Universität Duisburg-Essen

Standort Essen

Sommersemester 2005

Institut für Politikwissenschaft

Seminararbeit im Hauptseminar: ,,Politische Rhetorik"

Christine Um

The American Dream as a subject in speeches.
Jimmy Carter′s Inaugural Address (January 20th, 1977) and
Ronald Reagan′s Acceptance Speech (July 17th, 1980):
a comparison

The American Dream as a subject in speeches.
Jimmy Carter′s Inaugural Address (January 20th, 1977) and
Ronald Reagan′s Acceptance Speech (July 17th, 1980):
a comparison.

I. The American Dream 1
II. President Carter′s Inaugural Address 2.1.
The person Carter 3
2.2. The speech4
2.3. Illustration of what Carter says about the  American Dream 6
2.4. The creation of an image to the public 8
2.5. Rhetorical devices employed by Carter to give an impression of himself 9
III. Ronald Reagan′s Acceptance Speech
3.1. The person Reagan 12
3.2. The speech 13
3.3. The historical references in context of the intended message 14
3.4. Illustration of the values and virtues hinted at or talked about 16
3.5. Rhetorical devices employed by Reagan  to convince the audience of his message 18
IV. Comparison: Mutuality and differences
4.1. Comparison: values and virtues 18
4.2. Comparison: the audience 21
V. Bibliography 23
5.1. Internet sources 23

I. The American Dream

The American Dream has always been a central subject in political speeches. Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan were not the only presidents who referred to it in their speeches. Quite possibly every presidential candidate and president related to it when they accepted their nominations and when they outlined their political programmes at their inaugurations. Ever since it has become part of the tradition of political rhetoric in the United States, one can say how centrally important the American Dream (still) is and what great influence it has on the American people.

So what exactly is the American Dream? Peter Freese calls the attempt of defining it "subjective and imcomplete",1 especially because he is of the opinion that the vision and beliefs transferred in the American Dream change with the times. However, he quotes Hartmut Keil by using his definition of the American Dream with a lot of its beliefs and convictions that are substantial parts of it: "Individual success, advancement, materialism, personal success, neighborliness, naturalness, individuality, freedom, equality, equal opportunity, search for identity, national purpose, American consciousness, democratic dream, dream of paradise (...), moving force, liberation of humanity, world′s salvation";2 but he comes to the conclusion that there is not the possibility of a precise definition in case one does not want to list nearly every aspect of "American society".

Still, the fundamental values and virtues that build the basis and are the core function of the American Dream, are the main part of American political rhetoric. The metaphor of the American Dream has always been used by being glorified by politians in their speeches, and mostly with the promise of fulfilment soon after the elections in case it was a nomination speech. Therefore the

^{1 Freese, Peter: America. Dream or Nightmare? Reflections on a Composite Image, Essen 1990, page 68.
2 As said in : Keil, Hartmut : Die Funktion des ,,American Dream" in der amerikanischen Gesellschaft, München 1998, page 4f.}

1

American Dream seems to have a realistic side, it is not only a vision or a utopia when presidential candidates and presidents talk about its fulfilment. Since the promise of fulfilment is made ever since this subject has played a major role in political speeches, it is a dream which can and ­ referring to the politicians′ promises ­ will come true.

One can discover something concrete and important: even though the American Dream may sound "vague and grandiose"3 in all its values and beliefs, it - and the promise of it - actually means something to the Americans. In "Reviving the American Dream", Alice M. Rivlin tries a definition by considering it from the political perspective: from this view the American Dream means an "economy in which people who work hard can get ahead and each new generation lives better than the last one", it means a "democratic political system in which most people feel they can affect public decisions and elect officials who speak for them".3 The Dream gets another dimension through Rivlin′s definition: it is used as a central theme in political speeches because the dream itself has a political content. The incredible importance to the American people results from the connection of both personal and political aspects the American Dream comprises.

Although there might be a "history of dreams about America, and of dreams in America",4 it seems as if there is not such a thing as the one American Dream which everyone in the United States seems to share. Every American must have a personal relationship to this special dream, otherwise it would not have been chosen for most acceptance and inaugural speeches.

In this essay two speeches referring to the American Dream will be analyzed: Jimmy Carter′s inaugural address and Carter′s successor Ronald Reagan′s

^{3 Rivlin, Alice M.: Reviving the American Dream. The Economy, the States and the Federal Government, Washington, D.C. 1992, page 1.
4 Madden, David (edit.): American Dreams, American Nightmares, London & Amsterdam 1970, page 16.}

2

acceptance speech. Both speeches will be elucidated under the aspects of the specific historical contexts and their meaning, i.e. their audiences; and under the aspect of the use of rhetorical devices to either create an image of oneself to the public or to convince the audience.

At last there will be a short comparison of both speeches: how does each speaker refer to the American Dream and how do they present it? In which way do they affirm its fulfilment? Which influence has the fact they spoke to two different audiences?

II. President Carter′s Inaugural Address
2.1. The person Carter

Jimmy Carter, born 1924 as James Earl Carter, Jr, entered state politics in 1962 after seven years′ service as a naval officer. He announced his candidacy for President in 1974. After a two-year campaign he was nominated at the Democratic Convention. Back then, the Watergate scandal was still in everyone′s minds, and it is often said that the fact he was an outsider against nationally better-known politicians, was having the advantage of him. In the following excerpt of his inaugural speech the values and virtues of the American Dream will be highly regarded. Then a closer look at the creation of an image to the public will follow because this speech did not have the function to convince voters ever since he was already elected. This is an important factor in comparison to Ronald Reagan′s speech. Both speeches will be analyzed in a linked comparison in IV.

3

2.2. Inaugural Address of President Jimmy Carter: January 20, 1977

(...)

1 Here before me is the Bible used in the inauguration of our first

2 President, in 1789, and I have just taken the oath of office on the

3 Bible my mother gave me a few years ago, opened to a timeless

4 admonition from the ancient prophet Micah:

5 "He hath showed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the

6 Lord require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to

7 walk humbly with thy God." (Micah 6:8)

8 This inauguration ceremony marks a new beginning, a new

9 dedication within our Government, and a new spirit among us all.

10 A President may sense and proclaim that new spirit, but only a

11 people can provide it. Two centuries ago our Nation′s birth was a

12 milestone in the long quest for freedom, but the bold and brilliant

13 dream which excited the founders of this Nation still awaits its

14 consummation. I have no new dream to set forth today, but rather

15 urge a fresh faith in the old dream.

16 Ours was the first society openly to define itself in terms of both

17 spirituality and of human liberty. It is that unique self-definition

18 which has given us an exceptional appeal, but it also imposes on

19 us a special obligation, to take on those moral duties which, when

20 assumed, seem invariably to be in our own best interests.

21 You have given me a great responsibility--to stay close to you, to

22 be worthy of you, and to exemplify what you are. Let us create

23 together a new national spirit of unity and trust. Your strength can

24 compensate for my weakness, and your wisdom can help to

25 minimize my mistakes.

26 Let us learn together and laugh together and work together and

27 pray together, confident that in the end we will triumph together in

28 the right.

29 The American dream endures. We must once again have full faith

30 in our country -- and in one another. I believe America can be

31 better. We can be even stronger than before. (...)

32 We have already found a high degree of personal liberty, and we

33 are now struggling to enhance equality of opportunity. Our

4