Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Theology - Systematic Theology

“Wahrheit und Methode“ by Gadamer. Critical Interaction with a Philosophical Hermeneutics

Title: “Wahrheit und Methode“ by Gadamer. Critical Interaction with a Philosophical Hermeneutics

Term Paper , 2006 , 16 Pages , Grade: 14 von 20 Punkten

Autor:in: Daniel Steffen Schwarz (Author)

Theology - Systematic Theology
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

What is truth? This question raised by Pilatus to Jesus does not only bother theological scholars ever since, but also philosophical thinkers. This paper examines how one of the most important German philosophers of the 20th century, Hans Georg Gadamer, dealt with the issue of truth within his hermeneutical main work “Wahrheit und Methode.” Even one of his critics, E.G. Hirsch admits: “Hans Georg Gadamer has published the most substantial treatise on hermeneutic theory that has come from Germany this century.” After the presentation of his main thesis, which can only be done in a rough overview, an evangelical response will be worked out. This main task of the paper will deal with the question how Gadamer´s ideas can be adopted in an apologetics within a postmodern framework. Aiming at a balanced evalutation both helpful and difficult aspects will be highlighted. A short conclusion bundling up the most important results will round of the paper.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Critically applies Gadamer’s hermeneutics to apologetics in a postmodern context
  • 12 sources in the bibliography

Table of Contents

0. Introduction

1. Wahrheit und Methode: Main features of a philosophical hermeneutics

1.1. Historical classification and def. “the truth of understanding”

1.1.1. The problem of truth

1.1.2. The truth of understanding

1.2. Theoretical main features of Gadamer´s hermeneutic

1.2.1. The hermeneutical circle

1.2.2. The prestructure of understanding: the prejudices

1.2.3. The principle of the effective history

1.2.4. The meaning of the application

1.3. The practice of hermeneutics

1.3.1. The hermeneutical experience

1.3.2. Understanding as conversation in the dialectic of question and answer

2. Critical Interaction with Gadamer

2.1. Preliminary remarks

2.2. Helpful ideas in Gadamers doctrine

2.2.1. The claim for an own hermeneutical methodology for theology

2.2.2. Applications of the hermeneutical circle

2.2.3. The role of prejudices

2.2.4. Implications from the call to effective historical consciousness

2.2.5. The worth of the application

2.2.6. Implications from the hermeneutical experience

2.2.7. Hermeneutics as dialogue

2.2.8. Human rationality as participating in transcendense

2.3. Critical aspects

2.3.1. Situatedness of the text and the noetical content of sense

2.3.2. Context of words in hermeneutics?

2.3.3. Text as communication partner?

2.3.4. Going beyond the author´s understanding?

2.3.5. Between objectivism and relativism and theological hermeneutics

3. conclusion

Objectives and Themes

This paper examines Hans-Georg Gadamer’s account of truth and understanding in his philosophical hermeneutics and asks how his ideas might be adopted in evangelical apologetics within a postmodern context. It presents his principal concepts before assessing their potential uses and difficulties for theological interpretation.

  • Truth, method and the humanities
  • The hermeneutical circle and the role of prejudices
  • Effective history and the fusion of horizons
  • Application, dialogue and the experience of understanding
  • Evangelical theological interpretation and postmodern apologetics
  • Authorial meaning, textual context and relativism

Excerpt from the Book

2.2.3. The role of prejudices

The own prejudices play probably the main role in Gadamer´s hermeneutical presuppositions. Following the descriptions above we can apply important advices for our purposes. Against the Enlightment project who saw prejudices as a distracting hinderance for researching Gadamer objects several aspects.

It is first of all a matter of fact that our understanding is deeply stamped by our presuppositions. The idea of pushing away our situatedness in favor of a putative objective understanding, arrogantly mastering the theology is an illusion. The interpret of a text simply has not the possibility to go beyond it and understand it, judging the text from a highler level, but is heavily influenced not only by the text itself but also by the history of interpretation that has affected his way of thinking still before he has opened the book to start his exegesis.

Having seen this impossibility of object interpretation must consequently lead to our second aspect: Gadamers calls not only indirectly for a more academicly humble attitude but also for the need of making the own prejudices consciously. In the light of what we have seen it seems academically inacurate to hide the own situadedness. Rather we should reflect on it like we do with the texts themself.

The following question could provide some helpful hints in order to become aware of the own prejudices. What are the main doctrinal statements of the theological school I am a part of? How does my religious experience shape my perception of theological texts? How does my character effect my way of working? Further for Gadamer those prejudices are not only desirable to be mentioned in the hermeneutical context both are necessary factors for gaining new wisdom from text.

This is the third hint we can observe from Gadamer here. Our situatedness is not to be seen distructing but it is an important condition to come to better conclusions. This means that every single interpret enacts about personal skills due to his background nobody else has and thus can contribute academically informations that other interprets lack. On the other side being situated means that you have only a limited perspective while approaching a text, which leads to the need of regarding also other thinkers and engage with their ideas.

Chapter Summaries

0. Introduction: The introduction establishes the question of truth and outlines the paper’s examination of Gadamer’s hermeneutics from an evangelical perspective.

1. Wahrheit und Methode: Main features of a philosophical hermeneutics: This chapter presents Gadamer’s account of truth and understanding, including the hermeneutical circle, prejudices, effective history, application and dialogue.

2. Critical Interaction with Gadamer: The author considers how Gadamer’s ideas might inform postmodern apologetics and evaluates tensions concerning biblical interpretation, textual meaning, authorial understanding and relativism.

3. conclusion: The conclusion brings together the paper’s principal theological assessments of Gadamer’s approach.

Keywords

philosophical hermeneutics, Hans-Georg Gadamer, truth, understanding, hermeneutical circle, prejudices, effective history, fusion of horizons, theological hermeneutics, evangelical apologetics, postmodernism, biblical interpretation, authorial meaning, relativism

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this paper about?

It examines Gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutics and evaluates its relevance for evangelical theology and apologetics.

What are its central themes?

The central themes include truth and method, the hermeneutical circle, prejudices, effective history, application and dialogue.

What is the paper’s primary question?

It asks how Gadamer’s ideas can be adopted in apologetics within a postmodern context.

What method does the author use?

The paper presents Gadamer’s principal ideas and then critically considers selected concepts from an evangelical perspective, adapting them as potential methodological insights for apologetic conversation.

What does the main body discuss?

It explains Gadamer’s theory and practice of understanding before considering both helpful ideas and critical issues for theological interpretation.

Which keywords characterize the paper?

Key terms include philosophical hermeneutics, truth, understanding, prejudices, effective history, biblical interpretation and postmodern apologetics.

How does the paper address the interpreter’s prejudices?

It discusses Gadamer’s view that interpreters approach texts with presuppositions and considers the importance of becoming aware of them.

What does the paper say about the fusion of horizons?

It describes the relationship between the interpreter’s perspective and the historical horizon of a text, and considers its implications for theological interpretation.

Does the author address the meaning intended by an author?

Yes. The critical discussion considers whether interpretation can go beyond an author’s understanding, particularly when biblical texts are understood as having divine authorship.

Excerpt out of 16 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
“Wahrheit und Methode“ by Gadamer. Critical Interaction with a Philosophical Hermeneutics
College
Evangelical Theological Faculty
Grade
14 von 20 Punkten
Author
Daniel Steffen Schwarz (Author)
Publication Year
2006
Pages
16
Catalog Number
V284907
ISBN (eBook)
9783656852285
ISBN (Book)
9783656852292
Language
English
Tags
wahrheit methode gadamer critical interaction philosophical hermeneutics
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Daniel Steffen Schwarz (Author), 2006, “Wahrheit und Methode“ by Gadamer. Critical Interaction with a Philosophical Hermeneutics, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/284907
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  16  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract