Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › American Studies - Literature

Is Irene Redfield in Nella Larsen's "Passing" the "black bourgeois" Franklin E. Frazier described in his book?

Title: Is Irene Redfield in Nella Larsen's "Passing" the "black bourgeois" Franklin E. Frazier described in his book?

Term Paper , 2018 , 15 Pages , Grade: 1,3

Autor:in: Annika Gerle (Author)

American Studies - Literature
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

This paper examines the roots of Black Bourgeoisie in Franklin E. Frazier’s book "Black Bourgeoisie" from 1957 and addresses its role in the novel "Passing" by Nella Larsen. Franklin E. Frazier’s book is still one of the most important analysis of African American life. It traces the upcoming and the development of the black middle class from the separated South to the after-war period in the North. He asserts how African Americans in the middle class lost their roots and traditions instead of gaining the wished acknowledgment of their white counterparts. Frazier presents the losing of their identities and an inferiority complex they cannot escape as a result.

Until today Frazier’s remarks on the black bourgeoisie are still relevant to many other authors engaging in the topic of the African American middle class. His findings and considerations are often being referred to in other works, they are worshiped as well as reviled. Reading some of these works regarding Frazier’s early work, it gets clear that in the last decades a lot had changed, especially regarding the position of the blacks in the economy and white society and their feelings towards their black roots. To get a detailed insight into the life of a black bourgeois, it is important to firstly look at how the black middle class arose, how it came to wealth, how it changed through time and what status in the white economy and society it had. Following Frazier’s and newer remarks from other authors the findings will belooked at regarding the character Irene Redfield in "Passing".

Is she the black bourgeois Frazier describes in his book? Does she represent the old class of black bourgeoisie or rather the new one, which appeared in books and articles after Frazier wrote Black Bourgeoisie? Further to that analysis this work will concentrate on Irene Redfield’s behavior and attitude towards her black roots and traditions and towards the values of the American society she decides to live in. It will be analyzed in how far she tries to be acknowledged by the Whites and in how far this wish for recognition makes her break with her blackness. Summing up, in how far this process leads to becoming nobody as a result of a severe identity loss.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Analyzes the protagonist Irene Redfield in Nella Larsen's literary work Passing
  • 14 sources in the bibliography

Table of Contents

1. Introduction 2

2. The Historical Background 3

2.1. Frazier’s Remarks on the Roots of Black Bourgeoisie 3

2.2. Frazier’s Remarks on the Influence of the Freedman’s Savings Bank 4

2.3. Development of Black Bourgeoisie since Frazier 5

3. The Role of Black Bourgeoisie in Passing 6

3.1. Irene Redfield – A Typical Black Bourgeois? 6

3.2. Irene Redfield’s Loss of Identity 8

4. Conclusion 12

5. List of Works Cited 14

Objectives and Key Themes

This paper examines how the socio-historical concept of the "black bourgeoisie," as theorized by E. Franklin Frazier, manifests in Nella Larsen's 1929 novel Passing. It investigates the psychological, racial, and class-based tensions experienced by the protagonist, Irene Redfield, addressing how her desperate pursuit of white middle-class validation leads to an alienation from her cultural roots and culminates in a profound loss of identity.

  • E. Franklin Frazier's foundational critique of the black middle class and its world of make-believe
  • The historical evolution and occupational shifts of the black bourgeoisie before and after 1960
  • Irene Redfield as an archetype of bourgeois consumerism, emotional detachment, and racial ambivalence
  • The psychological mechanisms of racial passing, social insecurity, and the resulting identity disintegration

Excerpt from the Book

3.1. Irene Redfield – a Typical Black Bourgeois?

At the beginning of the novel Irene Redfield can be seen shopping for gifts for her sons in Chicago. She is walking through the streets looking for the things she had promised to bring home with her (Larsen 4) when returning to Harlem. This shopping for things is the first aspect of her whole behavior which leads to the assumption that she indeed is a member of the black bourgeoisie (Brody 1057), because Frazier names consumption as one of many values of the bourgeois lifestyle (26). This assumption confirms in the following actions: It is known for the black bourgeoisie to “look down upon masses of the race” as Bart Landry explains in his article (211) or as Frazier puts it, to “reject identification with the Negro masses” (24). This is a fact that one can see very clearly in the behavior of Irene Redfield. When walking through the streets of Chicago on a hot summer day and a man collapses right besides her, she, as soon as possible, flees from the masses that gather together to help the man. She herself feels “soiled from the contact with so many sweating bodies” (Larsen 4) and escapes into a hotel café on the rooftop of the Drayton, a presumably “only whites” hotel.

She feels like she is being uplifted into another world by a magic carpet while leaving everyone else “below” (5). This highlights her aversion towards the working class and the masses she tries so hard to escape, not only in this scene, but in her whole life. To Irene it is very important what others think of her, her outer appearance is what other see and therefore her most important treasure (5,7). These standards of beauty are a typical bourgeois value (Frazier 26): Her appearance does not show that she is black, she could easily pass as white, regarding her outer appearance, and while the black middle class was trying to get the acknowledgment of whites it is only logical, that Irene’s appearance is so important to her.

Chapter Summaries

1. Introduction: Outlines the core framework of Franklin E. Frazier's Black Bourgeoisie and introduces the central question of whether the protagonist of Nella Larsen's Passing undergoes a progressive loss of identity when striving for white middle-class acceptance.

2. The Historical Background: Details the historical origins of the African American middle class from the antebellum period through the Freedman's Savings Bank, followed by an overview of sociological developments after the 1960s Civil Rights Movement.

3. The Role of Black Bourgeoisie in Passing: Explores Irene Redfield's alignment with bourgeois values, consumer habits, class aversion, and her psychological descent into rootlessness, culminating in the complete disintegration of her identity.

4. Conclusion: Synthesizes the critical findings, affirming that Irene typifies Frazier's traditional black bourgeois dilemma while contextualizing the ongoing relevance of race and class dynamics in contemporary society.

5. List of Works Cited: Compiles the academic literature, historical studies, and primary texts cited throughout the research paper.

Keywords

Black Bourgeoisie, Nella Larsen, Passing, Irene Redfield, E. Franklin Frazier, Identity Loss, Harlem Renaissance, Race and Class, Social Mobility, Make-Believe World, African American Literature, Racial Insecurity

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the central focus of this research paper?

The paper examines Nella Larsen's novel Passing through the sociological lens of E. Franklin Frazier's 1957 study Black Bourgeoisie, analyzing how middle-class aspirations and racial ambivalence lead to identity dissolution.

What key topics and historical contexts are discussed?

The text explores the historical origins of the African American middle class, the role of institutions such as the Freedman's Savings Bank, twentieth-century socio-economic mobility, and literary representations of racial passing.

What is the primary objective of the author?

The objective is to establish whether the character Irene Redfield functions as a typical representative of the black bourgeoisie as formulated by Frazier, tracing how her psychological desire for bourgeois security destroys her cultural identity.

What academic methodology is applied?

The study uses close literary textual analysis combined with a socio-historical framework, integrating sociological critique and scholarly literary commentary on Harlem Renaissance fiction.

What themes are explored in the main body?

The main section investigates Irene's consumerism, her aversion to the working-class black masses, her complex fascination with Clare Kendry, and the emotional isolation stemming from living in an illusory world modeled on white bourgeois ideals.

Which critical keywords best describe the paper's scope?

Key terms include Black Bourgeoisie, Nella Larsen, Passing, Irene Redfield, E. Franklin Frazier, Identity Loss, Race and Class, and Assimilation.

How does E. Franklin Frazier define the "make-believe" world of the black middle class?

Frazier argues that because black middle-class individuals faced systemic racial rejection despite their economic gains, they escaped into an illusory world of prestige and consumerism, mimicking white elite values to compensate for their underlying feelings of inferiority.

Why does Irene Redfield feel threatened by Clare Kendry's return to her life?

Clare embodies both the dangerous freedom of fully passing into white society and a disruptive reminder of Irene's repressed desires, ultimately threatening Irene's carefully structured domestic security and bourgeois self-image.

Excerpt out of 15 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Is Irene Redfield in Nella Larsen's "Passing" the "black bourgeois" Franklin E. Frazier described in his book?
College
University of Münster  (Englisches Seminar)
Grade
1,3
Author
Annika Gerle (Author)
Publication Year
2018
Pages
15
Catalog Number
V1243930
ISBN (PDF)
9783346680877
ISBN (Book)
9783346680884
Language
English
Tags
Passing Black Bourgeoisie
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Annika Gerle (Author), 2018, Is Irene Redfield in Nella Larsen's "Passing" the "black bourgeois" Franklin E. Frazier described in his book?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1243930
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  15  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract