Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Region: Western Europe

Is the sovereignty of the UK Parliament a meaningless concept and should it be abandoned?

Title: Is the sovereignty of the UK Parliament a meaningless concept and should it be abandoned?

Term Paper , 2011 , 6 Pages , Grade: 77%

Autor:in: Roy Whymark (Author)

Politics - Region: Western Europe
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

This paper considers whether the concept of ‘parliamentary sovereignty’ is a reality in the modern United Kingdom.

To frame the boundaries of this essay, ‘parliamentary’ is taken as referring to action taken by the Westminster-based tripartite authorities of the House of Commons, the House of Lords and the British monarchy.

Since an incontrovertible definition of ‘sovereignty’ is more difficult, I turn to Dicey (1915) who uses two criteria. Firstly, Parliament has ‘the right to make or unmake any law’, and secondly ‘no person or body is recognized by the law of England as having a right to override or set aside the legislation of Parliament’.

Taking these together, I define ‘parliamentary sovereignty’ as a concept which considers that the Westminster Parliament has complete control over the legal affairs of the UK and that no individual or body can override any Act of Parliament. This also incorporates the Diceyan concept that no Parliament can bind its successor.

In recent decades, the reality of parliamentary sovereignty has been increasingly questioned due to a number of constitutional changes. In particular, this paper considers the impact on parliamentary sovereignty of: (i) membership of the European Union; (ii) the passing of the Human Rights Act; (iii) the changing role of the judiciary; and (iv) devolution.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Examines the Factortame case and the Merchant Shipping Act 1988
  • Applies Dicey’s two criteria for parliamentary sovereignty
  • Examines devolution across Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
  • 12 sources in the bibliography

Contents

1. Membership of the European Union

2. Human Rights Act 1998

3. Changing role of the judiciary

4. Devolution

5. Conclusion

Objectives and Topics

This essay asks whether parliamentary sovereignty remains a meaningful concept in the United Kingdom. Using Dicey’s definition as a starting point, it examines the distinction between Parliament’s formal legal authority and the practical constraints associated with constitutional change.

  • Dicey’s criteria for parliamentary sovereignty
  • European Union membership and the Factortame case
  • The Human Rights Act and declarations of incompatibility
  • Judicial independence and review
  • Devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
  • Legal sovereignty and political constraints

Excerpt from the Book

Devolution

Devolution for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland has involved the delegation of powers from Westminster to Holyrood, Cardiff Bay and Stormont respectively. Under the asymmetrical devolution agreements, the governing bodies in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have assumed new powers to varying degrees. For example, both the Scottish Government and the Northern Ireland Assembly are able to legislate on a range of domestic issues such as welfare and justice.

The impact on Parliamentary sovereignty is interesting. In the Northern Ireland case, there has most definitely been a loss of sovereignty since the 1998 Belfast Agreement established the British-Irish Council, meaning that the Republic of Ireland would have to be consulted on any changes Westminster wished to make in relation to the status of the province.

Aside from Northern Ireland, the impact of devolution on parliamentary sovereignty has yet to be fully tested. Under the devolution agreements, Westminster’s supremacy was explicitly included. For, example, the Scotland Act 1998, notes that devolution ‘does not affect the power of the Parliament of the United Kingdom to make laws for Scotland’ (The Scottish Office, 1998).

As with the Europe, the theory and practice of parliamentary sovereignty in relation to devolution may be very different. While Westminster may retain the power to overrule the devolved bodies, or indeed suspend the devolved bodies, this would practically be very difficult and it is hard to see how this could be achieved without causing lasting damage to Westminster politics and perhaps the state of the union itself. Elliot concludes that ‘while it remains legally possible for Westminster to legislate unilaterally on devolved issues, adopting such a course would be politically very difficult, since it would undermine the very philosophy on which devolution is based’ (Elliot, 2002).

Chapter Summaries

1. Membership of the European Union: The essay examines the European Communities Act 1972 and the Factortame case in relation to the authority of EU law. It considers the distinction between the legal possibility of leaving the EU and the practical constraints on doing so.

2. Human Rights Act 1998: This section discusses compatibility with the European Convention on Human Rights and the role of declarations of incompatibility. It considers examples including prisoners’ voting rights and the possibility of repealing the Act.

3. Changing role of the judiciary: The author examines judicial review, judicial independence and the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. The discussion considers whether the courts themselves pose a challenge to parliamentary sovereignty.

4. Devolution: This section considers the delegation of powers to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland and the relationship between Westminster’s legal authority and political constraints.

5. Conclusion: The author distinguishes formal parliamentary sovereignty from its practical exercise in a constitutional system involving national, regional and supranational bodies.

Keywords

parliamentary sovereignty, Dicey, United Kingdom constitution, European Union, Factortame, Human Rights Act 1998, European Convention on Human Rights, judicial review, judicial independence, devolution, Westminster, Scotland Act 1998

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this essay about?

It examines whether parliamentary sovereignty remains meaningful in the United Kingdom in light of constitutional change.

What are its central themes?

The essay focuses on European Union membership, human rights legislation, the judiciary and devolution.

What is the main question?

The author asks whether Parliament retains effective sovereignty and whether the concept should be abandoned.

What method does the author use?

The essay uses legal and constitutional analysis, drawing on legislation, court decisions and academic commentary.

What does the main discussion cover?

It considers how European law, human rights protections, judicial authority and devolved government relate to Westminster’s law-making power.

Which keywords characterize the essay?

Key terms include parliamentary sovereignty, Dicey, Factortame, the Human Rights Act, judicial review and devolution.

Why is the Factortame case discussed?

The case provides an example of a conflict between UK legislation and European law, raising questions about Parliament’s authority under the European Communities Act 1972.

How does the essay approach devolution?

It compares Westminster’s formal legislative authority with the political difficulties that could arise from intervening in devolved matters in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Excerpt out of 6 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Is the sovereignty of the UK Parliament a meaningless concept and should it be abandoned?
College
Birkbeck, University of London  (University of London)
Course
Contemporary British Politics
Grade
77%
Author
Roy Whymark (Author)
Publication Year
2011
Pages
6
Catalog Number
V207479
ISBN (eBook)
9783656348078
Language
English
Tags
parliament
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Roy Whymark (Author), 2011, Is the sovereignty of the UK Parliament a meaningless concept and should it be abandoned?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/207479
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  6  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract