(...) In theory, it was a decent compromise between a king and his subjects. But practice showed a much different picture. As much as Japan was acquainted to stratification of the people it is surprising that this did not reflect in its constitution: Nobody was responsible. The emperor was by default infallible, therefore could not be held responsible; in theory it was the government by countersignature, but in reality, nobody could be held there responsible either as nobody had any official authority. It would soon unravel into a convoluted political intrigue and even assassinations. Moreover, the constitution didn’t account for the most important factor of all concepts to regulate humanity: human character itself. But for now, the revolutionists of the Meiji restoration were able to master the balancing act between spiritual commitment and worldly necessity.
Contents
1. Shintō Ideology in the 20th Century
Aims and Topics
This essay examines the relationship between Shintō, imperial authority, nationalism and Japanese wartime conduct. It asks how religious ideas became intertwined with state ideology and how the author connects that development to practices during Japan's wars.
- Shintō traditions and the idea of divine imperial authority
- The Meiji Restoration, constitutional government and national identity
- State Shintō and the development of ultranationalism
- Imperial expansion and comparisons with Nazi Germany
- Wartime sexual violence and kamikaze pilots
Excerpt from the Book
Shintō Ideology in the 20th Century
During the Edo period (江戸時代), Japan’s ruling elite followed strict politics of isolationism. This protected the long established feudalism in Japan, while western revolutions had forced its popular sovereignty onto its nobility. The powerful class of the daimyo (大名 lords) repressed modern thought of Enlightenment to ensure the ancient ways and with that their power base. The installed rigid monarchy was led by a shogun, but the actual power lay with the lords. A conscious decision to abstain from global affairs and its exposure of different thought proved of course eventually fruitless.
The resulting Meiji Revolution (1868 until 1912) installed the monarch firmly into his power position. Emperor Meiji and his advisors led Japan into the modern age. Their aim was to modernize Japan in economically, industrially, and militarily, after seeing the gap between their own development and the threatening western powers. Nevertheless, Japan was to remain true to its Kokutai (國體 sovereign, national essence or identity) by returning to its roots on which Shintō was the unifying factor. Great scholars of the time are Hozumi Yatsuka and Minobe Tatsukichi. Those men set the intellectual framework for the combination of the worldly powers of the emperor and his divine right to do so. Refraining to any modern European thought, the emperor was the reincarnation of the sun goddess Amaterasu Ōmikami (天照大神/天照大御神), and with that the legitimacy and divinity by birth appointed ruler.
The constitution aiming for reform ensured the survival of the monarchy by a move which outcome those creators of the writing had so not intended: Article 1 makes the emperor head of state and a deity. As a deity the emperor was infallible, but as the head of state he was infallible due to his divinity. To overcome this apparent incongruity in the spirit of the Meiji Restoration, democratic representation and the appointment of ministers were installed. The politicians then had to affect the proposed legislature by signature after a reviewed proposal by the emperor. This way, a decision could be made for the welfare of Japan to include the spiritual leader and the government. All power lay with the head of Japan, the emperor. But he in turn was dependent on the advice of his ministries. The ministries equally answered directly to the emperor, all ministries had the same access ability. In theory, it was a decent compromise between a king and his subjects. But practice showed a much different picture. As much as Japan was acquainted to stratification of the people it is surprising that this did not reflect in its constitution: Nobody was responsible. The emperor was by default infallible, therefore could not be held responsible; in theory it was the government by countersignature, but in reality, nobody could be held there responsible either as nobody had any official authority. It would soon unravel into a convoluted political intrigue and even assassinations. Moreover, the constitution didn’t account for the most important factor of all concepts to regulate humanity: human character itself. But for now, the revolutionists of the Meiji restoration were able to master the balancing act between spiritual commitment and worldly necessity.
Chapter Summary
Shintō Ideology in the 20th Century: The essay traces Shintō from its religious and cultural background through the Meiji political order and the rise of State Shintō. It connects imperial authority and ultranationalism to Japanese expansion and examines wartime sexual violence and kamikaze pilots as examples.
Keywords
Shintō, State Shintō, Japan, imperial authority, Meiji Restoration, kokutai, nationalism, fascism, ultranationalism, Japanese expansion, wartime sexual violence, kamikaze pilots, Second World War
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the essay about?
It explores the relationship between Shintō ideology, imperial authority and Japanese nationalism in the twentieth century.
What are its central themes?
The essay addresses religion, constitutional authority, national identity, militarism, imperial expansion and wartime conduct.
What is the essay's main aim?
It seeks to explain how religious ideas became connected to state ideology and how the author relates that connection to Japan's wartime actions.
What method does the author use?
The author develops a historical interpretive argument using published works and a lecture, alongside comparisons between Japan and Germany.
What does the main discussion cover?
It moves from Shintō traditions and Meiji political thought to State Shintō, ultranationalism, expansion and selected wartime examples.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include State Shintō, imperial authority, kokutai, nationalism, fascism, wartime sexual violence and kamikaze pilots.
How does the essay discuss the emperor's authority?
It considers the relationship between the emperor's attributed divinity, constitutional position and connections to his subjects, including Hozumi Yatsuka's ideas about sovereignty.
Which wartime examples does the author examine?
The author discusses wartime sexual violence, including the military's comfort stations, and the use of kamikaze pilots.
How does the essay use a comparison with Germany?
It compares aspects of political radicalization and wartime conduct in Japan and Nazi Germany while considering differences in their religious contexts.
- Quote paper
- Claudia Cease (Author), 2012, Institutionalized Fascism Shinto, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/263606