Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Political Theory and the History of Ideas Journal

Same Difference

Exploring the Divide between Critical and Conventional Constructivism

Title: Same Difference

Scientific Essay , 2009 , 10 Pages , Grade: 77%

Autor:in: Bachelor International Relations (Hons) Ralph Myers (Author)

Politics - Political Theory and the History of Ideas Journal
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Same Difference: Exploring the Divide between Critical and Conventional Constructivism
This paper explores the similarities and differences between the conventional and critical strands of constructivism within International Relation. It concludes that there is a serious cleavage between the two, even though they might appear to be similar.
The first paragraph of this paper tries to define some of the concepts used in this paper, particularly the terms ‘conventional constructivism’, ‘critical constructivism’, ‘research paradigm’ and ‘methodology’. The first part of the paragraph explains the importance of setting definitional parameters, in addition to suggesting an analogy to gain more appreciation for the cleavage, and particular the type of cleavage between critical and conventional strands that this paper will reveal. Then, using taxonomies put forward by a number of academics, the classification for both strands are given, in addition to identifying their most prominent academics. Definitions regarding methodology and research paradigm are examined through Kuhn’s interpretation of paradigms.
The second paragraph starts by giving an overview of similarities different academics have observed within the constructivist tradition. It focuses on the critique of positivism, interpretative methodology and the importance of socially constructed ideas.
The third paragraph highlights the cleavage between critical and conventional constructivism. It argues that, although the position this paper classifies critical constructivists in a certain way which is rejected by some of those scholars, it is legitimised through Kuhn’s interpretation of paradigms. Both differences in methodology and research paradigm are then exposed, and the main argument made is that critical constructivism is so radical that it not only alienates itself from other theories in IR but also conventional constructivism, using the aforementioned analogy to exemplify this.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Applies Kuhn’s interpretation of research paradigms to constructivism
  • 15 sources in the bibliography

Contents

1. INTRODUCTION

2. DEFINITIONAL PARAMETERS

3. SIMILARITIES

4. DIFFERENCES

5. CONCLUSION

Objectives and Themes

This paper examines similarities and differences between conventional and critical constructivism in international relations, asking how their research paradigms and methodologies relate and where the two strands diverge.

  • Definitions and classifications of constructivist approaches
  • Kuhn’s interpretation of research paradigms
  • Critiques of positivism and interpretive methodology
  • Socially constructed ideas, identity and action
  • Foundationalism, causal explanation and relations with other theories

Excerpt from the Book

Similarities

By examining a number of works (Campbell & George 1989, Hopf 1998, Price & Reus-Smit 1998, Guzzini 2000) one discovers a number of similarities regarding theoretical fundamentals between critical and conventional constructivists. These authors find that in general all constructivists attempt to highlight the inadequacies of positivism and empiricism which have previously dominated the field of International Relations. This is a critique of both the rationalist methodology as well as of attempts to formulate empirically objective and verifiable truth statements about the social and natural world. Continuing on the subject of methodology, constructivists reject the notion that there can only be one scientific approach to IR. They argue that a number of approaches should be possible, and although there are differences within constructivism, in general they tend to be interpretive.. As opposed to the rationalist approach of taking certain truths for granted, constructivists focus on the ‘power of ideas’ (Jackson & Sørensen 2007). Instead of taking truths to be natural, constructivists argue that knowledge about truth is grounded in human history, culture and power relations. They argue that individuals are not rational actors but instead are value-oriented. This is then linked to the social construction of identity, which in turn determines the interests and actions of actors. Campbell and George also stress the importance of the linguistic construction of reality.

The rejection (in the case of post-modernists) or critique (in the case of modernists) of positivism is in essence a meta-theoretical debate about positivism and post-positivism. Coming back to Kuhn’s critique of positivism, he showed that positivist paradigms were not necessarily based on the accumulation of scientific knowledge, but assumed certain truths. Therefore scientific progress, leading to changing world views, throughout history has created paradigm shifts. In Kuhn’s post-positivist interpretation of paradigms, science in itself cannot create such a shift as it does not entail the acceptance of exogenously imposed truths, but the promise of knowledge about such truths (Guzzini 2000, Vasquez 1997).

Chapter Summaries

INTRODUCTION: Introduces the comparison between conventional and critical constructivism and outlines the paper’s approach to research paradigms and methodology.

DEFINITIONAL PARAMETERS: Examines competing labels for the two strands and establishes the paper’s use of Kuhn’s interpretation of paradigms.

SIMILARITIES: Discusses shared critiques of positivism, interpretive approaches and the significance of socially constructed ideas and identities.

DIFFERENCES: Examines disagreements over epistemological foundations, causal explanation, linguistic approaches and relationships with other international relations theories.

CONCLUSION: Brings together the comparison and restates the paper’s argument about the division between the two strands.

Keywords

constructivism, international relations, conventional constructivism, critical constructivism, research paradigms, methodology, positivism, post-positivism, epistemology, interpretivism, social construction, identity, causal explanation, foundationalism

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this paper about?

It compares conventional and critical constructivism within international relations.

What are the central themes?

The paper considers research paradigms, methodology, positivism, socially constructed ideas and differences between constructivist approaches.

What is the paper’s main objective?

Its objective is to clarify the similarities and differences between the two strands, especially in their research paradigms and methodologies.

What research method does the author use?

The author compares and analyses scholarly literature and classifications, using Kuhn’s interpretation of paradigms as a conceptual framework.

What does the main discussion cover?

It defines key terms, considers common theoretical commitments and examines differences in epistemology and approaches to explanation.

Which keywords characterise the paper?

Key terms include constructivism, international relations, research paradigms, positivism, epistemology, interpretivism and social construction.

How is Kuhn’s concept of a paradigm used?

It provides a way to consider both the assumptions shaping legitimate research questions and the shared values and boundaries of a scholarly community.

How does the paper distinguish the two strands’ approaches to explanation?

It contrasts conventional constructivists’ interest in causal accounts with critical constructivists’ emphasis on how social realities are constituted.

Excerpt out of 10 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Same Difference
Subtitle
Exploring the Divide between Critical and Conventional Constructivism
College
Dublin City University
Course
International Relations
Grade
77%
Author
Bachelor International Relations (Hons) Ralph Myers (Author)
Publication Year
2009
Pages
10
Catalog Number
V159119
ISBN (eBook)
9783640755851
ISBN (Book)
9783640755998
Language
English
Tags
Constructivism Social Constructivism Conventional Constructivism Critical Constructivism Paradigm Kuhn Ontology Epistemology Third Debate Research Paradigm Østerud Rationalism Post-Modernism Meta-Theory International Relations
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Bachelor International Relations (Hons) Ralph Myers (Author), 2009, Same Difference, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/159119
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  10  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract