With the historical novel, it would seem that there is something of a dichotomy between the writer, who wants to concentrate on the story through a free flow of imagination, and the historian who must adhere to the known facts. To produce a successful historical novel, the author must embody both creative vision and accuracy.
Table of Contents
1. THE HISTORICAL NOVEL
2. WRITERS AND HISTORIANS
Objectives and Themes
The primary objective of this commentary is to analyze the technical and creative challenges involved in writing a historical novel, specifically focusing on establishing a compelling point of view, developing authentic characters, and integrating historical research. The author explores how different writers balance the demands of historical accuracy with the creative freedom required for narrative fiction.
- The dichotomy between historical fact and creative imagination.
- Technical approaches to narrative point of view in historical settings.
- Character development and the role of the "back story" in historical fiction.
- Methods for achieving authenticity and atmosphere in period-based narratives.
- Comparative analysis of writing styles from Philippa Gregory, Hilary Mantel, and C. J. Sansom.
Excerpt from the book
THE HISTORICAL NOVEL
For the aspiring writer, reading is an apprenticeship. For me it was one that began in childhood. Like most children, I knew what I wanted to hear or read. So, to some extent, children who like stories are already literary critics by the time they go to school. As we grow older, we begin to analyse and study. Eventually we find that books provide not only entertainment but templates for our own writing.
The craft of writing is inevitably linked to reading; the need to see how characters play out, why a particular point of view was chosen and how it works, the complexities of plot. But, apart from the technical aspects, there is the joy of finding a well written passage, a snappy piece of dialogue or a startling and effective image. It is these that make a book enthralling, the magical word web that binds you to the writer and from which there is no escape until you reach the end.
With the historical novel, it would seem that there is something of a dichotomy between the writer, who wants to concentrate on the story through a free flow of imagination, and the historian who must adhere to the known facts. To produce a successful historical novel, the author must embody both creative vision and accuracy.
Summary of Chapters
THE HISTORICAL NOVEL: This chapter provides an introduction to the author's personal journey into writing and establishes the foundational challenges of the historical novel genre, specifically the tension between imagination and factual accuracy.
WRITERS AND HISTORIANS: This chapter examines the specific methodologies of Philippa Gregory, Hilary Mantel, and C. J. Sansom, analyzing how each author navigates historical constraints to create believable characters, authentic settings, and compelling narrative structures.
Keywords
Historical novel, Philippa Gregory, Hilary Mantel, C. J. Sansom, point of view, historical accuracy, character development, creative writing, narrative, research, atmosphere, fiction, Thomas Cromwell, Shardlake, Cousins’ War
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the central focus of this document?
The work examines the craft of writing historical novels, focusing on how authors can successfully integrate diligent historical research with the creative demands of compelling storytelling.
What are the primary thematic areas covered?
The core themes include the balancing of historical facts with fiction, the selection of narrative points of view, character creation, and the importance of sensory detail in establishing period authenticity.
What is the author's primary research goal?
The author aims to investigate the challenges encountered in their own creative writing—specifically point of view, character development, and authenticity—by analyzing the techniques of three established authors.
Which scientific or analytical method is applied?
The author employs a comparative literary analysis, examining the specific writing techniques, narrative choices, and stylistic approaches of three successful authors in the genre.
What does the main body of the text cover?
The text details the narrative choices made by Philippa Gregory, Hilary Mantel, and C. J. Sansom, evaluating their success in creating historical worlds and engaging readers while remaining faithful to the spirit of their respective time periods.
Which keywords characterize this work?
Key terms include historical fiction, narrative perspective, characterization, historical research, creative vision, authenticity, and the specific works of the authors mentioned.
How does Hilary Mantel distinguish her portrayal of Thomas Cromwell?
Mantel uses a third-person deep viewpoint and free indirect discourse to provide an intimate, objective look at Cromwell's psyche, grounding his development in his back story and private struggles.
How does C. J. Sansom differentiate his approach in the 'Shardlake' series?
Sansom prioritizes plot and atmosphere, using a first-person narrative for his protagonist, a lawyer named Shardlake, to navigate the social and political complexities of Tudor England.
What role does the 'back story' play in these novels?
The back story is essential for character motivation, explaining why characters act the way they do and allowing readers to understand the formative experiences that drive the current narrative action.
Why does the author argue that first-person narratives can be restrictive?
First-person accounts are limited to the protagonist's perspective and personal bias, which can create difficulties for the author if the plot requires action to be depicted outside the character's immediate presence.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Sandra Spirling (Autor:in), 2013, The Historical Novel. Writers and Historians, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/304104
