The strongest state on the African continent – that is definitely South Africa.
Their economic strength and international acceptance as a representative for
the whole continent established that position. South Africa’s international
reputation as an emerging middle power (Erdmann 2007: 2) enabled the
former Pariah-state to develop a unique foreign policy whose basic values
are shared by most of the powerful states in the world. The importance of a
flourishing African continent and economic as well as political success
especially in Southern Africa was always emphasized by the representatives
of the rainbow nation. According to this position, South Africa joined the
South African Development Community (SADC) after its successful transition
into a democracy in 1994, using this institution for cooperation with the
neighbour-states. But 14 years after the termination of Apartheid questions
regarding South Africa’s foreign policy are raised: In how far plays the SADC
a role in the plans of South Africa? Is SADC really, as often implicated, the
top priority in South Africa’s foreign policy? Does the vision of the institution
and the expressed South African foreign policy go in the same direction?
To answer these questions I will use an historical approach and start with an
overview of the South African foreign policy since 1994. I will identify different
phases, strongly linked to presidency, which will help to understand South
Africa’s current foreign policy. In chapter two I will focus on these current
positions of the government and the national interests. The definition of the
term national interest and its differentiation from foreign policy will take part in
chapter two as well. Chapter three will focus on the SADC with its historical
grown values and visions before a detailed analysis of the main question will
be done in chapter four. By bringing the foreign policy on one side and the
visions and goals of SADC on the other side together, a comparative analysis
can be done. The assignment will conclude with an evaluation of the question
if SADC and South Africa are still fitting together and if the mutual way will
lead to a deadlock or a lockstep towards a prospering future for Southern
Africa.
At a glance
- Grade: 2.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Compares South African foreign policy with SADC’s visions and goals
- Examines South Africa’s bilateral TDCA with the European Union
- Examines Zimbabwe’s crisis as a challenge to SADC security policy
- 26 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
Introduction
1. The South African foreign policy since 1994 – an overview
2. Strategic interests and foreign policy of South Africa today
3. The SADC – aims, visions, tasks
4. South Africa and SADC – walking in the same direction?
Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This work examines the relationship between South African foreign policy and the goals of the Southern African Development Community (SADC), asking whether regional integration is a priority for South Africa and whether the country’s policies and SADC’s objectives move in the same direction.
- South African foreign policy under Nelson Mandela and Thabo Mbeki
- National interests and strategic foreign policy priorities
- SADC’s history, objectives and regional integration plans
- Multilateral cooperation and bilateral trade relations
- Regional security and the crisis in Zimbabwe
Excerpt from the Book
1. The South African foreign policy since 1994 – an overview
After the successful transition from the white dominated Apartheid-state to one of Africa’s most modern democracy’s, South Africa struggled to define its foreign policy. No wonder after 40 years of isolation in world politics. The reason for South Africa’s struggle can be seen mainly in the self perception of the ruling party ANC. Coming out of a past where the ANC was working as a banned underground organisation with its headquarter abroad, they now had to represent a state with severe social, political and economic problems. The new president Nelson Mandela therefore gave himself basic rules to construct South Africa’s international relations. These guidelines lasted for the first few years of the ANC governance. Mandela emphasized the importance of human rights in international relations, the values of democratization and peace and the superior relevance of the African continent for South Africa’s foreign policy (Mandela 1993: 87). Furthermore Mandela pointed out to a future where South Africa and the Southern African states would have strong relations and are bind together through institutions. In this respect Mandela spoke about South Africa’s African destiny (Mandela 1993: 90). But reality drew a different picture. Analyst’s accused the new South African government to be opportunistic and inconsistent. “South Africa first, even at the expenses of the continent” seemed to be the rule in Pretoria (Landsberg/Kornegay 1998: 18). This inconsistency became obvious when Mandela dropped diplomatic recognition of Taiwan in favour of China, one of South Africa’s most important trade partners nowadays (McNeil 1997: 1). The accusations even went to a point where scientists spoke about a non-existing South African foreign policy in the years after transition (Hentz 2004: 31 f.). One of the reasons for this statement can be seen in the long lasting process of staff replacement in the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA). Here, where the foreign policy is made, South Africa’s old elite remained on their posts (Vale 1995: 3). A discrepancy between the new policy of reconciliation represented by Mandela and the old DFA-staff is more then obvious. While Mandela started his journey to establish his country as a rising middle power, his staff at home worked in a different direction (Vale 1995: 4).
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction sets out the questions concerning South Africa’s foreign policy and SADC’s objectives and explains the historical and comparative approach.
1. The South African foreign policy since 1994 – an overview: This chapter traces foreign policy under Mandela and Mbeki, addressing diplomatic priorities, regional relations and the African Renaissance.
2. Strategic interests and foreign policy of South Africa today: The chapter considers the relationship between national interests and foreign policy and describes the government’s five strategic pillars.
3. The SADC – aims, visions, tasks: This chapter examines SADC’s origins, objectives, integration timetable and security arrangements.
4. South Africa and SADC – walking in the same direction?: The comparative analysis considers regional priorities alongside bilateral trade, international representation and security policy, including Zimbabwe.
Conclusion: The conclusion brings together the comparison of declared objectives and practical foreign policy.
Keywords
South African foreign policy, Southern African Development Community, regional integration, national interests, Nelson Mandela, Thabo Mbeki, African Renaissance, multilateralism, bilateral trade, regional security, Zimbabwe, European Union
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It examines the relationship between South African foreign policy and SADC’s goals for regional integration.
What are its central themes?
The main themes include foreign policy, national interests, regional integration, trade, security and cooperation in Southern Africa.
What is the main research question?
The author asks whether South African foreign policy and SADC’s goals are moving in the same direction and how important SADC is to South Africa’s foreign policy.
What method does the author use?
The work uses a historical approach to trace foreign policy since 1994 and a comparative analysis of that policy alongside SADC’s visions and goals.
What does the main discussion cover?
It covers the presidencies of Mandela and Mbeki, South Africa’s strategic priorities, SADC’s development and objectives, and points of comparison between national and regional policy.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include South African foreign policy, SADC, regional integration, national interests, multilateralism and regional security.
How does the work address South Africa’s relationship with the European Union?
It discusses the bilateral Trade, Development and Cooperation Agreement with the EU in the context of South Africa’s regional commitments.
Why is Zimbabwe discussed?
Zimbabwe serves as a case through which the author considers South Africa’s diplomacy and SADC’s approach to regional security and sovereignty.
What role does the African Renaissance play in the discussion?
The work presents it as a concept associated with Mbeki’s foreign policy, linking political and economic aspirations for the African continent.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Florian Pretz (Autor:in), 2008, South African foreign policy and SADC goals - lockstep or deadlock?, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/113402