Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › English Language and Literature Studies - Linguistics

What is a Compound? Stress in English Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions

Title: What is a Compound? Stress in English Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions

Essay , 2020 , 11 Pages , Grade: 1,0

Autor:in: Sebastian Just (Author)

English Language and Literature Studies - Linguistics
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

The question, whether a construction consisting of two or more nouns can automatically be considered a compound has been subject to discussion amongst many linguists. The topic seems to be of particular importance because it sheds some light on the relationship between morphology and syntax in the English language.

The Cambridge Dictionary defines a compound as “a word that combines two or more different words“, which at first glance implies that a construction of two nouns can always be considered a compound. In fact, the matter linguists are discordant about is whether all noun-plus-noun (N+N) construction can be considered morphological compounds – or in other words – if all compounds are derived from the lexicon and not also from the syntax. The main criterion, which the articles trying to solve this issue use as a basis of argumentation, is stress. More precisely, it is examined whether the first or the final constituent of the construction is emphasized.

To further examine this topic, I want to put in contrast two texts which are each based on a different view. At first I will look at “Compounding and stress in English: A closer look at the boundary between morphology and syntax“ by Susan Olsen, which was published in the German linguistic journal Linguistische Berichte in 2000. The second text will be “Compound or phrase? English noun-plus-noun constructions and the stress criterion“ by Heinz J. Giegerich, an article first published in the international linguistic journal English Language and Linguistics in 2004. The purpose is to determine whether the two perceptions are completely dissenting or if some accordance can be found in certain arguments.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Compares Susan Olsen’s and Heinz J. Giegerich’s theories of compounds
  • Examines lexicalization and analogy through examples including “blackboard” and “whiteboard”

Contents

1. Introduction to Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions

2. Olsen’s Account of Compounds and Stress

3. Giegerich’s Account of Compounds and Phrases

4. Conclusion

Objectives and Themes

This work examines whether English noun-plus-noun constructions are necessarily morphological compounds or whether some are syntactic phrases. It compares Susan Olsen’s and Heinz J. Giegerich’s accounts, asking where their arguments about stress, meaning and structure agree or diverge.

  • Stress patterns in compounds and phrases
  • The boundary between morphology and syntax
  • Compound-internal and compound-external meaning
  • Complement-head and attribute-head constructions
  • Lexicalization, analogy and exceptions

Excerpt from the Book

What is a compound?

Giegerich recognizes that final-stressed constructions are those where the first noun functions as an attribute towards the head noun (e.g. plastic box) and that in CHCs, the first noun functions as the object of the second.

For Giegerich’s theory to be true, CHCs must show similar behavior as other syntactic phrases, e.g. adjective+noun constructions. The first criterion is the final-stress characteristic of phrases, the second is that the meaning is clear (transparency) and that they are always available (productivity) – the third is that the pre-head relational entity of a phrase is a modifier or an attribute, so consequently nouns must be able to functions as attributes.

“Plastic box” is, according to Giegerich, a syntactic phrase, in which “plastic” functions as the adjective modifying the head “box”. Since there is no fitting adjective that describes how something is made out of plastic, a noun is used (other examples would be “stone tower” or “concrete floor”). The pre-head nouns are not fixed and can be moved around when in combination with another entities:

41) [new [plastic box]] (a new box that is made of plastic)
42) [[colored plastic] box] (a box that is made out of colored plastic)

Also, the pre-head nouns can be listed in combination with other adjectives (43) and the head itself can be replaced with “one” (44).

43) We have wooden and plastic boxes.
44) We have a wooden box and a plastic one.

Giegerich also looks at the behavior of lexical compounds, using the lexicalist hypothesis to argue for the difference of CHCs and AHCs. CHCs, unlike syntactic phrases, can’t be used in an anaphora (45) and the first noun can’t be modified (46).

45) *a gun owner and a knife one
46) [deadly [gun owner]] vs. *[[deadly gun] owner]

In 47, CHCs with right-conjoined constituents are compared with simple nouns with a right-conjoined foot. A foot represents the stress structure of a word and consists of a strong syllable and one (or more) weak syllable, with the strong one being stressed. The foot whose strong syllable is stressed more has primary stress. In 48, a non-complex CHC with no right-conjoined noun is compared to a simple noun with no right-conjoined foot.

47) afternoon [bike tour] vs. natio[nality]
48) clan leader vs. table

In both cases, lexical compounds show the same stress patterns as simple nouns, what reinforces that they share the same behavior.

Chapter Summaries

Introduction to Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions: The opening introduces the relationship between morphology and syntax and establishes stress as a central criterion in the debate over compounds.

Olsen’s Account of Compounds and Stress: This section discusses stress rules and Olsen’s distinction between compound-internal and compound-external meaning, using examples of differently stressed constructions.

Giegerich’s Account of Compounds and Phrases: The discussion turns to complement-head and attribute-head constructions, their structural properties, and the roles of lexicalization and analogy.

Conclusion: The final section brings the two accounts together, considering their points of agreement and their differing explanations of noun-plus-noun constructions.

Keywords

English linguistics, word formation, noun-plus-noun constructions, compounds, stress patterns, morphology, syntax, lexicalization, analogy, compound-internal meaning, compound-external meaning, complement-head constructions, attribute-head constructions

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this work about?

It examines how English noun-plus-noun constructions are classified as compounds or phrases, with particular attention to stress.

What are its central themes?

Its themes include word formation, stress, the relationship between morphology and syntax, semantic interpretation and lexicalization.

What is the main research question?

The work asks whether noun-plus-noun constructions are all morphological compounds and compares two accounts to identify agreements and differences.

What method does the author use?

The author compares and discusses two published linguistic articles, drawing on their arguments and examples.

What does the main discussion cover?

It presents Olsen’s account of compound meaning and Giegerich’s distinction between lexical compounds and syntactic phrases, including examples and exceptions.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include compounds, stress patterns, morphology, syntax, lexicalization and noun-plus-noun constructions.

How are compound-internal and compound-external meaning discussed?

They are presented as categories in Olsen’s account for interpreting relationships between the constituents of noun-plus-noun constructions.

Why does the discussion consider “blackboard” and “whiteboard”?

These examples illustrate Giegerich’s discussion of lexicalization and the formation of compounds by analogy.

Excerpt out of 11 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
What is a Compound? Stress in English Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions
College
Humboldt-University of Berlin  (Institut für Anglistik und Amerikanistik)
Course
Word Formation
Grade
1,0
Author
Sebastian Just (Author)
Publication Year
2020
Pages
11
Catalog Number
V1335594
ISBN (PDF)
9783346861726
Language
English
Tags
nouns compound linguistics english anglistic noun stress
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Sebastian Just (Author), 2020, What is a Compound? Stress in English Noun-Plus-Noun Constructions, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1335594
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  11  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract