Election campaigns are common rituals in democracies.
Politicians try to persuade voters in order to be elected.
Therefore, political candidates usually make use of professional
campaigning strategies that involve the television as the most
important medium. Since the 1960s US presidential campaign
ads on TV have been increasingly successful and cutting-edge.
They sometimes were so convincing they even swung a
decision. Over the last decades the predominant topics in US
federal politics were the Cold War as well as national security
and the US military. In 1964 the presidential election campaign
was highly influenced by the escalating situation in Vietnam and
the general disquiet caused by the arms race and nuclear
weapons. The American psyche was collectively anxious about
the latent atomic menace so it suggested itself to address fear
in a presidential campaign ad. The Nixon campaign 1972 dealt
with one of the genuine Republican topics: Military. Due to its
success it was remade in two subsequent campaigns called
“Tank Ride” in 1988 for George Bush and 2004 in “Weapons
Florida” for George W. Bush. The latter will be examined in this
paper, too.
However, there are different approaches to persuade the
voting public; one of the most favorable techniques is playing
on the people’s emotions. Thus, it is not surprising that US
presidential campaign ads have a history of exploiting fear in
television ads. It leads from 1964 until 2004 and aims at
persuading voters by the well-directed use of sounds, images
and language.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. “Peace Little Girl (Daisy)”, 1964 (Johnson)
2.1 Images
2.2 Sounds
2.3 Language
3. “McGovern Defense”, 1972 (Nixon)
3.1 Images
3.2 Sounds
3.3 Language
4. “Weapons (Florida)”, 2004 (George W. Bush)
4.1 Images
4.2 Sounds
4.3 Language
5. Conclusion
Objectives and Topics
This paper examines how US presidential campaign television advertisements use fear to persuade voters, focusing on the interplay of images, sounds and language in three advertisements from 1964 to 2004. It asks how these elements evoke threats and present candidates in relation to national security.
- The nuclear threat in Johnson’s “Peace Little Girl (Daisy)”
- Military spending and national security in Nixon’s “McGovern Defense”
- The War on Terror in Bush’s “Weapons (Florida)”
- Visual symbolism, music, voices and verbal appeals
- Negative campaigning and portrayals of rival candidates
Excerpt from the Book
3.1 Images
The ad starts with a close up on toy soldiers that are lined up in units before an anonymous hand appears and sweeps them away as well as planes and warships. This stark action exemplifies the “McGovern Defense Plan” in the blink of an eye. However, there is a minatory statement behind the seemingly playful scene. McGovern’s cuts for defense would treat the US soldiers disrespectfully and forgetfully. The public arrives at the conclusion that presidential hopeful does not value the soldiers; thus, neither he does his fellow citizen. Nixon’s rival candidate is allegorized as rash and ruthless president to-be. Fear is even amplified because of the inanimate and helpless condition the plastic soldiers are in. There is no chance to escape the rigorous intentions to decimate and extinguish them. Their elimination equals the surrender to the Cold War enemies. If McGovern became president he would relegate the nation to the status of an unprotected victim. This is demonstrated in the close-up scene showing the toys that have just been mixed up lying around all in a tumble now. It looks like the defeated US army after a lost battle.
The soldiers, planes and warships symbolize the US American national security. Although they are only toys viewers will immediately conclude what they represent. Not only are they the country’s protective shield and life insurance but also the national pride and source of self-esteem. Not less than that is endangered by the McGovern Defense Plan. In the second part of the spot Nixon is shown on a battleship alongside top-ranking officers. Thus, the two opposing scenes are juxtaposing the good and the insecure and headless future with McGovern versus Nixon’s America with him as strong and popular leader surrounded by shiny military. The final fading says “Democrats for Nixon” which might confuse the audience at a first glance. Surprisingly there were Democrats favoring Nixon because they did not agree with their own presidential candidate’s politics. Mentioning Democratic supporters in the ad’s credits is an effective strategy; it fuels the mistrust concerning McGovern as even his own men consider him suspect and prefer his opponent.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The introduction places televised presidential campaign advertising in the context of nuclear anxiety, military policy and emotional persuasion.
2. “Peace Little Girl (Daisy)”, 1964 (Johnson): This chapter examines the advertisement’s imagery, sounds and language, including its juxtaposition of a child with a nuclear explosion.
3. “McGovern Defense”, 1972 (Nixon): The author analyzes toy military figures, contrasting music and claims about defense cuts in an advertisement targeting George McGovern.
4. “Weapons (Florida)”, 2004 (George W. Bush): The chapter considers how images of troops, military sounds and statements about John Kerry connect the campaign to the War on Terror and national security.
5. Conclusion: The conclusion discusses how images, sounds and language can prompt emotional responses to perceived threats and calls for critical reflection on campaign advertising.
Keywords
US presidential elections, television advertising, fear appeals, political campaigns, national security, nuclear weapons, military spending, negative campaigning, visual imagery, sound, political language, War on Terror, voter persuasion
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It examines the use of fear in US presidential campaign television advertisements.
What are its central topics?
Its main topics include nuclear anxiety, military policy, national security and the use of images, sounds and language to persuade voters.
What is the paper’s main objective?
It aims to show how selected presidential advertisements evoke fear through visual, auditory and verbal techniques.
What method does the author use?
The author offers a qualitative analysis of three advertisements, examining each one’s images, sounds and language. The paper also draws on published literature.
What does the main body cover?
It analyzes Johnson’s “Peace Little Girl (Daisy),” Nixon’s “McGovern Defense” and George W. Bush’s “Weapons (Florida).”
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include fear appeals, television advertising, presidential campaigns, national security, negative campaigning and voter persuasion.
How does the paper approach the “Daisy” advertisement?
It examines the contrast between a child picking petals and a nuclear explosion, as well as the advertisement’s countdown, voices and appeal to voters.
What connects “McGovern Defense” and “Weapons (Florida)”?
The introduction identifies the 2004 advertisement as a remake of the 1972 campaign’s military-themed advertisement. The analysis discusses national security and candidates’ positions on military spending in both.
- Quote paper
- Julia Wehner (Author), 2011, Television Ads in US Presidential Campaigns Have a History of Exploiting Fear , Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/189939