ8QWHUVFKLHGG]ZLVFKHQQWKHRORJLVFKHUUXQGGNRQWH[W XHOOHU $XVVDJH³ (VV JDE DOOHUGLQJV DXFKK =XVWLPPXQJ ]XX &KXQJVV 5HIHUDW LQGHPP XQWHUVWULFKHQQ ZXUGH GDVVV ÄGLHH .XOWXUU $XVJDQJVSXQNWW IUU %HNHKUXQJJ XQGG *ODXEHH VHL³ XQGG LQGHPP SRVWXOLHUWW ZXUGH GDVVV GLHH 9RUVWHOOXQJ HLQH .XOWXUUN|QQHHKHLGQLVFKKVHLQQLFKWWVWLPPHHXQGGGLHVHU*HGDQNHQJDQJZHVWOLFKK VHL .RQUDGG5DLVHUU GHUU *HQHUDOVHNUHWlU GHVVg5..YRQQ YHUVXFKWHH]XEHVFKZLFKWLJHQLQGHPPHUÄNHLQHQQ$QOD‰>VDK@)UDXX&KXQJ6\Q NUHWLVPXVV YRU]XZHUIHQ (UU GDQNWHH 3DUWKHQLRVV XQGG &KXQJ GLHH ÄHLQHQQ 6SDQ QXQJVERJHQQ HU|IIQHW³³ KlWWHQ XQGG EHWRQWH GD‰‰ GHUU +HLOLJHH *HLVWW .UDIWW XQGG

/LQ] XQGG 8UEDQ VFKUHLEHQ GLHH +DXSWNULWLNSXQNWHH DXII GHUU 9ROOYHU VDPPOXQJ DQQ &KXQJV 5HIHUDWW VHLHQQ IROJHQGHH JHZHVHQ RUWKRGR[HH 9HUWUHWHU KlWWHQQYRUUDOOHPPGLH%HIUFKWXQJJYRUJHEUDFKWGDVVV&KXQJVV5HIHUDWWGLHH(LQKHLWW LP g5. JHIlKUGH )U 3URWHVWDQWHQ KDEH VLFK GLH )UDJH QDFK GHP UHIRU PDWRULVFKHQQVROXVV&KULVWXVJHVWHOOWDOOJHPHLQQVHLLMHGRFKKGHUKlXILJVWH9RUZXUII GHUUGHVV6\QNUHWLVPXVVJHZHVHQ /DXWWGHU3UHVVHKlWWHQQGLH+DXSWNULWLNSXQNWH DQQ &KXQJVV 5HIHUDWW LQQ GHPP DOVV *HLVWHUEHVFKZ|UXQJ JHGHXWHWHQQ VFKDPDQ LVWLVFKHQ5LWXDOEHVWDQGHQVRZLHHLQQGHUUEHUZLHJHQGGZHLEOLFKHQQ%H]HLFKQXQJJ GHVV +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWHV XQG LQQ GHPP +LQZHLVV DXI GLH *|WWLQQ .ZDQQ ,Q DOV ZHLE OLFKHVV%LOGGIU&KULVWXV &KXQJVV,QKDOWHHKLQJHJHQHWZDDLKUHH$JHQGDIUUHLQH QHXHH SROLWLVFKHH gNRQRPLH KlWWHQQ MHGRFKK DXII *UXQGG GHUU HPS|UWHQQ .ULWLNN DQQ LKUHPP 5HIHUDWW NHLQHH %HDFKWXQJ JHIXQGHQ ,QVJHVDPWW OlVVWW VLFKK IHVWVWHOOHQ GDVVV /LQ] XQGG 8UEDQ &KXQJVV 5HIHUDW GHVVHQ ,QKDOWW XQGG &KXQJV ÄNRQVHTXHQW EHIUHLXQJVWKHRORJLVFKH>P@ IHPLQLVWLVFKH>P@ XQGG VFK|SIXQJVRULHQWLHUWH>P@ $QVDW]³ VHKUUDXIJHVFKORVVHQQJHJHQEHUVWHKHQQXQGGNHLQHQQ*UXQGGIUU.ULWLN ILQGHQQ XQGG &KXQJ VRJDUU YRQQ /LQ] XQGG 8UEDQ IU LKUH (UZHLWHUXQJ GHU

0OOHU5|PKHOG6

^{,EG 0OOHU5|PKHOG6I 0OOHU5|PKHOG6 9JO6 6 9JO/LQ]]8UEDQ6 ,EG ,EG} /LQ]]]8UEDQ6

3QHXPDWRORJLH JHOREWWZLUG (VV HUVFKHLQWW DEHUU IDLU DXFKK GLHH *HJHQVWLPPHQ ]X K|UHQ DOVRR GDV ZDVV GLHH RUWKRGR[HQQ 7HLOQHKPHU GHU 9ROOYHUVDPPOXQJ DQ &KXQJVV 5HIHUDWW NRQNUHW ]XX NULWLVLHUHQQ KDWWHQ 6LHH IRUPXOLHUWHQQ LQQ HLQHPP 6FKUHLEHQQLKUHH.ULWLNNDQQ&KXQJIROJHQGHUPD‰HQ

³$$ JHQXLQH GLDORJXHH LQYROYHVV JUHDWHUU WKHRORJLFDO HIIRUWV WRR H[SUHVVV WKH &KULVWLDQQ PHVVDJH LQQ ZD\V WKDWW VSHDNN WRR WKHH YDULRXV FXOWXUHVV RII RXUU ZRUOG$OOOWKLVKRZHYHUPXVWWRFFXURQQWKHEDVLVRIIWKHRORJLFDOFULWHULDD ZKLFKKZLOOOGHILQHHWKHOLPLWVVRIGLYHUVLW\7KHELEOLFDOOIDLWKKLQQ*RGGPXVWW QRWWEHHFKDQJHG7KHHGHILQLWLRQQRIIWKHVHHFULWHULDLVDPDWWHURIIWKHRORJLFDO VWXGG DQGG PXVWW FRQVWLWXWH WKHH ILUVWW SULRULW\ RI WKH :&&& LQQ YLHZ RI LWVV

(VVJlEHHGHPQDFKK3ULQ]LSLHQZLHHHWZDDGHUU*ODXEHHDQQGHQQELEOLVFKHQ*RWWGLH XQXPVW|‰OLFKK VHLHQ :HLWHUU VDJWHQQ GLH 2UWKRGR[HQ GDVVV DXFKK GLHH 3QHXPD WRORJLHHXQWUHQQEDUYRQQGHUU7ULQLWlWWXQGGGHUU&KULVWRORJLHHVHLLXQGGPDQQLFKWWMH GHQQ *HLVWW PLWW GHPP +HLOLJHQQ *HLVWW LGHQWLIL]LHUHQQ N|QQH DXFK VHL GDV +HUDXI EHVFKZ|UHQQGHUU*HLVWHUUYRQQ*HZDOWXQGG0RUGRSIHUQQSUREOHPDWLVFK

Ä>,@WW LVV ZLWK DODUPP WKDWW WKHH 2UWKRGR[ KDYHH KHDUGG VRPHH SUHVHQWDWLRQVV RQQ WKHHWKHPHHRIWKLVVDVVHPEO\>«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

,QWHUHVVDQWWVFKHLQWWMHW]WMHGRFKKYRUUDOOHPPGLHH)UDJHLQZLHIHUQQ&KXQJJVHOEVW]X GHUUDQQLKUUJHlX‰HUWHQQ.ULWLNN6WHOOXQJEH]RJHWZDZLHHVLHHDXIIGHQQ9RUZXUIGHVV 6\QNUHWLVPXVV UHDJLHUWH GHQQ .RQUDGG 5DLVHU &KXQJ YHUWHLGLJHQG EHVFKZLFK WLJHQGG ]XUFNJHZLHVHQQ KDWWH 6RR ZXUGHH &KXQJ LQQ HLQHPP ,QWHUYLHZZ JHIUDJW RE VLHH HLQHH 6\QNUHWLVWLQQ VHL XQGG VLHH DQWZRUWHWHH GDUDXII EHMDKHQGG PLW GLHVHQ :RUWHQ

9JO6II

^{$XVGHP$UWLNHO5HIOHFWLRQVRI2UWKRGR[[3DUWLFLSDQWV)URPWKHHRIILFLDO2UWKRGR[[UHSRUWRI} WKHH:&&$VVHPEO\LQQ&DQEHUUD,Q2UWKRGR[[&KULVWLDQQ,QIRUPDWLRQQ&HQWHU85/VLHKH ^{/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV=XJULII ,EG} 9JOXD0OOHU5|PKHOG6

³,II WKH\ DVNN PH ³$UH \RXX DD V\QFUHWLVW"´´ , VD\ ³ EXWW \RXX GRQ¶WW NQRZZ \RX DUHH D V\QFUHWLVWW EHFDXVHH \RX KDYHH KHJHPRQLFF SRZHU3HRSOHHZLWKKKHJHPRQLFFSRZHUUGRQ¶WWKDYHHWRRGHILQHHWKHPVHOYHVVLQ UHODWLRQQWRRRWKHUV¶GLIIHUHQFHVEHFDXVHHWKH\DUHHWKHHRQHVVLQFKDUJH7KH\ DUHPL[LQJHYHU\WKLQJWRJHWKHUWRRPDNHWKHLUU&KULVWLDQLW\UHOHYDQWWWRRWKHLUU FRQWH[W %XWW LWW LVV 2. EHFDXVHH WKHLU FXOWXUHH LVV WKH QRUP %XW VRFDOOHG QRQQRUPDWLYHH FXOWXUHV VRR FDOOHGG 7KLUGG :RUOGG FXOWXUHVV ±± $VLD $IULFD /DWLQQ $PHULFD ± WKDWW DUHH QRQ&KULVWLDQQ FXOWXUHV ZKHQQ WKH\ WU\ WRR LQWHUSUHWWKHHJRVSHORXWRIIWKHLUUOLIHHH[SHULHQFHWKH\DUHHV\QFUHWLVWV%XW WKH\DUHMXVWWEHLQJWUXHHWRRWKHLULGHQWLW\KLVWRU\DQGFXOWXUH6\QFUHWLVPPLVV DDJLYHQ$VVVRPHRQHHHOVHHKDVVVDLG³7KHZKROHH&KULVWLDQQPRYHPHQWWLVVD

,QlKQOLFKHUU:HLVHHKDWWHVLFKK&KXQJJEHUHLWVVJHlX‰HUW 6LHKDWDOVRJDU NHLQQ 3UREOHPP GDPLW DOVV 6\QNUHWLVWLQQ EH]HLFKQHW ]X ZHUGHQQ XQGG ZLUIWW VWDWW GHVVHQQDQGHUHQQ&KULVWHQQYRUVLHHVHOEVWWVHLHQQDXFK6\QNUHWLVWHQQXUUZUGHQQVLH VLFKK GLHVHVV QLFKWW HLQJHVWHKHQQ XQGG KlWWHQQ HLQQ 0DFKWPRQRSROO EHU GLH LP ZDKUVWHQQ6LQQHHGHVV:RUWHVVRUWKRGR[HDOVRRZDKUHE]ZULFKWLJH/HKUH )U &KXQJ VHLL GHVKDOE GDVV Ä.ULWHULXPP IUU GLHH WKHRORJLVFKHH 5HOHYDQ] YRQQ 7H[WHQ XQGG$XVVDJHQQ>«@QLFKWOlQJHUGLHH5HLQKHLWWGHUU/HKUHHRGHUUHLQQDEVWUDNWHUHU IDKUXQJVOHHUHU :DKUKHLWVEHJULII³ VRQGHUQQ VLH KDOWHH Ä$XVVFKDXX QDFKK HUPXW LJHQGHQQOHEHQVEHMDKHQGHQQ(OHPHQWHQQLQGHU%LEHO>XQGGHVVVHLLHQWVFKHLGHQG@RE

.RQUDGG 5DLVHU QDKPP GHWDLOOLHUW 6WHOOXQJ ]XX GHU .RQWURYHUVH 6HLQHUU 0HLQXQJJQDFKVHLLHVVEHLGHUU.RQWURYHUVHMHGRFKQLFKWWLQQHUVWHUU/LQLHXPPXQWHU VFKLHGOLFKHH/HKUDXIIDVVXQJHQQJHJDQJHQHVVKDEHHVLFKYLHOPHKUUHLQQ3UREOHPPLQ GHULQWHUNXOWXUHOOHQQWKHRORJLVFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQQJH]HLJW6RRVFKUHLEWW5DLVHUGDVVV ÄHVV LQQHUKDOE GHUU |NXPHQLVFKHQQ %HZHJXQJJ NHLQHH .ODUKHLWW EHU GLH KHUPHQ HXWLVFKHQQ.ULWHULHQQJLEW³ GKGDVVVHVVLPPEHUWUDJHQHQQ6LQQHHNHLQHHJHPHLQ VDPHH6SUDFKHHJHEH,QQGHUU'HEDWWHH]HLJHVLFKGDVVVÄHVV>«@QLFKWWQXUUXPPGDV

$XV ,QWHUYLHZ PLW Ä=LRQ¶VV +HUDOG³ MHW]WW EHNDQQW XQWHUU GHP 1DPHQ Ä7KH 3URJUHVVLYHH &KULVWLDQ³$XVJDEHH6HSW85/VLHKHH/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV=XJULII ^{9JO&KXQJ+\XQ.\XQJ6FKDPDQLQQLP%DXFK±±&KULVWLQLP.RSIZLU)UDXHQQ$VLHQVLP} $XIEUXFK1HZ