Topic to be discussed: "Discuss the extent to which the silent, silence and silences play an important role in Kate Grenville's novel "The Secret River"."
This essay discusses Kate Grenville attempt to convey the great Australian silence, especially the silence that followed the - mostly violent - confrontations between the Aboriginals and the white settlers.
At a glance
- Grade: 2.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines the carved fish beneath Thornhill’s house as a symbol
Contents
1. Colonial History and the Novel
2. Historical Fiction and Public Debate
3. Settlers, Aboriginal People and Silencing
4. Family Silence and the Carved Fish
5. Language and the Historical Record
Aim and Themes
This essay examines how silence, silencing and different forms of absence operate in Kate Grenville’s The Secret River. It asks how these motifs shape the novel’s representation of colonial settlement, relationships between settlers and Aboriginal people, and the historical record.
- Colonial dispossession and the suppression of historical violence
- The relationship between historical fiction and public debate
- Contrasting settler attitudes towards Aboriginal people
- Silence within the Thornhill family and settler community
- The carved fish as a symbol of Aboriginal culture
- Language barriers and Aboriginal voices
Excerpt from the Book
Discuss the extent to which the silent, silence and silences play an important role in Kate Grenville’s novel The Secret River.
Kate Grenville's motivation for writing a novel, which focuses on the confrontation of white settlers and Aboriginal people, can be mainly attributed to the research in her own family history, where she found out that her ”great-great-great grandfather Solomon Wiseman, shipped to Sydney in the early 1800s” where he ”must have had contact with the Aboriginals” and later ”turned himself into a wealthy landowner on the Hawkesbury River” (cf. Brosch 228). This is pretty much the story of William Thornhill who ”grew up, in the last decades of the eighteenth century” in London, where ”no one could move an elbow without hitting the wall or the table or sister or a brother” (cf. Grenville 9). After being pardoned and deported for the time of ”his natural life”, William starts a new life in a new land and tries to rise from the dirt to become a wealthy landowner. However, he pays the price and also makes others pay, not in hard cash but in terms of suppression and an act of silencing.
The characters in The Secret River can be generally divided into two groups. At the one hand there are the white settlers, who try to cooperate and interact with the Indigenous people. They recognize the Aborigines as the legitimate owners of the land and encounter them with respect and caution. Mrs. Herring and Thomas Blackwood can be assigned to this party. On the side are Smasher and Sagitty, of whom especially Smasher always brags about his harsh way of treating the Indigenous people, which serves as an extreme and shocking example of failures in the early settlement. His ”mistreatment of Aborigines and his cruel enslavement of an Aboriginal woman” (cf. Kossew 16) is explicitly documented in Kate Grenville's novel, but presumably would have been a historic event, that white settlers maintain 'silence' about, orally as well as in the written record. William Thornhill actually just wants to own his 'hundred acres' and escape from the life – as a poor thief – he lived in London. He eventually turns into a ”hardly recognizable William Thornhill” (cf. Grenville 328). No matter how much he ”achieves” he is never really satisfied with what he has, as we can see when Grenville writes: ”The finished place was not quite what Thornhill had pictured. Something was wrong with the way the pieces fitted together: some were too big, others too small” (Grenville 329). However he is easily manipulated by Blackwood and therefore led to participate in the massacre in the Aboriginal camp towards the end of the novel. Thornhill is kind of naive, which causes the reader to follow the protagonist on every step, but at the same time fret about his actions, which actually do not seem to fit his character.
Section Summaries
1. Colonial History and the Novel: The essay introduces colonial dispossession and the suppression of violence in historical accounts, placing Grenville’s novel within a discussion of Australian history.
2. Historical Fiction and Public Debate: It considers controversy surrounding the novel and the relationship between fiction, historical interpretation and public ethics.
3. Settlers, Aboriginal People and Silencing: The discussion connects Grenville’s family-history research with the novel and examines settler characters, their treatment of Aboriginal people and the silence surrounding violence.
4. Family Silence and the Carved Fish: The essay explores silences between William and Sal Thornhill and interprets the carved fish beneath their house as a symbol of Aboriginal culture.
5. Language and the Historical Record: The final discussion considers limited Aboriginal speech, barriers to communication and silence in the historical record.
Keywords
Kate Grenville, The Secret River, silence, silencing, Australian literature, colonial settlement, Aboriginal peoples, dispossession, historical fiction, historical record, William Thornhill, settler violence, cultural representation
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It examines the importance of silence and silencing in Kate Grenville’s novel The Secret River.
What are its central themes?
Its themes include colonial dispossession, settler violence, historical memory, communication and the representation of Aboriginal people.
What is the essay’s main question?
It asks how and to what extent silence and silencing matter in the novel and its treatment of Australia’s colonial past.
What method does the essay use?
It uses literary analysis, interpreting passages and characters from the novel alongside published critical commentary.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers settler attitudes, the aftermath of violence, silence within the Thornhill family, the carved fish and barriers between settlers and Aboriginal people.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include silence, colonial settlement, dispossession, historical fiction, Aboriginal peoples and historical memory.
How does the essay discuss the fish carved in stone?
It interprets the carving beneath Thornhill’s house as a symbol of Aboriginal culture and its concealment.
How does Grenville’s family history relate to the discussion?
The essay links her research into her ancestor Solomon Wiseman to the novel’s portrayal of a settler who becomes a landowner on the Hawkesbury River.
- Quote paper
- Volker Hartmann (Author), 2011, Silence in Kate Grenville's novel "The Secret River", Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/208190