A short essay written for a political science class discussing recent presidents and their particular approaches to urban policy and city planning.
Contents
1. Failure to Communicate
Objectives and Themes
This essay examines the development of federal urban policy across successive US administrations and asks what obstacles stand in the way of a coordinated national approach to the needs of cities.
- Federal urban policy under Presidents George H. W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama
- Housing tax credits and community empowerment zones
- Urban funding, education, and economic development
- Hurricane Katrina and the federal response
- Cooperation among federal officials, cities, and mayors
Excerpt from the Book
Failure to Communicate
The premature sinking of Obama’s Office of Urban Policy comes as another blow to cities already grappling with an economic recession. This lack of a cohesive urban policy has damaged the ability of most American cities to survive, and the situation has been especially dire since the period after the elder George Bush’s Administration’s Community Uplift Program. Under President Bush, the Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) established in 1986 became the centerpiece of an otherwise lacking American urban policy (Hendrickson). This credit was created in order to fight the slow process of urban decay by awarding tax deductions to developers who built, remodeled, or refurbished low cost housing. In turn, these contracts were lucrative because businesses benefited not just from the tax credit, but also from the positive public image associated with doing ‘charitable’ work. This series of public works projects became an attractive agreement for developers, as this program provided the “most impressive dollar for dollar offset against other Federal taxes” (Hendrickson). This program however has met its own set of obstacles in the form of massive public service projects such as sporting arenas and other tourist attractions that have either failed completely or simply do not generate enough revenue for the city to be considered successful (Hendrickson). The Community Uplift Program has been left the way it was revised under the Bush Administration, due to the fact that the low income housing projects funded by it do eventually become owner-occupied housing, a boon for cities both in terms of tax dollars and property value.
Other than this rebooted program from the Regan era 1980’s, the Bush Administration lacked any other form of a cohesive national policy. Elizabeth Agius, author of National Urban Policy: Problems and Prospects, writes that “the primary focus of the Bush Administration was not economics, but rather housing” (Agius 73). This deficiency was later addressed under the leadership of President Bill Clinton under his plan entitled the Community Empowerment Agenda, which had three main points, dubbed ‘connections’. President Clinton wanted to “reform welfare (employment connection)…invest in education, training, work force development (human capital connection)…and expand residential and employment options of inner city families in their metropolitan areas (access connection)” (National Urban Policy Report). This lack of focus on economics was also addressed by a second part to the Community Empowerment Agenda meant to obtain investments for urban needs from private companies, hoping to lure them through the attraction of an established infrastructure and the natural talent pool stemming from urban areas. Clinton also hoped to obtain this funding from locally owned businesses in order to strengthen the ties to their communities. This plan hoped to rebuild what the President saw as a series of ‘severed connections’ (National Urban Policy Report) in the hopes of making American urban areas competitive and economically sound once again. In the draft of his report on the state of urban America, Clinton states “the most pressing problems facing older cities and their suburban areas are not the results of periodic recessions or the business cycle, and thus cannot be address through traditional grant-in-aid programs” (Clinton). President Clinton was highly influenced by Jack Kemp former Secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development who served with distinction under the presidency of George H.W. Bush, and this influence is most evident given the structure of the Community Empowerment Agenda.
Chapter Summary
Failure to Communicate: The essay traces federal urban policy from housing and empowerment initiatives through Hurricane Katrina and the early Obama administration. It argues that fragmented responsibilities, limited funding, and strained cooperation have impeded a unified approach to urban development.
Keywords
urban policy, urban development, federal government, housing, Low Income Housing Tax Credit, Community Empowerment Agenda, empowerment zones, municipal finance, Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans, Barack Obama, Office of Urban Affairs, intergovernmental cooperation
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It examines federal approaches to urban policy in the United States and the difficulties of coordinating support for cities.
What are its central themes?
The essay addresses housing, economic development, municipal finance, disaster response, education, and cooperation between federal and local authorities.
What is its main objective?
It seeks to explain the obstacles to a cohesive national urban policy by considering initiatives across several presidential administrations.
What method does the author use?
The author develops an argumentative historical discussion using government policy documents, published commentary, and other cited sources.
What does the main discussion cover?
It discusses housing tax credits, Clinton-era empowerment zones, policy under George W. Bush, Hurricane Katrina, and Obama’s urban policy ambitions.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include urban policy, housing, empowerment zones, municipal finance, Hurricane Katrina, and intergovernmental cooperation.
How does the essay discuss empowerment zones?
It describes their intended economic incentives and examines disputes over funding, boundaries, and local control.
Why is Hurricane Katrina important to the discussion?
The author uses the disaster and the federal response in New Orleans to illustrate concerns about urban infrastructure, resources, and policy coordination.
What role does the Office of Urban Affairs play in the essay?
It provides a focus for the discussion of Obama’s plans for coordinated urban policy and the administrative challenges facing those plans.
- Quote paper
- Nicholas Liberto (Author), 2010, Obama's Urban Policy, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/264863