In this scientific essay, the three service operations online fashion retailing, retail banking, and management consulting are compared against the background of both Silvestro et al.'s (1992) service classification model and Heskett et al.'s (1994) service profit chain model. At the end, a critical analysis as to whether the classification of the service operations according to Silvestro et al.'s model explains and justifies the findings in the context of Heskett et al.'s model is conducted.
At a glance
- Applies Silvestro et al.’s classification model and Heskett et al.’s service profit chain
- Presents a modified retail banking classification model incorporating external factors
- 23 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Comparison of online fashion retailing to retail banking and management consulting regarding Silvestro et al.’s classification model
2.1 Comparison to retail banking
2.2 Comparison to management consulting
3. Comparison of online fashion retailing to retail banking and management consulting regarding the service profit chain
3.1 Comparison to retail banking
3.2 Comparison to management consulting
4. Discussion whether the classification of the service operations explains and justifies their applicability with regard to the service profit chain
Aim and Topics
This work compares online fashion retailing with retail banking and management consulting through Silvestro et al.’s service classification model and the service profit chain. It examines how the characteristics of each operation relate to service quality, customer loyalty and financial performance, and whether the classification model helps explain the applicability of the service profit chain.
- Service classification by customer contact, customisation and customer volume
- Digital and face-to-face retail banking services
- The role of consultants in creating service value
- Frontline employees and external service quality
- Relationships among satisfaction, loyalty, revenue growth and profitability
- External factors affecting service operations
Excerpt from the Book
2.1 Comparison to retail banking
Online fashion stores often serve entire countries. RB, in contrast, partly takes place in branch banks, which inevitably limits the number of customers processed per day. Besides, RB tends to feature more customer-employee contact than OFR, particularly regarding services that involve financial advice. This focus on people in some RB services further restricts the number of customers processed per day. A bank employee cannot, say, discuss individual credit terms with multiple customers simultaneously. On the contrary, an online fashion store can be used by many customers at the same time.
However, contactless forms of banking have gained in importance with regard to routine financial transactions, thereby reducing the value added in the front office as well as the customer contact time per transaction. In the UK, for instance, mobile and online banking are on the rise with more than 14 million mobile bank apps having been downloaded in total and nearly £1 billion being transferred online per day (British Bankers’ Association, 2014). Moreover, RB services are highly heterogeneous. For example, discussing the advantages and disadvantages of different types of credit is more time-consuming, involves more customer contact, and tends to leave more room for customisation than a cash withdrawal using an ATM.
In conclusion, RB is classified as a service shop. On the one hand, it shares some characteristics of mass services with OFR, most notably the increasing degree of standardisation and number of customers processed per day due to contactless forms of banking. On the other hand, potentially time-consuming face-to-face advice provided by frontline employees still plays a pivotal role with regard to rather complex, non-routine financial services like mortgages.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The introduction defines retail banking and management consulting and sets out the two frameworks used for the comparison. It identifies the service profit chain relationships examined in the work.
2. Comparison of online fashion retailing to retail banking and management consulting regarding Silvestro et al.’s classification model: This chapter compares the three operations by customer volume, contact time, customisation and the location of value creation. It places them within Silvestro et al.’s service classification model.
3. Comparison of online fashion retailing to retail banking and management consulting regarding the service profit chain: This chapter examines frontline service quality and the links between customer satisfaction, loyalty, revenue growth and profitability in the three sectors.
4. Discussion whether the classification of the service operations explains and justifies their applicability with regard to the service profit chain: The final chapter considers how far service classification explains the application of the service profit chain. It also proposes a modified model for retail banking that distinguishes service types and incorporates external factors.
Keywords
online fashion retailing, retail banking, management consulting, service operations, service classification, service profit chain, frontline employees, service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, revenue growth, profitability, digital banking, service customisation
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It compares online fashion retailing with retail banking and management consulting as service operations.
What are the central topics?
The work addresses service classification, customer contact, service quality, loyalty and the relationships between loyalty and financial performance.
What is the main question?
The work asks how the three operations compare under two service-management frameworks and whether their classification helps explain the applicability of the service profit chain.
What method does the author use?
The author conducts a comparative conceptual analysis using Silvestro et al.’s classification model, the service profit chain and published sources.
What does the main body cover?
It compares retail banking and management consulting with online fashion retailing under each framework, then discusses the relationship between classification and the service profit chain.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include service operations, service classification, service profit chain, frontline employees, customer satisfaction and customer loyalty.
How does the work approach different retail banking services?
It considers differences between advisory services, such as mortgage advice, and transactional services, such as cash withdrawals and money transfers.
What role do frontline employees play in the comparison?
The work examines their contribution to external service quality across automated retailing, banking and consultant-led services.
Does the work present a modified classification model?
Yes. It presents a model for retail banking that distinguishes advisory and transactional services and adds an external-factors dimension.
- Quote paper
- Marvin Mertens (Author), 2015, Online Fashion Retailing, Retail Banking, and Management Consulting, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/293089