12 September 1980, the third successful military coup in the history of Turkey, has had a debilitating impact on the social, political and cultural life of the country. This thesis examines the representations of the 12 September coup through the lens of film as memory. Based on content analysis of two films, Beynelmilel (2006) and Bu Son Olsun (2012) and their reception, this study examines the representations of the 12 September military coup by means of the concepts of cultural memory, communicative and material memory (memory of objects), and construes whether the reconstruction of this particular past event is challenged by the abovementioned cinematic products as a way to impinge upon the collective memories of this seminal event in Turkey. The results demonstrate that both cinematic products are reflective of multiple and fragmented memories of the 12 September, and that there is not a strong manifestation of remembering or references to memories of this event as the interpretation of online reviews of both products puts forward.
At a glance
- Qualitative analysis incorporates 595 online film reviews
- Applies Jan Assmann’s communicative and material memory concepts to the films
- 57 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. INTRODUCTION
2. AIM
3. RESEARCH QUESTIONS
4. STRUCTURE
5. MOTIVATION
6. MATERIAL
7. A BRIEF HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
8. CHAPTER ONE: THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
8.1 WHAT IS MEMORY?
8.2 INDIVIDUAL VS COLLECTIVE MEMORY
8.3 CULTURAL MEMORY
8.4 HISTORY VS MEMORY : THE PAST PRESENT AND THE PRESENT PAST
8.5 FILM, HISTORY AND MEMORY
9. CHAPTER TWO: METHODOLOGY
9.1 RATIONALE FOR SELECTION OF CASES
9.2 METHOD
9.3 LIMITATIONS AND CRITICISM
10. CHAPTER THREE: ANALYSIS
10.1 A RURAL PERSPECTIVE: BEYNELMİLEL
10.1.1 Synopsis of film
10.1.2 Beynelmilel as a 12 September Film
10.1.3 Silence and Peace: How Does Beynelmilel Construct Memory?
10.1.4 Communicative Memory
10.1.5 Memory of Objects
10.1.6 Seeing Reality On the Ground: Comparison of My Readings to The Reviews
10.2 WILL IT BE THE LAST?: SILENCİNG SOCIETY IN BU SON OLSUN
10.2.1 Synopsis of film
10.2.2 Bu Son Olsun as a 12 September Film
10.2.3 Communicative Memory
10.2.4 Memory of Objects
10.2.5 Reality On the Ground Two: Comparison of My Readings To the Reviews
11. CONCLUSION
Objective and Themes
This thesis examines how Beynelmilel and Bu Son Olsun reconstruct Turkey’s 12 September 1980 military coup and asks whether the films challenge collective memories of the event. It combines close readings of the films with an interpretation of online audience reviews, using concepts from cultural and collective memory studies.
- Film as a medium of historical and cultural memory
- Communicative memory and the memory of objects
- Rural and urban representations of the coup
- Narrative, setting, costume and character interaction
- Online reception and audience interpretations
- Silence, political repression and intergenerational remembrance
Excerpt from the Book
Individual vs Collective Memory
In sociology, history and cultural theory, the phrase, collective memory, proposes that practices of remembrance are shaped and reinforced by societies and cultures. Memory studies in a wider sense is a multi-disciplinary field to which psychology, neurology, sociology, anthropology etc. have contributed. However, there is an ongoing debate in collective memory studies which concerns the relation between the individual and collective. In the following lines, this disputed area will be put forward based on prominent scholars from both strands of memory studies by focusing on discussions and definition of both concepts.
Contemporary usage of the term collective memory is largely traceable to Emile Durkheim and his student, Maurice Halbwachs in the Social Frameworks of Memory (1925). Embarking upon the concept of memory as a purely individual phenomenon, Henri Bergson (1896) was challenged by Maurice Halbwachs in his fundamental work where Halbwachs asserts that studying memory does not pertain to ruminating on properties of the subjective mind. Instead, for Halbwachs, memory is a matter of how minds work together in society and how their operations are structured by social arrangements. According to Halbwachs, it is not possible for individuals to recollect or remember in a coherent and consistent way out of their group contexts. He examplifies this with the impossibility for an individual to remember with certainty regarding particular childhood memories as individuals recollect these memories based on the narratives of their parents.
Halbwachs explains his collective memory concept by using what he calls “social frameworks”. By defining collective memory in terms of social frames, Halbwachs adopts a constructivist perspective, which distances him from collective mythmakers and essentialists. Halbwachs’ thesis has been today verified by contemporary psychological and neurobiological studies which highlight the social nature of individual remembering and forgetting, and assert that narrative patterns used to express individual memories including autobiographical ones cannot be separated from the social. Therefore, both individual and collective memory interact, for remembering is categorized as a social phenomenon and individual remembering is influenced by the social frameworks (as suggested by Halbwachs) that exist in a society bounded by limited space and time. It is not productive to polarize the individual and collective strand of memory as they interact.
Chapter Summaries
INTRODUCTION: The introduction situates the project within debates about cinema, historical representation and the 1980 coup.
AIM: The author sets out to examine how the two films reconstruct the coup and how their reception relates to remembrance.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS: The questions concern the films’ reconstructions of the coup and their potential to challenge collective memories.
STRUCTURE: This section outlines the theoretical discussion, methodology, film analyses and examination of audience responses.
MOTIVATION: The author explains the importance of cinema in shaping how historical events are remembered and forgotten.
MATERIAL: The two selected films and their contrasting narrative settings are introduced.
A BRIEF HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: This section describes military intervention, political repression and changes in Turkish cinema after the coup.
CHAPTER ONE: THEORETICAL BACKGROUND: The chapter discusses individual, collective and cultural memory, the relationship between history and memory, and film as a medium of remembrance.
CHAPTER TWO: METHODOLOGY: The author explains case selection and qualitative content analysis, including the use of online reviews, and considers methodological limitations.
CHAPTER THREE: ANALYSIS: Separate readings of the two films examine narrative, communicative memory and objects before comparing those readings with audience reviews.
CONCLUSION: The final chapter brings together the interpretations of the films and their reception, reflecting on fragmented memories and collective forgetting.
Keywords
12 September 1980, military coup, Turkey, collective memory, cultural memory, communicative memory, material memory, Turkish cinema, film studies, reception studies, qualitative content analysis, historical representation, audience reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this thesis about?
It examines how two Turkish films represent the 1980 military coup and how their reception relates to collective memory.
What are its central themes?
The main themes include cinema and historical memory, political repression, communicative and material memory, and audience reception.
What is the primary research question?
The thesis asks how the films reconstruct the coup and whether they challenge collective memories of it.
What research method does the author use?
The author uses qualitative content analysis and interpretative readings of the films, comparing these with online reviews.
What does the main analysis cover?
It examines each film’s narrative, dialogue, objects and setting, then compares the author’s readings with audience responses.
Which keywords characterize the thesis?
Key terms include collective memory, cultural memory, Turkish cinema, the 1980 coup, qualitative content analysis and reception studies.
How do the two films differ in their settings?
Beynelmilel is examined through a rural southeastern setting, while Bu Son Olsun is situated in Istanbul and a prison.
How does the author use memory theory?
The analysis draws on Astrid Erll’s account of cultural memory and Jan Assmann’s concepts of communicative and material memory.
What audience material is considered?
The author reports using 595 online reviews and compares themes in these responses with the film readings.
- Quote paper
- Ozan Tekin (Author), 2012, Factories of Memory: Remembering the 12 September Military Coup in Beynelmilel and Bu Son Olsun, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/202613