The fact that demonstrations and street rallies in Belarus are only modestly attended
witness that the extent of European and American criticism seems to be more virulent than
the domestic resistance against the state authorities. As a matter of fact, in the 14th year
of Lukashenko’s presidency we have to ask ourselves why the level of civil disobedience
still remains very low. One assessment in this regard is beyond question: The argument of
the “people’s fear of the authorities” doesn’t serve any longer as the sole means of
explanation. The reasons for the longevity of this authoritarian regime in the heart of
Europe are cross-linked: On the one hand, the historical weakness and the reluctance of
the domestic political elite to accept independence in 1991 are very often brought into the
discussion. Apart from this, also Russian economic support made it possible for Belarus to
navigate itself into a deadlock in its relations with the EU. There may be other reasons
which can explain the contemporary situation of a political cul-de-sac. However, the EU
decision makers would be well advised to deal with two subjects: First of all, they should
seriously consider how much influence they really have over this awkward country and
secondly, they should – based on the first consideration – come to reasonable decisions.
The imposition of visa bans altogether with the conditional approach of EU rapprochement
will not enhance the chances of democratization for Belarus. This “strategy” will have the
opposite of the intended effect and provides the authorities with new tools to accuse the
opposition of anti-Belarusian behavior.
At a glance
- Examines Article 36 restrictions on political membership for public-sector personnel
- Discusses the European Humanities University’s 2004 loss of its educational license
- Uses Slavoj Zizek’s interpretation of the Polish Solidarnosc movement
- 22 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Civil Society: Requirement for Transition
3. Civil Society in Eastern Europe
4. Civil Society in Belarus
4.1 Civil Society and Identity in Belarus
4.2 Some Political and Economic Aspects of Civil Society in Belarus
5. Conclusions
Objectives and Topics
The work examines why civil society and democratic transition have remained weak in Belarus, considering the interaction of historical identity, political institutions, economic structures and European Union policy. It situates the Belarusian case within wider debates about post-communist transition and the role of civil society in democratization.
- Civil society and democratic consolidation
- Post-communist transitions in Eastern Europe
- Belarusian historical identity and nationalism
- Political restrictions on associations and public employees
- State control of the economy and civic activity
- European Union policy towards Belarus
Excerpt from the Book
Civil Society in Eastern Europe
Historically the term of civil society represents the social defense against the absolutist claims to power of the Communist party in Eastern Europe. And even today, the evaluation of civil society in Eastern Europe must not be seen as being isolated from the former Communist system, in which the state, the Communist party and the state-directed economy were part of a monolithic block and all decisions were marked by the character of monopolization.
So the comparison of “official political society” on the one hand and “islands of civil society” on the other hand can explain the phenomenon of civil society in the collapsing Communism of the 1980s. Apart from this, the nature of this concept was the intention of transforming the Soviet individual into a “component of a social subunit” in opposition to the delusional collectivization of the Communist system. This concept was not in accordance with the Marxist state theory because it vociferously advocated the mutual independence of politics and economy, in a purely Marxist view however, this model represented nothing more than a “façade of an arcane and evil power”. For this reason it was the main goal of civil society movements to liberate the people from authoritarianism and from the totalitarian claim to power of the Communist party.
But also the economic dimension of the civil society must be taken into consideration. The independence of the social space came along with the claim to private property. So very soon an ambivalent relation between the civil society and the economy came into being: Whereas in the beginning the focus was put on civil freedoms, over the years socio-economic ideas have prevailed. So the criticism which the concept of civil society had to face with was that its active participants acted in a self-interested manner without any view to the overall interest of society. This of course opened the floor to those who perceived the civil society as a “real utopia”. Ideas like these even culminated in the first half of the 1990s due to the impoverishment and economic desperation of large parts of post-Soviet societies. The desire for the iron fist of the state was the first missile which severely wounded this promised concept. Also the presidential election of 1994 in Belarus can serve as an appropriate example in this regard: Not even the big media support in the election campaign for Kebich could prevent the landslide victory of Lukashenko. While Kebich as well as Shushkevich were regarded as the clear favorites, Lukashenko, who campaigned as an independent on the populist platform “defeating the mafia”, won the second round with unbelievable 80% of the votes.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The author introduces the problem of weak domestic resistance in Belarus and places it within the simultaneous political, economic and social challenges of post-Soviet transition.
Civil Society: Requirement for Transition: This chapter discusses civil society’s proposed role in democratic consolidation and the tensions between participation, economic reform and loyalty to the state.
Civil Society in Eastern Europe: The discussion traces civil society’s opposition to communist rule and considers the social and economic strains that followed the collapse of communism.
Civil Society in Belarus: The chapter examines competing accounts of Belarusian identity before turning to political and economic constraints on civic activity, including restrictions on associations and the role of EU policy.
Conclusions: The author draws together the historical, institutional and economic arguments and calls for a different approach to engagement with Belarus.
Keywords
Belarus, civil society, democratization, political transition, post-communism, national identity, political participation, authoritarianism, state economy, civic associations, European Union, Eastern Europe
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the work about?
It examines the difficulties facing civil society and democratic transition in post-Soviet Belarus.
What are its central themes?
The main themes include civil society, national identity, political participation, economic control and relations with the European Union.
What is the work’s primary objective?
It seeks to explain the weakness of Belarusian civil society by relating domestic historical, political and economic conditions to the broader transition from communism.
What research method does the author use?
The work presents a qualitative discussion drawing on published scholarship, historical examples, legal provisions and political developments. It does not describe an original survey or interview study.
What does the main body cover?
It discusses civil society in transition theory and Eastern Europe, then examines Belarusian identity alongside political and economic restrictions on civic activity.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include civil society, Belarus, democratization, national identity, post-communism, political participation and European Union policy.
How does the work connect identity with civil society?
It discusses competing interpretations of Belarusian history, nationalism and Soviet identity as factors in the development of civic self-awareness.
Which constitutional provision does the author discuss?
The author discusses Article 36 in relation to restrictions on political membership among judges, security personnel and other groups.
What educational institution appears in the discussion?
The European Humanities University is discussed in connection with the withdrawal of its educational license in Belarus in 2004 and its subsequent relocation to Lithuania.
- Quote paper
- Mag. Benedikt Harzl (Author), 2008, Cancelled transition - The dilemma of civil society in Belarus, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/112385