Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Law - Civil / Private / Industrial / Labour

AGE CONCERN ENGLAND - Case C-388/07, The Incorporated Trustees of the National Council on Ageing (Age Concern England) v Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform

Title: AGE CONCERN ENGLAND - Case C-388/07, The Incorporated Trustees of the National Council on Ageing (Age Concern England) v Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform

Research Paper (postgraduate) , 2009 , 14 Pages , Grade: A-

Autor:in: Karina Oborune (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author)

Law - Civil / Private / Industrial / Labour
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

The judgments of the European Court of Justice (hereinafter “ECJ”) are not often covered by
media. With an exception, there are some cases that have a great impact in everyday life of
nationals of the European Union (hereinafter “EU”). One of such cases is the long-awaited
Age Concern England, which is significant for confirming that Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 th
November 2000 (Employment Equality Directive, hereinafter “Directive”) prohibits
discrimination on grounds of age.
On 5th March 2009, the ECJ referred a decision back to the High Court after clarifying that
social policy objectives “such as those related to employment and the labour market” may be
considered legitimate under EC law. This means that employers can still lawfully dismiss
employees at the age of 65. In the context of Directive, the present case both covers personal
scope (the Directives apply to all persons: natural and legal, in the EU regardless of
nationality, public and private sector) and material scope (question if retirement ages covered
by Directive).
In fact, Age Concern England case “enriches case law of discrimination on grounds of age,
especially on the obligations of the Member States (hereinafter, “MS”) in respect of the
prohibition of discrimination on grounds of age laid down in Article 2 (hereinafter – “Art.”)
of Directive, particularly the degree with which that prohibition must be transposed into
national law.” Moreover, Age Concern England continues case law of earlier cases involving
arguments regarding discrimination on grounds of age, for example, Mangold, Lindorfer,
Palacios de la Villa and Bartsch.
Opinions among employment lawyers and other experts differ regarding the implications of
the Age Concern England judgment. For employers, generally, this is a good decision; they
can dismiss employees if they wish to. On balance, this is crucial judgment for workers aged
65 and over. There are approximately ten thousand people aged 65 that are forcibly dismissed
every year in United Kingdom (hereinafter “UK”).

Excerpt


Contents

1. Introduction

2. Facts and legal issues

3. Opinion of Advocate General (hereinafter “AG”) Jan Mazák

4. Judgment of the Court of Justice

5. Comment

5.1. Dismissal ages are covered by the Directive

5.2. Directive does not have to be transposed literally into national law

6. Conclusion

Purpose and Key Topics

This case note examines whether the UK’s default retirement age of 65 complies with the EU Employment Equality Directive and how the directive’s prohibition of age discrimination applies to national retirement rules. It asks whether such rules fall within the directive’s scope, how age-based differences in treatment may be justified, and whether member states must transpose the directive through a specific list of exceptions.

  • Scope of Directive 2000/78/EC and retirement dismissals
  • Age discrimination and the justification of differences in treatment
  • Advocate General Jan Mazák’s opinion
  • The Court of Justice’s answers to the referred questions
  • UK implementation and the Employment Equality (Age) Regulations
  • Relationship to Palacios de la Villa and Mangold

Excerpt from the Book

Judgment of the Court of Justice

The ECJ has ruled that employees aged 65 or over can legally be forced into retirement. The ECJ agreed with the AG Mazák opinion on all of the referred questions, especially, that the national default retirement age of 65 falls within the scope of the Directive and it does not require MS to draw up a specific list of the differences in treatment, which may be justified by a legitimate aim.

Concerning first three questions the ECJ ruled that “the Age Regulations should therefore be regarded as establishing rules relating to “employment and working conditions, including dismissals and pay” within the meaning of Art. 3(1) (c) of the Directive and so coming within the scope of the Directive” (para.28).

Concerning fourth question, forced retirement at age of 65 in national legislation or in other words “difference of treatment on grounds of age” can be justified only if it is a “proportionate” means of achieving a legitimate employment policy (appropriate and necessary, of “public interest nature“, and of “purely individual reasons particular to the employer´s situation“, for example, cost reduction or improving competitiveness): such as those related to employment policy, the labour market or vocational training.

“By their public interest nature, those legitimate aims are distinguishable from purely individual reasons particular to the employer's situation, such as cost reduction or improving competitiveness. It is for the national court to ascertain, first, whether the UK legislation reflects such a legitimate aim and, second, whether the means chosen were appropriate and necessary to achieve it”. (para. 46)

Therefore, any dismissal by reason of retirement must be regarded as discriminatory unless the employer shows that it is proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. Moreover, the judgment suggested that the legitimate aims permitted by the Regulations should be limited to wider social and employment policy issues (i.e. controlled and prescribed by the Government) rather than specific to the employee (i.e. controlled and prescribed by the employer). Colm O´Cinneide in his research Age Discrimination and European Law argues that “distinctions based on seniority and experience will similarly be subject to the requirement to satisfy the objective justification test“. He concludes that “retirement ages will have to be measured against the strict proportionality standard set out in Art. 6, and the outcome will be a matter of case by case analysis.”

Chapter Summaries

1. Introduction: Introduces Case C-388/07 and its significance for the prohibition of age discrimination under the Employment Equality Directive. It frames the controversy around the UK’s default retirement age of 65.

2. Facts and legal issues: Describes the UK Regulations and the questions referred by the High Court concerning the directive’s scope and justification tests. It sets out the legal issues addressed by the Court.

3. Opinion of Advocate General (hereinafter “AG”) Jan Mazák: Summarizes Mazák’s analysis of implementation, age-based differences in treatment, and objective justification. It considers how legitimate employment and social policy aims affect retirement rules.

4. Judgment of the Court of Justice: Reviews the Court’s answers on the directive’s scope, justification of retirement rules, and comparison of direct and indirect discrimination tests. It notes that the case returned to the UK High Court.

5. Comment: Discusses the coverage of retirement ages by the directive and whether member states must transpose it literally. It relates the case to earlier European case law.

5.1. Dismissal ages are covered by the Directive: Connects the case to the principle of equal treatment and to Palacios de la Villa. It explains why retirement rules fall within the directive’s scope.

5.2. Directive does not have to be transposed literally into national law: Examines member states’ discretion in implementing the directive and the role of national courts in protecting the principle of non-discrimination.

6. Conclusion: Recaps the case note’s principal legal clarifications and identifies questions raised for future discussion of age discrimination and retirement.

Keywords

Age discrimination, Age Concern England, Case C-388/07, Directive 2000/78/EC, Employment Equality Directive, mandatory retirement, retirement age, equal treatment, European Court of Justice, Advocate General, legitimate aim, proportionality, UK Age Regulations, Palacios de la Villa, Mangold

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this case note about?

It examines the European Court of Justice case Age Concern England and the application of EU age-discrimination law to mandatory retirement at age 65 in the United Kingdom.

What are the central topics?

The main topics are the scope of Directive 2000/78/EC, retirement dismissals, age-based differences in treatment, and the standards for justifying those differences.

What is the primary legal question?

The case asks whether national rules permitting employers to retire workers aged 65 and over fall within the directive and when such rules can be justified.

What method does the work use?

It presents a legal case analysis, discussing the Advocate General’s opinion, the Court’s judgment, the relevant directive and regulations, and related case law.

What does the main part cover?

It reviews the referred questions, Mazák’s opinion, the Court’s answers, and commentary on the directive’s scope and national implementation.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include age discrimination, mandatory retirement, Directive 2000/78/EC, proportionality, equal treatment, and the Age Concern England case.

What did the European Court of Justice say about the directive’s scope?

The Court treated the UK Age Regulations as rules concerning employment and working conditions, including dismissals and pay, within the directive’s scope.

How may a retirement rule based on age be justified?

The case discusses justification by a legitimate aim, with the chosen means required to be appropriate and necessary.

What earlier cases does the case note discuss?

It refers in particular to Palacios de la Villa and Mangold when discussing retirement ages, implementation, and age discrimination.

What happened after the European Court of Justice judgment?

The case was returned to the UK High Court to determine whether the default retirement age of 65 was justified under the applicable law.

Excerpt out of 14 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
AGE CONCERN ENGLAND - Case C-388/07, The Incorporated Trustees of the National Council on Ageing (Age Concern England) v Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform
College
University of Basel  (Europainstitut)
Course
Social-Non Discrimination Law
Grade
A-
Authors
Karina Oborune (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author)
Publication Year
2009
Pages
14
Catalog Number
V157903
ISBN (eBook)
9783656245957
ISBN (Book)
9783656246046
Language
English
Tags
Age Concern Case C-388/07 Social-Non Discrimination Law
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Karina Oborune (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author), Ibragim Zalel (Author), 2009, AGE CONCERN ENGLAND - Case C-388/07, The Incorporated Trustees of the National Council on Ageing (Age Concern England) v Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/157903
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  14  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract