Task: Identify, analyze and discuss the treatment of two of the following themes (one from List A and one from List B) in poetry written in English in the British Isles since 1945. You should quote from two poems on each theme (a total of four different poems).
List A: Love, Loss, Death, Friendship, Loneliness/ Alienation
List B: Society, Politics, Nature/ Environment, Art, Language
Contents:
1. A comparison of the themes of ‘Death’ and ‘Loneliness’ in “Not Waving but Drowning” by Stevie Smith, and in “Warning” by Jenny Joseph
2. A comparison of the theme of ‘Society’ in “Poor Soul, Poor Girl!: A Debutante” by Stevie Smith, and in “This be the Verse” by Philip Larkin
Table of Contents
1. A comparison of the themes of ‘Death’ and ‘Loneliness’ in “Not Waving but Drowning” by Stevie Smith, and in “Warning” by Jenny Joseph
2. A comparison of the theme of ‘Society’ in “Poor Soul, Poor Girl!: A Debutante” by Stevie Smith, and in “This be the Verse” by Philip Larkin
3. Bibliography
Objectives and Themes
This academic paper examines the depiction of universal human themes such as death, loneliness, and societal pressure within selected British poetry written after 1945. The primary objective is to analyze how specific poets employ linguistic and structural stylistic devices to convey these complex conditions to the reader.
- Comparative analysis of death and loneliness in Stevie Smith and Jenny Joseph.
- Exploration of societal expectations and intergenerational conflict in poetry.
- Examination of stylistic devices such as rhyme schemes, meter, and anaphora.
- Evaluation of narrative voice and perspective in contemporary poetry.
- Critical interpretation of the interplay between form and thematic content.
Excerpt from the Book
A comparison of the themes of ‘Death’ and ‘Loneliness’ in “Not Waving but Drowning” by Stevie Smith, and in “Warning” by Jenny Joseph
To the present day there is no scientific evidence for a human creature coming back from the death, even though there are a number of people claiming to have had close-death experiences. A common theme in literature and film, there are a couple of works that attempt to describe how it would be to go through death and come back to life, among them the Resurrection of Christ in the Bible and Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, to mention a famous work. But also more recent pieces treat the same subject: the 1990 Columbia Tristar movie Flatliners shows a group of ambitious young scientists who, in an arrogant experiment, cross the border of life and death on purpose only to come back and describe the experience. All those works, however, are the bare attempt to paint a picture none of us will probably ever be able to verify. Literature, even so, has dealt with this subject for a long time and hand in hand with this goes also the theme of ‘Loneliness’, as everybody dies alone.
In her poem “Not Waving but Drowning” Stevie Smith deals with the both of the subjects exceedingly, no matter what short the text may look like at first glance. Using everyday language and employing a down-to-earth style, the author is capable of revealing the whole misery of someone who has died. There are at least three distinctive voices speaking in the poem; one of whose being the narrative voice that tells the reader what has happened. A man was out at sea, presumably swimming in the cold water. He was “much too far out” (Smith), so he called for help by waving his hands in order to make somebody be aware of his situation. But apparently the people on the beach misunderstood his gestures and did not help him. He died alone. After his death people, who obviously knew him little, talk about him and the reason why he died. They say he was a man who “always loved larking” (Smith). But the dead man replies them, “moaning” (Smith), that he needed help, not only in this final fatal situation but throughout his whole life. But nobody saw it coming, even though he had been warning them throughout his life, by metaphorically waving his arms.
Summary of Chapters
1. A comparison of the themes of ‘Death’ and ‘Loneliness’ in “Not Waving but Drowning” by Stevie Smith, and in “Warning” by Jenny Joseph: This chapter analyzes how Smith and Joseph treat the inevitability of death and the isolation of the individual through different narrative techniques and stylistic forms.
2. A comparison of the theme of ‘Society’ in “Poor Soul, Poor Girl!: A Debutante” by Stevie Smith, and in “This be the Verse” by Philip Larkin: This chapter explores how both poets critique societal structures, values, and the impact of the older generation on the younger one using irony and direct address.
3. Bibliography: This section provides a list of primary and secondary sources referenced throughout the analysis.
Keywords
Poetry, British Literature, Stevie Smith, Jenny Joseph, Philip Larkin, Death, Loneliness, Society, Stylistic Devices, Narrative Voice, Modernism, Social Criticism, Comparison, Post-1945, Literature Analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core focus of this work?
The work provides a comparative analysis of four specific poems by British authors, focusing on themes such as death, loneliness, and societal critique.
What are the primary thematic fields covered?
The themes include the isolation of death, the misery of misunderstanding, societal debutante expectations, and the intergenerational transmission of misery.
What is the primary research goal?
The research aims to identify and analyze how poets use specific stylistic devices and perspectives to treat their chosen themes effectively within their poems.
Which scientific methodology is applied?
The author uses a comparative literary approach, examining formal elements like rhyme schemes, meter, and rhetorical devices to interpret thematic depth.
What does the main body cover?
The main body is divided into two comparative analyses: the first focusing on death/loneliness in Smith and Joseph, and the second on social critique in Smith and Larkin.
Which keywords best characterize this work?
Key terms include British poetry, literary analysis, comparative studies, stylistic devices, and thematic exploration of human experiences.
How does the author interpret the "waving" in Stevie Smith's poem?
The author interprets the "waving" as a metaphorical cry for help throughout the protagonist's life, which is consistently misunderstood by those around him.
What is the significance of the "Janus-faced society" mentioned in the final chapter?
The term is used to describe the contradictory nature of parents who are supposed to provide love, yet simultaneously impose their own burdens and faults onto the next generation.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Katja Buthut (Autor:in), 2006, Death, Loneliness and Society. A comparison of poems by Stevie Smith and Jenny Joseph, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/134716
