Comparison of legal and illegal Markets - in Relation to the Organized Crime

8EFPISJGSRXIRX 4EKI

-RXVSHYGXMSR

8LI0IKEPERH-PPIKEP1EVOIXMR7GSTI (MJJIVIRGIWFIX[IIR1EVOIXWXLIMV)RXVITVIRIYVWERH

4IVWTIGXMZIXLIQSHIVR-PPIKEP)GSRSQ]7]WXIQ'EQSVVE 6IJIVIRGIW

-RXVSHYGXMSR

'MKEVIXXIWWQYKKPMRKKEQFPMRKTVSWXMXYXMSR[EWXIHMWTSWEPI\XSVXMSRXE\HSHKMRKERH

HVYK WIPPMRK WSYRHW PMOI X]TMGEPP] GLEVEGXIVMWXMGW JSV SVKERM^IH GVMQI PMOI XLI 7MGMPMER

1EJME -XdW GPIEV XLEX XLIWI eFVERGLIWf JEPP EYXSQEXMGEPP] MRXS XLI LERHW SJ SVKERM^IH GVMQIFIGEYWIXLI]LEZIRSXLMRKXSHS[MXLPIKEPMX]ERHJEMVTPE]MRQSHIVRWXEXI&YX MXdWEPWSGPIEVXLEXMPPIKEPQEVOIXWI\MWXERHXLEXXLI][SVOZIV]IJJMGMIRXERHTVSJMXEFPI *SVI\EQTPIXLI[SVPH[MHIHVYKXVEJJMGEGLMIZIHEZEVMSYWZSPYQISJGEXS FMPPMSR97 IEGL ]IEV 7GLRIMHIV 8LEXdWQSVI QSRI] YWIHJSV HVYKWXLER JSV TYFPMGVIWIEVGLMRXLI9RMXIH7XEXIW7S[IGEREWWYQIXLEXMPPIKEPQEVOIXWLEZIEFEWMW MRWYTTP]ERHHIQERHERHXLI]EVIMQTSVXERXERHTVIWIRXMRIZIV]IGSRSQ] 3RXLISXLIVWMHIXLIVIMWEKIRIVEPPMEFMPMX]XSTYVIGETMXEPMWQMRIZIV]IGSRSQ]g

PIKEP ERH MPPIKEP 8LMW QIER XLEX IRXVITVIRIYVW EVI WXVSRKIV GSRJVSRXIH F] FYWMRIWW

GSQTIXMXMSRGLERKMRKTSPMXMGWERHPSGEXMSRWXLITLIRSQIRSRSJKPSFEPM^EXMSRERHJEWX

GLERKMRK XVEHI GSRHMXMSRW IZIV][LIVI 8LI QEMR XEVKIX MW WXMPP XLI WEQI LEZMRK PS[

GSWXWEWTSWWMFPIERHEQE\MQYQSJTVSJMXXSWYVZMZI 8LMW TETIV [ERXW XS WLS[ XLI HMJJIVIRX XIVQW ERH QIXLSHW SJ PIKEP ERH MPPIKEP QEVOIXWERHXLIMVIRXVITVIRIYVWIWTIGMEPP]XLISVKERM^IHGVMQI-XEPWSWLS[WXLEXPIKEP ERHMPPIKEPEGXMZMXMIWTEVXMGYPEVP]SZIVPET*SVI\EQTPIMPPIKEPGETMXEPGERFIVIMRZIWXIH

MRXSPIKEPFYWMRIWWFYX EPWS PIKEP FYWMRIWW GERGSSTIVEXI [MXLMPPIKEP EGXMZMXMIW -XLMRO

EFSYX XE\ HSHKMRK GSVVYTXMSR QSRSTSPM^MRK ERH EPWS XLI YWI SJ ZMSPIRGI QSRI]

PEYRHIVMRK ERH QYPXMQMPPMSR FVMFIW XS XEOI XLI IGSRSQMGEP PIEH 8LI TYVTSWI MW XS

GSRWMHIV JEGXW IQTMVMGEP JMRHMRKW ERH GSLIVIRGIW JVSQ VIPIZERX PMXIVEXYVI XS KMZI E

TVSFPIQEXMGSZIVZMI[ERHXSEJJMVQXLEXMPPIKEPQEVOIXWEVIETEVXSJXLIIZIV]IGSRSQ] -REHZERGIMXdWWXMPPXSFIGPEVMJMIH[LEXQEOIWXLIHMJJIVIRGIFIX[IIRPIKEPERHMPPIKEP

QEVOIXWERH[ILEZIXSJMRHSYX[LEXWMQMPEVMXMIWXLI]LEZI1SVISZIV[I[MPPEWOLS[ HMJJIVIRXXLIWIEGXSVWSJFSXLQEVOIXWEVIERH[LEXHMJJIVIRXQIXLSHWXLI]YWI 4VMQEV]XLITETIVEREP]^IWXLIWXVYGXYVISJPIKEPERHMPPIKEPQEVOIXW8LIJSGYWMWWIX XSXLISVKERM^EXMSRXLITEVXMGMTEXSVWERHMRJPYIRGMRKJEGXSVWSJXLIWIQEVOIXW%JXIVXLEX

- [MPP [SVO SYX HMJJIVIRGIW ERH WMQMPEVMXMIW XS GSQTEVI XLIQ 8LI VIWYPXW [MPP FI

SYXPMRIH ERH EJXIV[EVHW HMWGYWWIH F] JSGYWMRK XLI QSHIVR SVKERM^IH GVMQI -XdW Q]

GSRGIVR XS WLS[ XLEX MPPIKEP QEVOIXW EVI SQRMTVIWIRX MR IGSRSQ] [IPJEVI ERH XLEX

SVKERM^IHGVMQIHMJJYWIWXLIQMRXSPIKEPQEVOIXW8LITETIVGPSWIW[MXLERI\EQTPISJ XLI'EQSVVE7]RHMGEXIERHKMZIW ETIVWTIGXMZISJQSHIVRMPPIKEPFYWMRIWWMREGVMXMGEP SYXZMI[

8LI0IKEPERH-PPIKEP1EVOIXMR7GSTI

8LIPIKEP QEVOIXMRGSQQSR

-RXLIFVSEHIWXWIRWIEQEVOIXMWHIWGVMFIHEWEKEXLIVMRKTPEGIJSVTISTPIdWWYTTP]ERH HIQERH8LIVIJSVIEQEVOIXSJJIVERHVIUYIWXHMJJIVIRXKSSHWERHWIVZMGIWERHHIJMRIE

TVMGI 8LI WYTTPMIVW [ERXIH XS WIPP XLIMV KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW [MXL E LMKL TVSJMX EW

TSWWMFPI&YXXLI]LEZIXSEGGITXFEWMGIGSRSQ]VYPIW8LIUYERXMX]SJEKSSHKVS[WMJ EPWSXLITVMGIMWKVS[MRK-JXLIWYTTPMIVWI\TIGXEPS[IVTVMGIJSVXLIMVKSSHWXLI][MPP EPWSVIHYGIMXWUYERXMX],IVIIZIV]WYTTPMIV[ERXIHXLILMKLIWXTVSJMXERHWSXLI]LEZI EWXVSRKGSQTIXMXMSRSRXLIQEVOIXW8LI]LEZIXLISTXMSRXSTVSHYGIQSVIIJJMGMIRXERH [MXLPS[IVGSWXWEWXLIMVGSQTIXMXMSR8LEXdWXLIFYWMRIWWGSQTIXMXMSR 3R XLI SXLIV WMHI XLIVI EVI XLI GYWXSQIVW 8LI] [ERX WEXMWJ] XLIMV MRHMZMHYEP RIIHW ERHXLEXd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dWXLIFEWMGJSVIZIV] IGSRSQ]ERH[IPJEVIWXEXI 8SOIITEQEVOIX[SVOMRKMXdWMQTSVXERXXSLEZIVYPIWERHRSVQWJSVXLIMVYWIVW8LI XVEHISREQEVOIXHITIRHWSRMRWXMXYXMSRW[LMGLHIJMRIXLIGLEVEGXIVSJXLIWIQEVOIXW-R

ER IGSRSQ] ZEVMSYW HIGMWMSRW ERH MRXIVEGXMSRW EVI GSSVHMREXIH F] VYPIW SJ XLIWI

QEVOIXW-XQEXXIVWXLEXMRWIGYVITVMGIWGSQTIXMXMSRFYWMRIWWPEGOSJMRJSVQEXMSRdWERH QMWWMRKVITYXEXMSRgWSGEPPIHXVERWEGXMSRWGSWXWgEVIRIYXVEPM^IHEXQSWX8LEXdWXLINSF

SJXLIMRWXMXYXMSRWXSWIXQEVOIXVYPIWERHQEOIXVEHIWIGYVIERHJEMVJSVIZIV]SRI7XEXI [MXLMXWMRWXMXYXMSRWMWXLIJEGXSVSJJYRHEQIRXEPQIERMRK8LIJYRGXMSRSJXLIWXEXIMWXS LSPHYTFEWMGVYPIWERHPE[WPMOIXLITVIZIRXMSRSJZMSPIRGIERHGLIEXMRKTVSXIGXMSRSJ S[RIVWLMT TVSXIGXMSR SJ JVIIHSQ SJ GSRXVEGX ERH XLI EHLIVIRGI SJ ETTPMGEFPI PE[ )ZIV]FSH] NSMRMRK E QEVOIX LEZI XS FI FSYRH F] XLIWI VYPIW 9WIVW GER I\TVIWW XLIMV ZEVMSYWMRHMZMHYEPTSWWMFMPMXMIWTVIJIVIRGIWVMWOWERHMRXIVIWXWMRWIGYVI%WWYVERGISJE

QEVOIX MW EW [IPP JYVXLIVIH F] X]TMGEP GSRXVEGXW WXERHEVHM^IH GYVVIRG] EHZMWMRK

WIVZMGIWKYEVERXIIWMRWYVERGIWXVEHIQEVOWERHWSSR7GLžPPIVT -RWLSVX

XLIWI EVI XLI QEMR JYRGXMSRW XS OIIT E PIKEP QEVOIX [SVOMRK ERH XS VIHYGI ZEVMSYW

XVERWEGXMSRGSWXW

8LIMPPIKEPQEVOIX

,S[IZIVXLI MPPIKEP QEVOIXGER FIHIJMRIHEWE TPEGISJGSRWXERXP] I\GLERKIFIX[IIR

KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIW FYX MR GSRXVEWX XS XLI PIKEP QEVOIX LIVI EVI TVSHYGXMSR WEPIW ERH

GSRWYQI WXVMGXP] JSVFMHHIR F] PE[ XS TVSXIGX WXEXI [IPJEVI ERH XS QEMRXEMR LYQERWd

HMKRMX] (VYKW [IETSRW WI\YEP WPEZIV] WQYKKPMRK QSRI] PEYRHIVMRK EVI XLIVIJSVI X]TMGEP MPPIKEP QEVOIXW 8LI SVMKMRW SJ MPPIKEP QEVOIXW EVI QSWXP] EVXMJMGMEP 8LI] KVS[

TEVEPPIP XSQSHIVR[IPJEVIWXEXIW ERHGER FIWIIR EW VIWTSRWI XSQYPXMREXMSREPXVIEXMIW

JSV LYQER VMKLXW XLI MRXIVREXMSREP GSRZIRXMSR EKEMRWX HVYKW WPEZIV] ERH [IETSR

HIEPMRK8LIGSRWMWXMRKRIX[SVOSJPE[WVIKMQIRXEXMSRERHGVMQIJMKLXMRKLEWSGGYVVIH ELMKLVMWMRKSJTVSJMXMRMPPIKEPQEVOIXW%RHWSWQYKKPMRKKEQFPMRKI\XSVXMSRERHWS

SR FIGEQI TPEGIW SJ [SVO JSV XLSYWERHW SJ TISTPI 8LMW eMRHYWXV]f GER FI REQIH EW

[IPJEVIWXEXISJXLIWXEXIPIWW7EZMERST 8LIWIQEVOIXWEVIRSRGSRXVSPPEFPI

F] WXEXI ERH XLIMV TVSXEKSRMWXW LEZI HIZIPSTIH S[R VYPIW ERH WXVYGXYVIW -PPIKEP IGSRSQMIWEVIGLEVEGXIVM^IHF]ERI\TERWISJXVEHIMHIRXMJMGEXMSR8LIMVTVSXEKSRMWXWEVI ER\MSYW XS I\GLERKI IPIQIRXW SJ TYFPMG PMJI MRXS XVEHEFPI KSSHW 8LEXdW LYQER PMJI

HYXMIW ERH EGXMZMXMIW SJ EHQMRMWXVEXMZI FSHMIW QSVEP TVMRGMTPIW EW [IPP EW WXEFMPMX] SJ

IGSRSQMG TSPMXMGW ERH TYFPMG WEJIX] %RH FIWMHI XLI IGSRSQMGEP GEPGYPEXMSR TSPMXMGEP

QERMTYPEXMSR ERH TYVI ZMSPIRGI EVI X]TMGEP JSV XLI MPPIKEP IRXVITVIRIYVW -R WSQI

PMXIVEXYVIXLIMPPIKEP QEVOIXWEVI GLEVEGXIVM^IH [MXLSTIVEXMSRW MRXLIYRHIVKVSYRH ERH

WSQIXMQIWQ]WXIVMSYWERHYRGSRXVSPPIHPSKMGW&YXMRVIEPMX]XLI]EVIWYFNIGXXSVEXMSREP

IGSRSQMGXLMROMRK -R GSQQSRXS XLIPIKEPQEVOIX XLIVI EVI EPWS WYTTP] ERHHIQERH

FVSOIVW ERH HMWXVMFYXSVW TVMGIW GYWXSQIVW FSSOW ERH TVSJMXW *YVXLIVQSVI XLI

IRXVITVIRIYVWSJMPPIKEPQEVOIXWLEZIXLIWEQIFEWMGQSXMZEXMSRPMOIXLITEVXMGMTEXSVWSJ PIKEPQEVOIXWXLIQE\MQYQTSWWMFPITVSJMXERHVIMRZIWXMKEXMSR &YX MR WGSTI HMJJIVIRGIW FIX[IIR FSXL QEVOIXW FIGSQI I\TPMGMX 8S JMKYVI SYX IWWIRXMEPHMJJIVIRGIWFIX[IIRXLI QEVOIXW MXdWRS[ RIGIWWEV]XS FVMRKXLITEVXMGMTEXSVW SJXLIQMRXSTPE]-XdWMQTSVXERXXSLMKLPMKLXXLEXMPPIKEPQEVOIXWQYWXEP[E]WFIWIIRMR PMROEKIXSXLISVKERM^IHGVMQI8LEXdWVIPIZERXFIGEYWISJXLIWXVYGXYVIXLIWYWXEMRMRK ERHXLIVIMRZIWXMKEXMRKSJMPPIKEPIGSRSQMIW8LISVKERMWIHGVMQILEWEWXVSRKMRJPYIRGI

XS MPPIKEP QEVOIXW ERH EVI UYMX HMJJIVIRX XLER RSVQEP GVMQI [MXLSYX ER] PMROEKI XS MX

7GLIPPMRKTJ 8LMWTETIVLEWMXWJSGYWSRXLISVKERMWIHGVMQI8LIRI\X GLETXIVKSIWHIITIVMRXSXLIQEXIVMEPERHGSRWMHIVWHMJJIVIRXQIXLSHWERHSVKERMWEXMSRW SJXLIQEVOIXWERHXLIMVTEVXMGMTEXSVW

(MJJIVIRGIW FIX[IIR 1EVOIXW XLIMV )RXVITVIRIYVW ERH XLI -RJPYIRGI SJ

3VKERM^IH'VMQIMR)GSRSQ]

&IWMHIXLIGSQTEVMWSRSJPIKEPERHMPPIKEPQEVOIXMXdWZIV]MRXIVIWXMRKXSGSQTEVIXLIMV TEVXMGMTEXSVW3JGSYVWIXLIGYWXSQIVWEVIEPQSWXXLIWEQIMRFSXLQEVOIXW8LI]LEZI EGIVXEMRMRGSQIERHMRHMZMHYEP[ERXW8SWEXMWJ]XLIMV[ERXWXLI]GERYWIFSXLQEVOIXW

HITIRHMRK SR [LEX XLI] RIIH %RH XLI] [MPP EP[E]W TVIJIV XLI PS[IWX GSWXW JSV XLIMV

[ERXW 7S ]SY GER SRP] EGGYWI XLIMV MQQSVEP FILEZMSYV ERH GSRWYQMRK SJ KSSHW ERH WIVZMGIWJVSQERMPPIKEPQEVOIXFIGEYWIXLIMV[ERXWEJJIGXXLIMPPIKEPWYTTP] %R][E]MXQEOIWQSVIWIRWIXSGSQTEVIXLIWYTTP]WMHISJXLIQEVOIXWFIGEYWIXLI] GSRWXVYGXWYTTP]ERHSVKERM^IMX8LIIRXVITVIRIYVWLEZIEP[E]WEQEMRTVSFPIQ0S[

GSWXW EW TSWWMFPI ERH E QE\MQYQ TVSJMX &YX MR XLEX GEWI IRXVITVIRIYVW EVI EPWS

GSRJVSRXIHF]ZEVMSYWTVSFPIQW&IWMHIX]TMGEPTVSFPIQWSJQEVOIXQEREKIQIRXXLIVI

EVI HMJJIVIRX MRJPYIRGMRK ZEVMEFPIW PMOI GIVXEMR KSZIVRQIRX ERH TSPMXMG EHNYWXQIRXW

FYWMRIWWGSQTIXMXMSRELYKIRYQFIVSJXVEHMRKRIX[SVOWXLITLIRSQIRSRSJQSHIVR KPSFEPM^EXMSR HMJJIVIRX PSGEXMSRW TVIWWYVI KVSYTW HMJJIVIRX XVEHI GLEMRW ERH WS SR 'SRWIUYIRXP]IRXVITVIRIYVWLEZIXSJYPJMPQER]XEWOWXSLSPHXLIMVQEVOIXTSWMXMSR )RXVITVIRIYVWSJXLIPIKEPQEVOIXWEGXMRGSRHMXMSRWQEHIERHEHQMRMWXIVIHF]WXEXI

MRWXMXYXMSRW 8LI] LEZI VMKLXW ERH HYXMIW LEZI XS TE] XE\IW ERH WYTTSVX WXEXI ERH

TYFPMG [IPJEVI -XdW JSVFMHHIR XSQSRSTSPM^ISVXSGVIEXI GEVXIPW8LIWEQIETTPMIWXS

YRJEMVGSQTIXMXMSRERH GLIEXMRK8LMWWSYRHWJERXEWXMGJSVPIKEPFYWMRIWW ERHZIV]JEMV

JSV E PIKEP QEVOIX FYX MR VIEPMX] MXdW UYMX HMJJIVIRX 0IKEP IRXVITVIRIYVW TEVXMGYPEVP]

SFXEMR ER EHZERXEKI F] GLIEXMRK - XLMRO EFSYX GSVVYTXMSR MR PIEHMRK XVEHI ERH

EHQMRMWXVEXMZI TSWMXMSRW IJJSVXW XS GEVXIPM^I MRHYWXVMEP MRZIWXMKEXMSR XE\ HSHKMRK ERH

GSRRIGXMSRW XS ZEVMSYW TVIWWYVI KVSYTW 4EVXMGYPEV IRXVITVIRIYVW HVMZI SR XLI VE^SVdW

IHKISJPIKEPMX]ERHSJXIRTYFPMGWGERHEPWEVIXLIVIWYPXW-KYIWWXLIWIMPPIKEPSTIVEXMSRW

VIWYPXW JVSQ E WQEPP QEVKMR SJ TVSJMX QSVI HMJJMGYPX XVEHI ERH WXVSRKIV GSQTIXMXMSR

[SVPH [MHI 7SQIXMQIW XLIWI IRXVITVIRIYVW EVI JSVGIH XS EGX MPPIKEP &YX EX XLMW TSMRX WXEXIMRWXMXYXMSRWGERTYRMWLIGSRSQMGEPQMWFILEZMSYV 8LI WEQI TVSFPIQW ETTP] XS XLI SVKERM^IH GVMQI &YX MR GSRXVEWX XS XLI PIKEP IRXVITVIRIYVWEPPXLIMVEGXMRKMWMPPIKEPERHXLI]QYWXEWTMVIXSQSRSTSPM^IXLIMVeJMVQWf

XS LSPH XLI PIEHMRK QEVOIX TSWMXMSR 1SVISZIV XLIWI FYWMRIWWIW EVI YRHIV TIVQERIRX

TVIWWYVISJTYVIGETMXEPMWQSXLIVSTTSRIRXWERHWXEXIGVMQIJMKLXMRK%R]QMWXEOIWEVI VI[EVHIH [MXL IGSRSQMGEP ERH SJXIR TIVWSREP VYMRW 8LEXdW EPWS FIGEYWI SJ E QMWWMRK

MRWXMXYXMSR [LMGL GER GSRXVSP ERH VIKYPEXI XLIWI MPPIKEP QEVOIXW -R QER] MQTSVXERX

eFVERGLIWfSJXLIMPPIKEPQEVOIX[IGERJMRHMRXIVREPWXVEXMJMGEXMSRFIX[IIRX[SWIGXSVW

4VMQEV] XLI GSQTIXMXMSR WIGXSV GSRWMWXMRK SJ WQEPP ERH QMHHPI YRMXW RIX[SVOW

HIPMZIVMRK XLI GYWXSQIVW ERH XLI SPMKSTSP] WIGXSV [MXL E JI[ EQSYRXW SJ eJMVQWf

WYTTSVXMRK XLI GSQTIXMXMSR WIGXSV %VPEGGLM T J -R WGSTI WIZIVEP

HMJJIVIRGIW ERH ERSQEPMIW GER FI JMKYVIH SYX MR GSRXVEWX XS PIKEP QEVOIXW ERH

IRXVITVIRIYVW8LIVIMWXLII\MWXIRGISJQYPXMZEPYIHWYFYRMXWEWXVYGXYVMRKSJE1EJME PMOIGPERSVKERM^EXMSRERHEQMWWMRKMRWXMXYXMSRXSWIGYVIXLII\GLERKISJKSSHWERHXLI EFMHERGISJGSRXVEGXW *MVWX [I GER GSQTVILIRH XLEX XLI SPMKSTSP] WIGXSV SJ MPPIKEP QEVOIXW GSRWMWXW SJ

QYPXMZEPYIH WYFYRMXW [LMGL EVI EFPI XS GSQFMRI IGSRSQMGEP TSPMXMGEP ERH QMPMXEV]

VIWSYVGIW 1EJME ERH 1EJMEPMOI SVKERM^EXMSRW GER YWI XLIMV IGSRSQMGEP ERH ZMSPIRX

TS[IV XS MRJPYIRGI STTSRIRXW ERH XS QERMTYPEXI TSPMXMGEP EHQMRMWXVEXMSR EGGSVHMRK XS XLIMVMRXIVIWXWERHXSXEOIIGSRSQMGEPPIEHIVWLMT8LIVIJSVIXLITSP]ZEPIRXGLEVEGXIVSJ

MPPIKEP IRXVITVIRIYVWLMT RIIHW XVII XLMRKW GETMXEP ZMSPIRGI ERH XLI PEGO SJ WXEXI

EHQMRMWXVEXMSR &YX GETMXEP MW EPWS MQTSVXERX XS IRXIV QSVI TVSPMJMGEPP] MPPIKEP QEVOIXW

ERH SJ GSYVWI PIKEP QEVOIXW XSS -R XLMW [E] MPPIKEP IRXVITVIRIYVW EVI WYFNIGX XS

IGSRSQMGVYPIW PMOIIZIV]SRI IPWI 8LI] LEZI XS[SVOLMKLIJJMGMIRX IZIRMXdW LEVHIV

VS[IVMXWTYVIGETMXEPMWQ7EZMERSTJ 7IGSRH MPPIKEP QEVOIXW LEZI E LMKL EQSYRX SJ XVERWEGXMSR GSWXW 8LI RIGIWWMX] SJ QER]HIXSYVWGSVVYTXMSRWVMWOWERHEQSYRXSJEGXSVWQEOIWEKSSHWSVWIVZMGIWZIV] I\TERWMZI 3RP] 1EJMEPMOI SPMKSTSP] IRXVITVIRIYVW LEZI QSRIXEV] TS[IV ERH

VITYXEXMSR XS QEMRXEMR LYKI RIX[SVOW SJ MPPIKEP XVERWEGXMSRW 0S[IVMRK XLI XVERWEGXMSR

GSWXWKMZIWERIRXVITVIRIYVGSQTIXMXMZIEHZERXEKIWERHQEOIWLMQQSVITVSJMXEFPI8LI GMVGYQWXERGIXLEXXVERWEGXMSRWEVITVSGIWWIHQSVIIJJMGMIRXF]GPERWXLERMRFYVIEYGVEXMG W]WXIQWMWEPWSE X]TMGEP HMJJIVIRGIFIX[IIRPIKEP ERHMPPIKEPQEVOIXW 3TIVEXMRKYRMXW

SR MPPIKEP QEVOIXW YWIW SRP] TVMZMPIKIH TIVWSREP GSRXEGXW MR XLIMV MRXIVREP

GSQQYRMGEXMSRERHXVEHIEPPSGEXMSR8LIWIMPPIKEPRIX[SVOWEVIEFEWMGTVIVIUYMWMXIERH EJJIGXKYEVERXIIERHVITYXEXMSRJSVMPPIKEPXVEHI8LISTIVEXMRKVERKISJXLIWIRIX[SVOW MWZIV]SJXIRKPSFEPERHZIV]HIITVSYXIH8LI] GSRWMWXSJHIEPIVWWEPIWQIR[SVOIVW

HMWXVMFYXSVW FSSOIVW TVSHYGIVW XVERWTSVXIVW FYX EPWS GSVVYTXIH TSPMXMGMERW NYHMGMEV]

SJJMGIVWERHEPQSWXXLIPIEHIVWLMTMRJSVQSJEQEJMEPMOIGSVI%JI[QIQFIVWSJEGPER

GSRXVSP XLIWI RIX[SVOW ERH YWI SJXIR HMJJIVIRX [E]W XVSYKL MX -XdW WIPHSQ XS YWI SRI

[E]XLVSYKLERIX[SVOEWIGSRHXMQI8LIWIRIX[SVOWEVIXLIZIMRWSJMPPIKEPXVEHIERH WYWXEMRXLI[LSPIMPPIKEPIGSRSQ] 8LI XLMVH MRHMGEXSV SJ MPPIKEP IGSRSQMIW MW XLI EFWIRGI SJ E GSRXVSPPMRK MRWXMXYXMSR 8LI MPPIKEP eWSGMIX]f HSIW RSX ORS[ [VMXXIR VYPIW TSPMGI GSYVXW SV ePIKEPf GSRXVSP QIGLERMWQW-RXLMWMPPIKEPFYWMRIWWIWQMWXVYWXMWIZIV][LIVIERHMXdWZIV]MQTSVXERXXS

LEZI XVYWXJYP TISTPI *YVXLIVQSVI MPPIKEP XVEHI MW EP[E]W EGGSQTERMIH F] HMJJMGYPX

STIVEXMSRWFIX[IIRHMTPSQEG]XVEHIERHEVQIHGSRJPMGXW%VPEGGLMT &YX MRJEGXXLIWIMPPIKEPMRWXMXYXMSRWWYVZMZIHWYGGIWWJYPJSVGIRXYVMIWYRXMPXSHE]%RHXLI] EHETXIZIV]IGSRSQMGWSGMEPSVTSPMXMGEPGLERKMRKF]WEZMRKEQMRMQYQSJGSRXMRYMX] ERHFEWMGVITVSHYGXMSR

4IVWTIGXMZIXLIQSHIVR-PPIKEP)GSRSQ]7]WXIQ'EQSVVE

%W+MSZERRM*EPGSRIEJEQSYWERXMQEJMEEHZSGEXISRGIWEMHe8LIQEJMEGSQTEVIHXS

EPP SXLIV MRWXMXYXMSRW ERH XS XLI [LSPI WSGMIX] MW XLI QSWX JPI\MFPI EHETXEFPI ERH

TVEKQEXMGSVKERM^EXMSRIZIVI\MWXMRKMRXLI[SVPHf(SRRI %RH-KYIWWLI[EW VMKLX3VKERM^IHGVMQIERHMPPIKEPQEVOIXWEVIQSVIERETTEVEXYWXLEREWXVYGXYVI-XdWE W]WXIQMHIRXMGEPXSERIRSVQSYWIGSRSQ] 8LI 'EQSVVE W]RHMGEXI MW E KSSH I\EQTPI JSV XLI TVSKVIWWMZI MPPIKEP EGXMZMXMIW SJ

XSHE] 8LMW W]RHMGEXI WYTTPMIW XLI KPSFEP QEVOIX [MXL -XEPMER XI\XMPIW 8LIMV MRZIWXMRK

GETMXEP GSQIW JVSQ IWXEFPMWLIH HVYK QEVOIXW ERH [SVOIVW GEQI JVSQ XLI LMKL

YRIQTPS]IHFEGOGSYRXV]SJ2IETIP8LIW]WXIQ'EQSVVEXEOIWLSPHMREPPFVERGLIWSJ XI\XMPIWLSSWERHPIEXLIVMRHYWXVMIWERHWSXLI][LIVIEFPIXSTVSHYGIWLMVXWNEGOIXW ERHWLSSW[MXLUYEPMX]ERHQEOMRKIUYEPXSXLIFMKPIKEPJEWLMSRFVERHW8LI]TVSHYGI EYXLIRXMGJEOIWFVERHIHMX[MXLTSTYPEV-XEPMERJEWLMSRPEFIPWERHQM\IHEYXLIRXMGERH

GSYRXIVJIMX TVSHYGXW ;MXL XLMW QIXLSH XLI] GER WIPP IZIV]XLMRK XS ER EXEVEGXMG TVMGI

[SVPH[MHI 8LIMV FYWMRIWW MW SVKERMWIH F] JMRIP] [SZIR RIX[SVOW GSRWMWXMRK SJ TVSHYGXMSRXVERWTSVXHMWXVMFYXSVWERHJEWLMSRQEVOIXWYTXSXLIWXVIIXZIRHSVWMRIZIV] GSYRXV]MRXLI[SVPH8LSYWERHWTVSJMXJVSQXLIWIMPPIKEPQEVOIXW[LMGLI\MWXWTEVEPPIP

XS XLI PIKEP SRIW &YX XLI PIKEP JMVQW LEZIRdX EGGYWIH XLMW GSYRXIVJIMXMRK MRHYWXV] 3R

XLIGSRXVEV]XLIPIKEPJMVQWTVSJMXJVSQXLIMQEKIFYMPHMRKFIGEYWIXLIMVPEXIWXTVSHYGXW [IVI EJJSVHEFPI JSV XLI QSWX TISTPI 3R XLI SXLIV WMHI XLI W]WXIQ QEJME MW MR XLI

TSWMXMSR XS FPSGOEHI GLIET [SVOJSVGI ERH XS SFWXVYGX PIKEP JMVQW FYWMRIWW 7EZMERS

TJ 7YQQEVMWMRK XLIWI JEGXW EJJMVQ +MSZERRM *EPGSRIdW WXEXIQIRX 1SHIVR SVKERMWIH GVMQIPMOIXLI'EQSVVEMWSRISJXLIJPI\MFPIEHETXEFPIERHTVEKQEXMGW]WXIQWMR[SVPH 8LI]EHNYWXTIVJIGXP]XSXLI[SVPHIGSRSQ]ERHQM\IHPIKEPERHMPPIKEPFYWMRIWW8LIMV

FSWWIW ERH JEQMPMIW EGX PMOI NSMRX ZIRXYVIW [LMGL EVI EPQSWX MR XLI TSWMXMSR XS

MRGSVTSVEXISVHMWQMWWRI[GPERWERHWXVYGXYVIW7SXLI]GERGVIEXIJPI\MFPIWXVEXIKMIWXS SGGYT]RI[QEVOIXWEX[MPP8LIVIJSVIQSHIVRSVKERMWIHGVMQIGERFIGSQTEVIHEXFIWX [MXL QYPXMREXMSREP IRXIVTVMWIW -XdW WMQMPEV XS XLIMV MRXVEJMVQ XVEHI JEWX GMVGYPEXMSR SJ

QSRI] GSRXVSPPMRK ZEVMSYW PSGEXMSRW ERH XLI TS[IV XS QEOI HIGMWMSRW [MXLSYX ER] TSPMXMGEPEHQMRMWXVEXMSR+PSFEPM^EXMSRERHMRXIVRIXXVEHIEPWSIEWIHMPPIKEPEGXMZMXMIWERH KMZIWSVKERMWIHGVMQIERI[UYEPMX] -XVIQEMRWXSFIWIIRMJTSPMXMGWWSGMIXMIWERHPIKEPFYWMRIWWEVIEFPIXSEGXIJJIXIP]

EKEMRWX SVKERMWIH GVMQI ERH XLIMV MPPIKEP QEVOIXW -XdW RSX SRP] E PSGEP SV REXMSREP

TVSFPIQEXMG8LISVKERMWIHGVMQIMWKPSFEPERHQYWXFIWIIREWETEVXSJ[LSPIKPSFEP IGSRSQ]ERHREXMSREP[IPJEVI-XdWRIIHPIWWXSWE]XLEXMPPIKEPIGSRSQMIWWYTTSVXFVSEH PIZIPWSJXLITSTYPEXMSR[MXL[SVOERHEJJSVHEFPIKSSHW(IJMRMXIP]MPPIKEPSVKERMWEXMSRW EVIXLITYTTIXQEWXIVWSJMPPIKEPQEVOIXWERHXLI][SVOLMKLIJJMGMIRXTEVEPPIPXSPIKEP

IRXVITVIRIYVW -R JYVXLIV VIWIEVGLIW MX [SYPH FI MRXIVIWXMRK XS JMRH SYX LS[ MPPIKEP

IGSRSQMIW YRHIVQMRI REXMSREP [IPJEVI GSWXW ERH LS[ XLI] WYTTSVX EPP WSGMEP VEROW

[MXL PEFSYV ERH EJJSVHEFPI KSSHW &YX XLEXdW XLI NSF JSV SXLIV IGSRSQMG WSGMSPSKMGEP WXYHMIW

6IJIVIRGIW

› %PFIVW1MPPIV 2( 'SRWYQIV QMWFILEZMSYV [L] TISTPI FY] MPPMGMX KSSHW(IRXSR1'&9RMZIVWMX]4VIWWTT › %VPEGGLM41EJME&YWMRIWW 8LI1EJME)XLMGERHXLI7TMVMXSJ'ETMXEPWMQ 3\JSVH3\JSVH9RMZIVWMX]4VIWW › %VPEGGLM 4 1EJMSWI )XLMO YRH HIV +IMWX HIW /ETMXEPMWQYW *VEROJYVX1EMR'SSTIVEXMZI › &EYIV1,SKER,(EW0I\MOSRHIV;MVXWGLEJX&SRR&YRHIW^IRXVEPI JžVTSPMXMWGLI&MPHYRK › (SRRI:(*EPGSRI(MI&MSKVETLMIc0IFIRYRH8SHMQ/EQTJKIKIR HMI1EJME*VEROJYVX1EMR&IVPMR9PPWXIMR › (MGOM . 'SWE 2SWXVE % ,MWXSV] SJ XLI 7MGMPMER 1EJME 0SRHSR ,SHHIV ERH7XSYKLXSR › 7EZMERS 6 +SQSVVLE c 6IMWI MR HEW 6IMGL HIV 'EQSVVE 1žRGLIR ,ERWIV › 7GLIPPMRK8'e;LEXMWXLI&YWMRIWWSJ3VKERM^IH'VMQI#f-R7GLIPPMRK 8''LSMGIERH'SRWIUYRIGI'EQFVMHKI,EVZEVH9RMZIVWMX]4VIWW › 7GLRIMHIV * -PPIKEPI *MRER^XVERWEOXMSRIR 4ETIV EZEMPEFPI EX [[[IGSRNOYEX7GLRIMHIV-PPIKEPI*MRER^XVERWEOXMSRIRTHJ › 7GLžPPIV % c(MI MRWXMXYXMSRIPPIR :SVEYWWIX^YRKIR IMRIV QEVOX[MVXWGLEJXPMGLIR 3VHRYRKe -R :EYFIP 6 ERH &EVFMIV ,( ,ERHFYGL1EVOX[MVXWGLEJX7XYXXKEVX+žRXIV2IWOI › ;MRHMWGL 6 c)MRJšLVYRK MR HMI ;MVXWGLEJXW[MWWIRWGLEJXf .IRE 6IEHIV :SPOW[MVXWGLEJXPILVI