The crisis of ethics in our time calls for a synoptic view capable of kindling confident teleological motivation, in persons and societies. It is futile to search for the "clear and distinct idea" in a field of such universal importance as ethics, for which the ordinary discourse of humanity is well suited. Rather, our notions must be open, open to the analogies in things and situations, and open too to the real human situation in all its depth and breadth, such things as the desires of the human heart, the burdens of finitude, misfortune and death, the polarization of the sexes, the insights and traditions of religion, the exigences of politics, the compelling witness of the arts and of literature.
The reason for this universal importance, such that a field of discourse considered especially intractable or even, recently, "queer" (J.L. Mackie), cannot be isolated as if somehow less scientific and hence inherently problematical or "emotive", was clearly stated by Aristotle when founding this science, this theoria of praxis. It is that ethics is concerned with the nature and end of man, with man, that is, in view of his characteristic action or praxis. That is to say, to take the short way for the present, it is the science of human happiness, of how to be happy. But this is the object of all human endeavour without exception. Hence, if its content be ever identified, e.g. as the vision of God, then it will follow that this content is the ultimate aim of all our civil and social arrangements, a conclusion that St. Thomas unhesitatingly draws.1
1 Summa contra gentiles III 37.
At a glance
- Systematic four-virtue scheme with definitions and integral, subjective, and potential parts
- Examines Aquinas’s account of virtue alongside objections from Geach and MacIntyre
- Appendix applies natural-law analysis to contraception and erotic attraction
Contents
INTRODUCTION: INCLINATIONS AND BEATITUDE
1. ETHICS
2. HUMAN ACTS
3. FINIS ULTIMUS
4. TELEOLOGY
5. THE VIRTUES
6. DUTY, OBLIGATION, LAW
7. MORALS AND METAPHYSICS: FACT AND VALUE
8. WHAT IS LAW?
9. NATURAL LAW IN ST. THOMAS'S THOUGHT
10. NATURAL LAW - OTHER VIEWS
11. DOES MORALITY REQUIRE A DIVINE LAW-GIVER?
12. CONSCIENCE
13. THE INTELLECTUAL VIRTUES
14. THE MORAL VIRTUES
15. THE CARDINAL VIRTUES
16. THE THEOLOGICAL VIRTUES
17. NATURAL LAW AND THE ACTS OF THE VIRTUES
18. PRUDENCE: THE UNITY OF THE VIRTUES
19. A FOURFOLD SCHEME
20. JUSTICE: LEGAL AND MORAL DEBT
21. FORTITUDE: THE EXAMPLE OF AUDACITY
22 TEMPERANCE AND THE BONUM HONESTUM
23. NATURAL INCLINATIONS AND THEIR ORDER
Objectives and Themes
Stephen Theron interprets Thomas Aquinas's ethics as a unified account of human flourishing. The work asks how happiness, natural inclinations, virtue and law belong together, and examines Aquinas's answers through philosophical and theological comparison.
- Happiness and the ultimate end of human action
- Natural law, reason and moral obligation
- Intellectual, moral, cardinal and theological virtues
- Prudence and the unity of the virtues
- Justice, fortitude and temperance
- Natural inclinations and their relationship to moral precepts
Excerpt from the Book
INTRODUCTION: INCLINATIONS AND BEATITUDE
Nonetheless, to speak of the most natural of our inclinations is to concede that we have a plurality of inclinations, among which, however, there has to be a certain order, both because order itself is something to which we are clearly inclined and because that inclination to universal good (bonum in communi) which we discuss in the text, identifying it as an end with that end which in fact specifies the human will in its being as a will and indeed with God, is already sufficient to order the rest.
We might ask how it is that we can have this plurality of inclinations if inclinations are to perceived goods and "good" has the meaning of "end", such that there is just one ultimate end not only of all human life but even, St. Thomas makes clear, of each and every human action. Here already, I believe, is the place to introduce the essential notion of participation. Human beings are so situated that there are a variety of ways of participating, of taking part in, the universal goodness of beings, whether in the order of learning or in the order of desire, use and enjoyment. The basic realities of birth and education to maturity are sufficient evidence of this. Before one even asks the question why do I live, how shall I be happy, not to speak of answering it, one has lived some years with one's energies bent upon nourishment, play, the search for love, or whatever it may be. Again, after those first, typically adolescent days of spiritual enlightenment in which, it may be, one discovers one's eternal destiny and the dignity of one's own soul as a necessary being, after those intense days of conversion the exhausted spirit will be forced to remember its continuing need for, and hence inclination, at least at some level of its nature, towards those finite goods which in its ardour it had forgotten, a recurring pattern to which we must not forget to add the need for healing and forgiveness of our own wounded being.
In all these ways we participate in the ultimate good which draws us to itself, and so it is only good for us to use these other goods when they do, in the particular circumstances as evaluated by the virtue of prudence, constitute such a participation. Hence we are advised never to seek fulfilment in them on their own, and even that such a desire defiles the soul. It is possible, however, to abstract such goods in the mind for separate consideration as to what is or is not to be done with respect to each, assuming the circumstances are otherwise right, and hence we arrive at those formalities of justice which are enunciated as laws.
Chapter Summaries
INTRODUCTION: INCLINATIONS AND BEATITUDE: The introduction presents happiness, natural inclinations and divine law as interconnected elements of Aquinas's ethical outlook.
1. ETHICS: Ethics is introduced as a practical science concerned with human action and the ultimate good.
2. HUMAN ACTS: The chapter distinguishes voluntary human acts from other acts and considers their objects, intentions and moral qualities.
3. FINIS ULTIMUS: Theron examines the argument for an ultimate end and Aquinas's account of happiness.
4. TELEOLOGY: The discussion relates moral precepts to ends and contrasts teleological ethics with alternative approaches.
5. THE VIRTUES: The chapter traces the place of habits and virtues in the structure of the Summa Theologica.
6. DUTY, OBLIGATION, LAW: Natural law and duty are considered alongside contrasting accounts of moral obligation.
7. MORALS AND METAPHYSICS: FACT AND VALUE: Theron explores the relationship between ethics, metaphysics and the distinction between factual and evaluative statements.
8. WHAT IS LAW?: The chapter develops Aquinas's definition of law through reason, the common good, authority and promulgation.
9. NATURAL LAW IN ST. THOMAS'S THOUGHT: Natural law is examined in relation to eternal law, rational participation and human inclinations.
10. NATURAL LAW - OTHER VIEWS: Alternative interpretations of natural law are discussed alongside questions about nature and practical reason.
11. DOES MORALITY REQUIRE A DIVINE LAW-GIVER?: The chapter considers whether moral obligation depends on divine authority and how different thinkers address that question.
12. CONSCIENCE: Aquinas's distinction between conscience and synderesis frames a discussion of error, obligation and respect for conscience.
13. THE INTELLECTUAL VIRTUES: The chapter distinguishes speculative and practical intellectual virtues and considers prudence's relation to moral action.
14. THE MORAL VIRTUES: Moral virtues are explored in relation to the will, the passions and prudence.
15. THE CARDINAL VIRTUES: Prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance are introduced as principal virtues and considered in relation to one another.
16. THE THEOLOGICAL VIRTUES: Faith, hope and charity are discussed in relation to grace, acquired virtue and the ultimate end.
17. NATURAL LAW AND THE ACTS OF THE VIRTUES: This chapter brings together natural-law precepts, virtuous acts and the role of human ends in obligation.
18. PRUDENCE: THE UNITY OF THE VIRTUES: Theron examines Aquinas's account of the connection between virtues alongside objections by Geach and MacIntyre.
19. A FOURFOLD SCHEME: A systematic scheme sets out the definitions and integral, subjective and potential parts of the four cardinal virtues.
20. JUSTICE: LEGAL AND MORAL DEBT: The chapter examines distinctions between legal and moral debt through virtues associated with justice, including truthfulness and gratitude.
21. FORTITUDE: THE EXAMPLE OF AUDACITY: Audacity provides a focus for examining fortitude, fear, rashness and related virtues and vices.
22 TEMPERANCE AND THE BONUM HONESTUM: The discussion connects temperance with moral beauty and the honourable good.
23. NATURAL INCLINATIONS AND THEIR ORDER: The final chapter considers how Aquinas's ordering of natural inclinations relates to natural law and the ultimate end.
Keywords
Thomas Aquinas, happiness, desire, virtue ethics, natural law, teleology, ultimate end, human action, moral obligation, conscience, prudence, cardinal virtues, theological virtues, natural inclinations
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It offers an interpretation of Thomas Aquinas's ethics, concentrating on the connections between happiness, desire, virtue and natural law.
What are its central themes?
The principal themes include human action, the ultimate end, moral obligation, conscience, natural inclinations and the intellectual, moral and theological virtues.
What is the work's primary aim?
It seeks to explain Aquinas's ethical thought as a unified account of the good life and to examine how law, virtue and happiness are related within it.
What method does the author use?
Theron uses philosophical and theological textual interpretation, closely reading Aquinas and comparing his arguments with those of other thinkers.
What does the main discussion cover?
It moves from human action and happiness to natural law and conscience, then examines the virtues individually and in relation to one another.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include natural law, teleology, beatitude, prudence, moral obligation, cardinal virtues and natural inclinations.
How does the work approach the four cardinal virtues?
It presents a systematic scheme of their definitions and parts, then explores selected questions concerning prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance.
Whose objections to the unity of the virtues are considered?
The discussion considers objections associated with P.T. Geach and A.C. MacIntyre in relation to Aquinas's distinction between perfect and imperfect virtue.
What additional subject does the appendix explore?
The appendix considers eros and the human good, including sexual ethics, love, freedom and natural law.
- Quote paper
- Dr. Stephen Theron (Author), 2008, Thomas Aquinas: Happiness, Desire, Virtue, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/114279