In this study interdependencies between dimensions of leadership and successful strategy implementation have been analyzed. As prerequisites both an integrative model of leadership and subjective parameters for successful strategy implementation have been developed and operationalized. Based on selected publications on leadership seven main dimensions of leadership have been derived.
Depending on how the sample was configured, different aspects of leadership proved to be good predictors for company success. For the whole sample the following dimensions and their relation to company success from an economic perspective turned out to be of particular significance:
• Focused activities in dealing with innovations.
• Economic sustainability as the guiding principle.
• Transparency regarding strategic decisions of the top management.
• The stability of decisions.
• The fit of the functional strategies to the corporate strategy of a company.
The empirical data suggested a slightly different dimensional structure for the leadership model as originally assumed. Given the high predictive value of the model regarding the success and futureability of a company the roughly fifty items operationalizing leadership can be reduced to the following ten dimensions:
1. Orientation and Direction.
2. Conflict and Caring.
3. Change Management and Enabling.
4. Decision-Making.
5. Sustainability.
6. Results-Orientation and Empowerment.
7. Innovation.
8. Authenticity.
9. Focus.
10. Active Involvement and Attentiveness.
Leadership is a multidimensional phenomenon in the mirror of a specific time spirit. Despite basic aspects may stay stable, future generations will come up with different requirements and challenges regarding the basic thing leadership is all about: the target-oriented influence of people on people.
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
2 Thesis and Research Questions
3 Main Part
3.1 Orientation and Direction
3.1.1 Strategy Development and Implementation: An Integrated Approach
3.1.2 Decision-making
3.1.3 The Difference Between Management and Leadership
3.1.4 Change Management, Change Leadership
3.2 Sensemaking
3.2.1 Building a Vision
3.2.2 Communication
3.3 Innovation and Protection
3.3.1 Schumpeter´s Idea of Creative Destruction
3.3.2 Innovation as a Core Competence
3.3.3 Innovation from an Entrepreneur’s Perspective
3.3.4 Innovation from a Systemic Perspective
3.4 Politics and Conflict
3.4.1 Setting the Stage: Micro-Politics in Organizations
3.4.2 Functions and Dysfunctions of Micro-Politics
3.4.3 Micro-Politics and Leadership
3.5 Shaping Norms
3.5.1 Company Culture: Definition
3.5.2 Company Culture: A Structure Model
3.5.3 Company Culture: Descriptive Dimensions
3.5.4 Cultural Change: Options and Restrictions
3.5.5 The Role of Leaders as Cultural Agents
3.6 Enabling
3.6.1 Strategy Types, Manager Types and Leadership
3.6.2 Level 5 Leadership
3.6.3 Transformational Leadership and New Leadership Approaches
3.6.4 Empowerment
3.6.5 Principles of Leadership in a Strategic Context
3.7 Results and Sustainability
3.7.1 Activity-Orientation vs. Results-Orientation
3.7.2 Results-Orientation as a Method
3.7.3 Results-Orientation as a Cultural Competence
3.7.4 Sustainability
3.7.5 The Evaluation of Implementation Success
4 An Integrative Model of Leadership
5 Methodology and Methods
5.1 The Data Collection Instrument
6 Results
6.1 Descriptive Statistics
6.2 Data Structure (Factorization)
6.2.1 Data Structure of the Independent Variables
6.2.2 Data Structure of the Dependent Variables
6.3 Predictive Validity (Regression)
6.3.1 Predictors for Attenuation/Futureability
6.3.2 Predictors for Identification/Success (EBIT)
6.4 Significant Effects of the Sample
6.4.1 Gender
6.4.2 Disciplinary Leadership
6.4.3 Professional Experience
6.4.4 Company Size
6.4.5 Different Industries
7 Interpretation
7.1 Data Structure: Hypothesis 1-3
7.2 Data Modeling: Hypothesis 4-5
7.3 Sample Effects: Hypothesis 6-9
8 Conclusion
Objectives and Research Focus
This thesis examines the interdependencies between various dimensions of leadership and the success of corporate strategy implementation. The primary research goal is to develop and validate an integrative leadership model that identifies key factors contributing to successful strategy execution, focusing on both present operational success and future corporate viability.
- Development of an integrative leadership framework encompassing seven core dimensions.
- Operationalization of leadership constructs to test their predictive validity on company success.
- Empirical analysis of leadership profiles using a quantitative online survey of 120 professionals.
- Examination of the influence of situational variables such as company size, industry, and leadership role on strategy success.
Excerpt from the Book
3.1.1 Strategy Development and Implementation: An Integrated Approach
The starting point of a strategy is an act of leadership. It is quite common that one of the first things a new CEO decides to do is to guide his or her management team through a strategy process. Working together on a company`s strategy can both be the basis for developing a common picture regarding future directions and also give an overview if the management team is aligned. At the beginning of many strategy processes the first decision which has to be made is if a strategy model should be used. Working with a strategy model brings both orientation and direction into the process of strategy development.
Most of the models mentioned above indicate fields for strategic decision-making and postulate that the alignment of certain dimensions lay ground for a company´s long term success. Some of the models neither take a process perspective nor do they take the phase of strategy implementation into consideration. Regarding strategy implementation most contemporary literature focuses on methods, structure, planning, monitoring and tools thereby often neglecting culture, leadership, Change Management or generally social dimensions of strategy implementation. Besides the guidance given by common strategy models the phase of strategy development typically follows a clear process.
Summary of Chapters
1 Introduction: Discusses the controversial debate on leadership's role in long-term success and sets the central premises for the study, emphasizing leadership as a wholistic, integrated task.
2 Thesis and Research Questions: Outlines nine specific hypotheses regarding leadership interrelations, predictive validity on strategy implementation, and the influence of sample characteristics.
3 Main Part: Provides a comprehensive literature review and theoretical grounding for the seven identified leadership dimensions, integrating perspectives from organizational development, change management, and strategy implementation.
4 An Integrative Model of Leadership: Synthesizes the theoretical findings into a unified model, positing that dimensions like Orientation, Sensemaking, and Shaping Norms serve as higher-level frameworks for execution.
5 Methodology and Methods: Describes the quantitative research design, including the data collection via an online survey and the use of factor and regression analyses to test the hypotheses.
6 Results: Presents the empirical findings, including descriptive statistics, factor analysis outcomes, and regression models identifying key predictors for company success.
7 Interpretation: Discusses the empirical results in relation to the initial hypotheses, confirming the interrelation of leadership dimensions while highlighting the impact of situational factors.
8 Conclusion: Summarizes the study’s findings, reaffirming that effective leadership is multidimensional and situational, requiring a focus on both the "what" and the "how" of strategy execution.
Keywords
Leadership, Strategy Implementation, Organizational Development, Change Management, Sensemaking, Corporate Culture, Empowerment, Results-Orientation, Sustainability, Micro-politics, Predictive Validity, Quantitative Analysis, Business Strategy, Management Traits, Organizational Alignment
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core focus of this research?
The research investigates the interdependencies between specific leadership dimensions and the successful implementation of corporate strategies in large organizations.
What are the central thematic fields?
The study centers on leadership, change management, organizational culture, decision-making processes, innovation, and strategic execution.
What is the primary research goal?
The goal is to develop an integrative leadership model and empirically validate its predictive power regarding organizational success and effective strategy implementation.
Which methodology does the author employ?
The study uses a quantitative research design, gathering empirical data through an online survey of 120 participants and applying statistical methods such as Factor Analysis and Multiple Linear Regression.
What topics are covered in the main body?
The main part covers seven key leadership dimensions: Orientation/Direction, Sensemaking, Innovation/Protection, Politics/Conflict, Shaping Norms, Enabling, and Results/Sustainability.
What characterises this study's approach to leadership?
The approach is integrative and wholistic, treating leadership as a shared organizational task rather than a purely charismatic or individual-based phenomenon.
How does company size influence strategy implementation according to the findings?
The findings suggest that SMEs demonstrate higher stability in decision-making and more authentic communication compared to larger companies, where political friction is more pronounced.
What role does gender play in the perception of leadership?
Female participants tended to rate leadership dimensions more critically, particularly in conflict management and sustainability, though the author notes this may be influenced by the sample composition.
Are there notable differences between industries?
Yes, the study indicates that leadership in consulting is perceived as more result- and performance-driven than in the automotive sector.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Holger Bodenmüller (Autor:in), 2013, Leadership as a Framework for Successful Strategy Implementation, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/271653
