This paper is aimed at showing why it is correct to call Edgar Allan Poe the godfather of crime fiction, and how much of an influence he actually was.
When we think of crime fiction two names immediately come to mind: Sherlock Holmes and, although maybe to a slightly lesser extent, Hercule Poirot. Their cases have been published all over the world, were an immediate success, and have since been adapted countless times for theater, radio, cinema, and TV. Although the first Sherlock Holmes case was published 120 years ago and Agatha Christie’s Poirot had his first appearance in 1914, their popularity remains unbroken until today.
Agatha Christie’s play "The Mousetrap" is "celebrating the 64th year of a record-breaking run during which over 26,000 performances have been given", and until today holds the "world record for the longest continuous run at one theatre" ("The Mousetrap"). And the latest Sherlock Holmes series Sherlock and Elementary have been renewed for their fifth and sixth season respectively.
It is safe to say their names have become household words for detective fiction. The name C. Auguste Dupin on the other hand is – at least today – relatively unknown, familiar probably only to the ardent crime fiction enthusiast. Yet, in literary circles "[t]he general critical consensus is that the detective story begins with Edgar Allan Poe, the ‘father’ of the detective genre".
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
2 History of Crime Fiction
3 Content and Storytelling
4 Character and Method
4.1 C. Auguste Dupin
4.2 Sherlock Holmes
4.3 Hercule Poirot
5 Plot Elements
6 Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This thesis examines the evolution of detective fiction by analyzing the character archetypes, narrative techniques, and structural motifs established by Edgar Allan Poe and further developed by Arthur Conan Doyle and Agatha Christie. The work explores how these authors transitioned from short stories to full-length novels while shaping the "godfather" role of Poe's C. Auguste Dupin as the template for subsequent investigative geniuses.
- The historical development of detective fiction from the classical age to the golden age.
- Comparative analysis of narrative structures, specifically the "Watson figure" as an essential storytelling device.
- Investigation of core methodology (ratiocination vs. psychology) and character traits among iconic detectives.
- Study of recurring plot motifs such as the locked-room mystery and the unjustly accused suspect.
- Evaluation of metafictional elements used to blur the boundaries between fiction and reality.
Excerpt from the Book
The Murders in the Rue Morgue
The Murders in the Rue Morgue is a short story written by the American author Edgar Allan Poe, published in 1841 in Graham’s Magazine. It is one of three short stories featuring C. Auguste Dupin and widely considered to be the first detective story. Until his tales of ratiocination, as he named them, Poe had mostly written gothic novels and poems. His protagonist, the brilliant chevalier Dupin, solves seemingly insoluble cases through ratiocination – analytical deduction and induction.
The Murders in the Rue Morgue is introduced with “a few paragraphs of analysis that set the key for the rest” (Thomson 75). The unknown narrator proposes a few theories regarding the analytical mind and then recounts how he met Dupin and gives an introduction of him. After a demonstration of his analytical abilities, Dupin and his companion concern themselves with a gruesome murder case of two women who had been found dead in their flat. At first the case seems to propose an insoluble problem, since apparently no one could have entered or left the apartment. After reading the newspaper articles and a close examination of the crime scene, Dupin concludes that the murder was in fact not really a murder at all and that an escaped orangutan had killed the two women.
The Murders in the Rue Morgue is told by an unnamed first-person narrator, who is Dupin’s only friend and living companion. Even though the story is narrated from his point-of-view, he is nevertheless not the hero of the story but the interested by-stander recounting it.
The unnamed companion is rather dimwitted and slow in the uptake. He is not a keen observer and he is not blessed with any of the analytical abilities Dupin possesses so abundantly. He is therefore constantly astonished by the conclusions Dupin puts forth to him and he admires him greatly.
Summary of Chapters
Introduction: Provides the historical context and identifies the core objective of analyzing Poe, Doyle, and Christie as pillars of detective fiction.
History of Crime Fiction: Offers an overview of the socio-cultural evolution of the genre, noting the shift toward rational explanation in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Content and Storytelling: Analyzes the use of debut novels and the first-person narrator as a strategy to filter information and build mystery.
Character and Method: Detailed profiles of Dupin, Holmes, and Poirot, focusing on their unique approaches to investigation and their relationships to the police and sidekicks.
Plot Elements: Explores universal tropes like the locked-room mystery, the unjustly accused, and the final missing link.
Conclusion: Synthesizes the legacy of Poe as the structural foundation upon which Doyle and Christie built their successful, more refined detective models.
Keywords
Crime Fiction, C. Auguste Dupin, Sherlock Holmes, Hercule Poirot, Ratiocination, Detective Story, Watson Figure, Locked-Room Mystery, Metafiction, Edgar Allan Poe, Golden Age, Deduction, Induction, Narrative Structure, Genre Evolution.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary focus of this thesis?
The work focuses on the evolution of detective fiction by comparing the methodologies and narrative traits of C. Auguste Dupin, Sherlock Holmes, and Hercule Poirot.
Who are the main figures analyzed in this research?
The central figures are Edgar Allan Poe's C. Auguste Dupin, Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes, and Agatha Christie's Hercule Poirot.
What is the thesis's position on Edgar Allan Poe?
The paper argues that despite his later detectives being more commercially successful, Poe remains the "godfather" of crime fiction, having provided the fundamental template for the genre.
What scientific or logical methods are identified in these stories?
The paper highlights "ratiocination" (analytical deduction and induction) as the primary method, later evolving into the psychological and observational insights used by Poirot.
How does the narrator contribute to the story structure?
The "Watson figure" serves as a narrative device that filters information to the reader, emphasizing the detective's superior intellect while maintaining suspense.
What characterize the genre-defining keywords of this study?
Key terms include Ratiocination, Deductive Reasoning, The Watson Figure, and the Golden Age of detective fiction.
Why is the "locked-room mystery" motif significant in this context?
It represents the genre's fascination with apparent impossibilities and the subsequent need for a rational, scientific explanation to resolve the enigma.
How does the role of the police differ across the studied authors?
While the detectives often assist the police, they typically maintain a condescending or superior attitude toward the official forces, highlighting the need for private, analytical investigation.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Nadja Niyaz (Autor:in), 2017, Crime Fiction. Dupin vs. Sherlock and Poirot, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1289823
