The idea of an internal-external security nexus is holding greater sway in both politics and academia.
The nexus describes the blurring of two formerly distinct security spheres: internal security (domestic affairs), the domain of police and law enforcement; and external security (foreign affairs), traditionally the domain of diplomats and the military.
The internal-external security nexus is widely acknowledged in contemporary European Union (EU) documents, also in respect to the issue of migration.
Central components of the EU’s approach to the current influx of irregular migrants are to enhance the capacity of countries at the Union’s periphery in order to prevent illegal migration movement early on, to fight migrant smuggling, and to rigorously return persons who do not qualify for international protection under the 1951 Geneva Convention.
However, the EU is externally lacking partners while at the same time appearing to be internally in quarrel over how to respond.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines Italy’s Mare Nostrum operation and Frontex border operations
- 42 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Abstract
2. Short Introduction
(1) Discussion of Literature on the Internal-External Security Nexus
(2) Brief Introduction of the Cross-Border Security Phenomenon
(3) Analysis of Relevant Political and/or Policy Documents
(4) Analysis of Programs, Actions or Policy Decisions
(5) Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
The work examines the relationship between internal and external security and considers how the European Union applies this relationship to irregular migration across the Mediterranean. It asks, in substance, how EU strategies and actions address migration as a cross-border security issue.
- The development of the internal-external security nexus
- Competing academic perspectives on European security
- Migration routes and drivers in the Mediterranean region
- EU security and migration policy documents
- Border operations, asylum and international cooperation
Excerpt from the Book
(1) Discussion of Literature on the Internal-External Security Nexus
Much has been written on the internal-external security nexus in recent years, and the academic world and political sphere both seem to agree on the blurring of internal and external security, as described above.
Kurowska & Pawlak maintain that security is becoming “an important dimension of almost every policy” within the European Union (2009: 475). This is also apparent in the number “of references to the increasing linkages between internal and external security” within official EU documents (Shepherd, 2015: 3). The changes in the international security environment have made more concerted and comprehensive action a necessity (Duke & Ojanen, 2006: 478; Tauner, 2011: 19), a fact that is exemplified by what Ioannides describes as a “rapid growth of the EU internal-external nexus” (2014: 130). Such a “comprehensive approach would provide a platform for overcoming the EU’s institutional stove-piping, bureaucratic turf wars and divergent security cultures” (Shepherd, 2015: 14).
Schroeder identifies a strategic void that is the result of a capability-driven approach to strategy formulating. According to Schroeder, this mismatch is caused by the variety of actors pursuing different security strategies (2009: 486). Kurowska & Pawlak agree with Schroeder, stressing that “security policies emerge out of the politics of security performed at different levels” (2009: 475) instead of being the result of genuine strategic-level thinking. The amount of different actors involved, divergent objectives, and diverse cultures are among the reasons identified for causing frictions. Issues regarding powers hold and the relations between actors, politics and society at large are also cited as complicating factors.
Carrapico (2013) describes the EU’s approach to the internal-external security nexus in relation to organized crime as a lengthy process that already started decades ago and is not yet concluded. Changing threat perceptions and the subsequent—but by no means inevitable—projection of a security concern from the formerly internal domain into the broader external realm has taken place with regard to organized crime. But despite the EU’s acknowledgment of intermingling internal and external dimensions, Carrapico identified “a disconnection between the rhetorically emphasized importance of OC [organized crime] and the practice being developed in the external dimension” (2013: 471). That the EU’s preceding internal security objectives frequently clash with its external security aspirations is also observed by Monar, who points to a prevailing “vagueness and lack of substance” (2010: 28) in the EU’s approach to security challenges.
Chapter Summaries
Abstract: The abstract introduces the internal-external security nexus and outlines the EU’s approach to irregular migration.
Short Introduction: The introduction explains how transnational challenges blur the traditional distinction between domestic and external security.
(1) Discussion of Literature on the Internal-External Security Nexus: The author reviews academic accounts of the nexus, including arguments about institutional coordination, securitization and the need for empirical research.
(2) Brief Introduction of the Cross-Border Security Phenomenon: This section describes Mediterranean migration, its varied causes and the framing of migration as a security issue.
(3) Analysis of Relevant Political and/or Policy Documents: The author examines EU security and migration documents, including the European Agenda on Migration and its four policy pillars.
(4) Analysis of Programs, Actions or Policy Decisions: This section discusses Mare Nostrum, Frontex operations, asylum arrangements and proposals for sharing responsibility among EU member states.
(5) Conclusion: The conclusion assesses the relationship between EU policy commitments and practice in response to the migration crisis.
Keywords
internal-external security nexus, European Union, Mediterranean migration, irregular migration, security policy, securitization, border management, asylum, refugee protection, Frontex, Mare Nostrum, European Agenda on Migration
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the work about?
It examines the connection between internal and external security through the European Union’s response to migration across the Mediterranean.
What are its central themes?
The main themes include transnational security, irregular migration, EU policy, border management, asylum and cooperation with countries outside the EU.
What is the main objective?
The work explores how the EU’s treatment of migration reflects the internal-external security nexus, comparing policy documents with selected actions and programs.
What research method does the author use?
The author reviews academic literature and analyzes EU political and policy documents alongside selected programs and policy decisions. No original survey or interview study is described.
What does the main body cover?
It reviews scholarship on the security nexus, introduces Mediterranean migration, examines EU documents and discusses operational and policy responses.
Which keywords characterize the work?
They include internal-external security nexus, European Union, Mediterranean migration, securitization, asylum and border management.
Which EU policy documents are examined?
The discussion includes the 2003 European Security Strategy, the European Agenda on Security, the European Agenda on Migration and the Global Approach to Migration and Mobility.
How does the work address maritime operations?
It discusses Italy’s Mare Nostrum operation and Frontex border operations in relation to rescue, border control and access to asylum.
How does the author discuss the causes of migration?
The work distinguishes displacement driven by conflict and insecurity from migration associated with limited economic prospects, while considering policy instruments relevant to both.
- Quote paper
- Stefan Pauly (Author), 2015, The Internal-External Security Nexus. Achieving Internal Security by Creating a Secure External Environment and the Current Migrant Crisis in the Mediterranean, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/303983