This essay compares the classical social contract theories of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau. Different perceptions of the state of nature resulted in different ideas about the social contract and its emphasis on either security (Hobbes), individual rights (Locke) or the collective freedom of Rousseau's general will. Political philosophy is believed to have started with Plato’s “Republic”, the first known
sophisticated analysis of a fundamental question that humans have probably been
concerned with much longer: how should human society be organised, i.e. who
should rule and why? Plato believed that ruling required special training and skills
and should therefore be left to an aristocracy of guardians who had received
extensive training. While the notion that ruling requires expertise can hardly be
denied there is also agreement among most philosophers that whoever qualifies for
the job of ruling needs to do so with the interest of the people in mind. But what is the
interest of the people and how can it be discovered? According to Plato, a necessary
precondition for rulers is wisdom and that is why he wanted his guardians to be
especially trained in philosophy. One may think that the people themselves should
know what is best for them but somewhat surprisingly this idea has been rejected not
just by Plato but also by many philosophers following him. Another approach is to link
rule on Earth to a mandate received from a divine Creator. However, even the idea
that humans could not exist without a government has been questioned, most
notably by anarchism.
Thus, the question of how political rule, the power to make decisions for others, could
be justified is an essential one. Only legitimate rule creates obligation and without
obligation it is hard to see how any form of society can survive.
It is precisely for these elementary questions that social contract theories attempt to
provide an answer for. The social contract can be seen as a device both for justifying
not only rule itself but a particular type of rule, and demonstrating that political
obligation can indeed be demanded. A unique feature of the classical social contract
theories discussed in this paper is that they started out with an analysis of the state
of nature.
Contents
Introduction
1. The State of Nature
1.1. Human Nature
1.2. Liberty and Equality in the State of Nature
1.3. Laws and Rights of Nature
1.4. Summary
2. The Social Contract
2.1. Nature and Purpose of the Contract
2.2. The Sovereign
2.3. Liberty and Equality
2.4. The Problem of Consent
2.5. The Impact of Classical Social Contract Theories
Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This work compares the classical social contract theories of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau, asking how their accounts of the state of nature and political agreement justify political rule and the obligation to obey it. It examines how differences in their assumptions lead to different conceptions of government, rights and freedom.
- Human nature and the state of nature
- Natural liberty, equality, rights and law
- The purpose and terms of the social contract
- Sovereignty and the powers of government
- Consent and political obligation
- The influence of classical contract theories
Excerpt from the Book
1.1. Human Nature
It is probably fair to assume that state and society impose several restrictions on natural human behaviour or even alter it. If an accurate assessment could be made about human nature without these restrictions or alterations it would not only be possible to develop a better understanding of the state of nature, but also to theorise about the form of society that is best suited to accommodate original human behaviour. Not surprisingly, there are considerable differences regarding human nature among the three philosophers examined here.
According to Hobbes, human nature is characterised by a constant drive for felicity. Humans will always desire something and felicity can only arise if these desires are achieved. Hardly anyone would deny that humans have desires but do we continuously crave for them? Is it not conceivably that there are periods in a human existence where those desires do not affect our behaviour? For Hobbes, the answer is no. Borrowing from Galileo’s principle of the conservation of motion he believes humans are essentially restless. Our desires act like a force upon us and will do so until substituted by a greater force: a new desire. In order to gain what they desire humans have to be powerful. Hobbes defines power as “one’s present means to obtain some future apparent Good”. It follows from this that to satisfy their desires and to achieve felicity humans not only have to be powerful but also have to constantly increase their power because one “cannot assure the power and means to live well, which he hath present, without the acquisition of more”. Thus, Hobbes depicts humans as naturally autonomous individuals who are egoistically only concerned with themselves.
Unlike Hobbes, Locke does not elaborate on human nature as he starts with a different premise. For Locke, Earth and human life on it are the creation of an almighty God who, Locke assumes, would not equip His children with purely egoistic qualities. Humans would have a sense of morality towards their fellow human beings to ensure the preservation of all mankind.
A radically different approach is taken by Rousseau. He criticises both Hobbes and Locke for having imposed social attributes on human nature. Rousseau believes that human nature has been corrupted by society and desires are only a product of this corruption. Thus by “constantly dwelling on wants, avidity, oppression, desires, and pride, [they (Hobbes and Locke) have] transferred to the state of nature ideas which were acquired in society; so that, in speaking of the savage, they described the social man”. Humans in the state of nature are solitary beings who, according to Rousseau, are nevertheless equipped with two main qualities: compassion and the capacity for self- improvement. Compassion for others leads Rousseau to depict humans in the state of nature as “noble savages”, but the capacity of self- improvement ultimately results in the formation of civil society and the corruption of man.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction frames the justification of political rule and obligation as fundamental questions of political philosophy. It introduces the social contract and the state of nature as devices for addressing them.
1. The State of Nature: This chapter compares the three philosophers’ accounts of human nature, liberty, equality, natural rights and natural law. It considers how their accounts of life without government inform their reasons for establishing political society.
2. The Social Contract: This chapter compares the purpose of the contract, sovereignty, liberty and equality in civil society. It also considers the problem of consent and the influence of classical contract theories.
Conclusion: The conclusion returns to the question of whether social contract theories justify rule and political obligation. It reflects on the difficulties of consent and the continuing significance of the debate.
Keywords
social contract, political obligation, legitimacy, state of nature, human nature, natural law, natural rights, sovereignty, liberty, equality, consent, civil society, general will, political philosophy
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It compares the classical social contract theories of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau and their approaches to justifying political rule.
What are its central themes?
The central themes include the state of nature, human nature, rights, sovereignty, liberty, equality and consent.
What question does the work seek to address?
It asks whether social contract theories can provide a satisfying justification for political rule and the obligation to obey it.
What method does the author use?
The author uses comparative philosophical analysis, drawing on the theorists’ arguments and published scholarship to examine similarities and differences.
What does the main discussion cover?
It first compares accounts of the state of nature, then examines the social contract, sovereign authority, freedom, equality, consent and the theories’ influence.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include social contract, state of nature, natural rights, sovereignty, political obligation, liberty, equality and consent.
How does the work approach the problem of consent?
It considers tacit consent as a proposed basis for political obligation and discusses David Hume’s objection that people may lack the means to leave a society.
What role does the general will play in the discussion of Rousseau?
The work examines the general will as a standard associated with the common interest and considers how it might be identified through the sovereign people’s legislative decisions.
Does the work consider later uses of social contract ideas?
Yes. It discusses John Rawls’s original position and considers the influence of Hobbes’s ideas on contemporary international relations theory.
- Quote paper
- Sebastian Erckel (Author), 2008, Classical Social Contract Theory, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/126144