The causes of the Gulf War are numerous. On each level of analysis, different reasons can be stated, be it in the personal character of a ruler, the national interest of the state or systemic constraints. From my point of view, there is no single cause that can be made out, but rather every illustrated explanation (and there are many more) accounts for the eruption of the Gulf War. In addition, I want to mention that within this level of analysis approach some important aspects (like values or norms etc.) are neglected, being taken into consideration by other theoretical schools like constructivism.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Applies Kenneth Waltz’s three levels of analysis to the Gulf War
- Uses Jervis’s approach to perceptions in examining Saddam Hussein’s decisions
- 22 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. The Gulf War in 1991
2. The conflict
3. Three levels of analysis
1. The individual level – Why Iraq seized Kuwait
2. The state level – Why the USA stepped in
3. The systems level – why Iraq attacked Kuwait and the US Iraq
4. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This essay examines the causes of the 1991 Gulf War, asking why Iraq seized Kuwait and why the United States and its coalition partners intervened. Through a literature analysis, it considers explanations at the individual, state and international-system levels.
- The invasion of Kuwait and the international response
- Kenneth Waltz’s levels-of-analysis framework
- Saddam Hussein’s motives and perceptions
- Democratic peace theory and US intervention
- Oil security and regional interests
- Neorealism and the international system
Excerpt from the Book
3. The systems level – why Iraq attacked Kuwait and the US Iraq
Jackson and Sorensen note that “theories at the systemic level explain foreign policy by pointing to conditions in the international system that compel or pressure states towards acting in certain ways” (2007, p. 228). Last but not least, it is situational settings that lead to international conflict.
Maybe the best-known explanation for war on this level is Kenneth Waltz’s Neorealism. According to this approach we live in an anarchic world, i.e. “the essential structural quality of the system is anarchy – the absence of a central monopoly of legitimate force” (Waltz 1989, p. 42), regulating international relations between nation-states. Or in Webber’s words, “the anarchy of the international system is primary, compelling states to act as self-preserving, power-seeking entities” which means that “the best possible policy formulas are determined by the structure of the system itself (anarchy) and the states’ place within that system (distribution capabilities)” (Webber 2008). Hence, increasing one’s own security through gaining power becomes the main motivation for states, thus creating a self-help system that leads in the end to a “‘security dilemma’, wherein measures that enhance one state’s security typically diminish that of others” (Waltz 1989, p. 43). In any case, Waltz considers the distribution of power in a bipolar system more stable than in a multipolar one, which is connected to more uncertainty.
According to the neorealist approach there is no overarching force that can prevent a state from using its power against a weaker one in order to reach its national goals, as happened when Iraq overran Kuwait. In the midst of the dissolution of the bipolar world order Iraq wanted to ensure its functionability as a state. One way to do this was by merging Kuwait into Iraq, thus getting access to the Gulf, and thus positioning itself as regional power in the Gulf area, increasing own capabilities. Furthermore, it didn’t seem likely that the UN would interfere through coercive action due to its inaction in the past. In addition, the international community was engaged with the current turmoil of the dissolving bipolar world order so that “it was perceived that it would not res pond to an act committed against a small state” like Kuwait (Mingst 2004, p. 60).
However, just as Waltz denoted that “in an anarchic domain, the source of one’s own comfort is the source of another’s worry” (1989, p. 43), this let especially the only left superpower United States regard Iraq’s step as a threat to their regional and vital national interests (oil), and last but not least also as possible danger to US power, should it go further. This had to be prevented, also by convincing its allies (especially the big Western powers) that such a step would be in their national interests as well (see Mingst 2004, p. 77).
Chapter Summaries
1. The Gulf War in 1991: The introduction sets out the research question and the use of three levels of analysis to examine the conflict.
2. The conflict: This section outlines Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait, the diplomatic response and the coalition’s military intervention.
3. Three levels of analysis: The author introduces levels of analysis as theoretical perspectives and explains Waltz’s distinction between the individual, the state and the international system.
1. The individual level – Why Iraq seized Kuwait: This section examines Saddam Hussein’s motives and perceptions, drawing on theories of individual decision-making and diversionary conflict.
2. The state level – Why the USA stepped in: The author discusses democratic peace theory alongside US interests in regional security and oil supplies.
3. The systems level – why Iraq attacked Kuwait and the US Iraq: This section uses neorealism to consider anarchy, the distribution of power and security concerns during the transition away from a bipolar world order.
4. Conclusion: The conclusion considers how explanations at different levels contribute to understanding the war and notes the importance of perspectives that address values and identities.
Keywords
Gulf War, Iraq, Kuwait, United States, levels of analysis, Kenneth Waltz, Saddam Hussein, democratic peace theory, neorealism, security dilemma, oil security, international conflict
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It examines the causes of the 1991 Gulf War, focusing on Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait and the international intervention.
What are the main themes?
The essay explores individual decision-making, state characteristics and interests, and the structure of the international system.
What is the primary research question?
It asks how the causes of an international conflict can be explained on at least three levels of analysis.
What method does the author use?
The author conducts a literature analysis, using international relations scholarship to examine the conflict.
What does the main analysis cover?
It considers Saddam Hussein’s motives and perceptions, US and coalition intervention, and systemic explanations associated with neorealism.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include Gulf War, levels of analysis, democratic peace theory, neorealism, security dilemma and oil security.
How is Kenneth Waltz’s framework used?
The essay organizes explanations of the war around Waltz’s three levels: the individual, the state and the international system.
How does the essay discuss oil security?
It considers access to oil reserves and secure oil flows when discussing Iraqi and US interests in the Gulf region.
- Quote paper
- Natalie Züfle (Author), 2009, Conflict and Levels of Analysis , Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/180080