This Master Thesis tries to analyze how both, sport and agile, could benefit from methods rooted in the other area respectively and where they have the same roots that could be utilized more efficiently. To analyze the current situation, a systematic literature review was conducted, trying to detect best practices and to receive a glimpse of the status quo.
Sport organizations as well as agile businesses are powered by the same engine: People. As these two areas here definitely have a common ground it would be interesting to see where else they could benefit and improve by orienting on the other area. One factor that needs to receive attention here is the impact of how people are educated, led, organized, and coached.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Systematic review followed 61 selected papers with backward and forward searches
- Examines four team coaching models identified by Peters and Carr
- 129 sources in the bibliography
Contents
Abstract
1 Introduction
2 Method
2.1 Research Questions
2.2 Review scope
2.3 Conceptualization
2.4 Literature search
2.5 Search results
2.6 Comments on the characteristics of this literature review
3 Success and failure
3.1 Potential success factors
3.2 Success factors for Olympic Sports
3.3 Performance factors
4 Organization
4.1 Change and innovation in organizations
4.2 Cooperation & competition in organizations
4.3 Comparison of sport and regular business organizations
4.4 Sport organizations
5 Organizational culture
5.1 Understanding organizational culture
5.2 Cultural identification
6 Resilience
6.1 How to improve resilience
6.2 Why resilience is important
7 Agile Methodology
7.1 The agile mindset
7.2 Key skills for innovation
7.3 Agile Organizations
7.4 Benefits and restrictions of agile
7.5 Implementing agile
8 Leadership
8.1 Leadership delimitations
8.2 Leader prerequisites
8.2.1 Leader’s traits
8.2.2 Leader’s attributes
8.2.3 Leader’s behavior
8.3 Leadership styles
8.3.1 Hierarchical or traditional leadership
8.3.2 Affiliative leadership & charismatic leadership
8.3.3 Commanding leadership, directive leadership and pacesetting leadership
8.3.4 Transactional leadership
8.3.5 Empowering leadership
8.3.6 Transformational leadership and visionary leadership
8.3.7 Coaching leadership
8.3.8 Shared identity leadership
8.3.9 Shared leadership
Leadership roles within shared leadership
Benefits of shared leadership
Selection of leaders in shared leadership
Barriers and disadvantages of shared leadership
8.3.10 Summary of leadership styles
8.3.11 Hybrid leadership
8.3.12 Strength-based leader development
8.3.13 Change implementation in leadership
8.3.14 Leadership development
8.3.15 Creative Leadership Model
8.3.16 Athlete leadership
9 Learning & Development
9.1 Learning methods
9.1.1 Experiential learning & development
9.1.2 Interdisciplinary learning
9.1.3 Collaborative learning
9.1.4 Setting learning goals
9.1.5 Single- and double-loop learning
9.2 Employee Training
9.3 Development
9.3.1 Individual development
9.3.2 Team-based development
10 Teams
10.1 Team processes & teamwork
10.2 Team effectiveness
10.2.1 Team design
10.2.2 Collective intelligence
10.2.3 Decision-making and information sharing
10.2.4 Shared leadership and clear role distribution
10.2.5 Interpersonal conflict and positive organizational behavior
10.2.6 Team learning
10.2.7 Task relevancy and organizational context
10.2.8 Communication
10.2.9 Team cohesion
10.2.10 Team performance models
11 Coaching
Complexity leadership theory
11.1 Functions and responsibilities of a coach
11.2 Coaching competence and knowledge
11.3 Coaching outcomes
11.4 Coaching effectiveness
11.5 Coaching success factors
11.6 Coach – coachee relationship
11.7 Coaching interventions
11.7.1 DLC in Coaching
11.7.2 Reflective practices
11.7.3 Positive psychology
11.7.4 Mindset training
11.7.5 Setting Performance Goals
11.8 Team coaching
11.8.1 Team coaching models
11.8.2 Team coaching interventions
11.8.3 Team coaching outcomes
11.9 Coaching of individuals
11.9.1 Executive / workplace coaching
11.9.2 Systemic coaching
11.9.3 Athlete coaching
11.9.4 Mentoring
Specifications of mentoring
Mentoring success
11.10 Coach development
11.11 How coaches learn to coach
11.11.1 Experiences as a practitioner
11.11.2 Informal and formal coach development
11.11.3 Learning individually
11.11.4 Learning from researchers
11.11.5 General conclusion
11.12 Learning approaches
12 Discussion
12.1 Limitations
12.2 Future research & theoretical implications
12.3 Practical implications
12.4 Conclusion
Aims and Topics
This thesis investigates what sport businesses and teams can learn from agile concepts and how sport coaching methods might support agility in organizations. Through a systematic literature review, it explores possible transfers between the two fields and the organizational conditions that shape coaching.
- Agile methods, mindsets and organizational change
- Sport and business organizations, culture and resilience
- Leadership styles, shared leadership and team effectiveness
- Individual and team learning and development
- Coaching interventions, relationships and coach education
Excerpt from the Book
10 Teams
With growing complexity, organizations are increasingly dependent on teams (Salas, Cooke, & Rosen, 2008), the basic building blocks of organizational design (Emich et al., 2020), as they further highlight their function in maximizing an organizations human capital and a way to bring task demands and member skills together. Definitions of the term team throughout the literature consist mostly of the elements: (1) group of two or more individuals, (2) working towards common outcomes, (3) in specified roles with different responsibilities, (4) which are interdependent from each other (Cannon‐Bowers & Bowers, 2006). Further definitions add (5) social interaction, (6) that tasks for the team should be organizational relevant (Kozlowski & Ilgen, 2006; (Quigley, Collins, Gibson, & Parker, 2018), (7) that teams “are embedded in an encompassing organizational system” (Quigley et al., p. 789) and (8) that they interact adaptively (Salcinovic et al., 2022).
Taking these building blocks of the definition for team together, teams can be categorized in different ways as it is explained e.g., by Marks, Mathieu & Zarraro (2001) as they mention project, service, production, action/performing, management and parallel teams, while they mostly focus on the four first listed. An overlap can be found here, as Owusu (1999) suggests permanent functional / divisional teams that include production as a line of business and temporary project teams as well, while Bartlett & Drust (2020) use the term multi-disciplinary team for functional teams if they consist of specialists from different disciplines and inter-disciplinary team if the same is given but team members are also working interdependently (Salcinovic et al., 2022). Additionally, the already mentioned performance teams are teams that produce an organization’s product where the team members are majorly important for organizational success (Wolfe, et al., 2005). Some of these types of teams already highlight their function in their name, while Salcinovic et al. (2022) generalize the functions of teams with coordination ability and cooperative interaction to solve task objectives based on a shared understanding of a team, its (human) resources, goals, objectives, and the constraints of its environment.
Chapter Summaries
1 Introduction: Introduces the proposed exchange between sport coaching and agile practice, and explains the research gap.
2 Method: Sets out the research questions, review scope, search criteria and selection process for the systematic literature review.
3 Success and failure: Examines failure as a learning opportunity and discusses organizational and sporting performance factors.
4 Organization: Compares sport and business organizations, including innovation, competition, cooperation and management roles.
5 Organizational culture: Reviews approaches to understanding and shaping culture and considers identification with organizations and teams.
6 Resilience: Discusses team resilience, its development and its relevance under uncertainty.
7 Agile Methodology: Explores the agile mindset, innovation skills, organizational practices and challenges of implementation.
8 Leadership: Surveys leadership prerequisites and styles, including shared, hybrid, creative and athlete leadership.
9 Learning & Development: Considers learning methods, employee training and individual and team-based development.
10 Teams: Examines team processes and factors associated with team effectiveness and performance.
11 Coaching: Reviews coaching roles, interventions, team and individual coaching, mentoring and coach development.
12 Discussion: Synthesizes the review, acknowledges limitations and identifies practical implications and directions for further research.
Keywords
agile coaching, sport coaching, systematic literature review, agile methodology, organizational culture, resilience, leadership, shared leadership, team effectiveness, experiential learning, coaching interventions, coach development, organizational agility
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the thesis about?
It explores possible exchanges between agile approaches and sport coaching, including the organizational settings in which coaching takes place.
What are its central topics?
The thesis covers agility, organizational culture, resilience, leadership, learning, teams and coaching.
What is the main research question?
It asks what sport businesses and teams can learn from agile concepts and how sport coaching methods can influence agility in organizations.
What research method does the author use?
The author conducts a systematic literature review, supplemented by backward and forward searches and additional manually located literature.
What does the main body cover?
It moves from organizational and leadership concepts to team effectiveness, coaching interventions, mentoring and coach development.
Which keywords characterize the thesis?
Key terms include agile coaching, sport coaching, shared leadership, organizational culture, resilience, team effectiveness and coach development.
How does the thesis approach shared leadership?
It considers distributed leadership roles, potential benefits and barriers, and hybrid arrangements combining formal and shared leadership.
Which coaching interventions are discussed?
Examples include double-loop coaching, reflective practices, positive psychology, mindset training and performance goal setting.
Does the thesis distinguish team coaching from group coaching?
Yes. Drawing on the literature, it describes team coaching as focused on shared team goals and relationships, while group coaching brings individuals together who work toward their own goals.
- Quote paper
- Kersten Thiele (Author), 2022, Agile Concepts in Sport Businesses and Influence of Sport Coaching Methods in Organizations, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1337155