Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Topic: European Union

Governance in EU Institutions: The Commission or Consensus as Effectiveness

Title: Governance in EU Institutions: The Commission or Consensus as Effectiveness

Term Paper , 2010 , 18 Pages

Autor:in: Johannes Wiedemann (Author)

Politics - Topic: European Union
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

The concepts of governance have the advantage of including the informal aspect of decision-making into their scope of analysis. The intention of this paper is the application of a fitting conceptual derivative of governance on the decision making process inside the institutional framework of the Commission of the European Union. The notion to be tested is the one of the Commission being by its institutional heritage inclined to promulgation of consensus among its principal actors, the members of the college of Commissioners. So what kind of governance might be characteristic for the Commission?
The political setting is that of the European Union, which is on the one hand an intergovernmental organization of member states on equal terms, but on the other hand a political institution. Apart from partly being established on a supra-national echelon, which is rationally designed and controlled for the purpose action and intervention to foster economic prosperity and integration in accordance with the concepts of functional and rational-choice institutionalism characteristic for social and political institutions of modernity. As the EU is itself an extension of the mostly politically pluralistic and socially fragmented Member States (MS), certain elements and processes influencing the promulgation of the political will on all legislative governmental echelons are present in the context of governance in the European Union as well.
The hypothesis of this paper consists of the following notions:
Due to the “sui generis”-character the EU,1 employing decisions by consensus even on intergovernmental as well as on supranational level is most effective politics possible.
Applying concepts of governance to the Commission‟s competences, institutional framework and formal as well as , if perceptible, informal decision-making procedures and customs, will show that although the Commission matches no distinct concept currently present in academia, it very well fulfils basic requirements of „good‟ governance.
Even as the supra-national institution per se, the Commission acts according to these notions.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Examines Commission decision-making through multi-level governance, open coordination and principal–agent models
  • Uses Eichener’s stakeholder analysis to examine Commission officials’ interests
  • 20 sources in the bibliography

Contents

Introduction

1. A Scale for Decision-Making: Consensus and Effectiveness

a. Theoretical and functional aspects of Consensus

b. The Struggle to define ‘Effectiveness’ as a Normative Category

2. Governance

a. Concepts of Governance

i. Multi-Level Governance

ii. Open Method of Coordination

iii. Principal-Agent Model

b. ‘Good’ Governance

3. Formal and Informal Aspects of Decision-Making

a. One-of-a-Kind: The European Commission as a formal Institution

b. Identifying Informal Means of in the Commission’s Decision-Making

c. Contestation and the Commission.

Conclusions

Objectives and Topics

This paper examines governance within the European Commission, asking which governance concepts best illuminate its decision-making and whether its institutional structure encourages consensus as an effective way to act.

  • Consensus, effectiveness and democratic legitimacy
  • Multi-level governance and the Open Method of Coordination
  • Principal–agent relationships in European governance
  • Formal structures and informal decision-making in the Commission
  • Stakeholder interests, consultation and political contestation

Excerpt from the Book

One-of-a-Kind: The European Commission as a formal Institution

In the public eye the Commission, quite understandably so, is perceived as a quasi-government of the EU, but it is more precise to see this institutions as the agenda-setting and executive organ of the union. Nevertheless, it has a mandate to steer the process of decision-making and execution within its responsibilities in the public sphere, a mandate for governance. But while the President of the Commission is seen for that reason as head of the EU institution most similar to a classical executive branch or government, he or she still is de facto a primus inter pares.

The changes implemented in the Treaty of Lisbon concerning the role of the President indicate an intermediate peak in the development from spokesperson to chairman the post of President of the Commission has undergone. The President now is in charge of laying down the political guidelines by which the Commission executes its responsibilities. Nevertheless, the recent decision amending the Commission’s Rules of Procedure according to the Treaty of Lisbon maintains the principle of collective responsibility of the college. This is in line with the institutional traditions of the Commission, and those in combination with the given structural incentives are the cause for the specific brand of governance the Commission employs by preparing decision on most issues for the consent of all stakeholders, therefore agreement is the prime modus of decision-making.

As mentioned, the Commission is not a government of the EU, but its central agenda-setting and supranational body. The Commission is formally the only body able to propose legislation by power of initiative and can therefore justifiably be deemed the driving force of integration. These proposals or initiatives each represent the current common interest among the participating bodies of the European Union, the Parliament and the Council. Connected to the power of initiative and supervision apt to a ‘guardian’ of the treaties and the aquis communautaire is the task of administration by issuance of directives, regulation and decisions and the execution of these. For this tasks the following basic ‘sui generis’ structure was designed: At the top one finds a College of Commissioners with one member from each of the twenty-seven Member States chaired by the President equivocally proposed by the European Council and acknowledged by the Parliament. Even though the Treaty of Lisbon declared that the number of commissioners could be reduced to a minimum of two-thirds of the number of Member States from 2014 onwards, the Council took its prerogative seriously and decided in 2008 to leave it as it is: The college will consist of one Commissioner per Member State beyond 2014. Each of candidates for a future college are proposed by the respective Member State, approved by the president and appointed by the Council.

Chapter Summaries

Introduction: The paper sets out its questions about consensus and governance in the European Commission and introduces its approach.

1. A Scale for Decision-Making: Consensus and Effectiveness: The first chapter considers consensus, democratic discourse, effectiveness and legitimacy as concepts for assessing political decision-making.

2. Governance: This chapter discusses multi-level governance, the Open Method of Coordination and the principal–agent model, as well as the principles of good governance.

3. Formal and Informal Aspects of Decision-Making: The final substantive chapter examines the Commission’s institutional structure, informal practices, stakeholder interests and political contestation.

Conclusions: The paper assesses its argument about consensus, legitimacy and the relationship between formal decisions and informal processes.

Keywords

European Commission, European Union, governance, consensus, decision-making, effectiveness, legitimacy, multi-level governance, Open Method of Coordination, principal–agent model, informal governance, political contestation

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the paper about?

It examines how governance concepts can be used to understand decision-making within the European Commission.

What are its central topics?

The main topics are consensus, effectiveness, legitimacy, governance models and the Commission’s formal and informal practices.

What is the primary research question?

The paper asks what kind of governance characterizes the Commission and considers whether its institutional setting encourages consensus.

What research method does the author use?

The author develops a conceptual and institutional analysis based on governance literature and published sources rather than reporting an original survey or interviews.

What does the main discussion cover?

It moves from theories of consensus and effectiveness to governance models and then to the Commission’s institutional structure and decision-making practices.

Which keywords characterize the paper?

Key terms include European Commission, consensus, effectiveness, legitimacy, multi-level governance, open coordination and informal governance.

Which governance models are examined?

The paper discusses multi-level governance, the Open Method of Coordination and the principal–agent model in relation to European governance.

How does the paper approach informal decision-making?

It considers consultation, negotiations, networks and agenda-setting alongside formal rules and institutional procedures.

How are Commission officials’ interests discussed?

The discussion draws on Volker Eichener’s distinction between primary and secondary interests and considers actions available to officials during the legislative process.

Excerpt out of 18 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Governance in EU Institutions: The Commission or Consensus as Effectiveness
College
University of Flensburg
Course
Course „European Governance“
Author
Johannes Wiedemann (Author)
Publication Year
2010
Pages
18
Catalog Number
V175479
ISBN (eBook)
9783640964482
ISBN (Book)
9783640964246
Language
English
Tags
European Union Governance Commission Europäische Union Effectiveness Effektivität Europäische Kommission
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Johannes Wiedemann (Author), 2010, Governance in EU Institutions: The Commission or Consensus as Effectiveness, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/175479
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  18  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract