Dr. Charles Doran, Professor of International Relations, titled his speech given on June 10th 2008 at the America House Munich “How Americans Choose - The most important Presidential Election in a Century”. Maybe – as we are still at the beginning of this century - this sounds somewhat exaggerated at first, but on a second look the upcoming presidential election in the United States indeed appears to be a unique and path-breaking event for the future
(…) As the topic of our seminar was “America and the world”, this term paper will focus on the nominees' foreign policy perspectives, which show surprisingly few differences but many similarities.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines the candidates’ positions on the Cuban embargo and Guantanamo
- Compares proposals concerning G8 membership and a League of Democracies
Table of Contents
1) Introduction
2.1) On Environment & Natural Resources
2.2) On Future Diplomacy
2.3) On Relationship to…
2.3.1) ...International Organisations (Ingo’s, NGO´s, UN, G8)
2.3.2) …Russia
2.3.3) …China
2.3.4) …Europe (Transatlantic Relations)
2.3.5) …Cuba and on Guantanamo
2.3.6) …Africa
2.3.7) …The Middle East:
2.3.7.1) Iraq
2.3.7.2) Iran
2.3.7.3) Israel
2.3.7.4) Afghanistan and Pakistan
2.4) On Terrorism
2.5) Military Plans
3) Personal Opinion
Objectives and Topics
This term paper compares the foreign policy perspectives of John McCain, Hillary Rodham Clinton and Barack Obama during the 2008 US presidential campaign. It asks where their positions differ in emphasis and where their outlooks overlap, concentrating primarily on McCain and Obama after Clinton ended her campaign.
- Climate change, energy and natural resources
- Diplomacy, alliances and international organisations
- Relations with major powers and regions
- Middle Eastern conflicts and regional security
- Terrorism, nuclear proliferation and military planning
Excerpt from the Book
2.3.5) …Cuba and on Guantanamo
The practices in Guantanamo Bay Prison “Camp Justice” on Cuba have been hotly debated as major infringements on human rights. As the policy of the Bush administration in this case has obviously damaged the United States' reputation, the Democratic view is that the detention camp has to be shut down as soon as possible. Maybe surprisingly for some people, who expected that a Republican would argue for the need to keep up the detention center, McCain goes along with the Democrats and promises to close Camp Justice as soon as possible. Arguably, his view on Guantanamo Bay is influenced by his own experience: During the Vietnam War, he was captured as a prisoner of war by the North Vietnamese and held under arrest from 1967 to 1973, himself experiencing episodes of torture there.
A point of contention, however, seems to be the embargo on Cuba, which is in effect for 50 years now. There is no clear statement regarding the issue on Obama's own website, but in his speech to the Cuban-American National Foundation (CANF) in Miami on May 23, 2008 he said he would end “the Bush administration’s draconian and counterproductive limits on both family travel and cash remittances sent to Cuba”27. In public discussions, Obama has been accused of "flip-flopping" about whether or not to lift the embargo: in 2004 he announced that he would end the embargo promptly, but on the mentioned occasion in Miami, he argued that he would not, because he still needed some leverage to put Raoul Castro under pressure. Hillary Clinton - just as McCain - opposes lifting the embargo, while Barack Obama seems to hold that the embargo cannot realize its original goal of collapsing the communist party, as it has adverse effects on the economic well-being of the Cuban people rather than on its government. In the end it appears as if the candidates’ positions have converged. While Obama argues for a normalization of American-Cuban relations and a diplomatic solution, McCain - though having opposed a lift of the embargo – announces that „[m]y administration will (…) also prepare immediately for Cuba's transition to democracy by developing a plan with regional and European partners for a post-Castro Cuba so as to be ready to spark rapid change in that long-suffering country when the time comes.” 28
Chapter Summaries
1) Introduction: The introduction places the 2008 presidential election in the context of dissatisfaction with the Bush administration and introduces the paper’s foreign policy focus.
2.1) On Environment & Natural Resources: This section compares the candidates’ approaches to climate change, energy independence and nuclear power.
2.2) On Future Diplomacy: The discussion considers American leadership, multilateralism and cooperation with allies.
2.3) On Relationship to…: This section compares positions on international organisations, individual countries and regions, including several Middle Eastern conflicts.
2.4) On Terrorism: The paper examines approaches to counterterrorism, prevention and nuclear proliferation.
2.5) Military Plans: This section considers proposals for military resources, personnel, equipment and training.
3) Personal Opinion: The author reflects on the candidates’ positions and expresses a preference for diplomatic approaches.
Keywords
US foreign policy, 2008 presidential election, John McCain, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, diplomacy, international relations, climate change, energy policy, Iraq, Iran, Cuba, terrorism, military policy
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the paper about?
It compares the foreign policy perspectives of John McCain, Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama during the 2008 presidential campaign.
What are its central topics?
It addresses energy, diplomacy, international relationships, Middle Eastern security, terrorism and military policy.
What is the paper’s main objective?
It seeks to identify differences in emphasis and similarities in the candidates’ foreign policy outlooks.
What method does the author use?
The author compares the candidates’ statements and policy positions using published material, primarily internet sources. No formal research method is specified.
What does the main body cover?
It compares positions across policy areas and relationships with countries, regions and international organisations.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include US foreign policy, the 2008 presidential election, diplomacy, climate change, Iraq, terrorism and military policy.
Why does the comparison focus particularly on McCain and Obama?
Clinton ended her campaign on June 7, 2008, so the author concentrates on the remaining Democratic and Republican candidates while retaining Clinton’s positions where relevant.
How does the paper address Cuba and Guantanamo?
It considers the candidates’ positions on closing the detention camp and on the Cuban embargo and US-Cuban relations.
Does the paper include the author’s own assessment?
Yes. A final section presents the author’s personal reflections on the candidates’ foreign policy approaches.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Bernadette-Julia Felsch (Autor:in), 2008, The differing foreign policy perspectives of Senators John McCain, Hillary Rodham Clinton and Barack Obama , München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/124413