In the 1970s the aim of the new Indonesians government was to lead the diverse, multicultural state to a national unity. This was a difficult task for which good ideas were necessary. By promoting tourism the government devised the most successful solution to approximate the aim of unity. Now, the government overlooked the historical ethnic boundaries and cultural and religious differences of some ethnic groups in Indonesia. Therefore some problems arised which must be seen as a threat for the national unity. In this homework I try to show which positive and negative effects the governments efforts had by promoting provincial identities as tourist destinations. I will show mainly the negative results of the governments tourist campaigns with the example of Toraja in South Sulawesi, Indonesia.
Table of Contents
Introduction
1. The unity of Indonesia
2. Tourism policy in Indonesia
3. Tourism and nation-building in South Sulawesi
3.1. The religious and social relations of two different ethnic groups in South Sulawesi in a short history
3.2. How tourism came to Tana Toraja
3.3. The primadonas of South Sulawesi
3.4. The new reasons of envy by age-old ethnic groups because of promoting special touristic destinations
3.5 Positive and negative experiences with domestic tourism refering to interethnic relations and nation-building
Conclusions
Aims and Themes
This paper examines how Indonesian tourism promotion and the construction of provincial identities relate to national unity. Using Tana Toraja in South Sulawesi as its principal example, it asks how tourism can foster connections between ethnic groups while also intensifying existing rivalries.
- Nation-building and Indonesia's cultural diversity
- Domestic tourism campaigns and provincial identities
- Historical relations between Torajans and Buginese-Makassarese
- The promotion of Tana Toraja and competing destinations
- Tourist guiding, representation and access to employment
- Encounters between domestic tourists and local communities
Excerpt from the Book
3.1.The religious and social relations of two different ethnic groups in South Sulawesi in a short history
In South Sulawesi exists among other little groups two different main ethnic groups - the Torajans and the Buginese-Makassarese. These groups are naturally separated by high mountains and had therefore a long time no real contact to each other. This is maybe one reason why both groups live in such different cultures. They had contacts in so far as the lowland-Buginese- Makassarese always tried to force their islamic religion upon the Torajans from the highlands. In the late 19th century the lowlanders raided and traded with frequency the highlands of Toraja and robbed from there coffee, slaves and other " good sources".
In 1920 began after the conquest of the Dutch in 1902 a long time of missionary work in Toraja. After the occupation of the Japanese from 1942 to 1945 and a bad, cruel time of suppression the Dutch returned again to Toraja. In 1949 started with the Indonesian independence a fifteen years long guerilla warfare led by South Sulawesi Muslim rebels. The end of these insurrections were in 1965. As a result a big rush of Torajans began emigrating into bigger towns with the hope to find a job. Consequently lived in 1985 230,000 Torajans outside of Toraja. In memory of the cruel time of Muslim rebellions and hence because of big fears of forced Islamicization more and more Torajans converted to the Chistianity.
Between 1950 and 1960 the number of conversions rose from 23,000 to 90,000. It was no problem to make the rituals of the Torajans suitable to the aspects of the christian religion. Non-religion aspects of the Torajans culture could be retained and other, pagan-like, religious parts had to be replaced by christian elements. After a countermove for the revival of tradition ( aluk ) in a new, cleaned-up, nationalized form, the "new" religion got in 1969 the legitimation from the Jakarta`s Ministry of Religion which declared it to be a branch of Hindu Dharma - the local religion of Bali. Now the Torajans had a religion with national status and by promoting their new aluk they showed the Muslims their insurance not to be forced to Islam ( Volkman,1990).
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction sets out the tension between national unity and the promotion of provincial identities, identifying Tana Toraja as the main example.
1. The unity of Indonesia: This chapter outlines the New Order's nation-building objectives and the challenges posed by Indonesia's ethnic and geographical diversity.
2. Tourism policy in Indonesia: The discussion considers domestic tourism, national campaigns and the promotion of cultural sites as instruments of national integration.
3. Tourism and nation-building in South Sulawesi: This chapter traces historical relations between ethnic groups, the growth of tourism in Tana Toraja, competition between destinations, disputes over guiding and encounters with domestic visitors.
Conclusions: The closing section considers both the potential contribution of tourism to national unity and the tensions associated with promoting particular destinations.
Keywords
Indonesia, South Sulawesi, Tana Toraja, nation-building, national unity, domestic tourism, tourism policy, provincial identity, ethnic relations, Torajans, Buginese-Makassarese, tourist guides, cultural representation
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It explores the relationship between tourism promotion and nation-building in Indonesia, focusing on South Sulawesi.
What are the main themes?
The paper addresses national identity, provincial tourism promotion, ethnic relations, cultural representation and domestic tourism.
What is the paper's primary question?
It asks how promoting provincial identities as tourist destinations can both support and challenge national unity.
What research method does the author use?
The author develops a literature-based discussion of Indonesian tourism policy and South Sulawesi, drawing particularly on published work by Kathleen M. Adams and other cited authors.
What does the main discussion cover?
It covers the history of relations between Torajans and Buginese-Makassarese, the development of tourism in Tana Toraja, destination rivalry, tourist guiding and domestic visitors' encounters.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include nation-building, domestic tourism, Tana Toraja, provincial identity, ethnic relations and cultural representation.
Why is tourist guiding discussed?
The paper uses disputes over guide licensing and training to examine questions of access to tourism work and the representation of Torajan culture.
What role does Taman Budaya Sulawesi play in the discussion?
The park is considered as a tourism attraction associated with Visit Indonesia Year 1991 and with competition over the promotion of destinations in South Sulawesi.
- Quote paper
- Marion Zimmermann (Author), 1998, Tourism and nation-building in South Sulawesi: Tourism promotion as threat for national unity?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/12977