The eighty-five essays, today commonly referred to as The Federalist Papers,
were written in 1787 and 1788 in order to help in securing the ratification of the
proposed United States Constitution in the State of New York. Although the essays
were all signed Publius, they were written by three men of different background and,
to some extent, different political ideas. John Jay, Alexander Hamilton and James
Madison have contributed to the Papers in different quantity. Due to an illness Jay
has contributed only five articles. Hamilton’s and Madison’s contributions are not
always easy to separate but most scholars ascribe twenty-nine articles to Madison
and fifty-one to Hamilton. The authorship of essays “18-20, 49-58, and 62-63 was
the subject of heated historical controversy for more than a century and a half,
because both Hamilton and Madison allegedly claimed authorship of these essays.”
The object of this paper is to analyze the rhetorical approach of Madison and
Hamilton in selected papers. Also, an attempt will be made to determine if, and to
what extent their rhetorical style and political ideas are distinguishable even under
the joint guise of Publius.
The analysis will be undertaken on the examples of four selected papers – No. 10,
54, 84 and 85, which were chosen as representatives of the respective author’s style,
since a detailed analysis of all 85 papers would be to extensive for a term paper.
Contributions by John Jay are deliberately left out since they consist of only 5 papers
which are arguably among the less important ones. Federalist No.10 was chosen as the most famous of Madison’s contributions due to
its prominence within the scholarly debate and the prevailing significance of the
problem discussed in the essay – the dangers or factions within a republic system.
No. 54 was chosen as an example of disputed authorship and due to its treatment of
the complex problem of slavery in regard to the number of Representatives of Southern States. A special interest lies in the author’s approach to distinguish the
slaves status of being ‘people’ and ‘property’ at the same time. No. 84 was chosen
due to Hamilton’s interesting rhetorical treatment of and political stance on the bill of
rights. No. 85 was chosen because of its importance as a conclusion to the complete
work and arguments of the whole body of texts. [...]
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Analyzes Federalist Papers No. 10, No. 54, No. 84, and No. 85
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Historical Background
3. Analysis of selected Federalist Papers
3.1. Federalist No. 10
3.2. Federalist No. 54
3.3. Federalist No. 84
3.4. Federalist Nr. 85
4. Summary and Conclusion
Main Objectives and Topics
This paper aims to analyze the rhetorical approach of James Madison and Alexander Hamilton in selected Federalist Papers to determine if and to what extent their rhetorical styles and political ideas are distinguishable under the pseudonym Publius.
- Rhetorical analysis of selected Federalist Papers (No. 10, 54, 84, and 85)
- Historical background of the United States Constitution ratification
- Investigation of political ideas, factions, slavery, and the bill of rights
- Comparison of Madison's and Hamilton's writing styles and argumentation strategies
Excerpt from the Book
3.1. Federalist No. 10
At the beginning of Federalist No. 9 Hamilton has already warned the audience of the danger of domestic factions giving examples of how such influences have endangered the classic republics and states in Greece and Italy. Madison begins No. 10 by repeating Hamilton’s emphasis of the advantages the Union would have in controlling such influences and addresses the task of his essay to the examination of the nature of factions and to a solution of the problems they cause.
There is, of course, some rhetorical embellishment. From the start, Madison endows the Union directly with positive attributes like having "numerous advantages" and being "well-constructed". He continues to describe the present state of affairs by a series of antitheses, opposing the "adversaries to liberty", who use the current chaos for their own goals, to the "most considerate and virtuous citizens" who fear for the public and private good. Thus he makes it obvious that he wishes to address the latter and solve their problems and to, at the same time, oppose the former.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: Introduces the background of the Federalist Papers and outlines the core objective to analyze the rhetorical approaches of Madison and Hamilton through four specific essays.
2. Historical Background: Outlines the historical context following the Declaration of Independence, the shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation, and the intense political struggle surrounding the ratification of the new Constitution.
3. Analysis of selected Federalist Papers: Provides an in-depth examination of Federalist Papers No. 10, 54, 84, and 85, focusing on their arguments regarding factions, slavery, the bill of rights, and state constitutions.
4. Summary and Conclusion: Synthesizes the main rhetorical devices used by the authors and compares the distinct styles of Madison and Hamilton based on historical and biographical approaches.
Keywords
Federalist Papers, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, Publius, US Constitution, Rhetoric, Factions, Slavery, Bill of Rights, Political Philosophy, American History
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary subject of this work?
The work examines the rhetorical strategies and political ideas of Alexander Hamilton and James Madison within selected essays of the Federalist Papers.
What are the central thematic fields covered?
The core themes include the historical background of the US Constitution, the management of political factions, the debate over slavery, and arguments surrounding the bill of rights.
What is the primary research question or objective?
The main objective is to analyze the rhetorical approaches of Madison and Hamilton and to determine whether their individual styles and political ideas remain distinguishable under the shared pseudonym Publius.
Which academic methods are applied in the paper?
The paper utilizes textual and rhetorical analysis, examining stylistic devices such as logos, ethos, pathos, and hypophora in historical political writings.
What does the main body of the work focus on?
The main body provides detailed textual analyses of Federalist No. 10 (factions), No. 54 (slavery and representation), No. 84 (opposition to the bill of rights), and No. 85 (concluding arguments).
Which keywords characterize the publication?
Key terms include Federalist Papers, Hamilton, Madison, Publius, Constitution, rhetoric, factions, and bill of rights.
Why were specifically Federalist Papers No. 10, 54, 84, and 85 chosen for analysis?
They were selected as representative samples of the authors' distinct styles and because analyzing all 85 papers would exceed the scope of a term paper.
How does Madison approach the problem of factions in Federalist No. 10?
Madison defines factions, evaluates methods to cure them, and argues that a representative republic is best suited to control the mischiefs of faction.
How does Federalist No. 54 address the issue of slavery?
It defends the three-fifths compromise through the rhetorical device of a fictional Southern speaker, balancing property considerations with human representation.
What conclusion does the author draw regarding Madison and Hamilton's styles?
The author concludes that Madison's rhetorical approach is generally more subtle and cautious, whereas Hamilton's style tends to be more straightforward, aggressive, and polemical.
- Quote paper
- Jelena Vukadinovic (Author), 2008, The Rhetorical Approach in the Federalist Papers No.10, No.54, No.84 and No.85, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/126097