Trade union membership has been steadily declining since 1979. According to the Trade
Union Membership Statistics (BIS, 2013), a growth of around 59,000 to 6.5 million trade
union members in year 2012 was recorded. Nevertheless, in the year 2011, for the first time
since the 1940s, trade union membership has decreased below six million. Accompanied by
this development, is the rising trend of individualism in the relationship between employers
and employees. The workforce these days is characterised by diverse individual interests,
higher expectations concerning the extent of determination in the employment relationship
and accordingly strives for direct say over employment agreements.
However, there is some disagreement about the balance of individualism or collectivism in
the employment relationship among industrial relations academics and practitioners (Legge,
1989, Purcell & Gray, 1986). For this reason it is worthwhile to scrutinise this aspect in more
detail. The objective of this essay is to critically examine the extent to which the employment
relationship is becoming more individualistic. First of all, to set the scene for the following
analysis the key terms ‘individualism’ as well as ‘collectivism’ will be defined and the main
perspectives associated with them will be presented. After that, focusing on individualistic
and collectivistic aspects, the historical development of the altering nature of the British
employment relationship will be outlined. Finally, based on these findings, a conclusion will
be drawn.
To begin with, the notion of individualism, according to Purcell and Gray (1986:213), is
marked by “[employers’] policies based on belief in the value of the individual and his or her
right to advancement and fulfilment at work”. The concept of collectivism is whereas defined
as “the recognition by management of the collective interests of groups of employees in the
decision making process” (Purcell & Gray, 1986:213). [...]
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Definitions of Individualism and Collectivism
3. Theoretical Perspectives: Pluralism and Unitarism
4. Historical Development of British Industrial Relations (1945–1979)
5. The Thatcher Era and the Shift Toward Individualism
6. Human Resource Management and Individualisation
7. Employment Relations Under New Labour
8. Sectoral Variations and Contemporary Trends
9. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
The primary objective of this paper is to critically analyze the evolution of the employment relationship in Britain, specifically examining the extent to which it has shifted from a collectivist model to a more individualistic approach since the post-World War II era.
- The historical transition from collective bargaining to individualized employment relations.
- The role of political legislation and government policies (Conservative vs. Labour) in shaping industrial relations.
- The impact of Human Resource Management (HRM) strategies on organizational commitment and individual voice.
- The dichotomy between unitarist and pluralist organizational frameworks.
- Analysis of trade union membership trends and sectoral differences in collective bargaining coverage.
Excerpt from the Book
The Thatcher Era and the Shift Toward Individualism
Yet, the election of Margaret Thatcher in 1979 represented a critical turning point for unions’ position of power and thus the development of British industrial relations. Based on unitarist and liberal individualistic values, Thatcher’s Conservative government focused, in contrast to the preceding Labour Party, on promotion of individualism, employers’ ‘right to manage’ and deregulation of the labour market. Following this, its legislation programme intended on limiting the bargaining power of trade unions as they were seen as being responsible for wage inflation and therefore imposed, inter alia, a prohibition against closed-shop agreements and restrictions on the their right to strike. Further, Conservative monetarist policies such as privatisation of public organisations and decentralisation of collective bargaining contributed significantly to the strong decrease in trade union membership and density.
Summary of Chapters
Introduction: Outlines the decline of trade union membership and introduces the central debate regarding the shifting balance between collectivism and individualism in the workplace.
Definitions of Individualism and Collectivism: Defines key terms using Purcell and Gray’s frameworks to set the scene for the subsequent analysis of employment relationships.
Theoretical Perspectives: Pluralism and Unitarism: Examines Fox’s organizational frames of reference and their respective links to collective versus individualistic management styles.
Historical Development of British Industrial Relations (1945–1979): Details the post-war period characterized by strong trade union influence and collective bargaining supported by Labour government policies.
The Thatcher Era and the Shift Toward Individualism: Analyzes the critical 1979 turning point, discussing how conservative legislative and economic policies dismantled traditional collective bargaining structures.
Human Resource Management and Individualisation: Explores how the adoption of HRM strategies shifted employee voice from collective representation toward direct, individualistic management communication.
Employment Relations Under New Labour: Investigates the 'partnership' approach adopted in 1997 and the paradox of enhanced individual rights alongside continued union decline.
Sectoral Variations and Contemporary Trends: Highlights significant differences in union density and collective bargaining coverage across various industries and firm sizes.
Conclusion: Synthesizes the findings, confirming a move toward individualistic HRM practices while noting that the extent of this shift remains dependent on specific sectoral and organizational contexts.
Keywords
Individualism, Collectivism, Industrial Relations, Trade Unions, Human Resource Management, Collective Bargaining, Unitarism, Pluralism, Thatcherism, Employment Contracts, Labour Market, De-collectivisation, Employee Voice, Management Style, British Employment Relations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core focus of this research paper?
The paper examines the extent to which the British employment relationship has transitioned from a traditional collectivist model to one characterized by individualism.
What are the primary themes discussed in the work?
Key themes include the impact of government policy, the role of Human Resource Management, the decline of trade union influence, and the conceptual frameworks of pluralism and unitarism.
What is the main research objective?
The objective is to critically assess the shift toward individualistic employment relations by tracing historical developments and organizational practices since 1945.
Which scientific methodology is employed?
The paper utilizes a literature-based analytical approach, reviewing historical evidence, government statistics, and academic theory to evaluate trends in industrial relations.
What is covered in the main body of the text?
The main body covers the theoretical foundations of the employment relationship, the impact of political cycles from the post-war period to the New Labour era, and the practical implementation of HRM strategies.
Which keywords define this paper?
Individualism, Collectivism, Trade Unions, HRM, and Collective Bargaining are the central descriptors.
How did the election of Margaret Thatcher influence industrial relations?
Thatcher's government introduced liberal individualistic policies and deregulation, which weakened unions through legislation on strikes and the decentralization of collective bargaining.
Does HRM inherently exclude collectivism?
There is academic debate; while many scholars argue HRM aims for individual commitment, some note that collective elements can still coexist within an organization.
Why has trade union density remained low despite later political shifts?
The decline is attributed to structural economic shifts from manufacturing to service sectors and the introduction of statutory individual employment protections that replaced some traditional union roles.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Natalie Philips (Autor:in), 2013, Examination of the extent to which the employment relationship is becoming more individualistic, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/268121
