Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › History - Asia

What Caused the Great Bengal Famine 1943-44? A Closer Look at Natural, Socio-economic and Political Causes

Title: What Caused the Great Bengal Famine 1943-44?  A Closer Look at Natural, Socio-economic and Political Causes

Seminar Paper , 2023 , 24 Pages , Grade: 1

Autor:in: Katrin Simon (Author)

History - Asia
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

The aim of this paper is to give a picture of the famine and all its elements as complete as possible within the restraints of this paper, as well as discussing several different theories as to the cause of the famine, e.g. food availability decline and food entitlement decline. At the end of the paper, the question “What caused the Great Bengal Famine?” will be extensively answered from as many perspectives as possible by comparing and criticizing them throughout the text.

Establishing the incidence, spread, and severity of famines in the past has never been easy. There is a plethora of preconditions, causes and hazards coming together resulting in disaster. This is no different in the case of the Great Bengal Famine or Ponchasher Monnontor in 1943-44. In examining the causes of this particular famine, not only are there a lot of different factors to consider, but there are many contradictory theories surrounding the events taking place in the province of Bengal during that time period. Further complicating the research is the uncertainty on circumstances surrounding the famine and the official inquiry published by the colonial government. Over and beyond there does not seem a complete study on the Great Bengal Famine considering and comparing all aspects of the time and most of the theories surrounding it.

This goal is going to be accomplished by discussing the general history and the key data of the Bengal famine 1943-44 in the first chapter. The following and main chapter of the paper concentrates on causes and hazards in regard to the Great Bengal Famine and is threefold. First, there is a discussion about natural causes including a description of the natural hazards occurring at the beginning of the famine, a description of the consequential rice shortage and a closer look at the food availability decline (FAD) approach. Second, the socio-economic causes of the famine will be examined in connection with the concept of vulnerability, the food entitlement decline (FED) approach and the hoarding and speculation claim by the colonial government will be discussed. Third, a closer look will be taken at political causes of the famine including the war related policies instated during the Second World War in Bengal and famine relief policies as well as the general approach to the Great Bengal Famine the colonial government exhibited. At the end, the different causes are being put in relation to each other and their interplay is discussed.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Compares food availability decline and food entitlement decline explanations
  • Examines the Famine Inquiry Commission’s rice estimates and Amartya Sen’s interpretation
  • 18 sources in the bibliography

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

3.1. Natural Causes

3.1.1. Natural Hazards

3.1.2. Food Availability Decline (FAD)

3.2. Socio-economic Causes

3.2.1. Vulnerability: Poverty and Inequality

3.2.2. Food Entitlement Decline (FED)

3.2.3. Hoarding and Speculation

3.3. Political Causes

3.3.1. The Second World War and War Policies

3.3.2. Famine Policies

4. Conclusion

Objectives and Themes

This paper asks what caused the Great Bengal Famine of 1943–44. It compares competing explanations and examines how natural hazards, socioeconomic vulnerability and political decisions interacted during the crisis.

  • Food availability decline and contested harvest statistics
  • Food entitlement decline, poverty and inequality
  • Cyclones, flooding and crop disease
  • Hoarding, speculation and food distribution
  • Wartime policies and colonial famine relief

Excerpt from the Book

3.1.2. Food Availability Decline (FAD)

The food availability decline (FAD) approach to explaining famines basically presents the idea that there just simply is not enough food to go around in a specific region or country on a systemic level (cf. Daoud 2018, 453). This shortage is usually due to a natural disaster (cf. Tauger 2006, 47).

In regards to the Great Bengal Famine the Famine Inquiry Commission had “no doubt that shortage of supplies was a basic cause of the famine” (FIC 1945, 77). However – as will be discussed at a later point – they did not believe FAD to be the main cause of the famine, but hoarding and speculation. Contrary to the commission’s claim of FAD being a basic cause their own rice estimations show that there was 13% more rice in 1943 than in 1941, without a famine occurring in 1941. The validity of these numbers was already questioned at the time of their release by the FIC. Supporting the FAD theory in the case of to the Great Bengal Famine are the numbers published by the agriculture and industries minister, the Nawab Bahadur of Dacca, regarding the 1942/43 harvest: “The estimated rice production in 1942/43 (6.9 million tons) was far short of consumption requirement (9.3 million tons)” (Ó Gráda 2015, 59). Additionally the Muslim League believed as well that Bengal had a serious rice shortage and its leader warned of a reenactment of the 1770 disaster (cf. Ó Gráda 2015, 60). Not only is a shortage in rice indicated by the above numbers, but there is also no evidence of a significant carry-over of rice stocks from previous years (cf. Ó Gráda 2015, 60). How reliable any figures regarding a carry-over are is widely debated.

The scientific community at present seems to still be split on how reliable the statistics on rice supply published by the FIC are. Amartya Sen – who will be discussed in detail in an upcoming chapter – based his theory of food entitlement decline (FED) on the FIC’s statistics like other historians and social scientists did later on. In contrast new present data suggests that FAD or crop failure may have been underestimated in the FIC’s report and Sen’s interpretation (cf. Tauger 2006, 57). There seems to be a fundamental underlying qualitative issue with the government’s statistics namely that they are not actually production statistics at all, but rather “pre-harvest projections” (Tauger 2006, 60). This means they were in fact not based on measurements of actual harvests, but solely on projected estimations. Tauger explains how these pre-harvest projections were done by the government’s Agricultural Department:

They estimated the crop area based on an assumed normal area with corrections for the particular year. They determined the yield by multiplying an assumed standard yield and condition factor. (Tauger 2006, 60)

Chapter Summaries

1. Introduction: The author frames the research question and outlines the comparison of natural, socioeconomic and political explanations.

3.1. Natural Causes: This section examines cyclones, flooding and crop disease alongside competing estimates of rice availability.

3.2. Socio-economic Causes: The discussion considers poverty and inequality, Sen’s entitlement approach, and claims about hoarding and speculation.

3.3. Political Causes: The author examines wartime policies, colonial administration and famine relief, including debates over the Famine Inquiry Commission’s report.

4. Conclusion: The author brings the explanations together and argues that food shortages, unequal access to food and political decisions interacted.

Keywords

Great Bengal Famine, Bengal, food availability decline, food entitlement decline, Amartya Sen, colonial government, famine relief, Second World War, rice production, poverty, inequality, hoarding, crop failure

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this work about?

It examines competing explanations for the Great Bengal Famine of 1943–44.

What are its central themes?

The paper addresses natural hazards, food supply, unequal access to food, wartime policy and colonial responses.

What is the main research question?

The author asks what caused the Great Bengal Famine and compares explanations from several perspectives.

What research method does the author use?

The paper compares and critiques published historical interpretations, official reports and estimates; it is a literature-based analysis.

What does the main discussion cover?

It examines natural, socioeconomic and political causes, including crop damage, vulnerability, speculation, war policies and famine relief.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include food availability decline, food entitlement decline, colonial government, poverty, wartime policy and famine relief.

How does the paper discuss Amartya Sen’s entitlement approach?

It explains Sen’s emphasis on access to food and purchasing power and considers criticisms of the statistics underlying his interpretation.

Why are crop estimates important to the argument?

They inform the debate over whether a decline in food availability contributed to the famine, although the paper questions their reliability.

Which wartime policies receive particular attention?

The discussion considers the boat denial and scorched earth policies, as well as wartime inflation, disrupted rice imports and requests for relief shipments.

Excerpt out of 24 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
What Caused the Great Bengal Famine 1943-44? A Closer Look at Natural, Socio-economic and Political Causes
College
University of Vienna  (Südasien-, Tibet- und Buddhismuskunde)
Grade
1
Author
Katrin Simon (Author)
Publication Year
2023
Pages
24
Catalog Number
V1347651
ISBN (PDF)
9783346851017
ISBN (Book)
9783346851024
Language
English
Tags
famine Bengal colonialism fad fed sen secondworldwar britishindia britishempire India history longnineteenthcentury british india british empire great bengal famine second world war british colonialism colonial india churchill colonial government south asia south asian history bengal famine
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Katrin Simon (Author), 2023, What Caused the Great Bengal Famine 1943-44? A Closer Look at Natural, Socio-economic and Political Causes, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1347651
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  24  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract