,PP(QJOLVFKHQZHUGHQPHLVWWGLHH%H]HLFKQXQJHQQ³SKUDVHRORJLFDOOXQLW´´RGHUU ÄLGLRP³³EHQXW]W

³,GLRP´´ZLUGGLPP2[IRUG$GYDQFHGG/HDUQHU¶VV'LFWLRQDU\GHILQLHUWDOVV DDJURXSSRIIZRUGVVZKRVHHPHDQLQJLVVGLIIHUHQWWIURPPWKHHPHDQLQJVVRIIWKHHHHHH LQGLYLGXDOZRUGVV³/HWWWKHHFDWWRXWRIWKHEDJ´LVDQQLGLRPPPHDQLQJWRWHOODDDDDDD VHFUHWWE\PLVWDNH

'HILQLWLRQ3KUDVHRORJLHHLPPHQJHUHQQ6LQQHH

%XUJHUUIXQWHUVFKHLGHWWQDFKK3KUDVHRORJLHHLPPHQJHUHQQ6LQQHXQGG 3KUDVHRORJLHLPPZHLWHUHQQ6LQQH'DEHLLKDQGHOWWHVVLFKKXPP3KUDVHRORJLHHLPP HQJHUHQ6LQQHZHQQQIROJHQGHHGUHLL9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQQHUIOOWZHUGHQ3RO\OH[L NDOLWlW)HVWLJNHLWWXQG,GLRPDWL]LWlW+LHUEHLKDQGHOWWHVVVLFKKXP,GLRPH:HUGHQQ QXUUGLHHHUVWHQEHLGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQQHUIOOWDOVRR3RO\OH[LNDOLWlWWXQGG)HVWLJ NHLWVSULFKWW%XUJHUUYRQQ3KUDVHRORJLHHLPZHLWHUHQ6LQQH 3RO\OH[LNDOLWlW

Ä'HUU3KUDVHRORJLVPXVEHVWHKWWDXVPHKUUDOVVHLQHP:RUW³³%XUJHUUI 'LHVVVFKHLQWWHLQHHHLQIDFKK]XXEHUSUIHQGH9RUUDXVVHW]XQJJ]XVHLQ'RFKKKLQ VLFKWOLFKKGHUU:|UWHUUJLEWWHVVXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH$QVLFKWHQQGDUEHUZDVVDOVV:RUWW ]lKOWWXQGZDVQLFKW%HLL:|UWHUQQZLUGXQWHUVFKLHGHQQLQ$XWRVHPDQWLNDD,Q KDOWVZ|UWHUPLWHLJHQHUU%HGHXWXQJZLHVFKZDU]RGHUUIDKUHQXQGG6\QVHPDQ WLNDD)XQNWLRQVZ|UWHURKQHH,QKDOWZLHHDQXQGG]XYJODXFKK'RQDOLHVV 0DQQLVWWVLFKKXQHLQLJGDUEHUREEHVVLFKEHLLGHQQ]ZHLL:|UWHUQQXPP$XWRVHPDQ WLNDDKDQGHOQQPXVVRGHUUREEGLHH:RUWYHUELQGXQJJDXFKKDXVVHLQHP,QKDOWVXQG HLQHPP)XQNWLRQVZRUWRGHUUVRJDUXQGGGLHVHUU0HLQXQJJLVWWDXFK%XUJHUQXUUU DXVV)XQNWLRQVZ|UWHUQQ]%ELVV]XLPP6LQQHHYRQQÄPD[LPDO³EHVWHKHQQNDQQ )OHLVFKHUðKLHU]XÄ/HJHQQZLUUZHLWHUUIHVWGDVVVHLQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPXVV HLQHH:RUWYHUELQGXQJLVWGLHHPLQGHVWHQVVHLQQDXWRVHPDQWLVFKHV:RUWWHQW KlOWW>«@³$OVV2EHUJUHQ]HHSKUDVHRORJLVFKHUU:RUWYHUELQGXQJHQJLOWWZHLWKLQQQQQ GHUU6DW] )HVWLJNHLWW

Ä:LUUNHQQHQQGHQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPXVLQQJHQDXXGLHVHUU.RPELQDWLRQQYRQQ:|UWHUQ XQGGHUULVWWLQQGHUU6SUDFKJHPHLQVFKDIWW±±lKQOLFKKZLHHLQQ:RUWW±±JHEUlXFKOLFK³ %XUJHUU'DEHLLLVWWGHUU3KUDVHRORJLVPXVV%XUJHU]XIROJHPHQWDODOVV (LQKHLWWDEJHVSHLFKHUWWXQGGZHLVWWHLQHHVWUXNWXUHOOHH)HVWLJNHLWWDXI±LPP*HJHQ VDW]]]XUUIUHLHQ:RUWYHUELQGXQJEHLLGHUGLH.RPELQDWLRQQYRQ:|UWHUQQOHGLJOLFKK GXUFKKGLHPRUSKRV\QWDNWLVFKHQQXQGGVHPDQWLVFKHQ5HJHOQQHLQJHVFKUlQNWWLVW 'RQDOLHVVIHUNOlUWWHVVVR

1DWUOLFKKLVWWMHGHVV3KUDVHPGXUFKHLQHUVWHVV$XVVSUHFKHQQRGHU$XIVFKUHLEHQ HQWVWDQGHQDEHUHLQQ3KUDVHPPZLUGHVVQDFKGLHVHPP.ULWHULXPHUVWZHQQQHVV ZLHGHUXQGGZLHGHUZLHGHUKROWWZLUG'XUFKKGLHYLHOIDFKH:LHGHUKROXQJZLUGHVV HQQEORFFLQQXQVHU*HGlFKWQLVVHLQJHEUDQQW

'REURYRO¶VNLM3LLUDLQHQVSUHFKHQKLHUUYRQQ6WDELOLWlW,GLRPHHZHUGHQ ÄMHZHLOVVLQQGHUUQDKH]XJOHLFKHQQ)RUPPXQG%HGHXWXQJJUHSURGX]LHUW³ %HLVSLHOHHIUUGLHH)HVWLJNHLWWYRQ3KUDVHPHQYJODXFKK%XUJHUUI D/H[LNDOLVFKHH*HEXQGHQKHLWW

%HLLIUHLHQ:RUWYHUELQGXQJHQQLVWWGHUU$XVWDXVFKKYRQ:|UWHUQQP|JOLFK 'LHHbSIHOODXIIGHPP0DUNWWNDXIHQ!'LHH.DUWRIIHOQQLPP6XSHUPDUNWWNDXIHQ %HLL3KUDVHPHQQLVWWGLHVVMHGRFKKQLFKWWRKQHZHLWHUHVP|JOLFK 'LHH.DW]HLP6DFNNNDXIHQ!'HQ+XQGLPP%HXWHONDXIHQ

E6\QWDNWLVFKHH*HEXQGHQKHLWW

:lKUHQGGPDQQGLHHIUHLHH:RUWYHUELQGXQJJSUREOHPORVVXPVWHOOHQQNDQQJHKWWEHL HLQHUU8PVWHOOXQJJGHV3KUDVHPVVGLHSKUDVHRORJLVFKHH%HGHXWXQJJYHUORUHQQXQGG GHUU3KUDVHRORJLVPXVZLUGG]XXHLQHUUIUHLHQQ:RUWYHUELQGXQJ 'DVVLVWWNDOWHVV:DVVHU!!'DVV:DVVHUULVWWNDOW 'DVVLVWWNDOWHUU.DIIHH!!'HUU.DIIHHHLVWWNDOW

F*HEXQGHQKHLWWDQQ6LQJXODUXQGG3OXUDOO

$XFKKNDQQQQLFKWWHLQIDFKKGHUU6LQJXODUURGHU3OXUDOOHLQHVV$XVGUXFNHVVJHlQGHUWW ZHUGHQRKQHHGDVVVGDVV3KUDVHPPQLFKWWPHKUUIXQNWLRQLHUWWRGHUU]XPLQGHVWWVHOW VDPPNOLQJW

'HUU$SIHOOIlOOWWQLFKWWZHLWWYRP6WDPP!!'LHHbSIHOOIDOOHQQLFKWWZHLWWYRQQGHQQ 6WlPPHQ

(VVOLHJWWDOOHUGLQJVVNHLQHHDEVROXWHH)HVWLJNHLWWYRUGHQQQRIWWVLQG9DULDWLRQHQQ]X JHODVVHQ6RNDQQPDQQ]%EHLLHLQHUU6DFKHHVHLQHH+DQGRGHUVHLQHH+lQGHLP 6SLHOOKDEHQ0DQQNDQQQPLWEHLGHQ%HLQHQRGHUUPLWEHLGHQQ)‰HQQIHVWWLPP/H EHQQVWHKHQ$XFKK)OHLVFKHUUðVSULFKWWGDYRQGDVVVGLHH.RPSRQHQWHQQ LKUHQQÄ:RUW&KDUDNWHUUSULQ]LSLHOOOEHZDKUWWKDEHQZDVVVLFKKYRUUDOOHPPLQQGHQQ V\QWDNWLVFKHQQXQGGOH[LNDOLVFKHQQ9DULDWLRQVP|JOLFKNHLWHQQ]HLJW³ 'HVV:HLWHUHQQNDQQQPDQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPHQDXFKKIUUHLQHQQEHVWLPPWHQQ=ZHFNN PRGLIL]LHUHQXPP]%GXUFKKGHQQ9HUIUHPGXQJVHIIHNWW$XIPHUNVDPNHLWW]XXHUUH JHQQRGHUUHWZDVV]XXYHUVWlUNHQ]%GDVVLVWWHLVNDOWHUU.DIIHHRGHUUGDVVLVWW 6FKQHHYRQQ9RUJHVWHUQ ,GLRPDWL]LWlWW

'LHHOH[LNDOLVFKHQQ%HVWDQGWHLOHH.RPSRQHQWHQELOGHQQÄHLQHHGXUFKKGLHHV\QWDNWL VFKHQQXQGGVHPDQWLVFKHQQ5HJXODULWlWHQQGHUU9HUNQSIXQJJQLFKWWYROOHUNOlUEDUH (LQKHLW³³%XUJHUU(VVJLEWWXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHH%H]LHKXQJHQQ]ZLVFKHQGHUU LGLRPDWLVFKHQ%HGHXWXQJJXQGGGHUIUHLHQ%HGHXWXQJJGHUU.RPSRQHQWHQQE]Z GHUUJHVDPWHQ:RUWYHUELQGXQJ%HVWHKWWHLQHH'LVNUHSDQ]VRRLVWWÄGHUU$XVGUXFNN LGLRPDWLVFKKLPPVHPDQWLVFKHQ6LQQ³³%XUJHUUZREHL$XVGUFNHHXQG :HQGXQJHQQPHKUURGHUUZHQLJHUULGLRPDWLVFKVHLQQN|QQHQ

6RRN|QQHQQ3KUDVHPHXQWHUWHLOWWZHUGHQQLQYROOWHLOXQGGQLFKWLGLRPDWLVFKHH :HQGXQJHQMHHQDFKGHPREMHGHU%HVWDQGWHLOOGHUU:HQGXQJHLQQ7HLOORGHUUJDUU NHLQHUULGLRPDWLVFKKLVW D9ROOLGLRPDWL]LWlWW

$XIIGHUU(EHQHHGHV6SUDFKV\VWHPVVEHVWHKWWNHLQH%H]LHKXQJJ]ZLVFKHQGHUU IUHLHQQXQGGGHUULGLRPDWLVFKHQQ%HGHXWXQJ:lKUHQGGVLFKKGLHHIUHLHH%HGHXWXQJJ DEOHLWHQQOlVVWIXQNWLRQLHUWWGLHVVEHLLGHUULGLRPDWLVFKHQQ%HGHXWXQJJQLFKWWYJO %XUJHUU

1LPPWWPDQQGDVV%HLVSLHOOLQVV*UDVVEHL‰HQVRRLVWWNODUGDVVVPDQGLHH:HQGXQJJ NHQQHQPXVVXPPGLHHLGLRPDWLVFKHH%HGHXWXQJJÄVWHUEHQ³³]XXYHUVWHKHQ:HLWHUHH %HLVSLHOHHVLQGDXVVGHUU+DXWWIDKUHQMHPDQGHQQXPGLHH(FNHHEULQJHQRGHUUGHQQ 1DJHOODXIIGHQ.RSIIWUHIIHQ E7HLOLGLRPDWL]LWlWW

(LQQ7HLOOGHUU:HQGXQJJLVWWLGLRPDWLVFKZlKUHQGGHLQQDQGHUHUU7HLOOVHLQHHIUHLHH%H GHXWXQJJEHLEHKlOW

%XUJHUUQHQQWKLHUUDOV%HLVSLHOGHQQEOLQGHQQ3DVVDJLHU(VVJHKWXPPHLQHQQ3DV VDJLHUUIUHLHH%HGHXWXQJGHUUDEHUUQLFKWWXQEHGLQJWWZLUNOLFKKEOLQGLGLRPDWLVFKHH %HGHXWXQJVHLQQPXVVVRQGHUQQXQEHPHUNWWXQGGXQEHUHFKWLJWWPLWUHLVW F1LFKWLGLRPDWL]LWlWW

'LHH:HQGXQJJLVWWÄGXUFKKNHLQHHRGHUUQXUUPLQLPDOHVHPDQWLVFKH'LIIHUHQ]HQQ ]ZLVFKHQSKUDVHRORJLVFKHUUXQGGZ|UWOLFKHU%HGHXWXQJJFKDUDNWHULVLHUW³³%XUJHUU 'LHIUHLHH%HGHXWXQJJHLQHVVMHGHQ%HVWDQGWHLOVEOHLEWWHUKDOWHQ 6LFKKGLH+DDUHHZDVFKHQHLQNDXIHQQJHKHQHWFVLQGG%HLVSLHOHHIUUQLFKWLGLRPDWL VFKHH:HQGXQJHQ

(LQWHLOXQJJYRQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPHQQ

'REURYRO¶VNLM3LLUDLQHQIIXQWHUVFKHLGHQQIROJHQGHH.ODVVHQQYRQQQ 3KUDVHPHQ ,GLRPH

'LHH]HQWUDOHHSKUDVHRORJLVFKHH.ODVVH,GLRPHHZHUGHQQDOVVJHVSHLFKHUWH/H[L NRQHLQKHLWWUHSURGX]LHUW]%MPGPIlOOWWHLQQ6WHLQQYRP+HU]HQ+LQ]XQGG.XQ] .ROORNDWLRQHQQ

(LQHHJHZLVVHH)HVWJHSUlJWKHLWDXFKK)XQNWLRQVYHUEJHIJHKRKHUU*UDGGDQQVH PDQWLVFKHUU5HJXODULWlW]%MPGPHLQHH$EVDJHHUWHLOHQ

*UDPPDWLVFKHH3KUDVHRORJLVPHQQ

9RUZLHJHQGGDXVV6\QVHPDQWLNDDEHVWHKHQG]%ZLHHGHPPDXFKKVHL

3DU|PLHQQ6SULFKZ|UWHU

6LHHVWHKHQQGHQQ,GLRPHQQQDKHZHUGHQQDEHUUDOVV7H[WHH]LWLHUWWXQGYHUVSUDFKOL FKHQQÄDOOJHPHLQHH:DKUKHLWHQ³]%(LQQ%LOGGVDJWWPHKUUDOVVWDXVHQGG:RUWH RGHUHVVLVWWQLFKWWDOOHV*ROGZDVVJOlQ]W

*HIOJHOWHH:RUWH6HQWHQ]HQ0D[LPHQ$SKRULVPHQQ 9RUJHIRUPWHH)JXQJHQOLWHUDULVFKHH=LWDWH]%DXVV*RHWKHVV)DXVWWJUDXLVWW DOOHH7KHRULH

5RXWLQHIRUPHOQQ

+|IOLFKNHLWV*UX‰'DQNHVIRUPHOQQHWF]%*XWHQQ$SSHWLWPLWIUHXQGOLFKHQQ *U‰HQJHUQQJHVFKHKHQQHLJHQHH%HLVSLHOH

'HVV:HLWHUHQQOlVVWWVLFKMHHQDFKK:RUWDUWWGHUU%DVLVHOHPHQWHHLQHH.ODVVLIL]LH UXQJJQDFKKVXEVWDQWLYLVFKHQDGMHNWLYLVFKHQDGYHUELDOHQXQGYHUEDOHQ3KUDVH RORJLVPHQQYRUQHKPHQYJO)OHLVFKHUUð

'LHH)XQNWLRQGHVV3KUDVHRORJLVPXVV

3KUDVHPHHZHUGHQQYRUUDOOHPPZHJHQQLKUHUUVWLOLVWLVFKHQQXQGGSUDJPDWLVFKHQQ )XQNWLRQHQQYHUZHQGHW$XIJUXQGGLKUHUUKRKHQQ$XVGUXFNVNUDIWWN|QQHQQVLHHLPP 7H[WWLQWHQVLYLHUHQGGZLUNHQ6RRN|QQHQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPHQQGHPP7H[WW$QVFKDX OLFKNHLW:LW]2ULJLQDOLWlW,URQLHHRGHUU6DUNDVPXVVYHUOHLKHQ 'HVV:HLWHUHQQN|QQHQ3KUDVHRORJLVPHQLP7H[WW]XUU*HOWXQJJNRPPHQGHH.RQ QRWDWLRQQWUDJHQYRUDOOHPPH[SUHVVLYHHXQGVWLOLVWLVFKH'LHH[SUHVVLYHQQ.RQQR WDWLRQHQQN|QQHQQ]%DXIRGHUUDEZHUWHQGRGHUUVFKHU]KDIWWVHLQYJO*OlVHUU I6LHH]HLJHQQGLHH(LQVWHOOXQJJGHVV9HUZHQGHUVVYRQQLGLRPDWLVFKHQQ :HQGXQJHQQ]XUUEHVFKULHEHQHQQ6DFKHRGHUU3HUVRQVLHN|QQHQQVHLQHH:HUWXQJJ XQGGVHLQHH*HIKOHVLFKWEDUUPDFKHQQXQGG3HUVRQHQQFKDUDNWHULVLHUHQ'HUU7H[WW ZLUNWWLQVJHVDPWWLQWHUHVVDQWWXQGGOHEHQGLJ(UUZLUGGVWUXNWXULHUWWXQGGGLHH$UJX PHQWDWLRQQZLUGXQWHUVWW]W

:HQQQMHPDQGGYHUVSULFKWW+LPPHOOXQGG+|OOHHLQQ%HZHJXQJJ]XVHW]HQVRNOLQJW GLHVVYHUOlVVOLFKHUUDOVYHUVSUlFKHHHUDOOHVV]XXYHUVXFKHQ $XFKKLPP(QJOLVFKHQEHPHUNWWPDQQEHLLGHP9HUJOHLFKKIROJHQGHUU]ZHLL6lW]HHHL QHQQ8QWHUVFKLHGGLQQGHUU.RQQRWDWLRQ

+HHZDQWHGGVRPHWKLQJJVSHFLDOQRWVRPHSODFHHIRUUHYHU\7RP'LFNNDQGG+DUU\ +HHZDQWHGGVRPHWKLQJJVSHFLDOQRWVRPHSODFHHZKHUHHDQ\RQHFRXOGGJR ,QQGHUU:HUEXQJJZLUGVHKUUKlXILJJDXII3KUDVHPHH]XUFNJHJULIIHQ/DXWW3DOPP HQWKDOWHQQPLQGHVWHQVVGHUU:HUEHDQ]HLJHQQXQGGGHU:HU EHVSRWVPLQGHVWHQVHLQHQQ3KUDVHRORJLVPXVZHOFKHHLQQGHQQ$Q]HLJHQQ]XUU+lOI WHHLQQPRGLIL]LHUWHUU)RUPDXIWUHWHQ6LHHHUUHJHQQGLH$XIPHUNVDPNHLWWGHUU/HVHUU XQGG=XVFKDXHUUXQGVWHOOHQQHLQHH9HUNQSIXQJJ]XXEHNDQQWHQQ,QKDOWHQQKHU