Organizational justice research identified a broad set of possible emotional, attitudinal and behavioral consequences to justice perceptions. Empirical evidence of these relationships strongly emphasizes the importance of justice concerns for organizations. Mainly discussed are behavioral reactions to justice, categorized in organizational citizenship behavior, task performance and counterproductive work behavior. Several theoretical approaches offer deeper understanding into why these consequences may occur, and facilitate accurate predictions. In order to clarify what individuals perceive as just in organizations, scholars identified different dimensions of justice. Taken together, the field of organizational justice research offers valuable insights for practical application. These conceptualizations of consequences, underlying processes and the sources of justice perceptions can serve as a practical valuable guideline for organizations. Thus, it helps companies to identify reasons for beneficial and harming employee behavior and points out ways to foster employee’s organizational support.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Applies the group engagement model to organizational citizenship behavior
- Examines a hospital-network study involving 195 employees
- 79 sources in the bibliography
- 3 figures and 1 table
Contents
1. Abstract
2. The Sources of Justice Perceptions
2.1 Distributive Justice
2.2 Procedural Justice
2.3 Interactional Justice
2.4 Fairness Theory
2.5 Distinction and Overall Justice
3. Theoretical Frameworks of Justice Perceptions
3.1 Control Model
3.2 Social Exchange Theory
3.3 Fairness Heuristic Theory
3.4 Relational Model
3.5 Moral Virtues Model
3.6 Integrating the Theories
4. The Consequences of Organizational Justice
4.1 Organizational Citizenship Behavior
4.1.1 Organizational Citizenship Behavior and the Group Engagement Model
4.1.2 Organizational Citizenship Behavior and Social Exchange Theory
4.1.3 Organizational Citizenship Behavior and Fairness Heuristic Theory
4.2 Task Performance
4.2.1 Task Performance and Equity Theory
4.2.2 Task Performance and Intrinsic Motivation
4.3 Counterproductive Work Behavior
4.3.1 Counterproductive Work Behavior and Equity Theory
4.3.2 Counterproductive Work Behavior and the State of Affect
5. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This literature review aims to make organizational justice research accessible for practical use by asking what employees perceive as fair, why they respond to fairness concerns, and how those perceptions relate to their behavior.
- Distributive, procedural and interactional justice
- Fairness judgments and overall justice
- Instrumental, relational and moral explanations
- Social exchange, uncertainty and group identification
- Citizenship behavior, task performance and counterproductive behavior
- Implications for organizational practices
Excerpt from the Book
Distributive Justice
Initially scholars focused on the perceived fairness of resource distributions to discover the role of justice in organizations. Distributive justice has mainly been studied from the equity theory perspective (Adams, 1965). According to Adams, individuals form a ratio between their organizational input and outcome. The sum of the individually as positive considered factors constitute the outcome, such as pay, rewards intrinsic to the job, satisfying supervision, seniority benefits, fringe benefits, job status and status symbols, and a variety of other advantages. The inputs include education, intelligence, experience, training, skill, seniority, age, sex, ethnic background, social status, and, most important, the work effort. Following Adams, a person experiences inequity whenever he perceives that the ratio of his outcomes to inputs is unequal to the ratio of others outcomes to others inputs. If a colleague doing the same job earns more, a person is likely to perceive distributive injustice. According to the relative deprivation approach (Stouffer, Suchmann, DeVinney, Star & Williams, 1949), Adams (1965) highlighted the importance of the different frames of comparison. A worker can compare his outcome/input ratio to the ratio of his immediate colleague, or to the ratio of a comparable position in another company. This choice might be determining the judgment of distributive justice. Resulting from the subjectivity of the evaluation of input and outcome and the choice of reference group, the following distributive fairness judgment is absolutely subjective (Colquitt et al., 2001).
Equity theory implies that a perceived state of inequity evokes a feeling of distress. Adams (1965) describes it as anger in case of underpayment inequity and guilt as consequence of overpayment inequity. This distressing state will motivate individuals to restore equity through actual or psychological reactions. Altering one’s own outcomes or inputs, revaluating outcomes or inputs or changing the comparison other have been discussed as possible mechanisms to restore inequity (Colquitt et al., 2005). In an early experimental study, Adams and Rosenbaum (1962) tested the predictions of equity theory. Participants were either told they were qualified (no inequity) or unqualified (overpayment inequity) for a certain job with fixed payment. As predicted, the overpaid participants showed higher performance.
Chapter Summaries
Abstract: The abstract introduces justice perceptions, their behavioral consequences and the practical relevance of organizational justice research.
The Sources of Justice Perceptions: This chapter examines distributive, procedural and interactional justice, fairness theory, and the relationship between distinct dimensions and overall justice.
Theoretical Frameworks of Justice Perceptions: The author discusses instrumental, social exchange, heuristic, relational and moral explanations for why people care about justice.
The Consequences of Organizational Justice: This chapter connects justice perceptions and theoretical models to organizational citizenship behavior, task performance and counterproductive work behavior, drawing on published studies and meta-analyses.
Conclusion: The work brings together the proposed organizational implications of justice research and considers how fair practices may support employees and organizations.
Keywords
organizational justice, distributive justice, procedural justice, interactional justice, fairness theory, equity theory, social exchange theory, fairness heuristic theory, group engagement model, social identity, organizational citizenship behavior, task performance, counterproductive work behavior
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It reviews organizational justice research and the ways employees’ perceptions of fairness relate to workplace behavior.
What are its central themes?
The main themes are sources of fairness perceptions, theories explaining responses to justice, and behavioral consequences for organizations.
What questions guide the work?
It asks what people perceive as just, why they react to justice concerns, and how they respond to those perceptions.
What research method does the author use?
The author conducts a literature review, drawing on established theories, empirical studies and meta-analyses rather than reporting a new survey or experiment.
What does the main body cover?
It examines justice dimensions, theoretical explanations and three categories of employee behavior: citizenship behavior, task performance and counterproductive work behavior.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include organizational justice, procedural justice, distributive justice, social exchange theory, organizational citizenship behavior and task performance.
How does the work distinguish procedural from distributive justice?
Distributive justice concerns the perceived fairness of outcomes, while procedural justice concerns the fairness of the processes used to determine them.
What role does the group engagement model play?
The model provides a relational explanation linking fairness perceptions, social identity and employees’ willingness to support their organization.
How is counterproductive work behavior discussed?
The work considers equity theory and affect as alternative ways to understand behavior such as theft or sabotage in relation to perceived injustice.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Yannik Schenk (Autor:in), 2014, Why Justice Matters. Determinants and Consequences of Organizational Justice, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/283767