Amin points out that it is odd that the mainstream view of cities and regions is still one of territorial entities, although recent developments have been “transforming cities and regions into sites immersed in global networks of organization and routinely implicated in distant connections and influences”. These developments have become known as globalization and were they reason why spatial configurations (e.g. territorial borders) are no longer necessarily territorial or scalar, because “the social, economic, political and cultural inside and outside are constituted through the topologies of actor networks which are becoming increasingly dynamic and varied in spatial constitution” (Amin). This paper intends to outline the circumstances and consequences of the development identified by Amin in terms of the creation of new forms of inequality and disparity. The first part deals with definitions in the realm of borders and boundaries, the second part treats the historical, current and future meanings of borders and the third part draws the connection between borders and inequality.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Applies Myrdal’s cumulative causation model to migration after German reunification
- Examines German reunification and migration between East and West Germany
- 14 sources in the bibliography
- 4 figures
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
2 Definitions
2.1 Static Boundary Classifications: Antecedence vs. Subsequence
2.2 Functional Boundary Classifications: Open vs. Closed
3 The Meaning Of Borders
3.1 Artificial and Natural Borders
3.2 The Necessity of Borders
3.3 The Future of Borders: the Changing Meaning
3.4 The Complexity of Borders
3.4.1 Wishing Boundaries Away?
3.4.2 Borders Are Everywhere
4 Borders and Inequality
4.1 Inequality Through Migration
4.2 Global Cities
4.3 Theory of Fragmenting Development
4.4 Gated Communities
4.5 Problems of Inequality and Possible Solutions
5 Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This paper examines how globalization and changes in the meaning and function of territorial borders can create or reshape social and economic inequalities. It asks what is new about these inequalities and considers their expression across regions and within cities.
- Definitions and classifications of borders, boundaries and frontiers
- Changing border functions and European integration
- Migration and regional disparities after German reunification
- Global cities, urban polarization and fragmenting development
- Gated communities and socio-spatial exclusion
- Urban inequality and possible policy responses
Excerpt from the Book
3.3 The Future of Borders: the Changing Meaning
At the end of World War II, the last major “official” change of borderlines of a bigger extent took place. The world was laid out according to the plans of the winning nations and divided into the “East” and the “West” – the Cold War had commenced. Only twelve years later, however, starting with the Treaty of Rome in 1957, which marked the beginning of what we now know as the European Union, a process took off which was to change boundaries again, although in a much slower and subtler way. Borderlines were not simply done away with, but boundaries were altered firstly in the minds of politicians and secondly on a supra-state level.
During the past 15 to 20 years, the major social and political transformations taking place all over the world (the collapse of the rigid Cold War geopolitical divide between West and East) gave the change in the meaning of territorial borders another push. The rapid development of information and communication technologies provided the background for the accelerating globalization – partly generating it and partly illustrating it. The result was the rise of the political and economic importance of regions, as the national borders became less and less important. Nowadays, regions need not necessarily end at a state border, but have become cross-border regions in some cases – a development promoted especially by the European Union in its INTERREG programs. The European integration of many former communist countries in its expansion process starting in 2004 also played an important part in the changing meaning of borders. In general, the functional role of borders and boundaries in Europe as defined in chapter 2.2 shifted from a state of relative closure to a more open one (Paasi 2011: 1ff).
Also the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center in New York City in 2001 can be regarded as change in the meaning of boundaries. The western powers, with the United States of America in the forefront, had to reconsider the meanings of the lines dividing societies, nations, states and even cultural realms. Politicians had to alter their definitions of friend and foe and also the ordinary citizen was forced to incorporate new fears, dividing lines, and insides and outsides into his or her view of the world (Paasi 2011: 2).
Chapter Summaries
1 Introduction: The author introduces globalization and changing spatial configurations as the starting point for examining new forms of inequality.
2 Definitions: The chapter distinguishes borders, boundaries and frontiers, and discusses classifications based on their origins and degrees of openness.
3 The Meaning Of Borders: The author considers the origins and perceived necessity of borders, their changing functions and competing perspectives on their continuing significance.
4 Borders and Inequality: The chapter connects changing borders with migration, regional disparities, global cities, fragmenting development and gated communities. It also discusses socio-spatial inequality and possible policy responses.
5 Conclusion: The author returns to the question of what is new about inequalities associated with changing borders, emphasizing their visibility and spatial scale.
Keywords
territorial borders, boundaries, globalization, social inequality, economic inequality, migration, regional disparities, German reunification, global cities, spatial polarization, fragmenting development, digital divide, gated communities, European integration
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It explores the relationship between the changing meaning of territorial borders and social and economic inequality.
What are its main themes?
Its themes include border classifications, globalization, migration, regional disparities, urban polarization and gated communities.
What is the central research question?
The paper asks how changes in the meaning of territorial borders can lead to new forms of social and economic inequality and what is new about those forms.
What research method does the author use?
The paper develops a conceptual discussion using published literature, existing theories and previously published examples and figures. It does not report an original survey or interviews.
What does the main body cover?
It examines how borders are defined and understood, how their functions change, and how those changes relate to inequalities between regions and within cities.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include territorial borders, globalization, migration, global cities, spatial polarization and gated communities.
How does the paper use German reunification?
It discusses migration from eastern to western Germany as an example of the relationship between changing borders and regional disparities, drawing on published migration figures and Myrdal’s model of cumulative causation.
What is the role of the global city thesis?
The paper uses the thesis to discuss changes in urban employment structures and the relationship between globalization and social polarization within cities.
Why are gated communities discussed?
They provide an example of physical and symbolic boundaries within urban areas and raise questions about segregation and access to space.
- Quote paper
- Mag. phil. Martin Payrhuber (Author), 2014, The Changing Meaning of Territorial Borders, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/271187