In the course of this essay the terminology that was applied by the Russian Formalist theoreticians shall be investigated (many terms were even invented and introduced by the Formalists themselves). More precisely, a careful look will be taken at how the literary critics, Medvedev and Bakhtin in The Formal Method in Literary Scholarship and Hansen-Löve in Der Russische Formalismus examine the Formalist terms. In order to evaluate Formalist terminology accurately and objectively, the mentioned critics’ theories shall be underpinned by and contrasted with the opinion of other critics in this field.
Two of Shklovsky’s articles, The Resurrection of the Word and Art as Device are taken as a starting point for paving the way for a detailed analysis of the formal terminology.
The major focus lies on the term ‘ostranenie’ that was firstly introduced by Shklovsky (1991) and is most commonly translated as ‘estrangement’, ‘defamiliarisation’ or ‘making it strange’. The essay shall not only analyse the origins of this concept, but furthermore, compare the different interpretations the term entails. Hansen-Löve’s evaluation of the concept of ostranenie as well as Medvedev and Bakhtin’s assessment of Shklovsky’ analysis of Tolstoy’s
Kholstomer in the view of estrangement reveals the critical approach on which this essay is based on.
Moreover, the Russian term of ‘obnazenie’, the ‘laying-bare’ of the work (Hansen-Löve, 1978) and ‘oveshchestvlenie’, the process of materialisation (Medvedev & Bakhtin, 1978), shall be regarded throughout this essay, since both concepts go hand in hand with the idea of ostranenie.
In the last part of the essay, the formal theory of shutting out subjective consciousness from the work (Medvedev & Bakhtin, 1978) and the effects of this concept are in the centre of the attention. This shall lead to the final evaluation of the quality in the formalist concept of perception.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.2 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines Medvedev and Bakhtin’s criticism of Shklovsky’s reading of Tolstoy’s Kholstomer
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Ostranenie, Obnazenie and Oveshchestvlenie
3. Formalism’s Contribution to Scholarship
4. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This essay examines how critics use and assess Russian Formalist terminology, asking how their interpretations of key concepts inform an evaluation of Formalism’s contribution to literary scholarship. It compares the approaches of Medvedev and Bakhtin and Hansen-Löve, drawing on Shklovsky’s writings and other critical perspectives.
- Estrangement and the renewal of perception
- Exposing literary devices and materialising the word
- Critical interpretations of Shklovsky’s terminology
- Tolstoy’s Kholstomer as an example of estrangement
- Formalism’s relationship to ideology and subsequent literary theory
Excerpt from the Book
2. Ostranenie, Obnazenie and Oveshchestvlenie
This concept of de-automising an object is brought about by the artistic device of ostranenie. In his famous article Art as Device Shlovsky, for the first time, defined the term ostranenie as a device of art. It encourages the artistic process, namely the process of materialising the word and of seeing habitual correlations with fresh eyes; which is the general aim of estrangement from a formalistic point of view (Hansen-Löve, 1978).
Hansen-Löve sees the starting point of estrangement in the linguistic criticism of Greek Sophism, which influenced the Socratic ‘laying bare theory’ that is compared to Formalism’s concept of obnazenie. This calls for greater exploration. Minimal similarities can indeed be drawn between the Russian idea of estrangement and the mentioned Socratic philosophy, since the Greeks saw and used speech as a device of delusion and deception. However, they did not apply this device in order to distinguish an artistic work from a non-artistic work and to keep the reader’s attention on it, as the Formalists did, but rather to influence people in favour of their own, mostly political interests. Nevertheless, the Socratic laying bare concept bears resemblance to the idea of obnazenie that is described as the process through which the attention is drawn away from the object towards the form and composition, the making of the work itself (Hansen-Löve, 1978).
It is this seeing of a thing in a novel light that, in the formal method, leads to a materialised perception. At this point a closer look shall be taken at the process of materialisation, in Russian oveshchestvlenie. In introducing the term oveshchestvlenie, Medvedev and Bakhtin take the example of Acmeism, a literary movement that evolved at around the same time as Russian Formalism, and was, too, concerned with a worshipping of the word. The Acmeist’s aimed at subordinating and weakening the meaning of the poetic word, precisely materialising it and divorcing the literary work from ‘other spheres of ideology’ (Medvedev & Bakhtin, 1978, p. 58). Similarities to the theory of the Russian Formalists’ are to be observed in this concept. However, when more precisely comparing the two movements, it becomes unveiled that, while the Formalists were focusing on revolutionising poetic arts, the Acmeists were more interested in a clear and definite use of plain language in poetics.
Additionally, for the Russian Formalist theoreticians the Acmeist concept of materialisation of the word was not radical enough as the Formalists aimed to completely cut off the ideological significance of the word (Medvedev & Bakhtin, 1978).
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The essay introduces its comparative approach to Formalist terminology and identifies estrangement as its central concern. It also outlines the related concepts and critical perspectives considered in the discussion.
2. Ostranenie, Obnazenie and Oveshchestvlenie: This chapter examines estrangement, the laying bare of devices and materialisation through Shklovsky and his critics. It compares critical accounts of these concepts and considers Shklovsky’s reading of Tolstoy’s Kholstomer.
3. Formalism’s Contribution to Scholarship: The discussion considers objections to Formalist accounts of perception and ideology alongside assessments of the movement’s significance. It also considers relationships with Structuralism and New Criticism.
4. Conclusion: The conclusion revisits the conceptual difficulties surrounding estrangement and assesses Russian Formalism’s place in later literary scholarship.
Keywords
Russian Formalism, literary theory, estrangement, defamiliarisation, ostranenie, obnazenie, materialisation, oveshchestvlenie, literary devices, perception, ideology, Viktor Shklovsky, Structuralism, literary criticism
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It examines Russian Formalist terminology and evaluates the movement’s contribution to literary scholarship through a comparison of critical interpretations.
What are the central topics?
The essay focuses on estrangement, the laying bare of literary devices, materialisation, perception and the relationship between literary form and ideology.
What is the essay’s primary aim?
Its aim is to compare how selected critics examine Formalist terms and use that comparison to assess the movement’s contribution to literary studies.
What scholarly method does the essay use?
It uses comparative textual and critical analysis, reading works by Medvedev and Bakhtin and Hansen-Löve alongside Shklovsky’s essays and other criticism.
What does the main discussion cover?
It traces the meanings and interpretations of ostranenie, obnazenie and oveshchestvlenie, then considers criticisms of Formalist perception and the movement’s influence on literary theory.
Which keywords characterise the essay?
Key terms include Russian Formalism, estrangement, defamiliarisation, literary devices, materialisation, perception and ideology.
How is Tolstoy’s Kholstomer used?
The essay considers Medvedev and Bakhtin’s criticism of Shklovsky’s reading of the story, particularly their different accounts of the purpose of estrangement.
Which later literary movements are discussed?
The essay considers the Prague School and French Structuralism, as well as points of comparison between Russian Formalism and New Criticism.
- Quote paper
- Robert Stolt (Author), 2009, Russian Formalism, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/145245