Two stories, two authors, two epochs – to compare them will be the purpose of this paper by focussing on the two portraits which are each the important element of their story. At the same time, confusing and paradoxical relationships between art, life and death constitute the thematic centre of both stories. The portraits, as pieces of visual art, are presented in a verbal or ekphrastic form. Why and how are they represented with words? To answer this questions I will first give an overview about ekphrastic theory, second classify the narrative situations, third compare the relations of observer and observed subject and finally by the discussion of their function and importance.
At a glance
- Applies Murray Krieger’s and W. J. T. Mitchell’s theories of ekphrasis
- 25 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
2 Ekphrastic Theory
3 Analysis
3.1 The narrative structure of “The Oval Portrait” and “The Picture of Dorian Gray”
3.2 Who watches whom?
3.3 Ekphrastic characteristics
3.3.1 The Titles
3.3.2 “The Oval Portrait”
3.3.3 “The Picture of Dorian Gray”
3.4 The importance of the portraits
4 Conclusion
Aim and Topics
This paper compares the use of ekphrasis in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Oval Portrait” and Oscar Wilde’s “The Picture of Dorian Gray”. It asks why and how the portraits in these works are represented in words, examining narrative structure, relationships between observers and observed subjects, and the function of the portraits.
- Ekphrastic theory and the relationship between words and images
- Narrative framing, focalisation and time
- Acts of looking and relationships between observers and subjects
- Descriptions of fictional portraits
- Art, life, death and identity
Excerpt from the Book
Who watches whom?
A very interesting question for both stories is the question: Who watches whom? In case of “The Oval Portrait” there is quite a wide range of pairings figuring an opposition between live and art, “between one who gazes and one who is gazed at”37. In this context, both parts of the story, the framing story of the wounded narrator and the anecdote in the volume are mixed up. Relationships exist between the painter and his idealized bride , the woman and her painted analogy, the portrait and the narrator, as well as the anecdote and the narrator ´s story. The painter gazes at his bride and her portrait while he translates her into it – this can be seen as a double–translation. The woman herself is transformed into her portrait which retains something vivid of its model. The narrator gazes the portrait of the young bride and describes it for the reader so that in his or her imagination arises a mental image of the picture. And the whole story is translated into words, so the reader gets both stories – the one of the narrator and the one of the painter and his bride - in a textual form. The second story is already written when the narrator is introduced to it, so a parallel reading of the narrator and the reader can be assumed.
Also in “The Picture of Dorian Gray” diverse pairings can be determined. Firstly, we have Basil Hallward who is gazing and painting Dorian Gray. Secondly, Lord Henry Wotton is gazing Dorian Gray whom he sees as an experiment of his Hedonism. Dorian “could be fashioned into a marvellous type…He could be made a Titan or a toy” (D.G.: 53). Further more and most important it is Dorian Gray who is gazing at his portrait as “Höhepunkt und Zentrum seines Begehrens”38 and himself as a person outside a world of moral and inside an aestheticistic world. He also gazes on the actress Sybil Vane:
Night after night I go to see her play. One evening she is Rosalind. And the next evening she is Imogen. I have seen her die… I have watched her wandering through the forest of Arden…I have seen her in every age and in every costume. (D.G.: 67)
Dorian also gazed at several young men who admired him, spent their time with him and ended in moral or social descent. In the further action Dorian again is gazed at by Basil Hallward who tries to be his moral conscience and has to pay for it by death. Another gazing person is James Vane. He tries to find the “Prince Charming” who has led his sister to suicide. Another observer is the high society of London which has already realized Dorian`s moral decline.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction situates Poe and Wilde in their respective literary contexts and presents the paper’s comparative questions about the verbal representation of portraits.
Ekphrastic Theory: This chapter discusses definitions and historical conceptions of ekphrasis, drawing particularly on Murray Krieger and W. J. T. Mitchell.
Analysis: The analysis compares narrative structures, relationships between observers and observed subjects, ekphrastic passages and the significance of the portraits in the two works.
Conclusion: The conclusion revisits the comparison of art and life, patterns of observation and the relationship between imagined portraits and literary texts.
Keywords
ekphrasis, Edgar Allan Poe, Oscar Wilde, The Oval Portrait, The Picture of Dorian Gray, visual representation, literary analysis, portraiture, narrative structure, focalisation, spectatorship, aestheticism, art and life
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It compares the verbal representation of portraits in Poe’s “The Oval Portrait” and Wilde’s “The Picture of Dorian Gray”.
What are its central themes?
Its central themes include ekphrasis, narrative perspective, observation, portraiture, and the relationships between art, life and death.
What is the main research question?
The paper asks why and how the portraits in the two literary works are represented in words.
What method does the author use?
The author uses comparative literary analysis, informed by ekphrastic theory and close attention to narrative structure, perspective and descriptions of the portraits.
What does the main analysis cover?
It examines the structure of each narrative, patterns of looking, ekphrastic characteristics and the importance of the portraits.
Which keywords characterise the paper?
Key terms include ekphrasis, portraiture, visual representation, narrative structure, spectatorship and aestheticism.
How does the paper approach the act of looking?
It identifies relationships between people who observe and those who are observed, including painters, their subjects, narrators and viewers of the portraits.
Which ekphrastic theorists are discussed?
The theoretical chapter discusses Murray Krieger and W. J. T. Mitchell, among others, in considering the relationship between verbal and visual representation.
How does the analysis address narrative structure?
It considers Poe’s framed tale and wounded narrator alongside Wilde’s use of dialogue, focalisation and the passage of time.
- Quote paper
- Nancy Reinhardt (Author), 2007, The use of ekphrasis in comparison of Edgar Allan Poes´s 'The Oval Portrait' and Oscar Wilde´s 'The Picture of Dorian Gray', Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/131489