In Germany in particular, more and more people are adopting a vegan diet. They do without animal products completely and want to pass this diet on to their children. However, they often encounter criticism because an increased risk of nutrient deficiencies is suspected.
Marlene Pirker provides clarity on the effects of a vegan diet on pregnant women, nursing mothers, infants and young children up to the age of three. Is a vegan diet in these phases of life also recommendable from a nutritional point of view? Or can it cause damage to the health of the child or mother?
Pirker addresses reference values for pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, infants and toddlers and evaluates risk nutrients. She also explains how mothers can design a vegan diet. She presents relevant studies and provides testimonials so that expectant mothers can get a comprehensive picture of the effects of a vegan diet.
At a glance
- Questionnaire responses from five vegan mothers, summarized as experience reports
- Examines Vandenplas and colleagues' review of soy-based infant formula safety
- Discusses the Farm Study of children's growth in a Tennessee vegan community
- 68 sources in the bibliography
- 4 tables
Table of Contents
Note
1 Introduction and question
2 Methodology
3 Pregnant and breastfeeding women
3.1 Recommendations for nutrient intake
3.2 Nutritional evaluation of vegan diet in pregnant and breastfeeding women
3.3 Breast milk from vegans
3.4 Example of practical implementation
3.5 "Vegan- Vegetarian diets in pregnancy: danger or panacea? A systematic narrative review"
3.6 "A maternal vegetarian diet in pregnancy is associated with hypospadias"
4 Infants and young children
4.1 Recommendations for nutrient intake
4.2 Nutritional evaluation of vegan nutrition in infants and children
4.3 Soy-based infant formula
4.4 Nutrient supplementation in infants
4.5 Weaning and complementary food
4.6 Example of practical implementation
4.7 "The Growth of vegetarian children: The Farm Study"
4.8 "Growth and Development of British vegan children"
4.9 Macrobiotic nutrition in infants
5 Expert opinions
5.1 Position of the German Nutrition Society
5.2 Position of the American Dietetic Association: Vegetarian Diets
6 Reviews
7 Discussion
Summary
Objectives and Topics
This bachelor thesis examines whether a vegan diet during pregnancy and breastfeeding and in infancy and early childhood can meet nutritional needs, or whether it may pose health risks to mothers and children. It considers nutrient requirements, published research, professional positions and the experiences of vegan mothers.
- Energy, protein and micronutrient requirements during pregnancy and lactation
- Breast milk composition and maternal nutrient intake
- Infant nutrition, supplementation and complementary feeding
- Published studies of pregnancy outcomes and children's growth
- Professional positions on vegan diets in sensitive life stages
- Questionnaire-based experience reports from vegan mothers
Excerpt from the Book
4.5 Weaning and complementary food
The guidelines for the introduction of complementary foods are also the same as those for omnivorous children. When children are weaned, it is of great importance that the diet is rich in calcium, iron, zinc and B12 is. If necessary, the use of supplements would be advisable. Vegan toddlers should receive energy-dense food in the form of three meals and two to three snacks a day to meet energy and nutrient needs [Messina & Mangels, 2001]. The introduction of complementary foods is recommended from the sixth month. Iron-enriched baby porridge is well suited as the first, solid food, as it provides a lot of energy and iron in an easily digestible form. Rice porridge is often used because it is hypoallergenic. Breast milk or infant formula should continue to be a part of the diet. If cereals are well tolerated, pureed fruits and fruit juices, pureed vegetables and vegetable juices can be tried. However, juice consumption should be limited, as excessive intake can lead to diarrhea. From the seventh and eighth months, other high-quality protein sources can be tried, including pureed, boiled beans, pureed tofu, and soy yogurt [American Academy of Pediatrics, 1998]. If breast milk or infant formula has been replaced for the most part, care must be taken to use foods that have a high energy and nutrient density. Examples of this would be soft tofu, bean spreads, avocado and dried fruits. Since fat is very high in energy, it might be beneficial to incorporate smaller amounts of soft margarine or vegetable oils into the diet when the child is a little older. Care should be taken to ensure that the oil is rich in linolenic and/or low in linoleic acid [Mangels and Messina, 2001]. It's possible that healthy, vegan children have a lower risk of allergies because they don't consume cow's milk, which is considered the main source of allergies. Foods that can cause allergies in the vegan diet would be, for example, peas, corn products, citrus fruits, soy products and wheat. However, children without an increased risk of allergies are less likely to be triggered by soy-based infant formula than cow's milk. When introducing complementary foods, one food after another should be tried to test tolerability [American Academy of Pediatrics, 1998].
Chapter Summaries
1 Introduction and question: The author introduces the controversy surrounding vegan nutrition in life stages with increased nutrient requirements and sets out the central research question.
2 Methodology: The work describes a literature search begun in September 2016, primarily using Google Scholar and PubMed, alongside a specialist book.
3 Pregnant and breastfeeding women: This chapter examines nutrient recommendations, potentially critical nutrients, breast milk and a sample meal plan. It also discusses published research on pregnancy outcomes.
4 Infants and young children: The author considers nutrient intake, soy-based formula, supplements and complementary feeding, followed by a sample meal plan and studies of children's growth and development.
5 Expert opinions: The positions of the German Nutrition Society and the American Dietetic Association are presented alongside their approaches to nutrient supply.
6 Reviews: Experience reports summarize questionnaire responses from five vegan mothers concerning pregnancy, feeding, supplementation and family practices.
7 Discussion: The author discusses the published evidence, its limitations and the differing positions of professional organizations.
Summary: The closing overview brings together the work's principal considerations concerning nutrient supply and the need for further research.
Keywords
vegan diet, pregnancy, breastfeeding, infant nutrition, early childhood, nutrient requirements, vitamin B12, vitamin D, iron, calcium, soy-based infant formula, complementary feeding, dietary supplementation, child growth
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It examines vegan nutrition during pregnancy and breastfeeding and in infancy and early childhood, with particular attention to nutritional needs and possible health effects.
What are its central topics?
The main topics include maternal and child nutrient requirements, breast milk, infant feeding, supplements, growth studies and professional dietary positions.
What is the main research question?
The author asks whether vegan diets are nutritionally advisable during these life stages or may cause harm to mothers or children.
What research method does the author use?
The thesis draws on a literature search using Google Scholar and PubMed and supplements the discussion with experience reports based on questionnaires completed by five vegan mothers.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers individual nutrients, practical feeding examples, published pregnancy and child-development studies, infant formula and the views of nutrition organizations.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include vegan diet, pregnancy, breastfeeding, infant nutrition, vitamin B12, supplementation, complementary feeding and child growth.
Does the work include practical meal examples?
Yes. It presents a one-day meal plan for a pregnant vegan woman and another for a nine-month-old infant.
How are professional opinions addressed?
The author presents the positions of the German Nutrition Society and the American Dietetic Association and discusses their differing assessments of vegan diets in sensitive life stages.
What does the work say about soy-based infant formula?
It discusses its use in infant feeding and reviews research on safety, including growth, bone health and developmental outcomes.
What material accompanies the mothers' experience reports?
The appendix reproduces the questionnaire used for the reports, with questions about pregnancy, feeding, supplements and family experiences.
- Quote paper
- Marlene Pirker (Author), 2016, Vegan diet during pregnancy and first years of life, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1188408