In this paper I will compare and contrast the theoretical foundations of theories of democratization which emphasize structural determinants and theories which focus on agency, and assess their potential for explaining democratization during the third wave. To do this I will first present some background theory, before I go into a discussion and reach a conclusion. The paper is based up on literature from course syllabus for SAMPOL115 "Democracy and democratization".
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Theory
2.1 The structural view
2.2 Agency theory
2.2.1 The strategic view / transition theory (Teorell 2010:19-21)
2.2.2 Social forces tradition
2.2.3 Economic approach
2.3 Third wave of democratization
3. Discussion
3.1 Compare and contrast the theoretical foundations of these perspectives
3.2 Assess their potential for explaining democratization during the third wave
3.2.1 Structural approach
3.2.2 Agency approaches
4. Conclusion
Purpose and Topics
This paper compares theories that emphasize structural determinants of democratization with theories focused on agency, and assesses their ability to explain democratization during Huntington’s third wave. Its central question is how well these perspectives account for the transitions of that period.
- Modernization theory and structural prerequisites for democracy
- Strategic transition theory and elite bargaining
- Social forces, class relations, and democratization
- Economic approaches to regime change and distribution
- Huntington’s third wave and its defining factors
- Comparisons of theoretical perspectives against historical cases
Excerpt from the Book
Assess their potential for explaining democratization during the third wave
Recall, Lipset’s argument; “The more well-to-do a nation, the greater the chances that it will sustain democracy.” (Diamond 1991:93). Hence, countries with reasonable economic growth and strong institutions should democratize during the third wave.
Møller and Skaaning (2013:98) argue that of the South American countries experiencing growth and modernization in the third wave, the autocracy in a number of countries actually piggybacked on modernization. Examples mentioned here are Argentina in 1976-1983, Uruguay in 1973-1985 and Chile in 1973-1990. These countries were also some of the wealthiest South American countries at the time and should by Lipset’s standard democratize instead of strengthen the autocracy. However, “…once established in a wealthy country, a democracy is more likely to endure.” (Przeworski, Adam, Michael Alvarez, José Antonio Cheibub, and Fernando Limongi 2001:177).
South Korea is often considered to be the best example of modernization theory as it experienced economic growth, higher living standards, educational levels and subsequently developed from autocracy to democracy (Pippa Norris 2008:90). But modernization theory does not explain why Singapore does not democratize, as it has considerable similarities with South Korea, but is still an autocracy.
If we look at countries that did democratize during the third wave we find for example India, Pakistan and Sri-Lanka. The three countries have in common that they were poor and underdeveloped during the democratization process (Diamond 1991:100).
3.2.2 Agency approaches
3.2.2.1 Strategic:
The strategic view emphasized the importance of negotiations between political elites, “hard-liners” and “soft-liners” and that the transition to democracy happened in a set of phases.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The paper sets out to compare structural and agency-based theories and assess their explanatory potential for the third wave. It identifies course literature as its basis.
2. Theory: This chapter defines democracy and democratization and introduces the agency-structure debate. It presents structural theory, three agency approaches, and the third wave.
2.1 The structural view: The section outlines Lipset’s association between economic development, modernization, and democracy, including the role of institutions.
2.2 Agency theory: This section introduces approaches that emphasize the role of agents in democratization.
2.2.1 The strategic view / transition theory (Teorell 2010:19-21): The section describes a phased transition model centered on elite decisions and bargaining.
2.2.2 Social forces tradition: This section explains approaches that trace democracy to relationships and struggles among social classes.
2.2.3 Economic approach: The section presents economic models explaining actors’ preferences through material resources and distribution.
2.3 Third wave of democratization: The section reviews the third wave’s definition, timing, geographic spread, and proposed explanatory factors.
3. Discussion: The chapter compares the perspectives and assesses their explanatory potential for democratization during the third wave.
3.1 Compare and contrast the theoretical foundations of these perspectives: The section contrasts the theories’ prerequisites and their different emphasis on institutions, elites, classes, and broader populations.
3.2 Assess their potential for explaining democratization during the third wave: The section considers how well the theories account for historical cases and transitions.
3.2.1 Structural approach: The section evaluates modernization theory against cases including South Korea, Singapore, and poorer democracies.
3.2.2 Agency approaches: This section examines strategic, social forces, and economic approaches in relation to third-wave cases.
4. Conclusion: The paper argues that the theories have explanatory limitations and discusses combining structural and agency perspectives.
Keywords
democratization, democracy, third wave, structural theory, agency theory, modernization, strategic transition theory, social forces, economic approach, elite bargaining, class struggle, regime change
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It compares structural and agency-based theories of democratization and evaluates their ability to explain transitions during the third wave.
What are its central subject areas?
It covers modernization, elite strategy, social class relations, economic approaches, and the historical context of the third wave.
What is the paper’s main research question?
It asks how well structural and agency-focused perspectives explain democratization during the third wave.
Which research method does the paper use?
It uses a comparative discussion of theoretical approaches, drawing on existing scholarly literature and historical examples.
What does the main body examine?
It compares theoretical foundations and assesses each approach against cases such as South Korea, Singapore, Spain, Portugal, and South American countries.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include democratization, third wave, modernization, agency, structural theory, social forces, and regime change.
When and where did Huntington’s third wave begin?
The paper identifies Portugal’s Carnation Revolution in 1974 as its starting point and traces its spread through several regions.
How does the paper distinguish the strategic and social forces approaches?
The strategic approach emphasizes elite bargaining and transition phases, while the social forces tradition focuses on class relationships and pressures from below.
Which countries illustrate contrasting modernization outcomes?
South Korea is presented as a case of economic growth followed by democratization, while Singapore is discussed as a comparable autocracy.
- Quote paper
- Aleksander Bjelland Koldingsnes (Author), 2014, Democratization Theories and the Third Wave of Democracy, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/300720