The purpose of this study is to replicate the associations between severity of childhood abuse and punitive behaviour, and Hostile-Helpless (HH) states-of-mind; and to assess the gender-dependent effect of childhood abuse severity on HH states-of-mind via punitive behaviour. A secondary data set of longitudinally studied adolescents and their mothers was used. The study used interview and interaction measures as well as information from the state’s protective services.
HH states-of-mind levels in late adolescence have been repeatedly linked to higher severity of abuse in childhood, and to higher levels of adolescent punitive behaviour. To our knowledge, whether the link between severity of childhood abuse and adolescent HH states-of-mind is mediated by punitive behaviour has not yet been explored. Due to gender likely having an effect on the link, the present study aims to investigate whether the link between severity of childhood abuse and HH states-of-mind via punitive behaviour differs depending on gender, so that the effect is significant for females, but not males.
HH states-of-mind are a form of an adolescent’s or adult’s current representations of childhood attachment experiences. 'Attachment' describes the bond between an infant and their primary caregiver, and plays an important role in an individual’s functioning from cradle to grave. Infants are predisposed to seek closeness to their attachment figures – usually their predominant caregiver – to increase their chances of survival. In this infant-caregiver relationship, the infant forms a sense of self, and whether they can trust, and rely on their caregiver.
A caregiver’s display of frightening or frightened behaviour, or other forms of disrupted affective communication towards the infant, prevents the functional purposes of the attachment system: establishing proximity to the caregiver and reducing fear in stressful situations. Such behaviour can form a disorganized attachment relationship between the caregiver and their child, where the child externalizes their disorganized attachment by showing contradictory approach-avoidance behaviours towards
their caregiver.
Furthermore, disorganized attachment experiences can have a negative impact on the development of autonomy, and individual identity in adolescence. Thus, they can have adverse influences on the adolescent’s transition into adulthood as well as leading the development of HH states-of-mind.
At a glance
- Secondary analysis of 109 participants from a longitudinal adolescent–mother dataset
- Uses data from Harvard University's Family Pathways Project
- Uses GPACS to assess videotaped adolescent–mother interactions
- 76 sources in the bibliography
- 2 figures and 4 tables
Table of Contents
Abstract
1. Introduction
1.1 Hostile-Helpless (HH) States-of-Mind
1.2 Severity of Early Childhood Abuse
1.3 GPACS Punitive-Behaviour
1.4 Gender Differences
1.5 Aims and Hypotheses
2. Methods
2.1 Participants
2.2 Procedure
2.3 Measures
2.3.1 GPACS Punitive Behaviour
2.3.2 Hostile-Helpless States-of-Mind on the AAI.
2.3.3 Overall Severity of Childhood Abuse
2.3.3.1 Traumatic Stress Schedule (TSS).
2.3.3.2 Childhood Traumatic Experiences Scale-Revised (CTES-R).
2.3.3.3 Conflict Tactics Scale – Second Version (CTS-2).
2.4 Analytical Strategy
3. Results
3.1 Descriptive Statistics
3.2 Correlations Between Study Variables
3.3 Differences Between Genders on Study Variables
3.4 Exploring the Potential Moderating Effect of Gender
3.5 Exploratory Analysis: Logistic Regression
4. Discussion
4.1 Limitations and Future Directions
4.2 Strengths
4.3 Implications
4.4 Conclusion
Aims and Topics
This study examines associations between the severity of childhood abuse, punitive behaviour in adolescent–mother interactions, and hostile-helpless states of mind. It seeks to replicate established associations and asks whether the indirect relationship between abuse severity and hostile-helpless states of mind through punitive behaviour varies by gender.
- Attachment disorganisation and hostile-helpless representations
- Severity of childhood abuse and its assessment
- Punitive behaviour in adolescent–mother interactions
- Gender as a potential moderator
- Secondary analysis of longitudinal data
- Clinical implications and directions for research
Excerpt from the Book
1.3 GPACS Punitive-Behaviour
A possible underlying mechanism linking severity of childhood abuse to subsequent HH states-of-mind is punitive behaviour. Punitive behaviour - first described in early childhood - is a form of externalising, controlling behaviour characterised by a child’s harsh commands, devaluing comments, verbal threats, or subtly humiliating behaviours towards their caregiver. Controlling behaviour can also manifest itself in an opposing manner described as caretaking behaviour, where the child plays a supportive, entertaining, or encouraging role in the interaction with their caregiver. Children who exhibit controlling-punitive or controlling-caretaking behaviours do so to achieve their frightening or frightened caregiver’s submission and compliance, or to maintain an emotionally distanced caregiver’s attention and involvement (Lyons-Ruth et al., 2019). Furthermore, both controlling behaviours are characteristic of parent-child role-confusion, which “refers to a dyadic process in which the parent fails to exercise appropriate parental functions and the child takes on functions usually assumed by the parent” (Vulliez-Coady et al., 2013, p.1). Expectedly, evidence suggests that controlling-behaviours are prevalent in many previously disorganised children (NICHD Early Child Care Research Network, 2001; Moss, Cyr, & Dubois-Comtois, 2004; O’Connor et al., 2011).
The controlling-behaviours prevalent in childhood can also be examined in adolescence (Obsuth et al., 2014). As adolescents have less need for an attachment figure’s physical presence than children, the observation of ongoing and subtle responses occurring during a conflict interaction with a parent is most suitable for the assessment of their attachment (Obsuth et al., 2014). The adolescent-parent interaction is observed during a 10-minute conflict situation where the topic of the conflict is chosen based on the separately completed Issues Checklist (Kobak et al., 1993), rating sources of disagreement in the relationship. This interaction can be coded using the Goal-Corrected Partnership in Adolescence Coding System (GPACS; Lyons-Ruth, Hennighausen, & Holmes, 2005). The GPACS captures dyadic collaborative behaviour, and parental validating behaviour, which are indicative of a secure attachment relationship as well as four forms of adolescent, and four forms of parental disorganised behaviour, such as punitive behaviour (Obsuth et al., 2014). These behaviours are discussed further in section 2.3.1. Given the aforementioned relation between attachment disorganisation and severity of child abuse, it is unsurprising that there is evidence of punitive adolescent-parent interactions also being linked to prior severity of childhood abuse.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The introduction develops the study’s attachment-theory framework and reviews research on childhood abuse, punitive behaviour, hostile-helpless states of mind and gender. It concludes with the aims and hypotheses.
2. Methods: This chapter describes the participants, the secondary dataset, the assessment measures and the analytical strategy. It explains how interview and interaction data were used to examine the proposed relationships.
3. Results: The results chapter presents descriptive statistics, correlations and gender comparisons, followed by moderated mediation and exploratory logistic regression analyses.
4. Discussion: The discussion interprets the findings in relation to earlier research and considers limitations, strengths, clinical implications and future research directions.
Keywords
childhood abuse, abuse severity, attachment, disorganised attachment, hostile-helpless states of mind, punitive behaviour, gender, adolescence, adolescent–mother interaction, moderated mediation, mentalisation, Adult Attachment Interview, GPACS
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the study about?
It examines how childhood abuse severity, punitive behaviour and hostile-helpless states of mind are related in a sample of adolescents and their mothers.
What are the central topics?
The central topics are attachment representations, childhood abuse severity, punitive behaviour, gender differences and their potential clinical implications.
What is the primary research question?
The study asks whether the association between childhood abuse severity and hostile-helpless states of mind through punitive behaviour differs by gender.
What research method is used?
The author conducts a quantitative secondary analysis of longitudinal data, using non-parametric comparisons, correlations, moderated mediation and exploratory logistic regression.
What does the main body cover?
It develops the theoretical background, describes the participants and measures, presents statistical analyses, and discusses the findings and their implications.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include childhood abuse severity, disorganised attachment, hostile-helpless states of mind, punitive behaviour, gender and moderated mediation.
Whose data are analysed?
The analysis uses data from 109 participants selected from a longitudinal dataset of adolescents and their mothers in the Family Pathways Project.
How is punitive behaviour assessed?
The study uses dyadic punitive-behaviour scores derived from coded adolescent–mother interactions, including a discussion of an area of conflict.
How is childhood abuse severity assessed?
A seven-level rating combines information from abuse assessments, interviews and information about foster care or protective-services involvement.
- Quote paper
- Marie-Louise Meiser (Author), 2020, Psychology of Mental Health. Gender, Childhood Abuse and Hostile-Helpless States of Mind, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1021147