Considered as one of the first American writers to produce American national literature, Charles Brockden Brown belongs to the forefathers of the American Gothic Fiction and embodies the pioneer spirit of the American Short Story. Although throughout the last decades, intense and prolific research has been conducted about his life and works, respectively Wieland and Edgar Huntly, Brown’s Somnambulism yet remains a relatively obscure and unexplored narrative. The goal of this paper is to bring fourth its literary relevance within the context of the American Gothic Fiction by analyzing the occurrence, narrative usage and effect of Gothic elements in Brown’s fragment Somnambulism. By doing so, I will firstly give a short overview about its publishing history, followed by a brief excursion to the definition of short story to underline that Brown’s account is both short and Gothic story. The definition of the Gothic Fiction describes the historical development of the Gothic story, explaining its relevance in the American context and broaching Brown’s political use of the Gothic mode. Finally, the main body of this paper will demonstrate the comprised gothic elements of the story, exemplifying the constantly rising construction of horror through the lovelorn protagonist’s sick double mental existence and the sinister description of his counterpart Nick Handyside.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Close reading of Richard Althorpe and Nick Handyside as sources of Gothic horror
- Applies Hogle’s distinction between terror Gothic and horror Gothic
- 20 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Publishing History
3. Short Story about the Short Story
4. Definition of Gothic Fiction
5. Analysis of Gothic Elements in Somnambulism
5.1 The Double Mental Existence in Richard Althorpe
5.2 Nick Handyside: The Incorporation of Human Evil?
6. Conclusion
Objectives and Topics
This paper examines the literary significance of Charles Brockden Brown’s Somnambulism within American Gothic fiction. It asks how Gothic elements appear in the narrative, how they are employed, and how they contribute to the creation of horror.
- The publication history of Somnambulism
- The story’s relationship to the early American short story
- Gothic fiction and its adaptation to the American context
- Richard Althorpe’s divided mental existence
- Nick Handyside’s role in suspense and horror
- Rationality, irrationality, guilt, and individual consciousness
Excerpt from the Book
5.1 The Double Mental Existence in Richard Althorpe
In this chapter, I will reveal Althorpe’s madness and dangerous “double mental existence” (Green 183), rendering the whole story not only uncanny, but already offering various denouements. As we take a closer look at Althorpe, his maniac tendencies and inability to cope with elements of reality, such as e.g. loss, become first notable with his reception of the message about the impending departure of the Davis family. Describing his feelings about the departure of Miss Davis and his painful emotions towards their separation, Althorpe instinctively employs to a great extent negatively connotative adjectives and verbs: Words like “ravished” (Brown, “Somnambulism” 6), “impossible” (6), “swallowed up” (6) or “hateful obligation” (6) underline the dominating acrimonious atmosphere. As effect, we as reader do not learn only about his anxiety of loss, but even feel with him a sort of empathy for his desperate situation. At this stage of the story, Althorpe is still awake, conscious and master of his emotions. Ensuing from the worst case scenario, that is, the next time he “saw her again, it would probably be as a wife” (6), Althorpe expands and intensifies this train of thought, imagining who could be the lucky one Miss Davis has chosen to marry. In his enumerations of questions circling about the unknown lucky, it becomes clear that Althorpe, albeit an adult and an alleged rational being, cannot cope with jealousy, too: “Who was he that Constantia Davis had chosen? Was he born to outstrip all competitors in ardour and fidelity?” (6). His passion for Miss Davis turns into her idolization. In her, he perceives the personified innocence and aesthetics, denominating her as “prize” (6), simultaneously denying her autonomous traits. His negative emotions, if not aggressions towards the unknown opponent, grow constantly to the point that he perceives Miss Davis fiancée as a “competitor” (6). As a physical confrontation is temporary not at hand, he switches to the verbal level, ridiculing him: Thus, Althorpe calls his adversary “pusillanimous and feeble” (6) in order to justify his thoughts and future conduct – which is by all means socially inappropriate and, as we will see, will tend towards stalking and harassment. He cannot lose; the experienced reader might foreshadow at this early stage an upcoming lethal confrontation, eventually between Althorpe and his unknown rival. Although approval is yet to be given, suspension builds itself up as the reader wants to know Althorpe’s solution approach. Jealousy, anxiety of loss and solitude become best visible in the following passage which elicits Althorpe’s self-doubt, selling himself below value and ending in absolute desperation:
I shall speedily be forgotten by her. I have done nothing that entitles me to a place in her remembrance. While my rival will be left at liberty to prosecute his suit, I shall be abandoned to solitude, and have no other employment than to ruminate on the bliss that has eluded my grasp. […] I am manacled and powerless (7).
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The author sets out the paper’s aim and explains its approach to Gothic elements in Brown’s narrative.
Publishing History: This chapter considers the story’s anonymous publication and its relationship to Brown’s editorial work and the political context of the early republic.
Short Story about the Short Story: The author discusses definitions of the short story and considers how Brown’s fragment relates to the development of the American short story.
Definition of Gothic Fiction: This chapter traces Gothic fiction from its English context to its adaptation in America and considers the political implications of Brown’s Gothic writing.
Analysis of Gothic Elements in Somnambulism: A close reading examines Althorpe’s divided mental existence and the portrayal of Nick Handyside, focusing on their contribution to suspense and horror.
Conclusion: The author brings together the discussion of the story’s genre, psychological tensions, and relationship to American Gothic fiction.
Keywords
Charles Brockden Brown, Somnambulism, American Gothic fiction, early American short story, sleepwalking, Richard Althorpe, Nick Handyside, double mental existence, horror, suspense, rationality, irrationality, abjection, literary analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It examines Gothic elements in Charles Brockden Brown’s Somnambulism and their role in creating horror.
What are its central topics?
The paper addresses the story’s publication history, its relationship to the short story, American Gothic fiction, divided consciousness, and the portrayal of its characters.
What is the paper’s primary objective?
Its objective is to establish the narrative’s literary relevance within American Gothic fiction by analyzing the occurrence, use, and effect of Gothic elements.
What method does the author use?
The author conducts an intrinsic literary analysis of the text, supported by scholarship on Gothic fiction and early American narratives.
What does the main analysis discuss?
It focuses on Richard Althorpe’s double mental existence and Nick Handyside’s contribution to suspense and horror.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include American Gothic fiction, sleepwalking, double mental existence, horror, rationality, irrationality, and abjection.
How does the paper distinguish terror Gothic from horror Gothic?
Drawing on Jerrold E. Hogle, it describes terror Gothic in terms of anxious suspense and horror Gothic in terms of explicit confrontation with physical or psychological violence.
Why does the paper discuss the American short story?
It considers whether Brown’s fragment meets criteria associated with the short story and how early American narratives relate to the genre’s development.
How is Nick Handyside considered in the analysis?
The paper examines his portrayal alongside Althorpe’s divided consciousness and discusses abjection as a way of understanding their relationship.
- Quote paper
- Mario Nsonga (Author), 2012, Between Madness and Sanity: Gothic Elements in Charles Brockden Brown’s “Somnambulism”, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/207836