Tony Kushner′s "Angel in America" - A Jewish American Epic

by: Sonja Richter

Content

I. Introduction page 3-4

II. Tony Kushner’s diverse Jewish Characters page 4

i. The Old Meets the New World: The Rabbi, Sarah and Louis Ironson page 5-8
ii. The Real Meets the Fictitious World: Roy M. Cohn (1927-1986) and Ethel Greenglass Rosenberg (1915-1953) page 8-10

III. Tony Kushner’s Angels page 11-12

IV. Bibliography page 13

I. Introduction

Much has been written about the homosexual and political playwright Tony Kushner. Interestingly, not so much has been said about his Jewish background and its impact on his dramatic work. Especially, his most acknowledged play ‘Angels in America – A Gay Fantasia on National Themes,’ which is mainly set in New York City “this strange place, in the melting pot where nothing melted”¹ as Rabbi Isidor Chemelwitz observes in the first scene of ‘Millennium Approaches,’ is highly concerned with Judaism in general and American Jewry in particular. Naturally, different readings of Tony Kushner’s two-part play are possible. Nevertheless, it is crucial to reveal and analyze the importance of the Jewish tone and setting in ‘Angels in America’ to fully understand Kushner’s complex work.

The play is set in the mid-nineteen-eighties with an epilogue located in 1990. Even though the play takes on epic dimensions with its different settings, a time frame of at least five months, and its various characters, the story nevertheless concentrates mainly on seven protagonists throughout both parts of the play. These characters are Prior Walter, a gay man suffering from AIDS, Joe Pitt, a Mormon discovering that he is gay, Harper Pitt, Joe’s wife suffering from depression, Hannah Pitt, Joe’s mother from Salt Lake City, who does not act according to cliché, Belize, an African American former drag queen and former lover of Prior, Roy Cohn, based on the real Jewish lawyer, who denies being gay and having AIDS, and Louis Ironson, Prior’s boyfriend and grandson of Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe. Kushner’s round characters bring about several main topics to this rich play addressing issues of race, class, gender, sexuality and politics in America duri ng the conservative Reagan Era. James Fisher wrote that “Kushner presents this America as a place where present, past, and future intersect in a blur of reality, fantasy, and guardedly hopeful imagination. […] [Thus] ‘Angels’ presents the mid-1980s as a critical transitional period in the history of the nation in which complicated questions about the future of American society are raised.”² One major topic of the play is the AIDS pandemic, which hit the liberated gay movement in the 1980s and changed their attitudes and lifestyles tremendously. Above all, Kushner picks out the topic of religion and traditional heritage in our secular, modern world as one of his central themes. As Hilary de Vries wrote in her Chicago Tribune critique, “Kushner credits much of his interest in religion to his family background as part of the little known but thriving Jewish community in [Lake Charles] Louisiana.”³

When Kushner moved to New York City in 1974, the Jewish population of the city was over one million making it the largest Jewish community in the world. Even though “Kushner struggles with an ambivalence toward Judaism due to homophobic traditions within his faith,”⁴ as James Fisher stated, he nevertheless strongly connects to his own Eastern European roots. Kushner’s ambivalence is that of American Jewry in general, being torn between the modern, secular society and historical ties to ethnic and religious identity.⁵ This dilemma is put forward through the play’s fine-nuanced Jewish characters. Furthermore, the play circles around general religious allegories, which origins can be traced back to writings of Judaism, such as the Old Testament and the Kabbalah, as well as to Christian traditions.

II. Tony Kushner’s diverse Jewish Characters

Five Jewish characters play a significant role in Kushner’s play giving it its Jewish tone: Louis Ironson, an intellectual, secular, third-generation New York immigrant, Sarah Ironson, Louis grandmother from Eastern Europe speaking mostly Yiddish, the orthodox Rabbi Isidor Chemelwitz with a heavy Eastern European accent, Roy M. Cohn, an anti-Semitic, self-loathing Jew, and Ethel Rosenberg, the historical figure associated with Communism and espionage. Even though, these figures seem rather stereotypical at first sight, Kushner manages to display them as round, diverse characters in the course of the play. As Alisa Solomon has observed in her essay ‘Wrestling with Angels,’ “Kushner calls forth self-conscious Jewish types precisely to undo them.”⁶ He “undoes” these familiar types by challenging stereotypical behavior and displaying contradictions within his characters, thus creating “real” individuals.

II.i. The Old Meets the New World: The Rabbi, Sarah and Louis Ironson

[...]

1 Tony Kushner, Angels in America – A Gay Fantasia on National Themes, Theatre Communications Group, Inc., New York, 1995, p. 16.

2 James Fisher, The Theater of Tony Kushner – Living Past Hope, Routledge, New York, 2002, p. 2.

3 Hilary de Vries, “A Gay Epic,” in: Chicago Tribune – The Arts, April 25, 1993, pp. 6-7. Taken from: James P. Draper (ed.), Contemporary Literary Criticism – Yearbook 1993, Vol. 81, Gale Research Inc., Detroit, 1994, p. 208.

4 James Fisher, The Theater of Tony Kushner, 2002, pp. 10-11.

5 For a closer reading on American Jewry see: Catherine L. Albanese, America – Religions and Religion, 2nd edition, Wadsworth, Inc., Belmont, California, 1992, p. 55.

6 Alisa Solomon, Wrestling with Angels: A Jewish Fantasia, in: Deborah R. Geis and Steven Kruger (eds.), Approaching the Millennium – Essays on Angels in America, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, 1997, p. 126