Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Didactics for the subject English - Applied Geography

What motivated Ulster resistance to Home Rule

Title: What motivated Ulster resistance to Home Rule

Essay , 2010 , 10 Pages , Grade: 1,5

Autor:in: Patricia Schneider (Author)

Didactics for the subject English - Applied Geography
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

When Irish nationalists wanted to introduce Home Rule, Ulster Unionists found a variety of reasons to prevent it. There were both moderate opponents to Home Rule as well as rather radical ones. Therefore, various arguments can be found, some of which are based on an objective examination of the Irish question, while others rely on subjective views and personal feelings. Among the arguments that were based on rather individual perceptions was the probably most salient argument: the religious objection to Home Rule. Loyalty towards the Protestant British monarchy and family ties resulting from British or Scottish ancestors were further reasons to resist Home Rule. As a result of the family ties within the Union, many Ulster Unionists felt that there were two nations in Ireland, which strengthened their opposition to the Nationalists’ demands even more. Apart from these arguments which are based on the Unionists’ individual perceptions, there were also objections which were based on a fear of the consequences for an independent Ireland both in terms of domestic matters and in terms of foreign policy. These rather objective arguments involve economic and financial objections to Home Rule as well as concerns about Ireland’s military position.
This essay will first examine the objections that were based on Ulster Unionists personal fears then go on by observing the concerns about the consequences for a self-governed Ireland in terms of domestic matters and foreign policy and finally conclude by judging about the validity of the arguments.

Excerpt


Inhaltsverzeichnis

Die Arbeit enthält kein Inhaltsverzeichnis.

Zielsetzung und Themen

Der Essay untersucht, welche religiösen, sozialen, wirtschaftlichen, finanziellen und militärischen Gründe Ulster-Unionisten gegen die irische Selbstverwaltung anführten. Dabei fragt die Autorin auch nach der Tragfähigkeit dieser Argumente.

  • Religiöse Befürchtungen der protestantischen Minderheit
  • Loyalität zur britischen Krone und familiäre Bindungen
  • Nationale Identität und Vorstellungen von Zugehörigkeit
  • Wirtschaftliche Verflechtung mit Großbritannien
  • Finanzielle und militärische Einwände gegen die Selbstverwaltung

Auszug aus dem Buch

What motivated Ulster resistance to Home Rule?

When Irish nationalists wanted to introduce Home Rule, Ulster Unionists found a variety of reasons to prevent it. There were both moderate opponents to Home Rule as well as rather radical ones. Therefore, various arguments can be found, some of which are based on an objective examination of the Irish question, while others rely on subjective views and personal feelings. Among the arguments that were based on rather individual perceptions was the probably most salient argument: the religious objection to Home Rule. Loyalty towards the Protestant British monarchy and family ties resulting from British or Scottish ancestors were further reasons to resist Home Rule. As a result of the family ties within the Union, many Ulster Unionists felt that there were two nations in Ireland, which strengthened their opposition to the Nationalists’ demands even more. Apart from these arguments which are based on the Unionists’ individual perceptions, there were also objections which were based on a fear of the consequences for an independent Ireland both in terms of domestic matters and in terms of foreign policy. These rather objective arguments involve economic and financial objections to Home Rule as well as concerns about Ireland’s military position.

This essay will first examine the objections that were based on Ulster Unionists personal fears then go on by observing the concerns about the consequences for a self-governed Ireland in terms of domestic matters and foreign policy and finally conclude by judging about the validity of the arguments.

The most obvious reason against Home Rule was a religious one: Ulster Unionists feared the suppression by Roman Catholics if they succeeded in introducing Home Rule. For several decades there had been religious animosity between Protestants and Catholics. As a result, the political affiliation of many people in Ireland coincided with their religious denomination. Therefore, Ulster Unionists, who were commonly Protestant, were afraid of being a minority in an independent Ireland. Various concerns about possible consequences resulted from the fear of being a religious minority.

Zusammenfassung der Arbeit

Der Essay ist nicht in benannte Kapitel untergliedert. Nach einer Einführung behandelt er religiöse und persönliche Einwände, die Bindung an Großbritannien und die nationale Identität sowie wirtschaftliche, finanzielle und militärische Argumente. Abschließend bewertet die Autorin die Überzeugungskraft dieser Einwände.

Schlüsselwörter

Ulster-Unionismus, irische Selbstverwaltung, irischer Nationalismus, Protestantismus, Katholizismus, britische Krone, nationale Identität, Religionsfreiheit, Wirtschaft, Staatsfinanzen, militärische Sicherheit, Großbritannien

Häufig gestellte Fragen

Worum geht es in der Arbeit?

Der Essay untersucht die Gründe, mit denen Ulster-Unionisten die irische Selbstverwaltung ablehnten.

Welche Themenfelder stehen im Mittelpunkt?

Behandelt werden Religion, Loyalität zur Krone, familiäre Herkunft und nationale Identität sowie wirtschaftliche, finanzielle und militärische Fragen.

Welche Frage verfolgt die Autorin?

Sie fragt, was den Widerstand der Ulster-Unionisten gegen die irische Selbstverwaltung motivierte, und bewertet die vorgebrachten Argumente.

Welche wissenschaftliche Methode wird verwendet?

Der Essay wertet veröffentlichte historische Darstellungen und zeitgenössische Beiträge zur Selbstverwaltungsdebatte aus. Eine eigene empirische Erhebung wird nicht beschrieben.

Was behandelt der Hauptteil?

Er stellt zunächst religiöse und identitätsbezogene Einwände dar und untersucht anschließend Befürchtungen hinsichtlich Wirtschaft, Staatsfinanzen und militärischer Sicherheit.

Welche Schlüsselbegriffe charakterisieren die Arbeit?

Wichtige Begriffe sind Ulster-Unionismus, irische Selbstverwaltung, Protestantismus, nationale Identität, britische Krone und wirtschaftliche Verflechtung.

Welche Rolle spielte die Religion für den Widerstand?

Die Arbeit beschreibt die Sorge protestantischer Unionisten, in einem selbstverwalteten Irland als religiöse Minderheit benachteiligt zu werden, etwa bei Ämtern und im Bildungswesen.

Warum waren familiäre Bindungen und Herkunft bedeutsam?

Der Essay verweist auf englische und schottische Vorfahren sowie Verwandtschaftsbeziehungen innerhalb des Vereinigten Königreichs als Gründe für die Verbundenheit mit der Union.

Welche militärischen Bedenken werden angesprochen?

Die Autorin schildert die Befürchtung, eine politische Trennung von Großbritannien könne Irlands Verteidigung angesichts eines bevorstehenden Krieges schwächen.

Excerpt out of 10 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
What motivated Ulster resistance to Home Rule
College
University of Ulster
Grade
1,5
Author
Patricia Schneider (Author)
Publication Year
2010
Pages
10
Catalog Number
V278158
ISBN (eBook)
9783656708261
ISBN (Book)
9783656712510
Language
German
Tags
what ulster home rule
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Patricia Schneider (Author), 2010, What motivated Ulster resistance to Home Rule, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/278158
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  10  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract